Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Once again, I am baffled by your point of view. I have no idea why you believe I think millions of dead are a price worth paying for alignment with my views. What views? What dead? What do you think I am doing or saying to promote this? I'm an American, for sure, but unless you'd like to accept me as an immigrant, which seems unlikely, there's only so much I can do about the sins of the country I was born into.

In any case, I don't think I've ever seen you come up before with the direct answer I highlighted, which is what I was asking, so I will leave it, with apologies if I missed that specific statement previously. Consider it said.
It is my earnest belief that "stars aligning" aside, you cannot make society better by instituting something that makes it worse.
I remember an amusing, if fiercely utilitarian, old computer game called "Hamurabi," (the single M a concession to 8-character file names). In this game one is the administrator of a society with a small body of rules and a budget, and the kicker is that you must allow a certain percentage of your subjects to starve or the society will collapse. I don't think life is that simple.

You might make it better for some, more comfortable for some, even for a majority, but a society is a whole thing, and while the comfort of the many is one value, it is not the only one. In what essential way does your conditional acceptance of racism differ from that of genocide or slavery, other than your personal judgment of its importance?
Well said.

And I am interested in what shuttlt would think if a majority (or maybe not a majority, just those with power) decided that it was in society's best interests to harm a group they belong to, say by confiscating all their wealth and meaning they'd be unable to afford to travel outside their home town.
 
I would say it would only be worth the cost if it made people's lives happier (not necessarily in that generation) and was plausibly the best way of achieving that. I am dubious about ideals in the abstract of outcomes. Otherwise it becomes a little bit too much like doing it to keep one's own soul pure.


Isn't that the popular view of what happened in the 1860s? The North believed slavery was wrong and fought a war to force the South to comply?


Sure. Maybe we aren't so far apart? I don't think this is where we are going though. Gradually power has been pulled from the states to the federal government and a single centralised morality is being imposed on everybody. It's been bleeding out into the rest of theEnglish speaking world. That is one of the sources of the current tension.


shuttit, I don't see how our views could be any further apart, or our approach any more different:

1. I find racism vile. You ...clearly don't?

2. I think the idea that, to take it to specifics, marriage between races might not be "allowed", a monstrous thought, an utterly reprehensible proposal. You ...clearly don't?

3. You seem to believe that whatever the majority wills is what should happen. Your own position about individual issues, or at least, about this individual issue, seems ...amoral? utterly pragmatic? entirely free of value judgment? While mine isn't, and I don't.

4. You refuse to engage with the question of whether banning mixed race marriages is in your view a good thing. Because, it seems to me, you don't want to face your views on this, or at least make it evident to us. While I am upfront about this.

5. I could go on, but the biggest difference between us, as far as this issue, is that I oppose racism in the strongest possible terms. I think it a vile and barbaric idea, and indefensible on any scientific grounds. So that I actually find it offensive that my words should be twisted to make it appear that my POV might be at all similar to yours, when it comes to either the question of mixed marriages, or to racism generally.
 
Once again, I am baffled by your point of view. I have no idea why you believe I think millions of dead are a price worth paying for alignment with my views. What views? What dead? What do you think I am doing or saying to promote this? I'm an American, for sure, but unless you'd like to accept me as an immigrant, which seems unlikely, there's only so much I can do about the sins of the country I was born into.

In any case, I don't think I've ever seen you come up before with the direct answer I highlighted, which is what I was asking, so I will leave it, with apologies if I missed that specific statement previously. Consider it said.

It is my earnest belief that "stars aligning" aside, you cannot make society better by instituting something that makes it worse.

I remember an amusing, if fiercely utilitarian, old computer game called "Hamurabi," (the single M a concession to 8-character file names). In this game one is the administrator of a society with a small body of rules and a budget, and the kicker is that you must allow a certain percentage of your subjects to starve or the society will collapse. I don't think life is that simple.

You might make it better for some, more comfortable for some, even for a majority, but a society is a whole thing, and while the comfort of the many is one value, it is not the only one. In what essential way does your conditional acceptance of racism differ from that of genocide or slavery, other than your personal judgment of its importance?


Very well put. shuttit is either racist himself, or at the very least permissive and indeed supportive of racism on pragmatic grounds. Even if we should agree, charitably, with the latter view, that he is not a racist but only an extreme pragmatist, even then, as you point out here, to collude with that kind of evil is, effectively, to participate in it.
 
Well said.

And I am interested in what shuttlt would think if a majority (or maybe not a majority, just those with power) decided that it was in society's best interests to harm a group they belong to, say by confiscating all their wealth and meaning they'd be unable to afford to travel outside their home town.


I think he'd support such a move, on pragmatic grounds. He is, or claims to be, an extreme pragmatist, that would support summarily castrating all racists, should the majority want that.

I think he's hiding his actual racist ideas behind this guise of uber-pragmatist; but even if not, even if that is truly and honestly his position, even then, to collude with something as vile as racism is, in effect, to participate in it.
 
A society in which something is impossible isn't a society in which the impossible thing can be positive or negative because it is impossible. Do you want me to say whether it would be positive or negative if we changed society such that it were possible? It would depend how we changed society to make it possible. Maybe Chanakya understands this and can explain it to you, I don't know. There is no answer in my morality to the question that does not take into account the practicalities of implementing it and how it would play out. Given that it can't be implemented, I have no answer.

Your question is like demanding to know whether it is a good idea to drive to the moon. You can't drive to the moon, and if you somehow found a way of doing it.... the answer would probably depend a lot on knowing the details of how you proposed to do it. These things just aren't good or bad in a vacuum.


Yes. I have said this repeatedly. That is because of the structure of the liberal world view. You have universal goods that you can reason from and get answers to these kinds of questions.


There is no "should do" for me about impossibilities, certainly not when taken in isolation. That is another liberal trait.... looking at these things in isolation as if you could choose everything from the a la carte menu. Everything is intertwined. There is no "in isolation" answer to most of your questions.

And yet you have only offered a tautology: "If it's good I'm for it, if it's bad I'm against it."

However they come about, whether it be "Inalienable and endowed by a creator" or in alignment with some secular philosophy of universal rights, the basis of our constitutional government is that there are some rights taken as inherently worth preserving, that enough of us agree on to hold together as a nation. So I reject your apparent proposal that there can be no valid universal rights, or that it is a liberal-only idea.
 
shuttit, I don't see how our views could be any further apart, or our approach any more different:

1. I find racism vile. You ...clearly don't?
I might find the results of it vile sometimes. Fixating on the thing itself seems like puritanism to me.

2. I think the idea that, to take it to specifics, marriage between races might not be "allowed", a monstrous thought, an utterly reprehensible proposal. You ...clearly don't?
Depends what the results of it were. The thing itself doesn't bother me one way or the other.

3. You seem to believe that whatever the majority wills is what should happen.
No. I absolutely don't. I had rather thought that was the majority view of the forum. People keep banging on about "democracy" and the "popular vote".

Your own position about individual issues, or at least, about this individual issue, seems ...amoral? utterly pragmatic? entirely free of value judgment? While mine isn't, and I don't.
I'm not value free, but the world is a fallen place and man is a fallen animal. Do your values make the world better in a way that doesn't circularly refer back to your values? People complain about Christian morality being forced on people. You want to force your morality on people. I don't see much difference. It's just two different groups of people who are certain they know the right way to live. Again, ultimately I doubt your ability to persuade everybody to follow your morality.... so what then?

4. You refuse to engage with the question of whether banning mixed race marriages is in your view a good thing. Because, it seems to me, you don't want to face your views on this, or at least make it evident to us. While I am upfront about this.
Like I say. Mixed race marriage doesn't bother me. If in the distant future we get to the point where it becomes an issue, I'll probably have more of an opinion. I'm sure there are plenty of things religious people think are very important theoretical issues, but because your world view is different you wouldn't feel strongly about them.

One big difference i suspect is between us is that I see a lot more problems as coming from the implementation of liberal goods. I see a much more mixed and equivocal story. That just makes me more sceptical about jumping in with both feet without looking first.

5. I could go on, but the biggest difference between us, as far as this issue, is that I oppose racism in the strongest possible terms. I think it a vile and barbaric idea, and indefensible on any scientific grounds.
Why would one defend it on scientific grounds? What has that got to do with it? I'm curious.

So that I actually find it offensive that my words should be twisted to make it appear that my POV might be at all similar to yours, when it comes to either the question of mixed marriages, or to racism generally.
You are too easily offended. I didn't intend to twist your words. I found something we agreed on and I was pointing to commonality.
 
Last edited:
And yet you have only offered a tautology: "If it's good I'm for it, if it's bad I'm against it."
I'm running out of ways of telling you guys my position. My position is that when I think it is a good thing I am for it, when I think it is a bad thing I am against it, and when neither of those situations occurs I am somewhere in the middle. A 5 year old could understand my position. Where is the mystery here? I am not a liberal. I don't think about this like you.

However they come about, whether it be "Inalienable and endowed by a creator" or in alignment with some secular philosophy of universal rights, the basis of our constitutional government is that there are some rights taken as inherently worth preserving, that enough of us agree on to hold together as a nation.
That hasn't really been true since before the civil war. At this point, the constitution and the rest of it are like Bernie in Weekend at Bernie's. Sure many people still believe that the constitution is what governs everything, but it isn't. How did all the changes of the civil rights era get through without a change to the constitution? Beyond that, you have at least two different understandings of the constitution.

Thinking the constitution is enough to hold a country together is like thinking the bible is enough to hold a religion together. The Catholics couldn't even hold things together with the Orthodox church before Martin Luther. How many Protestant sects are there?

So I reject your apparent proposal that there can be no valid universal rights, or that it is a liberal-only idea.
What do you mean by "universal rights"? That somebody in the 18th Century slapped the word "universal" in front of a bunch of things the government said it was going to promise does not make them universal. The interpretations on them are so wildly different between the different sides and have so drift over time that they really only mean what the people who have the power to decide their meaning say they mean. What does it mean for constitutional rights to be universal in a world where judicial activism is an established judicial philosophy. There is nothing universal about them. Maybe you know this already, but the word Catholic means Universal. It aspires to be a universal church, but is it? Your rights aspire to be universal, but are they?

I guess in a sense any rights could be universal if you have the force of arms to make them so. Had the Jesuits had their way, the Catholic church would be universal. You don't have the power to make it universal. The rights are supposed to be self evident though, aren't they? They aren't universal in the sense that perhaps you have the military strength to force them on everybody, but that they are somehow natural truths that everyone will recognize. That's just false. Even within America there isn't agreement on what they mean.
 
Well said.

And I am interested in what shuttlt would think if a majority (or maybe not a majority, just those with power) decided that it was in society's best interests to harm a group they belong to, say by confiscating all their wealth and meaning they'd be unable to afford to travel outside their home town.
I'd be against it of course, but I'm not sure what that I've said before that clashes with it.
 
Once again, I am baffled by your point of view. I have no idea why you believe I think millions of dead are a price worth paying for alignment with my views. What views? What dead? What do you think I am doing or saying to promote this? I'm an American, for sure, but unless you'd like to accept me as an immigrant, which seems unlikely, there's only so much I can do about the sins of the country I was born into.
Sorry, I assumed you thought for example that the Civil War was good and just. There has been quite a bit of killing over the years in the service of progressive liberal values. If you think the Civil War was a mistake, then I take it back. You don't just get to have the society you want without a human cost.

In any case, I don't think I've ever seen you come up before with the direct answer I highlighted, which is what I was asking, so I will leave it, with apologies if I missed that specific statement previously. Consider it said.

It is my earnest belief that "stars aligning" aside, you cannot make society better by instituting something that makes it worse.
In that case I think you are an idealistic dreamer. Freeing the slaves killed three quarters of a million people, habeas corpus was withdrawn, the south was thrown into poverty and countless people were thrown into the most wretched poverty for the rest of their lives. The initial impact was definitely to make things worse. Am I misunderstanding what you mean by "better"?

I remember an amusing, if fiercely utilitarian, old computer game called "Hamurabi," (the single M a concession to 8-character file names). In this game one is the administrator of a society with a small body of rules and a budget, and the kicker is that you must allow a certain percentage of your subjects to starve or the society will collapse. I don't think life is that simple.
I played a similar game called Yellow River Kingdom. I agree that things are not that simple.

You might make it better for some, more comfortable for some, even for a majority, but a society is a whole thing, and while the comfort of the many is one value, it is not the only one. In what essential way does your conditional acceptance of racism differ from that of genocide or slavery, other than your personal judgment of its importance?
What is there beyond one's personal judgement?
 
I think he'd support such a move, on pragmatic grounds. He is, or claims to be, an extreme pragmatist, that would support summarily castrating all racists, should the majority want that.
You are wrong.

I think he's hiding his actual racist ideas behind this guise of uber-pragmatist; but even if not, even if that is truly and honestly his position, even then, to collude with something as vile as racism is, in effect, to participate in it.
And wrong again. I am telling you what I think.
 
I might find the results of it vile sometimes. Fixating on the thing itself seems like puritanism to me.


Depends what the results of it were. The thing itself doesn't bother me one way or the other.


No. I absolutely don't. I had rather thought that was the majority view of the forum. People keep banging on about "democracy" and the "popular vote".


I'm not value free, but the world is a fallen place and man is a fallen animal. Do your values make the world better in a way that doesn't circularly refer back to your values? People complain about Christian morality being forced on people. You want to force your morality on people. I don't see much difference. It's just two different groups of people who are certain they know the right way to live. Again, ultimately I doubt your ability to persuade everybody to follow your morality.... so what then?


Like I say. Mixed race marriage doesn't bother me. If in the distant future we get to the point where it becomes an issue, I'll probably have more of an opinion. I'm sure there are plenty of things religious people think are very important theoretical issues, but because your world view is different you wouldn't feel strongly about them.

One big difference i suspect is between us is that I see a lot more problems as coming from the implementation of liberal goods. I see a much more mixed and equivocal story. That just makes me more sceptical about jumping in with both feet without looking first.


Why would one defend it on scientific grounds? What has that got to do with it? I'm curious.


You are too easily offended. I didn't intend to twist your words. I found something we agreed on and I was pointing to commonality.

That seems rather disingenuous. It's a law, not an attitude. The "thing" under discussion is a law which means that people doing a certain act are prosecuted. The Supreme court case that ended those laws concerned a real prosecution and a real sentence. Whatever beneficial consequences you can infer from such a law, they are conjectural, and may or may not be achievable by other means. But some results are exactly known, because it's a law, and the result of a law is what it is a law about, when it is enforced. A law forbidding certain behavior treats that behavior as criminal, and punishes or nullifies it. We know this. We know exactly what that exact law exactly did when it was a law!

Of course we're entitled to our opinions and all that, but I contend that a law that is in itself wrong has little hope of accomplishing the kind of right we ought to be striving for. And a law that is not only wrong, but based on false ideas and outright nonsense as race laws are, has even less chance.
 
Very well put. shuttit is either racist himself, or at the very least permissive and indeed supportive of racism on pragmatic grounds. Even if we should agree, charitably, with the latter view, that he is not a racist but only an extreme pragmatist, even then, as you point out here, to collude with that kind of evil is, effectively, to participate in it.
I thought you had understood me. You do not.
 
That seems rather disingenuous. It's a law, not an attitude. The "thing" under discussion is a law which means that people doing a certain act are prosecuted.
That is a myopically narrow view of what the results of passing a law are.

The Supreme court case that ended those laws concerned a real prosecution and a real sentence. Whatever beneficial consequences you can infer from such a law, they are conjectural, and may or may not be achievable by other means.
Sure.

But some results are exactly known, because it's a law, and the result of a law is what it is a law about, when it is enforced.
OK. But we surely don't restrict our considerations to only the effects that are 100% guaranteed?

A law forbidding certain behavior treats that behavior as criminal, and punishes or nullifies it. We know this. We know exactly what that exact law exactly did when it was a law!
You know some of the things it did and you are restricting the discussion down to a subset of them. I'm not.

Of course we're entitled to our opinions and all that, but I contend that a law that is in itself wrong has little hope of accomplishing the kind of right we ought to be striving for.
I think a law that is implemented completely ignoring the social impacts, incentives and other consequences of the law is an ill thought out law.Don't we hear a lot about how if abortion was illegal that will cause women to seek back alley abortions. I don't think the laws mandate that, yet we are asked to consider it in opposing such laws. Should we not consider things like that? If the only impact of abortion laws is that foetuses don't die, then why would anybody oppose them?

And a law that is not only wrong, but based on false ideas and outright nonsense as race laws are, has even less chance.
You are viewing this ideologically.
 
Last edited:
I might find the results of it vile sometimes. Fixating on the thing itself seems like puritanism to me.


Depends what the results of it were. The thing itself doesn't bother me one way or the other.


No. I absolutely don't. I had rather thought that was the majority view of the forum. People keep banging on about "democracy" and the "popular vote".


I'm not value free, but the world is a fallen place and man is a fallen animal. Do your values make the world better in a way that doesn't circularly refer back to your values? People complain about Christian morality being forced on people. You want to force your morality on people. I don't see much difference. It's just two different groups of people who are certain they know the right way to live. Again, ultimately I doubt your ability to persuade everybody to follow your morality.... so what then?


Like I say. Mixed race marriage doesn't bother me. If in the distant future we get to the point where it becomes an issue, I'll probably have more of an opinion. I'm sure there are plenty of things religious people think are very important theoretical issues, but because your world view is different you wouldn't feel strongly about them.

One big difference i suspect is between us is that I see a lot more problems as coming from the implementation of liberal goods. I see a much more mixed and equivocal story. That just makes me more sceptical about jumping in with both feet without looking first.


Why would one defend it on scientific grounds? What has that got to do with it? I'm curious.


I mention that, and in addition to and separately from the fact that it is vile, because I've seen some racists try to claim their POV is "scientific".


You are too easily offended. I didn't intend to twist your words. I found something we agreed on and I was pointing to commonality.


We don't, either one of us, want to be instrumental in causing death and destruction, no matter the 'cause'. That is a commonality, true.

But beyond that starting point our views seem to diverge utterly. You seem to take the above as grounds for remaining apparently value-free, and opinion-free, even on such extreme issues as banning mixed marriages--and castrating racists! While I'd consider either utterly vile, and do what I could to stop them. I guess I'd stop short of advocating killing people at large to have my views carry the day, but I'd never be complicit in something like either on grounds of pragmatism.

But that much, sure. I don't think I have the stomach for advocating killing others in order to have society conform with what I believe. But that's very different than therefore adopting, or at least becoming permissive/supportive of, racism.


------------------


To be frank, I think you're only using pragmatism as a fig leaf. Throwing in our willingness or otherwise to kill others as a distraction. What is YOUR view on racism, and on mixed marriages, independent of what others around you might want? It might help if you'd squarely answer those questions, that people keep asking, and that you keep avoiding.

You do say you'd view the results to arrive at your opinion case-by-case, but that's clearly a dodge. (Whether it's us you're dodging, or your own self, that I don't know!) Because the same might be said about ANY marriage. Surely you wouldn't point to an utterly agnostic case-by-case pragmatism if it came to a question of, I don't know, banning marriages altogether? That sounds crazy, I know; but without the blinkers of racism, even considering banning mixed marriages sounds no less crazy.

You seem, at best, to be indifferent to these questions (and, at worst, supportive of them, but hide that support behind apparent pragmatism). Even granted merely indifference, even then, that makes our respective positions on racism, and specifically on mixed marriages, not even remotely similar.
 
I mention that, and in addition to and separately from the fact that it is vile, because I've seen some racists try to claim their POV is "scientific".
Yeah, that's not a big thing with me either. Certainly not in relation to anything we are talking about.

I'll have to reply to the rest later.
 
But beyond that starting point our views seem to diverge utterly. You seem to take the above as grounds for remaining apparently value-free, and opinion-free,
Final thought that I will forget if I don't say it now. What you said just struck me as being very Platonic. It's like for you there is a world of abstract forms where things like racism have properties - like being wicked. They can be good or bad as a property of the idea. I don't believe in this ideal "form" of racism. There are only instances in the mud and contradiction of the real world.
 
Last edited:
You are wrong.


And wrong again. I am telling you what I think.


I thought you had understood me. You do not.


Pardon me, but I cannot help seeing in your appeal to case-by-case pragmatism a dodge.

What are your views on banning marriages between people of different colors of hair, or eyes? Of different ranges of height or weight? Different religions? Or, hell, banning marriages altogether, then?

The question of banning mixed marriages is one that makes any sense at all, even conditionally, only to a decidedly racist mindset.
 
That is a myopically narrow view of what the results of passing a law are.


Sure.


OK. But we surely don't restrict our considerations to only the effects that are 100% guaranteed?


You know some of the things it did and you are restricting the discussion down to a subset of them. I'm not.


I think a law that is implemented completely ignoring the social impacts, incentives and other consequences of the law is an ill thought out law.Don't we hear a lot about how if abortion was illegal that will cause women to seek back alley abortions. I don't think the laws mandate that, yet we are asked to consider it in opposing such laws. Should we not consider things like that? If the only impact of abortion laws is that foetuses don't die, then why would anybody oppose them?


You are viewing this ideologically.

Of course you don't know all the consequences of any law, or much of anything else, really. But you know some of them, and in some cases (such as the racist laws I have been talking about) it's quite true that those framing them did not ignore the social impacts, incentives and other consequences of the law. Race laws were meant to have far reaching social consequences and incentives and disincentives.

We don't want to limit ourselves to the results of a law that are 100 percent guaranteed, but if the results that are 100 percent guaranteed are bad enough, the good that might eventually result might best be ignored.

What law can possibly be contemplated if one cannot consider its immediate, intended effect first? Even if a cloud has a silver lining, it's cold comfort if it floods you and you drown. Religious nincompoops comfort the bereaved when a child dies, saying it goes to heaven and is folded up in God's embrace, but that grand possibility does not make it all right to murder children. I would contend that something that is wrong at its very foundation is wrong to do, even if something good might come of it at the end.

I think your abortion ban analogy has a flaw here, for that very reason, though not for that reason alone. If race laws are considered in their entirety, in terms of the reasonably likely effects on society, on what I think most decent human beings would consider virtue, stability and order in the long term, justice, even godliness if you're inclined to think along those lines, they're bad. History does them no favors either. You have to have a pretty florid imagination, and stretch things in a very arguable way, I think, to make racism come out well in the long run.

But if individual racist laws are taken alone, as just what they are, without those consequences, they are still bad.

Of course I know you look at things differently, have a different set of values, and probably would run a different algorithm to come up with the social consequences you like, and and likely manage, while surmising unknown, unknowable, speculative benefits, to accuse others of excessive abstraction.

I still contend that if racism is required to make a society great, it is a racist society and its greatness oxymoronic, no matter whether there's a chance the remaining majority will crack the secrets of time, speak sonnets in their sleep, do ten good deeds before breakfast, and piss rainbows.
 
Whiteness is a spurious American notion that has little to no relevance to European affairs. The people who think there's any significant commonality between Spaniards, Russians, Swedes and etc because of distant genealogical ties is laughably mistaken. If there was then Americans wouldn't be distinguishing between "White Americans" and "Latino Americans".
 
I'm not going to respond to nonsense like this. If people want to talk, I will talk.


Tell us what you think Burke’s position on mixed-race marriages was, and give us proper references as evidence to back up your assertion, and we can talk about it. If you won’t give any information or specific reference beyond “read Burke” there isn’t anything to discuss. You imply that Burke agreed with the proposition that mixed-race marriages would lead to ‘chaos’. It’s up to you to provide specific references references to back up your assertion.

As it is, I’m going to take your response as a “don’t know and don’t want to talk about it.”
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom