Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Burke didn't and in fact couldn't because his ideas were nonsense. That isn't to say that unrestricted social change is always necessarily a good thing, but his attitude that everything is fine stop ruining society was predicated on everything being fine when it manifestly was not.
Well, in the years that followed, what he said would happen happened in the way he said it would happen. These aren't the kind of ideas that you can prove scientifically. One either finds the arguments convincing, or one doesn't. The man who he was corresponding with wasn't convinced and thought the revolution was great, and was guillotined.
 
If Ireland, Germany, France, Denmark, Sweden, Russia actually dont care about maintaining their ethnic/cultural majority, and dont care if immigration eventually leads to them being a majority-minority society, they of course have that choice. And they should have that choice.

I simply believe they should also have the choice to maintain their ethnic majority. And folks who want to maintain that majority should not be automatically attacked as racists.

But its a free world, and people will do as they wish.
 
Last edited:
OK. So you had some dead laws that haven't been enforced since before I was born. What do you want me to say? I'd have to think about the specific circumstances. At the moment there seems no reasonable likelihood of such a thing being found constitutional.


Not one that is invariant of circumstances, no. Everything is a tradeoff. Everything has unintended consequences. I don't understand what is so incomprehensible to people about saying that my views are Burkian.... I'm not writing this in Yiddish.


I really don't think you guys understand what the other side thinks. The ability of this forum to get opposing views and see what the world looks like from within other perspectives is close to zero. I used to be like that too and it took me several years of really trying to understand conservatives rather than arguing with them to come out of it.


There is no point in talking. You aren't able to step outside your way of seeing this. I don't know what more to say. None of what I am saying in this conversation is particularly unique or original. These ideas have been around and quite prominent for hundreds of years.... again Burke is a rather dull, but well known, example of aspects of them.


I'm not ideological on this question, so there is no answer. How many times must I answer your question?


I don't see it as having anything to do with achieving a "dream" of mine. It's an irrelevant issue to me that for whatever reason is enormously important to you. You finding it important does not make it important to me.

I don't share the same rituals, taboos and fetishes as you. Like most of the world, I do not share your catechisms.... Once I've told you that, what is the point of over and over again saying "so which interpretation of the Trinity do you have?"? I don't share your religion. Maybe it's shocking to you that I don't believe the wafer is the body of Christ. I still wish my fellow man well, and think that increasing the sum of human happiness is a noble aim. Go ahead and excommunicate me for thinking that the way to achieve that is different from the one in your Gospel.



Interracial marriage is not a value.


Could be. It seems utterly irrelevant to me from anything I want. I've told you from the start that this wasn't something that I had a yes or no answer to, so I don't understand why you are talking like you have drawn this truth out of me.


It's not important at all. If I think it is going to cause more misery than it saves, I am against it. If I think it is going to save more misery than it causes, then I am for it. It's like "if by whisky...".

Interracial marriage is not a value. Forbidding it certainly is. It is an absolute declaration of racism, pure and simple. It may not have been enforced since before you were born, but it existed for sure, and some of us were born before 1967 (I may have misstated the date in post above) when the whole reason for the Supreme Court decision was exactly because the law was enforced, and there is no telling how long it would have been enforced if the case had not been brought.

I know you find this whole argument irrelevant, but I do not. You have stated, more or less, that you desire a certain sort of society, which does not, in your opinion exist at the moment. You appear to wish to change your current society to reflect the values you believe it has lost, owing to various developments.

I am not addressing whether you are right or wrong in that assessment, nor questioning the values of the society you would prefer.

I am not asking what you think reasonable, likely, even possible, nor what you think effective or responsive or stupid or smart.

I am not asking what conditions you might be willing to endure if you were born into them or they were imposed by a majority you do not belong to. You have certainly made it clear that you do not favor the freedom of people to flee cultures that offend their values and seek those that do.

I am not prepared to start a big digression on Burke, but I do note that you have expressed your distaste for individualism and presumably favor Burke's separation of happiness and virtue. But I think there are limits here. We are not bees in a hive. Even the proponents of a slave state did not propose that they be the slaves for its accomplishment. There is a reason Shirley Jackson's lottery was so shocking to many.

I think even the most determined, hive-minded statist will have a cutoff point where either the price of his desired state is too high, or an action erodes the value of the thing desired. Even people willing to die for their society or their nation require a convincing trade to give it meaning.

Your countryman Mr. Swift, for example, modestly proposed that the problem of Irish overpopulation could be solved by eating babies. Needless to say, though this proposal was quite feasible and almost certainly would have been both effective and efficient, it was not well favored even by those who would do the eating. Few people, no matter what their faith or political bent, or their opposition to "ideology," would accept baby eating as a thing you should ever consider for anything, not only because it's wrong to eat babies, but because no society can be enhanced by the practice.

A few years later, a notorious leader suggested that his people could restore the society they so sorely pined for, at the cost of persecuting minorities. Many, of course, did not realize just how big a little thing can grow until too late, but many did. There's a name for them, and they're coming back. Few people we can respect now would consider genocide an acceptable price ever to pay for anything, not only because it's wrong but because it is counter to the values of the society it claims to promote.

My question, which despite your objections I still contend is a very simple one which any person who is not a robot ought to be able to answer, is an offshoot of the above.

If an agency with trustworthy ability to deliver proposed a solution to the social problems you consider to be afflicting the society you claim to value said "yes, I can deliver that to you, but to do so would require making interracial marriage a crime," would you, whether or not you objected, whether or not you lobbied for a modification, whether you thought it dumb or unnecessary, vote for it?

In other words, would you consider racial laws a negotiable item in the fight for what you consider a good society? Would you find it conceivable that a desirable society could be overtly racist? Would you find that an acceptable compromise?

While this must be presented in a somewhat abstract form, it is not idle and abstract. Interracial marriage is specifically addressed by those espousing "replacement theory." It is explicitly targeted in current movements to overturn existing decisions in the US Supreme Court. It is explicitly disparaged by vociferous right wing minorities in this country.

It may well be (and I sure as hell hope so) that this radical fringe opinion does not sneak under the door and become possible again. But it is not trivial. It is the advance guard of an army of evil that, though it may not destroy the country itself, will destroy its virtue.

It is not just an abstraction, and though I hope it's not a likelihood, it is not an impossibility. You who along with your mentor consider history of such great importance, do not forget that it is part of our history. Recent not ancient. Real, not theoretical. Racism is a stain on our history, and when deciding what we want to preserve, restore, or change in our society, one of those things is the racist laws that some of us fought so hard for so long to overcome.

You may think it irrelevant or impertinent to ask just how much racism you can swallow in your social soup, but I do not.
 
If Ireland, Germany, France, Denmark, Sweden, Russia actually dont care about maintaining their ethnic/cultural majority, and dont care if immigration eventually leads to them being a majority-minority society, they of course have that choice. And they should have that choice.

I simply believe they should also have the choice to maintain their ethnic majority. And folks who want to maintain that majority should not be automatically attacked as racists.

But its a free world, and people will do as they wish.

All of the countries you bring up have been empires. Most of them have been majority-minority entities before thanks to having been empires. In the case of Russia, it was maintained through the existence of the Soviet Union.

The idea that letting in too many minorities is going to lead them to doom is pretty laughable since they have all done this before. They only thing really different this time is they won't have a racial hegemony if they were to allow unlimited immigration.

Keeping out minorities, OTOH, dooms them to stagnation. Immigration is not necessarily a binary situation. They can regulate the numbers that come in. But the moment they decided they don't want anymore they will surely be dying from their own isolationism.

Arguments about maintaining the status quo because the others are seen as a threat are BS. Historically, immigration changes countries. So does isolationism. With immigration you get new ideas. Without out it, you get Japan in the second half of the 19th century that went nowhere. Or Korea that ended up setting itself up for invasion by to keep out any contact with foreigners.
 
If Ireland, Germany, France, Denmark, Sweden, Russia actually dont care about maintaining their ethnic/cultural majority, and dont care if immigration eventually leads to them being a majority-minority society, they of course have that choice. And they should have that choice.

I simply believe they should also have the choice to maintain their ethnic majority. And folks who want to maintain that majority should not be automatically attacked as racists.

But its a free world, and people will do as they wish.

Indeed, ethnic cleansing is not always racial. Unfortunately, like "racism" it has acquired a nasty genocidal aftertaste, that soupcon of bitterness like the bad mushroom in the soup. Ah, to find a new value-free term for it. Ethnic decluttering! We can go after those pesky intermarriages too, and call it "ethnic disambiguation."
 
The idea that people would hold forth on liberal political philosophy and not have read him, and not feel any need to read him, is kind of startling. It's not even a long. How incurious are you guys?

What the hell has that to do with your personal incapability to state whether mixed race marriage should be banned.
 
Interracial marriage is not a value. Forbidding it certainly is. It is an absolute declaration of racism, pure and simple. It may not have been enforced since before you were born, but it existed for sure, and some of us were born before 1967 (I may have misstated the date in post above) when the whole reason for the Supreme Court decision was exactly because the law was enforced, and there is no telling how long it would have been enforced if the case had not been brought.
Sure.

I know you find this whole argument irrelevant, but I do not. You have stated, more or less, that you desire a certain sort of society, which does not, in your opinion exist at the moment. You appear to wish to change your current society to reflect the values you believe it has lost, owing to various developments.
Pretty much everybody has opinions about how society should be.

I am not addressing whether you are right or wrong in that assessment, nor questioning the values of the society you would prefer.

I am not asking what you think reasonable, likely, even possible, nor what you think effective or responsive or stupid or smart.

I am not asking what conditions you might be willing to endure if you were born into them or they were imposed by a majority you do not belong to. You have certainly made it clear that you do not favor the freedom of people to flee cultures that offend their values and seek those that do.
You mean like completely open borders?

I am not prepared to start a big digression on Burke, but I do note that you have expressed your distaste for individualism and presumably favor Burke's separation of happiness and virtue. But I think there are limits here. We are not bees in a hive. Even the proponents of a slave state did not propose that they be the slaves for its accomplishment. There is a reason Shirley Jackson's lottery was so shocking to many.
That's like holding up The Handmaids Tale as what will happen if the Democrats don't win in 2024. I'm not altogether sure we don't live in a bee hive.

I think even the most determined, hive-minded statist will have a cutoff point where either the price of his desired state is too high, or an action erodes the value of the thing desired. Even people willing to die for their society or their nation require a convincing trade to give it meaning.
Certainly life must have meaning.

Your countryman Mr. Swift, for example, modestly proposed that the problem of Irish overpopulation could be solved by eating babies. Needless to say, though this proposal was quite feasible and almost certainly would have been both effective and efficient, it was not well favored even by those who would do the eating. Few people, no matter what their faith or political bent, or their opposition to "ideology," would accept baby eating as a thing you should ever consider for anything, not only because it's wrong to eat babies, but because no society can be enhanced by the practice.
Societies will do plenty of things that don't enhance them. Did human sacrifice enhance societies of the past, did child sacrifice? Maybe I am misunderstanding what you mean by enhance. Liberalism and the cult of the individual wasn't needed to prevent such things. The French Revolution professed all sorts of rights, not so dissimilar to yours, and that was not that far from baby eating in its barbarity. An abstract set of liberal rights is no defence against barbarity.

A few years later, a notorious leader suggested that his people could restore the society they so sorely pined for, at the cost of persecuting minorities. Many, of course, did not realize just how big a little thing can grow until too late, but many did. There's a name for them, and they're coming back. Few people we can respect now would consider genocide an acceptable price ever to pay for anything, not only because it's wrong but because it is counter to the values of the society it claims to promote.
Is it counter to them? We kill millions of people to promote liberalism and think it's a price worth paying. This forum thinks the Civil War was a price worth paying, that's three quarters of a million dead right there. We could go on counting. The thing is they were in a cause you think is good, so they were OK... but the deaths for causes you don't like are a damning indictment on the barbarity of their perpetrators.

My question, which despite your objections I still contend is a very simple one which any person who is not a robot ought to be able to answer, is an offshoot of the above.

If an agency with trustworthy ability to deliver proposed a solution to the social problems you consider to be afflicting the society you claim to value said "yes, I can deliver that to you, but to do so would require making interracial marriage a crime," would you, whether or not you objected, whether or not you lobbied for a modification, whether you thought it dumb or unnecessary, vote for it?
No. That's not how good societies are built. This is going back to Burke. You can't come up with an ideal society in your head and expect it to work. These things are the work of huge amounts of time, slow work and evolution. What you are offering me is exactly the thing I keep saying doesn't work. If I can say to this genie, "give me a society in which people are happy and secure and can have confidence that they will leave a progressively better world for their children and grandchildren", why would I care whether inter-racial marriage was a thing in that society? Would it be worth having if it made people less happy, or contributed to the long term collapse of the society?

Going back to Burke. Burke criticises the idea that you can redesign the social order from scratch based on reason and self evident principles. You are coming back and saying, "OK, what self evident principles SHOULD we use". I fundamentally reject the project.

In other words, would you consider racial laws a negotiable item in the fight for what you consider a good society? Would you find it conceivable that a desirable society could be overtly racist? Would you find that an acceptable compromise?
Sure. I have said this already. How many times?

While this must be presented in a somewhat abstract form, it is not idle and abstract. Interracial marriage is specifically addressed by those espousing "replacement theory." It is explicitly targeted in current movements to overturn existing decisions in the US Supreme Court. It is explicitly disparaged by vociferous right wing minorities in this country.
OK. I think it is wildly unlikely that anything of that sort is going to happen without some Earth shaking changes in the world.

It may well be (and I sure as hell hope so) that this radical fringe opinion does not sneak under the door and become possible again. But it is not trivial. It is the advance guard of an army of evil that, though it may not destroy the country itself, will destroy its virtue.
We see the world very differently. It's like me telling you the Democrats want to bring in FEMA death camps. I guess I can empathise with you having fears, but they aren't my fears.

It is not just an abstraction, and though I hope it's not a likelihood, it is not an impossibility. You who along with your mentor consider history of such great importance, do not forget that it is part of our history. Recent not ancient. Real, not theoretical. Racism is a stain on our history, and when deciding what we want to preserve, restore, or change in our society, one of those things is the racist laws that some of us fought so hard for so long to overcome.
You are just preaching your liberal catechism at me. I understand your beliefs. I understand what you think is good, and what you think is evil and how you think the world functions. It's a progressive liberal vision. I think progressive liberalism is an incorrect understanding of how the world works and what makes people happy. What do you want me to say? The vast majority of people in the world aren't progressive liberals. You need to find a way of dealing with and talking to people who come from outside this world view.

You may think it irrelevant or impertinent to ask just how much racism you can swallow in your social soup, but I do not.
Sure, obviously because it's your secular religious belief. A catholic might find it terribly important how many rosaries one does, or when one last confessed. It's not my world view. Again, most of the world does not share your concerns, and I think it is unlikely they ever will share your concerns.
 
Last edited:
If Ireland, Germany, France, Denmark, Sweden, Russia actually dont care about maintaining their ethnic/cultural majority, and dont care if immigration eventually leads to them being a majority-minority society, they of course have that choice. And they should have that choice.

I simply believe they should also have the choice to maintain their ethnic majority. And folks who want to maintain that majority should not be automatically attacked as racists.

But its a free world, and people will do as they wish.

Depends how they do it. Pleas for racial solidarity detached from the fascism days? I don't mind. This is what the so-called white separatist movement does. Limiting immigration? I can see room for that. But I think it's an outrage if a country capable of taking in refugees from conflict zones just refuses to. Restricting interracial marriage? Flat out totalitarian.

And those are the mild options.
 
What the hell has that to do with your personal incapability to state whether mixed race marriage should be banned.
It's like asking why is it relevant that you haven't got past middle school maths in a complex analysis class. People have to have some basic understanding of the world view of the other side of the debate to make discussion possible. Otherwise, everything has to take place in the frame of the ignorant side which amount to conceding the debate before it has begun.

Certainly people don't actually have to have read Burke, but the blank incomprehension and repetitive questions that assume the only possible answers are liberal progressive ones creates the impression that very few people here actually know how people on the right think.
 
It's like asking why is it relevant that you haven't got past middle school maths in a complex analysis class. People have to have some basic understanding of the world view of the other side of the debate to make discussion possible. Otherwise, everything has to take place in the frame of the ignorant side which amount to conceding the debate before it has begun.

Certainly people don't actually have to have read Burke, but the blank incomprehension and repetitive questions that assume the only possible answers are liberal progressive ones creates the impression that very few people here actually know how people on the right think.

Yeah, we just don't understand the complex thinking of people on the right. :rolleyes:
 
Well, I'm not going to go on and on about whether Burke was right, but I do seem to have read somewhere that he was a champion of history - and yet his follower discounts recent history, and considers it irrelevant if it happened before he was born. It is true that I've forgotten all my Tacitus, but I humbly surmise that history has not stopped. It may not even have slowed down.

And I also seem to recall that Burke was as his disciple here is, a champion of social virtue above individual comfort (but somehow the idea of virtue is not ideological, no, no, because dependence on God is not I guess) yet he apparently discounts the efforts of those (admittedly a minority) who faced ostracism, assault, imprisonment and even death, not for their own comfort (after all many were enjoyers of white privilege), but to rid the society they valued of laws that they (and many who followed) believed were a shameful stain, that denied the very principles it claimed to espouse and negated the virtue they believed important. But hey you can interpret anything. It's all self interest. Saints just want an express flight to heaven. Anyway, they were all probably liberals, and it was just so so long ago, and they were just a mouthy minority, so ****'em.

But I guess it's time to give up. Our correspondent has made it clear enough that he cannot see any reason to exclude explicitly racist laws from his desired utopia. Salt to taste.
 
Well, I'm not going to go on and on about whether Burke was right, but I do seem to have read somewhere that he was a champion of history - and yet his follower discounts recent history, and considers it irrelevant if it happened before he was born. It is true that I've forgotten all my Tacitus, but I humbly surmise that history has not stopped. It may not even have slowed down.
I haven't discounted any recent history. I probably interpret it differently to you. Presumably you mean that 50+ years ago there were some laws on the books you don't like. I haven't seen a lesson in that yet. The issue isn't important to me like it is to you. I can't look in exhaustive detail into every detail every other person finds important. Nobody does this.

And I also seem to recall that Burke was as his disciple here is, a champion of social virtue above individual comfort (but somehow the idea of virtue is not ideological, no, no, because dependence on God is not I guess) yet he apparently discounts the efforts of those (admittedly a minority) who faced ostracism, assault, imprisonment and even death, not for their own comfort (after all many were enjoyers of white privilege), but to rid the society they valued of laws that they (and many who followed) believed were a shameful stain, that denied the very principles it claimed to espouse and negated the virtue they believed important.
You mean the French Revolutionaries? I am definitely on the side of Charlotte Corday over Marat. They signed peoples death warrants with careless abandon. The carnage was awful. Is this more death that's OK, because it's in a liberal cause as opposed to the death that happens for non-liberal causes which only reveals the horrid callous brutality at the heart of the non-liberal philosophy?

If it is so shocking that I won't rule out this hateful laws, how many people need to die for your utopia? Millions have died for it already gaining victories that you think were worth it.

But hey you can interpret anything. It's all self interest. Saints just want an express flight to heaven. Anyway, they were all probably liberals, and it was just so so long ago, and they were just a mouthy minority, so ****'em.
Most revolutionaries are rather nasty, brutal people. The nominal utopia that they are fighting for is seldom what actually rises out of the killing.

But I guess it's time to give up. Our correspondent has made it clear enough that he cannot see any reason to exclude explicitly racist laws from his desired utopia
Utopias are conceived by people who think they know how to design an ideal society. I don't. That is the progressive liberal dream.
 
Last edited:
I haven't discounted any recent history. I probably interpret it differently to you. Presumably you mean that 50+ years ago there were some laws on the books you don't like. I haven't seen a lesson in that yet. The issue isn't important to me like it is to you. I can't look in exhaustive detail into every detail every other person finds important. Nobody does this.
Not discounted any recent history? That's exactly what you have done. Sure, the enormous social upheaval and the change of national character involved in this country's struggle for civil rights is less important to you, but it was a big deal for many, it changed a lot of things in a lot of ways in a lot of places, and it sure as hell was about more than "some laws on the books you don't like."
You mean the French Revolutionaries? I am definitely on the side of Charlotte Corday over Marat. They signed peoples death warrants with careless abandon. The carnage was awful. Is this more death that's OK, because it's in a liberal cause as opposed to the death that happens for non-liberal causes which only reveals the horrid callous brutality at the heart of the non-liberal philosophy?

If it is so shocking that I won't rule out this hateful laws, how many people need to die for your utopia? Millions have died for it already gaining victories that you think were worth it.
I have no idea what you're referring to here, but maybe my "he" above was misread. The "he" I refer to is you, and the thing I refer to discounting is, once again, the history of the battle for civil rights in this country. I have no idea what utopia you imagine is mine, and who you presume is dying for it. Sure, there are many things wrong and bad and hateful in the world I inhabit, the world we all inhabit. I asked not if you could live with it but whether you would vote for it.
Most revolutionaries are rather nasty, brutal people. The nominal utopia that they are fighting for is seldom what actually rises out of the killing.


Utopias are conceived by people who think they know how to design an ideal society. I don't. That is the progressive liberal dream.

I guess it's a good thing then that I'm not a revolutionary or a utopian. I'm not the one here complaining about what's wrong with the population and what should be done to improve the demographics of society. So maybe you're not trying for an ideal society, but you're certainly speaking about an improved one, one in which trends you see as damaging are changed. And I think it unfortunate that you consider overt racism to be something you would support in that cause.
 
Numerous cultures across the world have faced outright invasion, occupation, subjugation, and violent repression. Yet, check back a few generations down the road, and you see little sign of the invaders' culture. Now they all sing the conquered peoples' songs, wear their clothing styles, eat their cuisine, etc.

Persian culture is a great example. "Oh, hey there Mr. Timur. Yes, the palace is yours now, do please mind the rugs (:9). Sir, we eat sitting on the floor, so stop whatever that is. Have this wine. Now have this hashish. Watch these pretty dancing girls. And if I could please insist you *speak Farsi* like something resembling a civilized being."

What the hell is wrong with "white culture" that makes it so hopelessly fragile it can't resist the influence of even a comparative trickle of immigrants?
 
Last edited:
It's like asking why is it relevant that you haven't got past middle school maths in a complex analysis class. People have to have some basic understanding of the world view of the other side of the debate to make discussion possible. Otherwise, everything has to take place in the frame of the ignorant side which amount to conceding the debate before it has begun.

Certainly people don't actually have to have read Burke, but the blank incomprehension and repetitive questions that assume the only possible answers are liberal progressive ones creates the impression that very few people here actually know how people on the right think.

What I want is for you to explain in your own words what is so convincing to you about Burke's thinking as a shield to avoid answering really simple questions.

Telling me to read Burke doesn't cut it when the arguments you have put forward, can be used to advocate not changing anything in case there are bad unintended consequences. Which does indeed seem a fairly reasonable summary of most of his arguments. Including most of them about slavery, "it's unpleasant and we shouldn't maybe encourage slave traders but really the most we should do is allow polite slaves to buying freedom with work".

Basically he was the master of self-serving arguments some of which would contradict others if taken to their conclusion.
But hey maybe that is appropriate.

Eighteenth century values for the twenty first century.
 
I don't share the same rituals, taboos and fetishes as you. Like most of the world, I do not share your catechisms.... Once I've told you that, what is the point of over and over again saying "so which interpretation of the Trinity do you have?"? I don't share your religion. Maybe it's shocking to you that I don't believe the wafer is the body of Christ. I still wish my fellow man well, and think that increasing the sum of human happiness is a noble aim. Go ahead and excommunicate me for thinking that the way to achieve that is different from the one in your Gospel.

Read Burke.

I didn't say what was at the root of the problem. The concept of blame and guilt is you using your morality to understand the situation. Please, park that. I don't know how many times I can tell you guys, I do not share your secular religion.

No, not humanitarianism. Humanism perhaps, which is a secular religion. You keep trying to smuggle in your religious catechisms as if they were universal self evident truths. They aren't.

Sure, obviously because it's your secular religious belief. A catholic might find it terribly important how many rosaries one does, or when one last confessed. It's not my world view. Again, most of the world does not share your concerns, and I think it is unlikely they ever will share your concerns.


Can someone explain to me why someone who is using "religion" as a pejorative is also telling us to read Burke?

At root of it is Burke's critique of the French Revolution.
In which Burke expressed his belief that religion is the foundation of civil society.

I have referred Burke. Any educated person with an interest in the topics we are discussing has read him.

It strikes me that “Read Burke,” is about as good an answer as “read the Bible.”
Have you ever noticed that people who tell you to "Read the Bible" are so often unfamiliar with the Bible's content?

Pointing to Burke is a lot easier than retyping the same thing in different ways only to have it ignored. For anybody on the forum who wanted to learn, Burke is not a bad way in to conservative thought.
 
Last edited:
What I want is for you to explain in your own words what is so convincing to you about Burke's thinking as a shield to avoid answering really simple questions.
Jimbob, this may be the last extended response I make to you about this topic, because I don't think there is much point in our conversation. You talk as if you have an MSNBC understanding of conservative, right wing, reactionary etc. politics. Maybe that is an act, and maybe it isn't. I don't know. Having crossed that gulf myself, I do not believe it is something that debates or conversations like this can bridge. It takes a lot of time, and respecting the world view of the other side and understanding culturally where they are coming from. Either you want to understand other people's politics, or you don't... but you aren't going to learn it in a place like this.

Telling me to read Burke doesn't cut it when the arguments you have put forward, can be used to advocate not changing anything in case there are bad unintended consequences. Which does indeed seem a fairly reasonable summary of most of his arguments. Including most of them about slavery, "it's unpleasant and we shouldn't maybe encourage slave traders but really the most we should do is allow polite slaves to buying freedom with work".
Again, the idea that either Burke, or I, or conservatism in general is about "not changing anything" is just such a profound misunderstanding and betrays such complete ignorance that I think it is probably best that I bring this conversation to a close. I will give you a brief answer, but that is all I am going to do.

It is not, and never has been an argument for no change. It is an argument for being humble, as I have said, about our ability to actually be able to control how the changes we want will play out. The person who Burke was writing to was utterly wrong about the nature of the revolution he was supporting, believing that the society that the revolution would deliver would accord with the principles of the revolution. The same with the Russian revolution. Society is just too complex and full of too many constraints that you can't possibly know when you are constructing your dream castles. In the thread of trans-genderism Emily's Cat has this whole idea of a society without gender roles. That is very easily conceived of, and I'm sure looks great on paper. Burke would say, I think, something similar to Rumsfeld.... there are a lot of known unknowns and unknown unknowns out there. It is just much easier and quicker to create chaos that leads to more suffering and allows unscrupulous, driven people to use the situation for their own gain, than it is to make the world genuinely better. We are like children taking apart a watch that we don't understand thinking we are going to improve the mechanism. Maybe... but probably we will just break something that we aren't able to fix.

There are two main ways of doing social change. One is to come up with some model, some set of principles. Maybe you think a society that maximises free individual choice is a good society, that has a whole bunch of implications that this taboo, and that law, and that custom has to go. The problem is that you don't actually know what you are doing and that principle that you are making decisions based on amounts to a religious dogma that was conceived in ignorance of the implications of implementing the dogma.

The other way of doing social change is slowly evolving things over time, based on what has worked before and trying where you can to make changes with the expectation that they aren't going to play out how you think.

I sometimes think of it as an expert system vs machine learning approach to social change.

Obviously all change will have some element of both. Progressive liberal change tends to be skewed very heavily to the revolutionary change type being based on assumed "truths" and reason rather than experience and evolution.

Basically he was the master of self-serving arguments some of which would contradict others if taken to their conclusion.
Pretty much everybody's position does that. That is partly why it is a bad idea to leap forward with irreversible revolutionary change based on somebody's arguments.

Eighteenth century values for the twenty first century.
That's what liberalism is.

I'll read any response you make, but I do not think I am likely to respond.
 
Last edited:
Not discounted any recent history? That's exactly what you have done. Sure, the enormous social upheaval and the change of national character involved in this country's struggle for civil rights is less important to you, but it was a big deal for many, it changed a lot of things in a lot of ways in a lot of places, and it sure as hell was about more than "some laws on the books you don't like." I have no idea what you're referring to here, but maybe my "he" above was misread. The "he" I refer to is you, and the thing I refer to discounting is, once again, the history of the battle for civil rights in this country. I have no idea what utopia you imagine is mine, and who you presume is dying for it. Sure, there are many things wrong and bad and hateful in the world I inhabit, the world we all inhabit. I asked not if you could live with it but whether you would vote for it.
When I talk about utopian thinking, I mean having a set of principles constructed by reason ... as I mentioned to jimbob, the idea that a society that maximises individual liberty is a good thing, and then seeks to implement that in the world. You have a mental image of how society should be based on deductive reasoning from principle and then you seek to manifest that in the world. The principles themselves are sacred and not subject to question and if they don't work out, then either the principles were not followed hard enough, or it is the fault of the kulaks.

You have widened the scope now from talking about a particular law being repealed to talking about the whole civil rights movement. That I wasn't talking about things before that you have only just introduced isn't my problem. Obviously I take the civil rights movement into account, we just weren't talking about it. Since I doubt it's fundamental assumptions about the world, it doesn't hold the same holy place in my heart that it does in yours.

I guess it's a good thing then that I'm not a revolutionary or a utopian.
You are.

I'm not the one here complaining about what's wrong with the population and what should be done to improve the demographics of society.
There is nothing revolutionary or utopian about believing one sees a problem. Where one heads in that direction is if one things idealised, rationally constructed principles are a sound footing to reorganise society.

So maybe you're not trying for an ideal society, but you're certainly speaking about an improved one, one in which trends you see as damaging are changed.
Yes, obviously. Nobody is arguing for an unchanging society.

And I think it unfortunate that you consider overt racism to be something you would support in that cause.
You guys think millions of dead bodies to be something you would support in your cause. I'm not sure you are on any kind of high ground from which to throw stones.

Is there anything more to be said here? I'll respond if there is, but not if it's just a repeat of the same stuff.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom