OK. So you had some dead laws that haven't been enforced since before I was born. What do you want me to say? I'd have to think about the specific circumstances. At the moment there seems no reasonable likelihood of such a thing being found constitutional.
Not one that is invariant of circumstances, no. Everything is a tradeoff. Everything has unintended consequences. I don't understand what is so incomprehensible to people about saying that my views are Burkian.... I'm not writing this in Yiddish.
I really don't think you guys understand what the other side thinks. The ability of this forum to get opposing views and see what the world looks like from within other perspectives is close to zero. I used to be like that too and it took me several years of really trying to understand conservatives rather than arguing with them to come out of it.
There is no point in talking. You aren't able to step outside your way of seeing this. I don't know what more to say. None of what I am saying in this conversation is particularly unique or original. These ideas have been around and quite prominent for hundreds of years.... again Burke is a rather dull, but well known, example of aspects of them.
I'm not ideological on this question, so there is no answer. How many times must I answer your question?
I don't see it as having anything to do with achieving a "dream" of mine. It's an irrelevant issue to me that for whatever reason is enormously important to you. You finding it important does not make it important to me.
I don't share the same rituals, taboos and fetishes as you. Like most of the world, I do not share your catechisms.... Once I've told you that, what is the point of over and over again saying "so which interpretation of the Trinity do you have?"? I don't share your religion. Maybe it's shocking to you that I don't believe the wafer is the body of Christ. I still wish my fellow man well, and think that increasing the sum of human happiness is a noble aim. Go ahead and excommunicate me for thinking that the way to achieve that is different from the one in your Gospel.
Interracial marriage is not a value.
Could be. It seems utterly irrelevant to me from anything I want. I've told you from the start that this wasn't something that I had a yes or no answer to, so I don't understand why you are talking like you have drawn this truth out of me.
It's not important at all. If I think it is going to cause more misery than it saves, I am against it. If I think it is going to save more misery than it causes, then I am for it. It's like "if by whisky...".
Interracial marriage is not a value. Forbidding it certainly is. It is an absolute declaration of racism, pure and simple. It may not have been enforced since before you were born, but it existed for sure, and some of us were born before 1967 (I may have misstated the date in post above) when the whole reason for the Supreme Court decision was exactly because the law
was enforced, and there is no telling how long it would have been enforced if the case had not been brought.
I know you find this whole argument irrelevant, but I do not. You have stated, more or less, that you desire a certain sort of society, which does not, in your opinion exist at the moment. You appear to wish to change your current society to reflect the values you believe it has lost, owing to various developments.
I am not addressing whether you are right or wrong in that assessment, nor questioning the values of the society you would prefer.
I am not asking what you think reasonable, likely, even possible, nor what you think effective or responsive or stupid or smart.
I am not asking what conditions you might be willing to endure if you were born into them or they were imposed by a majority you do not belong to. You have certainly made it clear that you do not favor the freedom of people to flee cultures that offend their values and seek those that do.
I am not prepared to start a big digression on Burke, but I do note that you have expressed your distaste for individualism and presumably favor Burke's separation of happiness and virtue. But I think there are limits here. We are not bees in a hive. Even the proponents of a slave state did not propose that
they be the slaves for its accomplishment. There is a reason Shirley Jackson's lottery was so shocking to many.
I think even the most determined, hive-minded statist will have a cutoff point where either the price of his desired state is too high, or an action erodes the value of the thing desired. Even people willing to die for their society or their nation require a convincing trade to give it meaning.
Your countryman Mr. Swift, for example, modestly proposed that the problem of Irish overpopulation could be solved by eating babies. Needless to say, though this proposal was quite feasible and almost certainly would have been both effective and efficient, it was not well favored even by those who would do the eating. Few people, no matter what their faith or political bent, or their opposition to "ideology," would accept baby eating as a thing you should ever consider for anything, not only because it's wrong to eat babies, but because no society can be enhanced by the practice.
A few years later, a notorious leader suggested that his people could restore the society they so sorely pined for, at the cost of persecuting minorities. Many, of course, did not realize just how big a little thing can grow until too late, but many did. There's a name for them, and they're coming back. Few people we can respect now would consider genocide an acceptable price ever to pay for anything, not only because it's wrong but because it is counter to the values of the society it claims to promote.
My question, which despite your objections I still contend is a very simple one which any person who is not a robot ought to be able to answer, is an offshoot of the above.
If an agency with trustworthy ability to deliver proposed a solution to the social problems you consider to be afflicting the society you claim to value said "yes, I can deliver that to you, but to do so would require making interracial marriage a crime," would you, whether or not you objected, whether or not you lobbied for a modification, whether you thought it dumb or unnecessary, vote for it?
In other words, would you consider racial laws a negotiable item in the fight for what you consider a good society? Would you find it conceivable that a desirable society could be overtly racist? Would you find that an acceptable compromise?
While this must be presented in a somewhat abstract form, it is not idle and abstract. Interracial marriage is specifically addressed by those espousing "replacement theory." It is explicitly targeted in current movements to overturn existing decisions in the US Supreme Court. It is explicitly disparaged by vociferous right wing minorities in this country.
It may well be (and I sure as hell hope so) that this radical fringe opinion does not sneak under the door and become possible again. But it is not trivial. It is the advance guard of an army of evil that, though it may not destroy the country itself, will destroy its virtue.
It is not just an abstraction, and though I hope it's not a likelihood, it is not an impossibility. You who along with your mentor consider history of such great importance, do not forget that it is part of our history. Recent not ancient. Real, not theoretical. Racism is a stain on our history, and when deciding what we want to preserve, restore, or change in our society, one of those things is the racist laws that some of us fought so hard for so long to overcome.
You may think it irrelevant or impertinent to ask just how much racism you can swallow in your social soup, but I do not.