Budhism Is Not A Religion

Power over the hearts and minds of men, what a high.

Less than 50 words:

Think what you like dear Yrreg.

ETA: Life is already complex without torturing yourself with pointless questions. You don't like Buddhism, thats fine. Now move on and have a nice day!

Thanks, Bodh, for your fraternal concern. Move on and have a nice day! Actually I do feel a little bit guilty for spending time more than I should writing posts here. But the wife and kids are happy to have me doing something that is safe and quiet, and I do enjoy writing posts.

There are a number of minor chores in the house I should be busy with, like replacing that ceiling bulb no longer lighting up since two years now, but the wife heartily agrees with me every time I tell myself in her presence that anyway we can get around safely without light from that bulb. That is the kind of wife she is, very accommodating to me when I shirk from small duties in the house out of preference for more interesting occupations.

Forgive me at this point, but I also have this vanity of explaining to people who do ask me, to explain things to them in KISS way, i.e., keeping the explanation simple and short, of course clearly -- in Less than 50 words.

So, and please forgive me for this hubris: anyone here even guest, wanting to know in photography, what is f22, and how to use your old film camera as to take two shots for every frame of the film, and with Wittgenstein, what he means with absence of clearness in human speech, just let me know and I will explain to you in each case with fifty (50) words or less, and promise you not only to be simple and short, but certainly also clear, enough for any person to grasp with at least an average intelligence.

Life is already complex without torturing yourself with pointless questions.

If asking pointless questions is torturing oneself, then I am a masochist; I refer to the pointless, not to the questions.


The more I know of Buddha's words and actuations the more I admire the man's clever and smart mind.

First, he is very clever and smart to not have written down anything at all, when he was certainly literate, could read and could write. No, he was a no read and no write guy? Then still very and even more clever and more smart. Why? Because only fools put down anything at all in writing.

Second, he tells people listening to him to decide for themselves what is true while he already enjoys and wields what I call psychological advantage over them, with his princely rank on the one hand, and his fancy concepts and words on the other.

Third, he clears the last obstacle in his drive to make captive the hearts and minds of men, again with his psychological advantage over them, by convincing them to not ask questions because and take it from him, they are pointless.

This is one dude of a religious teacher who lived and preached in that long span of years, 563-483 BCE, eighty years, when people could not survive unless exceptionally beyond forty, and he didn't put down anything in writing, not even by dictation to contractual pen pushers.


If gaining and exercising power over fellow humans is an eternal irrestible drive in man as in animals, then this dude, Buddha, had attained his power campaign and enjoyed his hold over men for over half a century in his long lifetime, posthumously still for 2,500 years now, even over guys like the Buddhists here: Ryokan, D David, Username, Nosho, Complexity, Bodh, et alii, all otherwise literate and no reprobate in the world of ideas and reasons, and that without ingesting any drug to experience that kind of a high.

That is also what I call studying Buddhism by studying Buddhists, starting with the first one and its originator.


Yrreg
 
hi yrreg

The more I know of Buddha's words and actuations the more I admire the man's clever and smart mind.

First, he is very clever and smart to not have written down anything at all, when he was certainly literate, could read and could write. No, he was a no read and no write guy? Then still very and even more clever and more smart. Why? Because only fools put down anything at all in writing.

Second, he tells people listening to him to decide for themselves what is true while he already enjoys and wields what I call psychological advantage over them, with his princely rank on the one hand, and his fancy concepts and words on the other.

Third, he clears the last obstacle in his drive to make captive the hearts and minds of men, again with his psychological advantage over them, by convincing them to not ask questions because and take it from him, they are pointless.

This is one dude of a religious teacher who lived and preached in that long span of years, 563-483 BCE, eighty years, when people could not survive unless exceptionally beyond forty, and he didn't put down anything in writing, not even by dictation to contractual pen pushers.


If gaining and exercising power over fellow humans is an eternal irrestible drive in man as in animals, then this dude, Buddha, had attained his power campaign and enjoyed his hold over men for over half a century in his long lifetime, posthumously still for 2,500 years now, even over guys like the Buddhists here: Ryokan, D David, Username, Nosho, Complexity, Bodh, et alii, all otherwise literate and no reprobate in the world of ideas and reasons, and that without ingesting any drug to experience that kind of a high.

That is also what I call studying Buddhism by studying Buddhists, starting with the first one and its originator.


Yrreg[/QUO

i putout a thread for people like you.
titled

'do you believe in what you read?'

now i can see that you are not a budhist critic. rather there are more negative feelings in you about budhism rather then to be a critic.
hay! that is totaly OK.

the budhist here does not mean you any ill feelings.

am i a budhist? the answer is NO

All that logic and memory from reading and growing up you display, which shows what is in side you does not do good justice for the 'real person that you are'
 
That is what we're trying to do, isn't it? Understand Buddhism, not just beat up on some straw-man version of it? If not, then this whole discussion is just a game of trying to find the most outrageous claims and poke holes in them. That might be fun, but it's not meaningful inquiry. To me it seems like a waste of time.

So, basically, you don't like what yyreg and I are trying to study, and it pisses you off, and you think that we should be doing something else.

Gotcha.
 
Definitions are not arbitrary unless you live inside the mind of a Buddhist in Nirvana, or with Alice in Wonderland.

See if you can get anywhere protesting that one plus one equals two is just a definition, in the bank and in the supermarket.

See if you can survive in the turnpikes with your protestation that the formulations of physical laws are only definitions to describe the physical world according to man's perception. They should take away your driver's licence and keep you in a safe house, for your own preservation and to save others from you.


Yrreg

Yrreg:
Do you not understand the difference bewteen concepts/thought and reality.

This is very old thread material on this forum. There are thoughts and concepts and then there is reality. The two are related but it is not solely a buddhist distinction to note the difference.

Physical processes exist, I did not say that they are solely the product of the mind. But thier description in languaga is just that, it is a description used by human beings to communicate thier thoughts about observations. It is a well accepted fact in science that theories are models that predict behavior, however there is a clear distinction between the theory and reality. A theory which acurately predeicts the behavior of observations is considered to be useful. Gravity, inertia exists but they are only described by 'laws' like (gravitational acceleration at the earth's suface equals sixteen feet per second squared) or (f=ma). There is not a law that exists in nature, there are observable processes that exist and there are the words and thoughts used to describe the observed process.

Do you think that you thoughts are a direct replication of reality? If so then you need to check out scepticism again.

I know that you aren't reading this because that's who you are: But do you understand that 'numbers' only exist in human thoughts and communications. They do not exist in reality , they are conventions of speach, they do not exist in reality except as humans relating thoughts to each other.

Take the phrase : 1+1+2
is that the truth or is the truth:
01+01=10?

This seems to further my belief that you are here just to say what you want and not communicate with other:

Can you give me a source for Pes Oir Asmus, or should we suspend our scepticism of your beliefs and statements completely?
 
Yrreg as compromised sceptic ;)

Just for laughs:
The more I know of the Yrregs here the more I am convinced of the deep and wide chasm between Yrreg skeptics and non-Yrreg skeptics here.

I have read the posts of Yrregs here, and they exhibit a trend.

First they proclaim themselves to be skeptics, but at the same time also call themselves and proudly in one of them to be Yrregs. And I am sure I have read their logically calling themselves Yrreg skeptics.

No, they don't call themselves skeptical Yrregs, but Yrreg skeptics, meaning they are Yrreg first and skeptics second.

Is that possible? I don't think so, because when you are a skeptic you don't subsume your skepticism under any other kind of limiting qualification like Yrreg or Christian or Masonic.

You can call yourself resident skeptic or visiting skeptic or alien skeptic or Polish skeptic or Indian skeptic, these designations don't detract from your skepticism, they just inform people of your extra or intra domicile circumstance or your foreign or national or country of origin.

But when you call yourself a Yrreg skeptic, you already encapsulate your skepticism to within the capsule of Yrreg which is a worldview.

You tell me that your Yrreg does not include karma, rebirth, nirvana beyond the grave, just meditation, the Four Noble Truths, and the Eightfold Path, and nirvana only the kind within one's lifetime.

Still I can't see your kind of Yrreg skepticism to be anything else than compromised Yrreg. I feel that it's not the right kind of skepticism, well at least not the kind that is practiced by the founders and operators of the CSICOP and the JREF which runs this skeptical forum.

Why do I feel this way?

The reason is because the skepticism I see in the CSICOP and in the JREF is what I know to be scientific skepticism; but as you Yrreg folks here admit and even declare yourselves, Yrreg is not science and not scientific, how then can you in a way straitjacket a scientific advocacy into a non-scientific worldview?

Consider that even though you don't believe in karma, in rebirth, in some nirvana post death and beyond the grave; what you do believe and cultivate are not scientific, namely, meditation in order to attain some kind of science knows what knowledge or information or data about life and the universe.

What about the Four Noble Truths and the Eightfold Path, they are not scientific but moralistic principles, or components of a code of conduct; however I grant that although they are not science or scientific, yet they can be studied scientifically to discern, why and how and to what effects people choose to embrace them and practice them.

Now, I think I know what is really absent in your Yrreg however you delimit it only to meditation, the Four Noble Truths, the Eightfold Path, and nirvana in one's lifetime -- what's absent in them? There is no scientific evidence for them.

You see, skepticism for me is complete liberty of inquiry; but you guys for spousing Yrreg cannot be free completely, because you have imposed on your mental horizons the Yrreg cosmos with its alpha and omega against which and beyond which you are not allowed to tread.

Suppose let's say that you guys, Yrregs here, are bachelors but are now going into marriage; your brides-to-be ask you whether you can be on your own with all kinds of freedom to think and decide and act; you say, yes.

Then after the wedding when one of you guys with your bride board the plane to fly to your honeymoon destinations, there is your mother also coming into the plane. you explain to your bride that your mother just happens to be going on the same trip.

But then she also checks into the same hotel in your first stop; you explain to your bride that she just happens to choose the same hotel. Yet for the rest of your honeymoon you and your bride always have your mother hanging around, still you keep explaining to your bride that your mother just happens to be hanging around you, and that you are definitely and completely freed of your mother, to think and to decide and to act for yourself.

And that's what the Yrregs are doing all the time here, explaining and defending and qualifying and making reservations, in order to keep to their attachment to Yrreg and at the same time claim to be skeptics.
 
Forgive me at this point, but I also have this vanity of explaining to people who do ask me, to explain things to them in KISS way, i.e., keeping the explanation simple and short, of course clearly -- in Less than 50 words.

And thats ok, if you are baking some eggs. But lets see, after 2500 years, I won't expect to have an accurate description of who was and how was the person called "Buddha". Why bother in trying to find out who he "really" was? This is for the historical part, but there is more.

Do you honestly think that if you talk with 5 (or 100) Buddhists you will understand it better? Every single individual is a universe, everything they think, see, believe, its because all those million of things that compose an individual. Ask 1000 of them about what, exactly, is Buddhism (or Science, or Philosophy or Christianism) and you will get 1000 different answers!

BTW Wittgenstein said that the meaning of a word (any word) its its use in a particular language.

This is with a lot less than 50 words, do you noticed it? ;) still, let me tell you that Im in a group of philosophers who discuss this matters, and we often spend hours talking about a small paragraph of one of his books.

Oh, and f22 is a calibrated aperture size of the diaphragm, it regulates the amount of light that passes to the film or digital sensor.

Now, does this definiton covers what you were thinking about f22? My guess is that no, exactly like the Wittgenstein definition (and Buddhism definition!), because you have your own "mental structure" (forgive me for the rather simple term) composed on the expectations you have generated in regard with your own way to see the world.

Nobody, but you, can construct what you want regarding your own expectations.

Now, if you really wanted to know about whats "the foundation" of Buddhism (according to me) then you need to focus only on one thing: Who is this "you" who likes to sign like Yrreg?
 
If the buddha is not a skeptic Yrreg is not a skeptic.

(In consideration of Yrreg’s request that all statements be of fifty words or less. )

Yrreg it would seem that you have made the following argument. There are questions to which the buddha offered no answer, therefore the buddha was not a skeptic. The quality that defines the skeptic is the asking of questions.

This seems to be a fallacy of composition. Through the specific definition of a skeptic as one who asks questions the buddha would be a skeptic , the buddha often use the Socratic method (so called). Therefore the buddha meets the standard of skeptic in that he asks questions.

If we use the alternate definition: the buddha was not a skeptic because he did not answer questions. The buddha chose to answer many questions. The buddha often tried to answer the questions posed and gave an answer that was appropriate to the questioner. In fact in many ways the buddha was quite a wind bag by today’s standards as he often answered in long prose statements.

For example: Yrreg you seem to have stated that you merit the badge of skeptic (and the cool benefits that derive thereof!) , but while you often pose questions, it would seem that you often do not seem to answer them. Through conjugation of Yrreg and the buddha the following devolves rapidly from there:

If Yrreg is a skeptic then the buddha is a skeptic as well. Yrreg does not answer questions ,he is a skeptic, therefore the buddha is a skeptic. Yrreg is a skeptic he chooses not to answer questions, the buddha is also a skeptic because he does the same. If Yrreg is a skeptic and he chooses to answer questions and not others, the buddha is the same: same.

If further we pose that in agreement of Yrreg’s assertion: the best way to study buddhism is through the observation of buddhists, it would seem that the buddhists ask a lot of questions and therefore are skeptics. Further the buddhists have tried to answer questions therefore they are skeptics. The buddhists also answer some questions and not others therefore they are skeptics.

In conclusion the following is suggested: Yrreg is a skeptic and chooses to ask questions, therefore the buddha is a skeptic, Yrreg is a skeptic and chooses to not answer questions , therefore the buddha is a skeptic. Yrreg is a skeptic and he chooses to answers some questions and not others, therefore the buddha is also a skeptic.

In summation If Yrreg is a skeptic then the buddha is a skeptic. If the buddha is not a skeptic then Yrreg is not a skeptic. Yrreg's first assertion that the buddha is not a skeptic because he did not answer questions therefore Yrreg is also not a skeptic because he does not answer questions. Same: same.
 
No stacks blown up yet?

Dear Bod, allow me to commend you on your Zen-ic equanimity, that is the upside; now the downside is most probably without the invest in Zen (time, labor, expense, trouble) you could have mastered equanimity as well.

Look at me, have I ever uttered a harsh word here in the midst of being called a cockroach, mentally ill, troll, strawman, etc., and having the a* word and the f* hurled at me, from one of your one Buddhist savant here? I just listened to my mother and the better behaved members of my family and close circles of friends, and keep myself in their company, emulating their polite social and personal manners.

Hahaha softly, this is the Fat Happy Laughing Buddha (aka Pu-tai in Chinese and Hotei in Japanese) talking.

(Please proceed outside this quote box for Bod's text and my reactions.)

Bod:
And thats ok, if you are baking some eggs. But lets see, after 2500 years, I won't expect to have an accurate description of who was and how was the person called "Buddha". Why bother in trying to find out who he "really" was? This is for the historical part, but there is more.

Do you honestly think that if you talk with 5 (or 100) Buddhists you will understand it better? Every single individual is a universe, everything they think, see, believe, its because all those million of things that compose an individual. Ask 1000 of them about what, exactly, is Buddhism (or Science, or Philosophy or Christianism) and you will get 1000 different answers!
​
Yrreg:
You remember I always insist on the big picture and the short statement. When you see so many different trees, plants, it is very hard to see the forest. But if you go up in an airplane and even higher in a satellite, or hook a camera in it to take pictures of the earth, then you can see where the forests are (if any are left or small patches), the oceans, the dry lands and the deserts.

-------------

Bod:
BTW Wittgenstein said that the meaning of a word (any word) its its use in a particular language.

This is with a lot less than 50 words, do you noticed it? ;) still, let me tell you that Im in a group of philosophers who discuss this matters, and we often spend hours talking about a small paragraph of one of his books.
​
Yrreg:
"BTW Wittgenstein said that the meaning of a word (any word) its its use in a particular language." -- Bod

And he had to retire to a monastery and worked in its gardens, doing fervid thinking on words and writing books to tell us, what a kid knows instinctively; that is why a kid always listens to how adults use a word in order to use it to their adults' understanding. Let's have a Fat Happy Laughing Buddha's laugh to that; and remember he was one of you Zen folks.

---------------

Bod:
Oh, and f22 is a calibrated aperture size of the diaphragm, it regulates the amount of light that passes to the film or digital sensor.
​

Yrreg:
If your stacks are still intact, just tell me if you are given a camera with the f/1.8, f/2.8, f/4, f/5.6, f/8, f/11, f/16, f/22 markings and stops defaced and the pointer removed; tell me how you are going to find out at what f/ stop the aperture happens to be opened?

Are you not curious to find out how to take two pictures on the same frame of a film in a very simple way without dismantling the camera, shooting a picture each in the two vertical halves of the film frame, that is with a very simple old celluloid photo camera?

--------------

Bod:
Now, does this definition covers what you were thinking about f22? My guess is that no, exactly like the Wittgenstein definition (and Buddhism definition!), because you have your own "mental structure" (forgive me for the rather simple term) composed on the expectations you have generated in regard with your own way to see the world.

Nobody, but you, can construct what you want regarding your own expectations.
​
Yrreg:
I think you mean that my construct of the world and my expectations are unique to the extent of being unbreachable obstacle to communicate with ordinary people like men in the street, and much less with Buddhists?

On the contrary, I tend to see clearly that Buddhists who insist on the non-self with their explanations are the ones, who are putting construct on and expectations of the world, which renders communication with them difficult if not impossible.

-----------------

Bod:
Now, if you really wanted to know about whats "the foundation" of Buddhism (according to me) then you need to focus only on one thing: Who is this "you" who likes to sign like Yrreg?
​
Yrreg:
You know, all these discussions about knowing Buddhism and knowing Buddhists, the fact is that Buddhism is a man-made stuff if it is anything at all in ideas or in objects. Now, man-man stuffs cannot be known faithfully except by asking their makers what they intend with their "manu-factures."

Even digging a hole by a man is senseless to onlookers unless you ask him about it, and he will tell you that it will be a well, or a cistern to catch and store rain water.

So also with Buddhism. We read the suttras to find out what purportedly the original Buddha -- though he was already one re-carnate from a line of incarnates [sic], meant by their teachings and their practices.

Now that there are still Buddhists, followers of Buddha, we have to ask them to tell us what Buddhism is all about for them; and much better than asking them is to study them; why? because people don't or can't tell you as well about themselves as you can know about them by studying them.

So, we can distinguish between the Buddhism that is the museum item good for antiquarian curiosity, and the Buddhism that is actually professed by living humans, and which we can access for examination to find out what these people are into.

Of course we can then if we prefer also compare what we find out about Buddhism from live-body Buddhists, to what antiquarians find out about the Buddhism in the suttras; and maybe or more probably realize that the Buddhism of the Westerners is really off-track from the Buddhism of the suttras.

And also most probably that the Buddhism of the Westerners are as far from Buddhism in the Far East, as American Indians are far far way from the Indians in India.

But don't count on me to study the suttras, my concentration is on live-body Buddhists. For the former we can depend on antiquarians.


Yrreg
 
Langauge is not only to communicate thoughts.

Physical processes exist, I did not say that they are solely the product of the mind. But thier description in languaga is just that, it is a description used by human beings to communicate thier thoughts about observations. It is a well accepted fact in science that theories are models that predict behavior, however there is a clear distinction between the theory and reality. A theory which acurately predeicts the behavior of observations is considered to be useful. Gravity, inertia exists but they are only described by 'laws' like (gravitational acceleration at the earth's suface equals sixteen feet per second squared) or (f=ma). There is not a law that exists in nature, there are observable processes that exist and there are the words and thoughts used to describe the observed process.

...........


Take the phrase : 1+1+2
is that the truth or is the truth:
01+01=10?

Physical processes exist, I did not say that they are solely the product of the mind. But thier description in languaga is just that, it is a description used by human beings to communicate thier thoughts about observations. -- D David​

Only to communicate? And not principally to control and manipulate what we can together with each other, the forces and materials of nature, and fellow humans?

Do this experiment, tell your wife or girlfriend: "Let's push this table to the opposite side of the room:" nothing happens between you and your partner together? Maybe nothing if your wife or girlfriend is dumb and blind. Okay, another example, in the movie house, shout: "Fire, fire, fire," loud and hysterically? Nothing happens?

-----------------------

Take the phrase : 1+1+2
is that the truth or is the truth:
01+01=10? -- D David
​

What indeed is your point here? that neither the decimal system nor the binary system can be employed in language to communicate with fellow humans about quantities and to construct computers and works of engineering and sciences of all kinds, and do also business and economics, and keep financial statements? and we choose one or the other or even more ways to represent quantities and manipulate them according to how easier and quicker and more accurately we can control and utilize the forces and materials of nature? Think also the formulas in physics, chemistry, and in mathematics.

------------------

You are completely dwelling in your non-world universe owing to your infatuation with Buddhist illusions, delusions, and hallucinations, that you can't think straight anymore as to know that language is not only to communicate thoughts but to enable people to work together to control and utilize the forces of nature and its materials.

No wonder Buddhists have produced nothing useful to mankind except groaning and moaning about suffering and groaning and moaning for eternal and absolute extinction of the self.


Anyway, let's have a good laugh together at how religion makes people think absurdly to their great inutility and even danger to themselves as well and worse to others.


Hahahaha, ala Fat Laughing Buddha. He is the best genius of a Chinese invention in religion.


Pachomius

PS Apologies for the apparently more fire to message ratio than I usually allow in my posts.


Pachomius
 
Dear Bod, allow me to commend you on your Zen-ic equanimity, that is the upside; now the downside is most probably without the invest in Zen (time, labor, expense, trouble) you could have mastered equanimity as well.

Huh, granted. Who said Buddhism is needed for that? ;) I would believe that, to a point, is a learned behaviour and also to an extent a genes thing.

You remember I always insist on the big picture and the short statement. When you see so many different trees, plants, it is very hard to see the forest. But if you go up in an airplane and even higher in a satellite, or hook a camera in it to take pictures of the earth, then you can see where the forests are (if any are left or small patches), the oceans, the dry lands and the deserts.

In both cases you are only seeing your expectations. Allow me to explain. When you focus, say, on a plant, what do you see? Maybe the textures, maybe its chemical composition, maybe its size, or could it be its medical properties? All depends on who you are, not in what is the "plant in itself". The same goes of course for the forest, or Buddhism. This is something I have told you in different ways, but you came back with the same arguments again and again ignoring what Im saying! ;)

Zen Buddhism helps you to change your point of view, and thus helps you to see that the knowledge about the world you believe to be "objective and real" is nothing but an opinion. For me, this is a good thing, for you it is not. I believe we can go along and with respect for each other without the need for the old "I am right you are wrong" stuff. Dont you?

And he (Wittgenstein) had to retire to a monastery and worked in its gardens, doing fervid thinking on words and writing books to tell us, what a kid knows instinctively; that is why a kid always listens to how adults use a word in order to use it to their adults' understanding. Let's have a Fat Happy Laughing Buddha's laugh to that; and remember he was one of you Zen folks.

Huh, I dont know anything about Wittgenstein being a Buddhist. I could be wrong, I tend not to focus on the people that much. I also dont understand what are you trying to imply when you say "he was one of you".

I do not suscribe myself to anything, including Buddhism. I do like it, but I also like so many other things. If anything, I would consider myself an Advaitin, as the title behind my avatar suggest ;) In fact, Im only writting here "defending" (LOL!) Buddhism because I do believe you are missinformed and sincerely wanting to learn. :)

Are you not curious to find out how to take two pictures on the same frame of a film in a very simple way without dismantling the camera, shooting a picture each in the two vertical halves of the film frame, that is with a very simple old celluloid photo camera?

I have never used a film camera. With a nice digital I would use Bulb, covering the lenses between the two pictures. Well thats the way I do it, how about you? Oh, and Im still learning btw, do you have any good sources, books or anything?

I think you mean that my construct of the world and my expectations are unique to the extent of being unbreachable obstacle to communicate with ordinary people like men in the street, and much less with Buddhists?

Nope, just to the extent of making you live in your particular world. Not that that is wrong, its normal, and we all do it.

On the contrary, I tend to see clearly that Buddhists who insist on the non-self with their explanations are the ones, who are putting construct on and expectations of the world, which renders communication with them difficult if not impossible.

Oh, on the contrary dear yrreg! some Buddhists are only seeing the world from a different perspective, one that its considered to be more primary because it defocus our particular liking (and attachement) for our ego. You see, it is the ego what is a construct, not what is "behind it".

You know, all these discussions about knowing Buddhism and knowing Buddhists, the fact is that Buddhism is a man-made stuff if it is anything at all in ideas or in objects. Now, man-man stuffs cannot be known faithfully except by asking their makers what they intend with their "manu-factures."

Still, you forgot, or ignore! the fact that EVERYTHING humans do is man-made stuff. Buddhism is no different from art, science, photography or bakery!

Lets say that some people are thirsty about "the truth", the so called "mystical stuff", about the old "god" or about what is this thing called "reality".

Then they find that all is an illusion projected to us "the individual" and then that even this individual is an illusion in itself.

You are welcomed to think what you like, dear yrreg, but in the end this thing has being around people for more than 2,500 years. Love it, hate it, embrace it, ridiculize it. That doesnt change anything!

You are certainly entitled to say that its a waste of time, but in the same manner I can say that all this effort from you is a waste of time, you will not change the buddhist world, or even a single believer. You can try, if that helps you, but I believe you really need something else.

Maybe learning to see the world from a different perspective. ;)
 
Last edited:
First agree, then agree to disagree, but no arbitrariety.

Bod:
In both cases you are only seeing your expectations. Allow me to explain. When you focus, say, on a plant, what do you see? Maybe the textures, maybe its chemical composition, maybe its size, or could it be its medical properties? All depends on who you are, not in what is the "plant in itself". The same goes of course for the forest, or Buddhism. This is something I have told you in different ways, but you came back with the same arguments again and again ignoring what Im saying!
​

Yrreg:
I think, Bod, we should work at what we can agree on first, instead on hammering on what we disagree on.

In the above paragraph from you, we can agree that we both see, say, a tree. I can see many things and aspects of the tree which we can agree about as what also you see. But we can also disagree about a number of things and aspects about the tree, like how old it is, how much water it takes from the soil every so many hours.

However in both instances what we agree on and what we disagree on are not arbitrary; they are founded on factors independent of our sight, namely, these factors continue to be and operate, if man were not around with eyes to see the tree.

Perhaps it boils down to what I might call interpretation, the basis for our difference in our perceptions of certain factors which are present in the tree and independent of our awareness of their existence.

Now, you can get as many people as you care and ask them what they agree on about the tree and what they disagree about, and what factors are responsible for their differing views; since these are factors independent of people which in the minds of people are called reasons, we cannot say that the differing views arbitrary or whimsical.

So, there are many things people agree on; and there are things people disagree on, but in all cases they have reasons founded upon objective reality; then the things people agree on about objective reality are much more and more important for people to get along, and survive together than the things they disagree on.

Now, about Buddhism, we can agree on more things about Buddhism than we can disagree. And those things we agree about and disagree about are founded not on purely arbitrary considerations, but on factors which are independent of ourselves, so that they are present were we not existing to be aware of Buddhism.

We can agree in regard to Buddhism that it is a phenomenon of beliefs and observances in some humans, authored by humans themselves, the same humans we find everywhere like ourselves, who have to eat, drink, go to the bathroom, and heirs to their psychology in all its dimensions postive and negative in regard to smooth interpersonal relationships.
--------------------


Bod:
Zen Buddhism helps you to change your point of view, and thus helps you to see that the knowledge about the world you believe to be "objective and real" is nothing but an opinion. For me, this is a good thing, for you it is not. I believe we can go along and with respect for each other without the need for the old "I am right you are wrong" stuff. Dont you?
​

Yrreg:
That's very good, Bod. But there are considerations other than abstractly who is right or wrong? For example, who is useful or useless or even harmful or even dangerous or even deadly to others and destructive to the works of nature and man.

That is why I now believe that my interest can be more absorbing and rewarding and more insightful by focusing on contributions of Buddhism to civilization and culture and science.
------------------


Bod:
Huh, I dont know anything about Wittgenstein being a Buddhist. I could be wrong, I tend not to focus on the people that much. I also dont understand what are you trying to imply when you say "he was one of you".
​

Yrreg:
"Let's have a Fat Happy Laughing Buddha's laugh to that; and remember he was one of you Zen folks." I am referring to Fat Buddha, not to Wittgenstein; and I certainly like to see more Zen monks and lay people develop and adopt the lifestyle, humor, mirth and certainly laughing cynicism of Brother Fat Laughing Buddha. Have to read up more about the man, the best genius of an invention from the Chinese in religion.
------------------


Bod:
I do not suscribe myself to anything, including Buddhism. I do like it, but I also like so many other things. If anything, I would consider myself an Advaitin, as the title behind my avatar suggest In fact, Im only writting here "defending" (LOL!) Buddhism because I do believe you are missinformed and sincerely wanting to learn.
​

Yrreg:
You use words and concepts like Advaitin and Avatar, taken from the myths, legends, religious, philosophical speculations of ancient Hindus. To me it is an indication of a fad. I don't think the ancient Hindus were into something we don't know about today or even way back before we come to know about words like Advaitin and Avatar, also in myths, legends, religious and philosophical speculations from Greek prehistory to the present.

And the ancient Hindus most probably if not certainly did not know the distinction: between myths and religions and philosophies and sciences plus technologies, with clear discrimination.
---------


Please proceed to next post.


Yrreg
 
Physical processes exist, I did not say that they are solely the product of the mind. But thier description in languaga is just that, it is a description used by human beings to communicate thier thoughts about observations. -- D David​

Only to communicate? And not principally to control and manipulate what we can together with each other, the forces and materials of nature, and fellow humans?

I did not state the purpose of the communication, there are many wills and intents to communicate. But the laws of nature do not exist they are human conventions.

Do this experiment, tell your wife or girlfriend: "Let's push this table to the opposite side of the room:" nothing happens between you and your partner together? Maybe nothing if your wife or girlfriend is dumb and blind. Okay, another example, in the movie house, shout: "Fire, fire, fire," loud and hysterically? Nothing happens?
What are you trying to communicate, I stated that you should not mistake concepts for the processes that they represent. I don't recall saying that there were not effects of communication.
-----------------------

Take the phrase : 1+1+2
is that the truth or is the truth:
01+01=10? -- D David
​

What indeed is your point here? that neither the decimal system nor the binary system can be employed in language to communicate with fellow humans about quantities and to construct computers and works of engineering and sciences of all kinds, and do also business and economics, and keep financial statements? and we choose one or the other or even more ways to represent quantities and manipulate them according to how easier and quicker and more accurately we can control and utilize the forces and materials of nature? Think also the formulas in physics, chemistry, and in mathematics.
Evidently you are noy aware that the world paradigm has shifted since the Victorian era, numbers do not exist, they are concepts used by humans, The tools used by humans can be very effective, I did not say that math is not a useful tool, just that it is 'truth' through defintion and convention.

Just because a tool exists does not mean that it represents 'truth', which was the statement you appeared to be making.
------------------

You are completely dwelling in your non-world universe owing to your infatuation with Buddhist illusions, delusions, and hallucinations, that you can't think straight anymore as to know that language is not only to communicate thoughts but to enable people to work together to control and utilize the forces of nature and its materials.

Ah, that is so well spoken Yrreg, I stand in awe of your careful reasoning and peacefull nature. ;)

If you think that you don't co-operate with other people by conveying thoughts, than I ask you a simple question:
What are you conveying?

I dwell in the world, I suggest that you learn to distinguish your finger from the moon.
No wonder Buddhists have produced nothing useful to mankind except groaning and moaning about suffering and groaning and moaning for eternal and absolute extinction of the self.
It is a wonder how you just like to slam other people, I am a buddhist , I help many people as best I can.

What do you do for a living Yrreg?
I am a crisis intervention counselor, my clients generaly find the services I provide to be useful, and they generaly agree with my interventions. I am a buddhist and I am productive. The only whining I read here seems to be coming from you whining about buddhists.

Any links to that philosopher Asmus yet?

:)
Anyway, let's have a good laugh together at how religion makes people think absurdly to their great inutility and even danger to themselves as well and worse to others.

By Frued man, what is inutility!

You have yet to think about the teachings of the buddha, so what utility it might have, you can't judge. It is like any other religion, it has ten percent fools, eighty percent sheep and ten percent practioners. Each may find thier own benefit.

Hahahaha, ala Fat Laughing Buddha. He is the best genius of a Chinese invention in religion.
I like green Tara and Kuan Yin, but if Hotei does it for you that is great. Somewhere there are buddhists who practice laughter, I forget which sect.
Pachomius
Is that a sneeze, or is it a word I should know?
PS Apologies for the apparently more fire to message ratio than I usually allow in my posts.
No problem, it would help if you showed more of yourself, I write stories and tell fables as well.
Pachomius
 
I will answer my own questions.

Yrreg:
If your stacks are still intact, just tell me if you are given a camera with the f/1.8, f/2.8, f/4, f/5.6, f/8, f/11, f/16, f/22 markings and stops defaced and the pointer removed; tell me how you are going to find out at what f/ stop the aperture happens to be opened?

Are you not curious to find out how to take two pictures on the same frame of a film in a very simple way without dismantling the camera, shooting a picture each in the two vertical halves of the film frame, that is with a very simple old celluloid photo camera?

Here is how to find the f/ setting of a lens aperture if the pointer is removed so you can't know from it at which f/ setting it should be pointing at were it not removed.

Consider that you are being tested for knowledge of camera designs and technology and engineering, and you are given a very simple old celluloid film camera with the f/ pointer removed, but every component otherwise intact; and you are asked what is the f/ aperture of the iris diaphragm, lens opening, as it is actually set, and how you arrive at it -- in 50 words or less.

Measure diameter of actual aperture, say, 1 centimeter; next, measure distance from inside lens to film frame, say, 4 centimenters; now divide 4 by 1, getting 4, the actual aperture setting of f/4. F/ means ratio of focal length to the lens opening. (43 words)​
-----------------------

Here is how to take two exposures on one frame of a film, using an old simple camera without anti double-exposure lock, and without dismantling the camera or working inside,

Cover one vertical half of lens tube opening with opaque stick-on tape, avoid contact with lens; draw vertical line to bisect front viewfinder; shoot on objects in viewfinder aligned to non-covered half of lens-tube; transfer stick-on tape to other side, and proceed accordingly as before. (45 words)​
---------------------------

Proof from MS Word word count:​


I really enjoy this stuff.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with lOve, Putai.

 
Cool Yrreg, that is the santa claus buddha, who predates santa, allegedly he used his alms to purchase toys for children that he carried in his sack!(The toys were is the sack, not the children.)
 
I am not a bandwagon skeptic.

Cool Yrreg, that is the santa claus buddha, who predates santa, allegedly he used his alms to purchase toys for children that he carried in his sack!(The toys were is the sack, not the children.)

I am glad, D David, that you also have an appreciation for FL Bude (Fat Laughing Buddha) as I have.

I am now busy playing the script of defendant for acupuncture and Chinese mediciine generally, contrary to self-appointed prosecutors of these non-conventional healing, shall we say, arts.

Know of any Buddhist literature on the side for acupuncture and Chinese medicine?


I now realize that I am somewhat a super skeptic (self-pedestal-ism), so that where there is a bandwagon, then that is where I like to dwell on, to examine how and for what psychological or material gains people jump into the bandwagon.


You know, I can see many things in Buddhism which is good and I mean good, except for its to my impression gloomy over-emphasis [hahahaha] on suffering, and also its in effect nihilism and negativism mind-set on the non-self and the non-world.

I still think that Buddha and his early followers were not really into non-self and non-world, but more for practical emphasis on not taking the material and temporal world so addictively.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Butai.
putai26eo.gif
 
Sorry Yrreg, nothing on acupuncture or TCM, from me. I do know that I had an old cat, she was fiveteen, that benefitted from akebia to treat some kidney problems.
 
What saith ye about acupuncture?

Dear good Buddhist friends, what do you think of my post in that thread on "Any Value in Acupuncture?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1445478&postcount=52

Yrreg said:
This is not directly connected with my present concern, namely:
3 logic said:
(http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1438966&postcount=30)
Originally Posted by Yrreg : (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1437823&postcount=18)
1. Acupuncture is an acceptable option for dealing with medical complaints, if you don't have enough money for treatment and medication in conventional scientific medicine, or if conventional scientific medicine has given up on you.​
--------------

[3 logic:]
Acupuncture is acceptable to whom and by what standards? The National Council Against Health Fraud does not consider acupuncture an acceptable option.
http://www.ncahf.org/pp/acu.html

I just like to share here as some kind of obiter materials, my wondering maybe some people here who are adverse to acupuncture are sympathetic to Buddhism and even call themselves Buddhists (people who are proud to call themselves Buddhists, like for example, Ryokan and Dancing David), with whom the undersigned has had and still going on many a discussion on Buddhism, from the standpoint of what I call scientific skeptical criticism.

I will ask them, the Buddhists in those threads where I either initiated or participate in, from my part as a critic with what I might consider valid exceptions, whether they being Buddhists are positively or negatively inclined toward acupuncture -- seeing that the folks who bring them Buddhism also bring acupuncture and medical practices from the Far East to the West.

What about the people here in this thread, anyone Buddhist here?

One impression I keep getting from the Buddhists here in this skeptics' forum is that there are things science as we have it now cannot deal with and therefore must be, at least not be suppressive in their regard.

These are the people who also do meditation and report favorable and even medical or broadly health benefits from meditation, specifically the Buddhist kinds of. There are also other kinds of meditation, practically all coming from the Far East, in particular that motherland of all such philosophico-religious speculations about karma and rebirths and ultimate nirvana, etc., India, and to a the way I see it lesser extent, China.

(The Chinese are not as mystical as the Indians, but they are a practical people who will absorb anything and everything that works, understanding 'works' as good for them -- understanding 'good' as anything that at least makes you feel better if nothing else. My opinion again, I could be wrong.)

Is acupuncture a fad as I keep saying to my Buddhist colleagues here that Buddhism is a fad; in which case acupuncture is winning over Buddhism by leaps and bounds.

[Hahahaha softly.]

-----------------

Oh well, back to my concern here at present with 3logic's authority from the NCAHF and now the authority of the HON: authorities to not say to anyone coming to me, that:

Originally Posted by Yrreg : (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1437823&postcount=18)
1. Acupuncture is an acceptable option for dealing with medical complaints, if you don't have enough money for treatment and medication in conventional scientific medicine, or if conventional scientific medicine has given up on you.​

No, I am not telling anyone coming to me with a medical problem, as to a man in the street with an opinion, that drowning oneself "is an acceptable option for dealing with medical complaints, if you don't have enough money for treatment and medication in conventional scientific medicine, or if conventional scientific medicine has given up on you."

So, shall we continue in polite and civil language, systematically, one step at a time?

And remember, keep the ratio of fire to message small or zero, but increase the message to fire ratio to massive degrees. And yes or no, no emotionalism, please.

Yrreg

Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Butai.
putai26eo.gif
 
Buddhism is not a religion.

Sorry I'm late to the list, just noticed it.
anyway here are my thoughts.

All I ever got from Buddhism was an invitation to investigate suffering.

The way that I see that it works is that if you have a problem, if you suffer, if you feel ill at ease about anything, you bring this to the Buddha and there is the possibility that he can help.

From this viewpoint, Buddha cannot help everyone. If you have no problems then you need no help, and there is no sense going to the Buddha.

chunol
 
Buddhism is not a religion.

Sorry I'm late to the list, just noticed it.
anyway here are my thoughts.

All I ever got from Buddhism was an invitation to investigate suffering.

The way that I see that it works is that if you have a problem, if you suffer, if you feel ill at ease about anything, you bring this to the Buddha and there is the possibility that he can help.

From this viewpoint, Buddha cannot help everyone. If you have no problems then you need no help, and there is no sense going to the Buddha.

chunol
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom