Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jesus, who the hell cares??? HM posted about burger flipping A page before I did, but it utterly doesn't matter. I'll take credit. Whatever. It simply doesn't matter. When posters repeat, both contextually and subtextully, that prostitution is a job like any other, it doesn't matter which job you use to illustrate that. Can you grit your teeth and discuss something relevant?
The thing is, not all service jobs are equivalent to each other. Being a burger flipper in a cheap fast food joint is not the same thing as being a waiter at an expensive Michelin starred restaurant, or a bellhop at a high-class hotel. You chose burger flipper to make your analogy. You could have chosen something more prestigious, but you didn't.

So when you say "a job like any other" you do actually have to specify what "other" you are comparing it to. Because there are a lot of different "others".
 
The thing is, not all service jobs are equivalent to each other. Being a burger flipper in a cheap fast food joint is not the same thing as being a waiter at an expensive Michelin starred restaurant, or a bellhop at a high-class hotel. You chose burger flipper to make your analogy. You could have chosen something more prestigious, but you didn't.

So when you say "a job like any other" you do actually have to specify what "other" you are comparing it to. Because there are a lot of different "others".

Yet when you were asked earlier why you chose "garbage collector" for one of your examples, you said:

I picked it at random. Almost any other profession would have equally served as an example.

Seems you let yourself off pretty easy when you give the same answer.

I chose burger flipper because it is another basically unskilled job, but requiring a few mature responsibilities (operating a dangerously hot griddle and other things not entrusted to an actual child). But like your garbage collecter, almost any unskilled job is interchangeable in terms of the point made.

So were you going somewhere else with taking me to task on this one?
 
So were you going somewhere else with taking me to task on this one?
Different context, Thermal, different context. I mentioned the job of garbage collectors as a specific example of a profession that one might (or might not) suggest as a career. I wasn't saying that prostitution is just like being a garbage collector.

You're not going to gotcha me with a context shift that hard.

ETA: And who says that prostitution is anything like an unskilled job?
 
Refreshing to find something upon which I and Thermal agree.

Indeed many women seem to prefer a much shorter and more agile appendage.

Its unfortunate that we have stated rules against this topic, because I think it makes for a valuable sharing experience.

When I was 16, I asked my father to sign a permission form to play soccer. He looked at me cross eyed drunk and evidently thought I asked him how to sexually satisfy a woman, which he went on to ramble about in graphic detail for about 20 minutes. That inebriated Ted Talk dramatically changed the course of my life.
 
Different context, Thermal, different context. I mentioned the job of garbage collectors as a specific example of a profession that one might (or might not) suggest as a career. I wasn't saying that prostitution is just like being a garbage collector.

You're not going to gotcha me with a context shift that hard.

Different context, yes, but identical theme. A random job was needed to compare. Why do you feel the need to scrutinize mine? It means nothing except to fill loose base criteria.

ETA: And who says that prostitution is anything like an unskilled job?

The same people that would say any of the other jobs mentioned are unskilled. No formal training needed. Most everything is in an adults wheelhouse already, with a few specialties aside. The training needed to be an effective sex worker could be run down in a matter of minutes. An article upthread stated that the prerequisites for working at a Nevada brothel were face and body pics.
 
Wrongly IMO. It is a service in which a person may be gainfully employed. In countries with full legalization such as Australia, New Zealand, Indonesia, the Philippines and over a dozen others, it is a legitimate, taxable form of employment or self-employment. Its a job in which the worker is supplying a service to satisfy a demand.

So is a hit man or drug dealer. And before you start in about consenting adults and no one getting hurt, I am solely responding to your characterization of a supplier filling a demand. Simply providing a service does not mean the service you provide is "like any other". Combat soldiers provide a service. It's not like any ******* other.


Utter bollocks. That might be partially that case in a progressively backward countries with archaic views on morality, such as the USA, but it is simply not true in any enlightened country with legalized prostitution.

LOL, I am referring to the brothel workers and owners in NZ and Straya. In every article presented, they change the names of those interviewed and the owners names, and picture no one. I even mentioned earlier that I thought it was strange that they were so clandestine, where here in the States, the Nevada brothel owners are all identified by real names, and face pics provided of the working ladies. No, it's not us with the weird hangups this time.

I mean, how is a prostitute going to get clients in a legal environment if they are as hell-bent as you claim on hiding who they are and what they do?

Um...by going to a brothel and seeing them behind closed doors? By word of mouth reference? It's not that complicated.



Correct!



Wrong!

An essential component of the strawman is the replacement of one argument with another argument that the proposer did not make.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man

"A strawman is a form of argument and an informal fallacy of having the impression of refuting an argument, whereas the real subject of the argument was not addressed or refuted, but instead replaced with a false one. One who engages in this fallacy is said to be "attacking a straw man".

"The typical straw man argument creates the illusion of having refuted or defeated an opponent's proposition through the covert replacement of it with a different proposition and the subsequent refutation of that false argument ("knock down a straw man") instead of the opponent's proposition."​
.
.

Seriously man? The thread has been auctioned twice for derailing into fallacy disputes specifically, and you're trying to bait us into a third round?
 
So is a hit man or drug dealer.

Nope.

Drug dealing is a crime in which people routinely get hurt or die.

Killing people for money is a crime in which people are... err, killed.

Prostitution is not a crime in dozens of countires, and is in any case victimless.

And before you start in about consenting adults and no one getting hurt...

Your pathetic attempt at poisoning the well is noted and summarily ignored forthwith.

I am solely responding to your characterization of a supplier filling a demand.

Of course, this is just mischaracterization.


Simply providing a service does not mean the service you provide is "like any other". Combat soldiers provide a service. It's not like any ******* other.

Who said anything about combat soldiers? This is just more mischaracterization - and a strawman to boot.

LOL, I am referring to the brothel workers and owners in NZ and Straya. In every article presented, they change the names of those interviewed and the owners names, and picture no one. I even mentioned earlier that I thought it was strange that they were so clandestine, where here in the States, the Nevada brothel owners are all identified by real names, and face pics provided of the working ladies. No, it's not us with the weird hangups this time.

Oh FFS, ROFL. Many, many people do not want their name or identity revealed in articles or TV interviews. I was interviewed on local TV and for "Stuff" about some trouble at a local gang HQ. I asked not to be named and to have my face blurred as a condition. They both complied.

Hint: I'm not a sex worker.


Seriously man? The thread has been auctioned twice for derailing into fallacy disputes specifically, and you're trying to bait us into a third round?

:rolleyes:
 
Different context, yes, but identical theme. A random job was needed to compare. Why do you feel the need to scrutinize mine? It means nothing except to fill loose base criteria.
Let's just say that I think it's an inappropriate analogy in this case and move on.

The same people that would say any of the other jobs mentioned are unskilled. No formal training needed. Most everything is in an adults wheelhouse already, with a few specialties aside. The training needed to be an effective sex worker could be run down in a matter of minutes. An article upthread stated that the prerequisites for working at a Nevada brothel were face and body pics.
You're still using the flawed, dysfunctional and only barely-legal Nevada model as a typical example. It's not.

Let's be clear here: Nevada boasts the worst example of legalised prostitution in the world.

Now that we've got that out of the way, let me assure you that workers in a functional and regulated legal brothel do undergo mandatory training. Sure, it's not as much training as an engineer gets, but they get training on their legal rights and obligations, their health and hygiene requirements, safety and security, and privacy before they are allowed to start work. The regulatory framework requires this, and it takes longer than a few minutes.
 
LOL, I am referring to the brothel workers and owners in NZ and Straya. In every article presented, they change the names of those interviewed and the owners names, and picture no one. I even mentioned earlier that I thought it was strange that they were so clandestine, where here in the States, the Nevada brothel owners are all identified by real names, and face pics provided of the working ladies. No, it's not us with the weird hangups this time.
You really can't see why privacy might be appropriate here?
 
Let's just say that I think it's an inappropriate analogy in this case and move on.

You're still using the flawed, dysfunctional and only barely-legal Nevada model as a typical example. It's not.

Let's be clear here: Nevada boasts the worst example of legalised prostitution in the world.

Now that we've got that out of the way, let me assure you that workers in a functional and regulated legal brothel do undergo mandatory training. Sure, it's not as much training as an engineer gets, but they get training on their legal rights and obligations, their health and hygiene requirements, safety and security, and privacy before they are allowed to start work. The regulatory framework requires this, and it takes longer than a few minutes.

Ok. So does our intrepid burger flipper (recall that I chose that profession as an example because they would also have to receive some degree of light training with commercial kitchen equipment and all), and would also be familiarized with safety and cooking hygiene requirements etc etc. Yet it is inarguably unskilled work, requiring no previous training.

We could cut to the chase, and you could say what prerequisite training is required of Austrailian sex workers if you like? Or might the answer be "none"?
 
Ok. So does our intrepid burger flipper (recall that I chose that profession as an example because they would also have to receive some degree of light training with commercial kitchen equipment and all), and would also be familiarized with safety and cooking hygiene requirements etc etc. Yet it is inarguably unskilled work, requiring no previous training.

We could cut to the chase, and you could say what prerequisite training is required of Austrailian sex workers if you like? Or might the answer be "none"?
Well, like I said, it certainly wouldn't be as extensive as an engineer would require, but I would dispute that it is "unskilled work". And some of the training - such as, for example, training in legal protections and obligations and in personal physical security - would not be required for a burger flipper.

And while I have no personal experience with this, I can certainly envision the more high-end brothels providing some training in... er... "professional skills".

Sure. There is a heavy stigma attached to the work. If there wasn't, why all the cloak and dagger?
It's not "cloak-and-dagger". It's simply a reasonable expectation of privacy. I don't give my surname out to my callers at work. Am I being clandestine? Or might there be an actual legitimate reason why I don't do that?

Oh, and I should add here that I do not dispute that there is still a stigma attached to sex work. We're not quite that utopian yet.
 
Ok. So does our intrepid burger flipper (recall that I chose that profession as an example because they would also have to receive some degree of light training with commercial kitchen equipment and all), and would also be familiarized with safety and cooking hygiene requirements etc etc. Yet it is inarguably unskilled work, requiring no previous training.
We could cut to the chase, and you could say what prerequisite training is required of Austrailian sex workers if you like? Or might the answer be "none"?

I know for a fact (because I have witnessed it) that workers at McDonalds and many, many other fast food outlets in Australia train their staff to Cert III level (the same level as a carpenter or cook). Why do they do such a costly thing? Because staff are more competent across a whole range of areas like customer contact, food preparation, supervision where appropriate, health and safety and food safety; they are more confident; and they stick with the job longer than untrained staff.

Just because fast food workers are not trained in the US, this is hardly a universal thing.

Working in a fast food outlet is not unskilled work. Neither is working in a licensed brothal.
 
Well, like I said, it certainly wouldn't be as extensive as an engineer would require, but I would dispute that it is "unskilled work". And some of the training - such as, for example, training in legal protections and obligations and in personal physical security - would not be required for a burger flipper.

And while I have no personal experience with this, I can certainly envision the more high-end brothels providing some training in... er... "professional skills".

Well, all in, I'd say a lass with an average sexual history could walk in off the street one afternoon and be a functional prostitute by evening. Don't know if there was any point in whittling away further at the precise skill level.

It's not "cloak-and-dagger". It's simply a reasonable expectation of privacy. I don't give my surname out to my callers at work. Am I being clandestine? Or might there be an actual legitimate reason why I don't do that?

By contrast, I am a contractor in NJ USA. I simply do not have the option to have ""privacy". My name, town, and registration number must be printed on my vehicle, and I am required by law to identify myself and present a business card on demand with my name and contact info. Anyone searching my registration number is treated to all my digits.

Oh, and I should add here that I do not dispute that there is still a stigma attached to sex work. We're not quite that utopian yet.

Honest answers always appreciated, thanks.
 
I know for a fact (because I have witnessed it) that workers at McDonalds and many, many other fast food outlets in Australia train their staff to Cert III level (the same level as a carpenter or cook). Why do they do such a costly thing? Because staff are more competent across a whole range of areas like customer contact, food preparation, supervision where appropriate, health and safety and food safety; they are more confident; and they stick with the job longer than untrained staff.

Just because fast food workers are not trained in the US, this is hardly a universal thing.

Working in a fast food outlet is not unskilled work. Neither is working in a licensed brothal.

Sure, but by that reasoning, any job requires some level of skill. Cutting grass. Digging ditches. Answering phones.

But there aren't other gigs that pay north of $100/hr that don't require normally years of education and specialized training.
 
By contrast, I am a contractor in NJ USA. I simply do not have the option to have ""privacy". My name, town, and registration number must be printed on my vehicle, and I am required by law to identify myself and present a business card on demand with my name and contact info. Anyone searching my registration number is treated to all my digits.
Fine, but you don't need to characterise anything that doesn't get this level of exposure as "cloak-and-dagger". There are professions where there is a reasonable expectation of a certain level of privacy.
 
Fine, but you don't need to characterise anything that doesn't get this level of exposure as "cloak-and-dagger". There are professions where there is a reasonable expectation of a certain level of privacy.

Fine, but when you are literally selling your personal services, it makes little sense to go that low profile. Can you picture a plumber who hides his face and won't give his name?
 
Fine, but when you are literally selling your personal services, it makes little sense to go that low profile. Can you picture a plumber who hides his face and won't give his name?
Again, this is a different business, with different pressures. Me saying that prostitution is a legitimate business does not give you license to draw inappropriate equivalences with every aspect of other professions. There will be similarities, there will be differences.
 
We could cut to the chase, and you could say what prerequisite training is required of Austrailian sex workers if you like?
I don't know about today, but it used to be the June Dalley-Watkins school of Deportment and Etiquette.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom