Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Pretty sure the thesis hadn’t been written then. There is really no reason an MA thesis would be part of the reporting. It’s false that the fatalities had not been reported. Of course they had. But it is only now that they have gained more attention.

Reported to whom? Clearly they were reported within China, Shi sent a team there to collect specimens I believe in the following year.

OK, let's review:
as said:
Science paper said:
Hu and Yu researched the novel lineage of SARS-like viruses from which SARS-CoV-2 hails, and in 2019 coauthored a paper with Shi Zhengli that described SARS-like lineages they had studied over the years.
Obvious contradiction there. They stopped making their findings public in 2016, but published a paper of their findings in 2019? Huh???

Also, "fatalities i[n Mojiang mine] not reported"? This is flat-out false as we all know. Article from 2014...
Re the contradiction, I already commented. Shi held part of her data back until Bloom investigated, so there is no contradiction.

I don't understand how this "contradiction" moves your argument forward anyway.

The full paragraph from The Times re the fatalities:
The Sunday Times said that the lab stopped making its findings public in 2016 after researchers discovered a new type of coronavirus in a mineshaft in Mojiang in Yunnan province where people had died from symptoms similar to Sars. The fatalities were not reported.
Without a clue as to who the fatalities were not reported to it's hard to assess this statement.

The Master's Thesis was published in 2013.
Xu L. The analysis of 6 patients with severe pneumonia caused by unknown viruses (Master's Thesis). The First Clinical Medical College of Kunming Medical University, Kunming Medical University, Kunming, China: (2013). http://eng.oversea.cnki.net/Kcms/de...ame=1013327523.nh&dbcode=CMFD&dbname=CMFD2014 [Google Scholar]

The PhD Thesis was published in 2016 and we know it was based on historical data and lab reports from earlier.
Huang C. Novel virus discovery in bat and the exploration of receptor of bat coronavirus HKU9 (PhD Thesis). National Institute for Viral Disease Control and Prevention, Beijing: China: (2016). Available online at: http://eng.oversea.cnki.net/kcms/de...cEjKensW4IQMovwHtwkF4VYPoHbKxJw!!&autoLogin=0 [Google Scholar]

Getting back to your post, The Times UK and the related Sunday Times have an excellent record for validity.

So what are you trying to say, everything in the news report is suspect and unreliable because you found one inconsistency? :confused:
 
Last edited:
Reported to whom? Clearly they were reported within China, Shi sent a team there to collect specimens I believe in the following year.

OK, let's review:
Re the contradiction, I already commented. Shi held part of her data back until Bloom investigated, so there is no contradiction.

I don't understand how this "contradiction" moves your argument forward anyway.

The full paragraph from The Times re the fatalities:
Without a clue as to who the fatalities were not reported to it's hard to assess this statement.

The Master's Thesis was published in 2013.


The PhD Thesis was published in 2016 and we know it was based on historical data and lab reports from earlier.


Getting back to your post, The Times UK and the related Sunday Times have an excellent record for validity.

So what are you trying to say, everything in the news report is suspect and unreliable because you found one inconsistency? :confused:

Let me keep this simple.

The “excellent” Times said “The fatalities were not reported.”

But the fatalities WERE reported. So this is false.
 
I didn't pay attention to this earlier but now its time is at hand:

Three things to watch as US intelligence prepares for Covid ‘lab leak’ reveal

It could be a huge moment, or a terrible anticlimax.

:popcorn1

My prediction.

A "terrible" anti-climax.

Like the 9/11 Truthers looking for evidence in Wikileaks that it was an inside job, we are going to see a few unevidenced claims with little reason to come to any hard conclusions.

What I would like to see is exactly who has made the claims to know about sick WIV workers. Who are these people?

Absolutely, get all the information public and stop hiding behind claims of security.

By the way, that article uses the term that lab leakers like to use as a term of abuse for those who say it came from nature....

The Zoonati remain sceptical. They say a wrap-up of all the work the WIV conducted on coronaviruses, including a list of viruses, was submitted to Nature in October 2019 and that there was nothing unusual about the research. Further, they say, nothing “obviously nefarious or weird” happened during the submission and review process, which ran to August 2020, to suggest the Chinese were hiding secret projects.
 
A few more predictions.

1.) Some people are going to be shocked... SHOCKED to learn that RaTG13 is 95% similar to SARS-CoV2 and there will be a lot of talk of bioweapons.

2.) There will also be lots of claims that we are "not being told the full story" by the intelligence community when it turns out to be a damp squib.
 
Oh look! Just found this screenshot on Twitter. I was blocked by Shellenberger long ago so didn't realize that this would come up.

They are already seeding the ground for claims that the evidence will have been manipulated.

These shameless grifters. Do you see why I don't trust people like this?

FyxVBf4WYAAq-bl


Total CT minded!
 
Seriously, as, must you pound on the keyboard in giant font shouting like that? :rolleyes:

I'll reply to your posts later in case you need time to calm down.
 
Media bias factcheck on The Times UK and The Sunday Times
Overall, we rate The Times and Sunday Times right-center biased based on story selection and editorial positions that favor the right and High for factual reporting due to a clean fact check record. ...

The Sunday Times is a print newspaper that publishes content on The Times website. The Sunday Times is the largest-selling British national newspaper in the “quality press” market category, and the editor is Martin Ivens. ...

The Sunday Times slightly differs from The Times in that they have stronger conservative editorial positions. They also produce more investigative journalism through their Insight Investigative Team. Further, a Reuters institute survey found that 52% of respondents trust their news coverage and 17% do not, ranking them #6 in trust of the major UK news providers.

Failed Fact Checks
None in the Last 5 years
What news source do you know of that gets every single fact correct? It's an absurd POV to point out a single fact that you believe they got wrong as if that discredits everything they've reported on.

And it isn't clear who the paper is saying it wasn't reported to. If they meant the WHO or the broader audience of researchers then the claim may be factual. But it's a moot point because it's such a trivial mistake if it was a mistake.


As opposed to my criticism of Worobey who left out the earliest cases of COVID and the fact the market was an identified early super-spreader location.

As opposed to follow-up reporting that suggested the quantities of the COVID RNA and the DNA of the raccoon dog sold in the same stall indicated COVID was likely from human contamination, not something carried by the r-dog.


I'm fine if you have something that discredits any of the evidence presented here supporting the lab origin hypothesis. But this bit from The Times is certainly not worth repeating in multiple posts as if repeating it makes it an important point.

And @Planigale's continuing repetition of Shi and Daszak's claims is really tiring. I doubt many researchers even under different circumstances would admit to a mistake that killed millions.
 
My prediction.

A "terrible" anti-climax.

Like the 9/11 Truthers looking for evidence in Wikileaks that it was an inside job, we are going to see a few unevidenced claims with little reason to come to any hard conclusions.
There you go again trying to smear the POV you don't like by claiming the 911 truthers are analogous. Maybe I should yell that in all caps, huge font and flashy colors so you quit doing it. But nah, I'm on solid ground here. The more you use this kind of smearing and ranting the more it looks like spillover supporters aren't.


What I would like to see is exactly who has made the claims to know about sick WIV workers. Who are these people?

Absolutely, get all the information public and stop hiding behind claims of security.
The information on those sick workers from the WIV was in a cable sent from embassy staff in China to the US gov. I don't recall if some of the cable was redacted or the original not shown at all, only reported on.

But given The Times revealed the names from documents they acquired it won't be a big deal.

I'm not sure why you think the US doesn't have legit security reasons for holding information back. OTOH it's out there in the open the US via the NIH likely granted some of the funds Shi and Daszak used in their research and gain of function was something the NIH knew was part of that research. That's something I hope comes out officially.

When the US stopped funding gain of function research Shi found money elsewhere. And again, that's not as important as the fact the US reinstated the funding. That needs to be exposed.


By the way, that article uses the term that lab leakers like to use as a term of abuse for those who say it came from nature....
I thought zoonati was quite clever. :sdl:

But tell me please why that outrages you so much when you've tried to equate lab leak leaning proponents with CTers in post after post? See highlighted sentence above for yet another example.

:id:
 
Media bias factcheck on The Times UK and The Sunday Times

What news source do you know of that gets every single fact correct? It's an absurd POV to point out a single fact that you believe they got wrong as if that discredits everything they've reported on.

And it isn't clear who the paper is saying it wasn't reported to. If they meant the WHO or the broader audience of researchers then the claim may be factual. But it's a moot point because it's such a trivial mistake if it was a mistake.


As opposed to my criticism of Worobey who left out the earliest cases of COVID and the fact the market was an identified early super-spreader location.

As opposed to follow-up reporting that suggested the quantities of the COVID RNA and the DNA of the raccoon dog sold in the same stall indicated COVID was likely from human contamination, not something carried by the r-dog.


I'm fine if you have something that discredits any of the evidence presented here supporting the lab origin hypothesis. But this bit from The Times is certainly not worth repeating in multiple posts as if repeating it makes it an important point.

And @Planigale's continuing repetition of Shi and Daszak's claims is really tiring. I doubt many researchers even under different circumstances would admit to a mistake that killed millions.

The "fatalities were not reported" line doesn't have any of the qualifiers you are trying to add to it to make a false statement less false. But as it stands, it is false.

And it doesn't seem to be just a mere error, which would merely make us wonder how competent the writer was, but rather that it insinuates something else such as a cover-up.
 
The information on those sick workers from the WIV was in a cable sent from embassy staff in China to the US gov. I don't recall if some of the cable was redacted or the original not shown at all, only reported on.

Could you give me the source of this? Or a link to the actual cable?

For example, I have found that someone who has been touting this claim is a guy called David Asher.

Link

A cluster of researchers from China's secretive Wuhan laboratories fell sick with 'Covid-like' symptoms at least six weeks before the Beijing government admitted an outbreak of a new virus in their city, according to the leading US investigator looking into the start of the pandemic.
David Asher, who led State Department inquiries into Covid-19's origins, told The Mail on Sunday that three scientists are believed to have become ill with the mysterious respiratory condition in the second week of November, 2019.

'There are suspicions – for good reasons – of an initial cluster tied to Wuhan Institute of Virology in November and that people started to be hospitalised,' he said.

'Hard to conclude definitely it was Covid but it seems highly likely.'

According to 'credible' information from a well-connected foreign government, the wife of one researcher died later that month, Asher added.

Do we have confirmation that one of the now named scientists lost a wife to Covid?
 
Flo Debbare has a nice thread in which she raises many eyebrows over the Times's reporting...

Link

Anonymous sources throughout the article.

It includes quotes about how "there was a belief" that coronavirus vaccine research was going on.

We have the claim about the sick workers, but only an anonymous source. Why?

There is some statement about how a WIV worker called Zhou fell from the roof of the WIV with the obvious insinuation that he was murdered, with the qualifier, "although this has not been verified". LOL!
 
The "fatalities were not reported" line doesn't have any of the qualifiers you are trying to add to it to make a false statement less false. But as it stands, it is false.

And it doesn't seem to be just a mere error, which would merely make us wonder how competent the writer was, but rather that it insinuates something else such as a cover-up.
This is really too much, as.

You need to give this one up.
 
Could you give me the source of this? Or a link to the actual cable?

For example, I have found that someone who has been touting this claim is a guy called David Asher.

Link

Do we have confirmation that one of the now named scientists lost a wife to Covid?
OMG, you are citing the Daily Fail! And the Beijing government*, is that gasp! an error? :shocked:

Silly me, the reference is to the *Chinese government, not the city.


The "cables" initially were in 2018 warning the US government of the lax safety controls and dangerous research at the WIV. I have a mixed memory but every bit of this was discussed earlier in the thread.

Politico: In 2018, Diplomats Warned of Risky Coronavirus Experiments in a Wuhan Lab. ... After seeing a risky lab, they wrote a cable warning to Washington. But it was ignored.
In January 15, in its last days, President Donald Trump’s State Department put out a statement with serious claims about the origins of the Covid-19 pandemic. The statement said the U.S. intelligence community had evidence that several researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology laboratory were sick with Covid-like symptoms in autumn 2019—implying the Chinese government had hidden crucial information about the outbreak for months—and that the WIV lab, despite “presenting itself as a civilian institution,” was conducting secret research projects with the Chinese military. The State Department alleged a Chinese government cover-up and asserted that “Beijing continues today to withhold vital information that scientists need to protect the world from this deadly virus, and the next one.”
That was back when nothing could be trusted because it came from lying Trump's government.


Later an intelligence report said there was evidence of the ill workers in Nov 2019 at the WIV.
State Dept Fact Sheet: Activity at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.
The U.S. government has reason to believe that several researchers inside the WIV became sick in autumn 2019, before the first identified case of the outbreak, with symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses. This raises questions about the credibility of WIV senior researcher Shi Zhengli’s public claim that there was “zero infection” among the WIV’s staff and students of SARS-CoV-2 or SARS-related viruses.

NBC News: U.S. intel report identified 3 Wuhan lab researchers who fell ill in November 2019
WASHINGTON — A U.S. intelligence report identified three researchers at a Wuhan lab who sought treatment at a hospital after falling ill in November 2019, a source familiar with the matter tells NBC News.

The new details, first reported by The Wall Street Journal, add to the body of circumstantial evidence that supports a hypothesis that the Covid-19 virus may have spread to humans after it escaped from a Chinese research lab in Wuhan. But the evidence is far from conclusive.



Do we have this... do we have that... could you relax? US to release confidential files ON SUNDAY. It's only Sat here.

The ill workers' names came from The Times UK which is behind a paywall. They examined multiple sources, remember? The quote is only a couple of posts up. And I said they had an ongoing investigation and we'd have to wait until more of their reporting filters down into the free media.

And before you start yelling again, no I have not finished Huff's book. The first chapters so far are going through his history and qualifications, IOW filler.
 
Last edited:
Flo Debbare has a nice thread in which she raises many eyebrows over the Times's reporting...

Link

Anonymous sources throughout the article.

It includes quotes about how "there was a belief" that coronavirus vaccine research was going on.

We have the claim about the sick workers, but only an anonymous source. Why?

There is some statement about how a WIV worker called Zhou fell from the roof of the WIV with the obvious insinuation that he was murdered, with the qualifier, "although this has not been verified". LOL!
Pretty sure I questioned Debarre's claims only a couple posts up. Maybe you could review that and address it before tossing her out here again as some verifiable expert. Remember, she conflated the missing genome data Bloom found in the cloud with the 22K missing data entries DRASTIC reported on. Truth be told, DRASTIC has a lot more credibility than Ms confirmation-bias Debarre has at the moment.


Oh, and that missing worker story was discussed upthread (again you need reminding) including the worker coming forward to say he wasn't dead.
 
Last edited:
The information on those sick workers from the WIV was in a cable sent from embassy staff in China to the US gov. I don't recall if some of the cable was redacted or the original not shown at all, only reported on.

Could you give me the source of this? Or a link to the actual cable?

The "cables" initially were in 2018 warning the US government of the lax safety controls and dangerous research at the WIV. I have a mixed memory but every bit of this was discussed earlier in the thread.

Huh? The cable about sick WIV workers in Novermber 2019, was released in 2018?

This makes literally no sense.
 
Pretty sure I questioned Debarre's claims only a couple posts up. Maybe you could review that and address it before tossing her out here again as some verifiable expert. Remember, she conflated the missing genome data Bloom found in the cloud with the 22K missing data entries DRASTIC reported on. Truth be told, DRASTIC has a lot more credibility than Ms confirmation-bias Debarre has at the moment.

No idea what you are talking about here. Though I think it was you and Plainigale who had a disagreement when you were both referencing different databases, not Debarre.
 
This is really too much, as.

You need to give this one up.

Why? The report was inaccurate. I don't have to "give up" on stating this just because you want to massage it from what it said to maybe, possibly what they meant if you add a bunch of qualifiers.

The article was dog ****.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom