Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Young kids who are not brought up with racism don't care about skin colour. When my kids were young, I could see how they and their friends played together.

And how they described which friend was which.

How dare you risk your children by exposing them to different races cultures !

You should have taught them that exposure to lesser different races cultures risks diluting their own blood race culture. :rolleyes:
 
Anecdote from long ago when I was 15 or so. I was on my way home in the bus when an older lady, about 60 or so, sat next to me and then started complaining about how the youth of today was rotten and how there was so much more violence in the streets etc etc.
I got fed up and told her that when she was my age dutch Blackshirts were marching down the streets beating up anyone disagreeing with their politics or actual razzias.

She got angry and moved to a different part of the bus.

I am old enough to remember when 'Paki-bashing' was a thing in Britain. :(
Before that, there was the Mods vs Rockers rivalry, in which Bank Holidays were characterised by mass gang fights in seaside resorts such as Brighton.

There is a tendency for people to hark back to a golden age that basically never existed, and also one to imagine the world is a much more violent and nasty place than it actually is. It's kind of like the Matrix: people want things to be bad, and will invent problems when there aren't enough. The Matrix had to be changed to include misery and violence, because people wouldn't believe in the better, more utopian version they were originally plugged into.
 
OK, let's look at how much violent crime there is.
Oh, it's been declining steadily, worldwide, for decades.
Interestingly, one of the reasons given for the fall in violent crime rates is........*drumroll*........
Immigration!



https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_drop

The graphs in this link are quite illuminating- they show a dramatic drop in homicide rates, from the Middle Ages up to the present.
With reference to the topic of this thread, it is interesting to note that the supposed golden ages of white majorities and limited immigration that the OP wishes to preserve were characterised by markedly high rates of violence.
This is an interesting post. I'm aware of the graphs. Pinker wrote a book on it. There is too much here for a quick response.
 
Young kids who are not brought up with racism don't care about skin colour. When my kids were young, I could see how they and their friends played together.

And how they described which friend was which.
Sure, perhaps. The recent posts have been mentioning multiculturalism. Thinking about it, I'm puzzled what some people on this thread must think multiculturalism means since supposedly America has one culture called "American culture" that everybody has by virtue of being an American. Anyway, one of the issues with multiculturalism is that it encourages immigrants to retain their different cultures, hence preserving race as a good proxy for culture.

When your children moved out into the world, if they moved amongst the great mass of the population, they would have found black people who are biased in favour of other black people, latino people who are biased in favour of other latino people and so on. About the only people who aren't like this are white progressives who are biased against white people. They would also discover that out in the world race does carry information about people, for example due to affirmative action, if they went to university they would likely see asians at the top of the class, while black students struggle at the bottom. If they were mugged, it is disproportionately likely to be by a black man. It's possible to shield children from these things, but people aren't racist for no reason.
 
Last edited:
One more time, as the information clearly hasn't been processed:
The definition of racism:

  • Prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism by an individual, community, or institution against a person or people on the basis of their membership of a particular racial or ethnic group, typically one that is a minority or marginalized.
  • The belief that different races possess distinct characteristics, abilities, or qualities, especially so as to distinguish them as inferior or superior to one another.
 
Sure, perhaps. The recent posts have been mentioning multiculturalism. Thinking about it, I'm puzzled what some people on this thread must think multiculturalism means since supposedly America has one culture called "American culture" that everybody has by virtue of being an American. Anyway, one of the issues with multiculturalism is that it encourages immigrants to retain their different cultures, hence preserving race as a good proxy for culture.

When your children moved out into the world, if they moved amongst the great mass of the population, they would have found black people who are biased in favour of other black people, latino people who are biased in favour of other latino people and so on. About the only people who aren't like this are white progressives who are biased against white people. They would also discover that out in the world race does carry information about people, for example due to affirmative action, if they went to university they would likely see asians at the top of the class, while black students struggle at the bottom. If they were mugged, it is disproportionately likely to be by a black man. It's possible to shield children from these things, but people aren't racist for no reason.

Wow, extremely weak points, like always.:jaw-dropp
 
I am old enough to remember when 'Paki-bashing' was a thing in Britain. :(
Before that, there was the Mods vs Rockers rivalry, in which Bank Holidays were characterised by mass gang fights in seaside resorts such as Brighton.

There is a tendency for people to hark back to a golden age that basically never existed, and also one to imagine the world is a much more violent and nasty place than it actually is. It's kind of like the Matrix: people want things to be bad, and will invent problems when there aren't enough. The Matrix had to be changed to include misery and violence, because people wouldn't believe in the better, more utopian version they were originally plugged into.
As Trevor Phillips says, were these problems actually fixed, or were they just suppressed? Making something socially unacceptable doesn't necessarily fix the issues that were driving it.
 
Ok, but if it turns out not in fact to be possible to teach these things away?
It may not be possible to "teach them away" but it's certainly possible to teach that they are unacceptable ways for a civilised person to behave, so they have repercussions.

Tolerating these things or not doesn't make them go away. Violent crime is discouraged and look at how much violent crime there is.
But nobody is saying it's acceptable, let alone a good thing. It's punished, not indulged.

Maybe that isn't what you expect to happen, but I think it underpins a lot of the arguments.
I do expect uncivilised people to continue to behave like uncivilised people, of course I do. I also expect them to be told that such behavior is not considered acceptable, and to be punished when they harm other people.
 
I am old enough to remember when 'Paki-bashing' was a thing in Britain. :(
Before that, there was the Mods vs Rockers rivalry, in which Bank Holidays were characterised by mass gang fights in seaside resorts such as Brighton.

There is a tendency for people to hark back to a golden age that basically never existed, and also one to imagine the world is a much more violent and nasty place than it actually is. It's kind of like the Matrix: people want things to be bad, and will invent problems when there aren't enough. The Matrix had to be changed to include misery and violence, because people wouldn't believe in the better, more utopian version they were originally plugged into.

With fish-hooks and razor blades sewn into lapels so if someone tried to get hold of you by your lapels they sliced their fingers open.

Just when I was young it would be rare on a night out on the town - and this was in the old licencing regimes of pubs closing at 10:30 and 11 - that you wouldn't have been in a pub where someone had got glassed that night.
 
Sure, perhaps. The recent posts have been mentioning multiculturalism. Thinking about it, I'm puzzled what some people on this thread must think multiculturalism means since supposedly America has one culture called "American culture" that everybody has by virtue of being an American. Anyway, one of the issues with multiculturalism is that it encourages immigrants to retain their different cultures, hence preserving race as a good proxy for culture.

When your children moved out into the world, if they moved amongst the great mass of the population, they would have found black people who are biased in favour of other black people, latino people who are biased in favour of other latino people and so on. About the only people who aren't like this are white progressives who are biased against white people. They would also discover that out in the world race does carry information about people, for example due to affirmative action, if they went to university they would likely see asians at the top of the class, while black students struggle at the bottom. If they were mugged, it is disproportionately likely to be by a black man. It's possible to shield children from these things, but people aren't racist for no reason.

Now you understand why we are puzzled what you mean by "European Culture".... but carry on, one rule for them eh?
 
...snip...

Tolerating these things or not doesn't make them go away. Violent crime is discouraged and look at how much violent crime there is. Maybe that isn't what you expect to happen, but I think it underpins a lot of the arguments.

Actually, violent crime was previously not discouraged in the same way it is today. That aside you pick an example that would seem to prove the point others are making.
 
The underlying trend continues to be from barbarism to civilisation, despite the occasional setback. That doesn't mean we'll ever reach a point when there are no more barbarians.
 
Sure, perhaps. The recent posts have been mentioning multiculturalism. Thinking about it, I'm puzzled what some people on this thread must think multiculturalism means since supposedly America has one culture called "American culture" that everybody has by virtue of being an American. Anyway, one of the issues with multiculturalism is that it encourages immigrants to retain their different cultures, hence preserving race as a good proxy for culture.

So you have never been to the US and only learned about it from film?
 
The recent posts have been mentioning multiculturalism. Thinking about it, I'm puzzled what some people on this thread must think multiculturalism means since supposedly America has one culture called "American culture" that everybody has by virtue of being an American.
:confused:

It's hard for me to believe that anyone who has actually lived in the United States thinks there is only 'one culture called "American culture" that everybody has by virtue of being an American.'

No one who has lived in Texas could believe that. As Molly Ivins wrote in Texas Observed:
Molly Ivins said:
Texas is a mosaic of cultures, which overlap in several parts of the state and form layers, with the darker layers on the bottom. The cultures are black, Chicano, Southern, freak, suburban, and ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊. (◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ is dominant.) They are all rotten for women. Humanism is not alive and well in Texas. Different colors and types of Texans do not like one another, nor do they pretend to.

....snip....

Texas is not a civilized place. Texans shoot one another a lot. They also knife, razor, and stomp one another to death with some frequency. And they fight in bars all the time. You can get five years for murder and 99 for pot possession in this state—watch your ass.
Texas endures 12.7 gun deaths per 100,000 citizens per year. Terrible though it is, that awful statistic is slightly below the average rate of gun deaths among the 50 states of the US.

...but people aren't racist for no reason.
True, but shuttit has been more eager to obscure those reasons than to expose them.
 
Last edited:
It may not be possible to "teach them away" but it's certainly possible to teach that they are unacceptable ways for a civilised person to behave, so they have repercussions.
OK. But the thing there is that while the attitudes to immigration may go up and down, in the UK at least, those who think that there is too much immigration has always dwarfed the number who would be keen for more. You have a minority tone policing the majority, while at the same time increasing the thing driving that discontent.

But nobody is saying it's acceptable, let alone a good thing. It's punished, not indulged.
Right, but punishing it doesn't make it go away. What you are doing is suppressing it.

I do expect uncivilised people to continue to behave like uncivilised people, of course I do. I also expect them to be told that such behavior is not considered acceptable, and to be punished when they harm other people.
OK. This is straightforward. The views you are advocating are effectively the views of the elite, the media class and so on. What we are talking about is that class imposing its will on the rest of the country and suppressing dissent. I don't disagree that that is what has happened, and to some degree what has always happened. Does it make the causes of the dissent go away though? This goes back to the Fabians despising the poor in whose benefit they were supposedly working.

Having said that ... in some ways immigration will make the problem better in that if there is no longer a united majority culture, it becomes less of an obstacle to the changes. The Amazon diversity solution to unions. The Tower of Babel as a model for power. The immigrants who have been brought in may be racist as well, but they will be made stronger by immigration and so will likely support it. From a Machiavellian point of view, it looks OK, but it also looks like a recipe for unresolvable racial strife.

At the end of the day, this is your tribe vs my tribe.
 
Last edited:
OK. But the thing there is that while the attitudes to immigration may go up and down, in the UK at least, those who think that there is too much immigration has always dwarfed the number who would be keen for more. You have a minority tone policing the majority, while at the same time increasing the thing driving that discontent.


Right, but punishing it doesn't make it go away. What you are doing is suppressing it.


OK. This is straightforward. The views you are advocating are effectively the views of the elite, the media class and so on. What we are talking about is that class imposing its will on the rest of the country and suppressing dissent. I don't disagree that that is what has happened, and to some degree what has always happened. Does it make the causes of the dissent go away though? This goes back to the Fabians despising the poor in whose benefit they were supposedly working.

Having said that ... in some ways immigration will make the problem better in that if there is no longer a united majority culture, it becomes less of an obstacle to the changes. The Amazon diversity solution to unions. The Tower of Babel as a model for power. The immigrants who have been brought in may be racist as well, but they will be made stronger by immigration and so will likely support it. From a Machiavellian point of view, it looks OK, but it also looks like a recipe for unresolvable racial strife.

At the end of the day, this is your tribe vs my tribe.

This is what right wing extremists want you to think. It's very weak of course but quite the amount of people believes this.
 
OK. But the thing there is that while the attitudes to immigration may go up and down, in the UK at least, those who think that there is too much immigration has always dwarfed the number who would be keen for more. You have a minority tone policing the majority, while at the same time increasing the thing driving that discontent.
The subject of this discussion AIUI is the ethnic diversity of the immigration, not the number of immigrants. You can limit the number if it's deemed necessary without discriminating on the basis of ethnicity.

Right, but punishing it doesn't make it go away. What you are doing is suppressing it.
It's probably impossible to make it go away entirely, but history shows you can reduce it. Everything from murder rates to blood sports demonstrates that trend.

OK. This is straightforward. The views you are advocating are effectively the views of the elite, the media class and so on. What we are talking about is that class imposing its will on the rest of the country and suppressing dissent.
I'm advocating civilised people imposing their will on barbarians. Note that is not a characteristic you're born with like ethnicity, it's a "content of their character" thing. Some of the worst barbarians are rich and white.

I don't disagree that that is what has happened, and to some degree what has always happened. Does it make the causes of the dissent go away though?
It reduces the incidence of barbaric behavior.

This goes back to the Fabians despising the poor in whose benefit they were supposedly working.
I despise barbarians no matter how rich or poor they are.

At the end of the day, this is your tribe vs my tribe.
No, it's the civilised vs the barbarians.
 
There seems to be a lot of the "Get them before the get us" rightious murder fantasy of

"If I were to come at you and try to kill you, you'd defend yourself, right?"
"Right."
"Well that's all the justification I need to come and kill you"

in the racial purity world view.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom