Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Apparently "life" dependent on silicon physics rather than hydrocarbon chemistry is a slight possibility. That would be interesting evolution, huh?

I've heard this before. In some science fiction with a greater-than-average concern for feasibility, silicon is proposed as the basis for alien life of some form or other. My memory is hazy on the specifics, but I think even the Aliens were subject to this idea on occasion.

I've not heard it described as "silicon physics" though. Why physics and not chemistry?
 
I've heard this before. In some science fiction with a greater-than-average concern for feasibility, silicon is proposed as the basis for alien life of some form or other. My memory is hazy on the specifics, but I think even the Aliens were subject to this idea on occasion.

I've not heard it described as "silicon physics" though. Why physics and not chemistry?
Silicon chemistry, although similar to carbon chemistry in some regards, tends to form bonds more difficult to break (sand, for example).

The physics takes it into semi-conductor tech.
 
My use of "like-us" to me means the big-bang mass/energy was of the correct amount give us a hydrogen-helium cloud and time to allow stellar evolution to fusion things into iron, and via high energy neutron capture to continue to produce the chemical elements in the correct proportions and spread them around so that planets formed, and provided a mechanism to add water at the appropriate time.

That fusion is tuned to carbon rather than oxygen is also a nice feature, as are the actual abundance of radioactive elements that provide internal planetary heating.

Apparently "life" dependent on silicon physics rather than hydrocarbon chemistry is a slight possibility. That would be interesting evolution, huh?
Sorry, I was short of time, so therefore the short answer. I will still point out that life has made do with whatever elements that were available. Now you can say that this is a knife-edge, and that the only other possibility is silicon based, but that just applies to this universe. In a different universe, the rules would necessarily be different, and we have no idea how life might form under a different set of rules. Again, you keep looking from the wrong end of the funnel: It may be a knife edge setup that creates this universe, but we can only hypothesise on which other setups might exist, had the rules been different.

And, I might add that the knife edge is rather broad. This universe contains an enormous range of different conditions, so retune it a bit, and the life-supporting realm may just shift a bit, but still exist.

Hans
 
Silicon chemistry, although similar to carbon chemistry in some regards, tends to form bonds more difficult to break (sand, for example).
Also, long-chain molecules are a bit of a problem, as the silicon-silicon bond tends to get weaker as chain length increases, and silicon is not very good at forming double bonds, so the range of available compunds is much less.
 
....This universe contains an enormous range of different conditions, so retune it a bit, and the life-supporting realm may just shift a bit, but still exist.
The values needed for, say, the fine tuning constant and the ratio proton mass to electron mass, when changed by a percent or 2 result in no universe with chemicals as we have them, or not enough time for anything interesting to occur.

Many other similar values can be found, and the actual interplay when several are examined together so far makes things get worse with lesser changes. SFAIK, these computations are not bullet proof, just highly indicative of the tuning needed to get "us".
 
I don't see how that is a part of science.
Oh, it's not. I was just continuing your speculation.

It's not hard to see that we are imperfectly built for science, that we could be smarter, or have better intuition about scientific matters.
Equally, the solar system could orbit the galaxy the other way, perpendicular to the disk, giving us a most excellent view.

God(in his perfection) didn't do this. Hence;

a)God didn't make us to be good at science.

b)If god made us to do science he was taking the ****.
 
I have not seen that IDers are remiss in targeting prebiotic origins as the best level to argue design. Established authoritarian science holds the microphone. It is very political. Those with darwin-faith turn and run when prebiotic origins are introduced for discussion - the microphone gets turned off. Its not the fault of the IDers - its the established media and academia.

Since 'science' has the microphone, and since you are minimally astute in having noticed this problem with origins of natural laws/constants, try pointing it out. Write a paper that IDers have a good point when considering pre-biotic issues. If you are a grad student or a professor, you know better than to do that. You will be censored if not censured.

Don't be so sure you are correct just because you belong to the club. Maybe you belong to the club of flatlanders, while the IDers say the world is round.
 
I have not seen that IDers are remiss in targeting prebiotic origins as the best level to argue design. Established authoritarian science holds the microphone. It is very political. Those with darwin-faith turn and run when prebiotic origins are introduced for discussion - the microphone gets turned off. Its not the fault of the IDers - its the established media and academia.

"Darwinism" (more properly, the modern synthesis) has nothing to do with the origins of life. Only the origins of species, once life (replicators) exists.

Since 'science' has the microphone, and since you are minimally astute in having noticed this problem with origins of natural laws/constants, try pointing it out. Write a paper that IDers have a good point when considering pre-biotic issues. If you are a grad student or a professor, you know better than to do that. You will be censored if not censured.

If you have good evidence and solid arguments, you will be neither censored nor censured. But saying "I don't know, so gunderscored did it" is neither evidence nor a solid argument, and that's all that IDers have presented so far.

Don't be so sure you are correct just because you belong to the club. Maybe you belong to the club of flatlanders, while the IDers say the world is round.

Maybe. But where's the evidence? Evolution (and let's be honest here, that's what ID is trying to attack) has reams of evidence to support it. ID has none. As for the origins of life, it is probably impossible to find evidence of what actually happened. However, science has come up with a number of guesses that can be tested at least as to their plausibility. ID cannot be tested.
 
And the mic isn't so quiet on the subject of abiogenesis, either. There are several good theories around, from replicating molecules to self-organizing clays. However, we don't have enough evidence or knowledge to say for sure, so nothing about abiogenesis is very firmly grounded.

Contrast this to the ID crowd, who are quick to pop up and crow "Science can't explain it, it must be God!" Where science doesn't know, it stays quiet until it finds out more. IDers trumpet everything as God's work until the sweat, work, and intelligence of scientists prove them wrong.

I don't see this as a downfall of science.

Just as an aside, (and I can only speak for myself, but I imagine the majority woudl second my opinion), I don't think I'm right because I'm in the club. In fact, being an "aetheistic evolutionist" in the middle of the U.S. Bible Belt pretty much makes me about as far from the "club" as I can get. I think I'm right because I've taken the time to educate myself, to study the relevant evidence with an open mind, and to let go of preconcieved fanatical literalist views. I was once a believer, before I grew up and learned better.
 
I am a grad student, and I know that these theories have been published and discussed before - I brought it up to see what people here thought. I don't buy it personally, and of course I hesitate to offer the IDers a new weapon. But I'm fascinated by the origin of the universe and how it might have come to be, so I wanted to see what others thought.

And I'm also an aetheist, who just moved to the Bible Belt. It's been interesting so far - I've never met so many grad students who regularly attend church.
 
"Darwinism" (more properly, the modern synthesis) has nothing to do with the origins of life. Only the origins of species, once life (replicators) exists.
Perhaps in the modern synthesis, there are fewer who are inclined to posture that there is a a natural explanation for life origins than there used to be. But if darwinists are to keep ID out of the picture then they should produce a naturalistic origin of life.

If you have good evidence and solid arguments, you will be neither censored nor censured. But saying "I don't know, so gunderscored did it" is neither evidence nor a solid argument, and that's all that IDers have presented so far.
There are many things for which there are no scientific theories. For example, non-linear dynamics was ignored or relegated to randomness - now we have some theories. I would rather see that darwinism prominently display a disclaimer when it comes to claiming to have evidence. I believe it is more accurate to say that the evidence sought for darwinism turned up as contra-evidence. Darwinism appears to remain only because there is no better naturalistic explanation - not because darwinism is a good explanation. As long as darwinism is accepted on faith in spite of the contra-evidence, it is no better than ID. I think darwinism says "I don't know, so 'chance' did it." What is chance that it has such an embedded creative power?

Maybe. But where's the evidence? Evolution (and let's be honest here, that's what ID is trying to attack) has reams of evidence to support it. ID has none. As for the origins of life, it is probably impossible to find evidence of what actually happened. However, science has come up with a number of guesses that can be tested at least as to their plausibility. ID cannot be tested.

Of course ID is antithetical to evolution. No doubt the idea of "purpose" and "design" and "teleology" have been weeded out because of a legal interpretation. Science is an artifact of man as is law. Neither science nor law is "truth" necessarily. But the 'rules' say that science will only consider mechanistic reductionist explanations - that is dogma - not intrinsic truth. It is like the central dogma of DNA. Because Crick was a darwinist, he believed DNA transcribed to RNA which transcribed to protein, one to one and with no backward transription. When we discovered humans only have 20,000+ genes instead of 100,000 genes, it was obvious the central dogma was wrong. This kind of dogma keeps science from progressing as fast as it would if minds would be more open. Darwinism closes minds. At the least, I think ID is valuable for opening minds to the possibility that, just as there is no naturalistic mechanistic explanation for the origins of pre-biotic complexity in this universe, the simple mechanistic explanation of darwinism also does not explain origins of differential biotic complexity. Taking darwinism on faith allows us to haughtily pretend we have 'the answer' when we do not.

I believe you are correct about the metaphysical nature of origins: the evidence may be impossible to obtain. The "reams of evidence" you believe to support "origin of complex information" (is it OK that I word it like that?) I do not agree with. It would be interesting for you to tell me what constitutes the best evidence amongst the reams. Also, what about the contra-evidence in the fossil record. Do you find any of these things troubling and if so, which (such as sudden complexity in the Cambrian, lack of gradualism in general, the extreme unlikelihood of thousands of bits of information springing from randomness, the non-linear jumping around in the fossil record, etc).
 
Perhaps in the modern synthesis, there are fewer who are inclined to posture that there is a a natural explanation for life origins than there used to be. But if darwinists are to keep ID out of the picture then they should produce a naturalistic origin of life.
The problem is, the members of the Science Club don't produce ideas just to fill gaps--they're not afraid to leave a question hanging until evidence tips the balance towards a particular answer. You must be thinking they work the same way as the members of the Religion Club.
 
Neither science nor law is "truth" necessarily. But the 'rules' say that science will only consider mechanistic reductionist explanations - that is dogma - not intrinsic truth.
Neither naturalistic nor materialistic, which are the actual limiting descriptive modifiers of scientific explanations, means mechanistic or reductionist.
 
I don't buy it personally, and of course I hesitate to offer the IDers a new weapon. But I'm fascinated by the origin of the universe and how it might have come to be, so I wanted to see what others thought.
You must think that those who dissent, including IDers, need YOU to help them with a 'new weapon'? Not to offend you Eri, but you appear naive that you just now opened your eyes to this. I am glad you at least have come to realize that the universe is stranger than fiction (read: darwinism). You won't let the cat out of the bag to admit, if you ever come to realize it, that darwinism is a very thin proposition.

And I'm also an aetheist, who just moved to the Bible Belt. It's been interesting so far - I've never met so many grad students who regularly attend church.
What is an athiest but someone who is certain there is(are) no God(s)? Is my definition accurate in your case? You are 'certain'? .. if you don't mind me asking. Perhaps the many graduate students know they are not 'certain' as you are. What are you studying BTW?
 
OK. So how would you have stated it?
Science can only support (with some degree of certainty less than 100) explanations that are naturalistic, based on logical and material evidence.

Scientific naturalism is not an artificial constraint based on a belief about existence. It's a pragmatic constraint based on the fact that supernatural hypotheses and conjectures always elude the successful application of the scientific method and so can never be developed into proper scientific theories.

If there are indeed aspects of existence that are ruled by supernatural laws, then science will never uncover them. But as long as there are reasonable natural possibilities to unanswered questions, scientists will continue to investigate them.

Scientists will never simply throw up their hands, saying, "Well, I can't explain it. I guess God did it."
 
The problem is, the members of the Science Club don't produce ideas just to fill gaps--they're not afraid to leave a question hanging until evidence tips the balance towards a particular answer. You must be thinking they work the same way as the members of the Religion Club.
When it comes to trying to fill in the gaps between the fossil record, the members of the darwin-faith club (which is a religion club as you called it, not a science club) ARE afraid to leave the void hanging and ARE afraid to take fossil evidence at face value. You must not be aware of this. They DO just conjure farfetched ideas just to fill the gaps.
Problem: gaps in the fossil record:
1. Cambridge explosion. Darwin-faith-speak fills the gap with the explanation that the fossil record is lacking because the precursors' body parts were too soft to be preserved (explain away lack of evidence).
2. Hoaxes: Piltdown man hoax, Nebraska man hoax (used in Scopes trial), etc. How do we know that H. Habilis is not just an ape - all alleged hominid fossil discoveries are guesses at best - wild conjectures.
3. Equus family tree was conjured 100+ years ago and finally dispelled in the 1950s yet still appears in some school texts. Why? Because the darwin-faith club needs to fill the gap with conjured nonsense because they afraid to let the question hang until evidence tips the balance towards a SUPPORTABLE answer.
3. The recurring problems we keep discovering with fossil record showing stasis instead of gradual change. Gould/Eldridge of the darwin-faith club couldn't totally ignore it so instead of explaining it, they gave it a cool sounding name "punctuated equilibrium". Why not name it "the stasis contra-evidence problem"?
4. I've got more ...

Yes chipmunk, you are exactly correct IMO. I do think the darwin-faith club behaves like a religion-club. If you are a scientist as I am, you should be insulted that they call themselves scientists. Kick them out. Quit thinking that little ol ladies with blue hair are your foe just because they believe in a young earth. Let the little ol ladies be and step up to the challenge. Police the scientific community of these numerologists, phrenologists, astrologists, and darwinists. Your enemy is your own lack of research into evolution.
 
If there are indeed aspects of existence that are ruled by supernatural laws, then science will never uncover them. "

I agree with that whole post. So we stand on the same ground about what science is for.

Lets try something else to induce thinking outside your box. Let's assume that 100 years from now we find some weird stuff with quantum physics or something and we determine that we live in a simulation. Perhaps some of the simulator starts showing through in some quantum experiments we do. Maybe we find that this simulation we live in is, by design, incapable of calculating 'intelligence' and 'creativity'. Imagine that our universe is like the graphics card, but the CPU (where our 'selves' are) is where our self awareness and creativity calculates. The material universe (the graphics card) is what we've been studying all along and our brains are a sort of remote-terminal that joins our CPU selves with our graphics-card simulation. The creators of the simulation chuckle to think we are dumb enough to think that everything self-created in the limited graphics card and that so many of us believe the delusion that the graphics card is all there is. Some are imaginitive enough to suspect that there must be another domain and other agents (the programmers of the simulation) but are angrily dismissed by those who believe the delusion.

I'm offering this as a metaphor so that you might consider that ID is for everyone. Open your mind but think critically. Maybe the darwinists are the ones who believe in the tooth fairy.
 
And the mic isn't so quiet on the subject of abiogenesis, either. There are several good theories around, from replicating molecules to self-organizing clays. However, we don't have enough evidence or knowledge to say for sure, so nothing about abiogenesis is very firmly grounded.
You have not studied about self-replicating molecules and self-organizing clays, have you? To say it is not very firmly grounded is as funny as 'scientists do not yet know everything there is to know about the human mind.'

I don't see this as a downfall of science.
There is a downfall of science, and that is that it constantly allows itself to become subject to the established politburo. If you are on grant who signs your check? Ford Foundation? Rockefeller Foundation? Go read how the UN edited the scientists' paper on global warming to suit their political goals (i'm too lazy to get the link but it was june 12, 1996 in the wall street journal by former honcho of the Academy of Science named Seitz). Established science is a whore. You are probably too young to have figured that out yet.
I think I'm right because I've taken the time to educate myself, to study the relevant evidence with an open mind, and to let go of preconcieved fanatical literalist views.
Unless you are a paleontologist/zoologist and know the facts but are too entrenched to admit evolution is wrong, then you could not possibly have educated yourself nor studied the relevant evidence with an open mind. What did you study, your (government-run) high school biology textbook? Its OK Huntsman, I was hook-line-sinker too (when I was young) and thought I was well educated too. No offense - its not your fault.
 
When it comes to trying to fill in the gaps between the fossil record, the members of the darwin-faith club (which is a religion club as you called it, not a science club) ARE afraid to leave the void hanging and ARE afraid to take fossil evidence at face value. You must not be aware of this. They DO just conjure farfetched ideas just to fill the gaps.
Problem: gaps in the fossil record:
1. Cambridge explosion. Darwin-faith-speak fills the gap with the explanation that the fossil record is lacking because the precursors' body parts were too soft to be preserved (explain away lack of evidence).
2. Hoaxes: Piltdown man hoax, Nebraska man hoax (used in Scopes trial), etc. How do we know that H. Habilis is not just an ape - all alleged hominid fossil discoveries are guesses at best - wild conjectures.
3. Equus family tree was conjured 100+ years ago and finally dispelled in the 1950s yet still appears in some school texts. Why? Because the darwin-faith club needs to fill the gap with conjured nonsense because they afraid to let the question hang until evidence tips the balance towards a SUPPORTABLE answer.
3. The recurring problems we keep discovering with fossil record showing stasis instead of gradual change. Gould/Eldridge of the darwin-faith club couldn't totally ignore it so instead of explaining it, they gave it a cool sounding name "punctuated equilibrium". Why not name it "the stasis contra-evidence problem"?
4. I've got more ...
Ignoring all your rhetorical catchphrases and the fact that this is all the same crap that's trotted out and shot down everytime some ID woo brings it up, and accepting your interpretation of these points at face value, the central idea remains: none of it invalidates the theory that speciation can explained by mutation and natural selection. These are (at best) lingering questions within the specifics of the working model, not fatal blows to the foundation of the theory.

Yes chipmunk, you are exactly correct IMO. I do think the darwin-faith club behaves like a religion-club. If you are a scientist as I am, you should be insulted that they call themselves scientists. Kick them out. Quit thinking that little ol ladies with blue hair are your foe just because they believe in a young earth. Let the little ol ladies be and step up to the challenge. Police the scientific community of these numerologists, phrenologists, astrologists, and darwinists. Your enemy is your own lack of research into evolution.
You're a little old lady with blue hair? I never would have guessed. What kind of scientist are you?

What insults me is a politician calling himself a scientist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom