Medical and Healthcare phishing

Once again skepticdoc, you've shown yourself as not up to the challenge of responding to the substance of my post. I have provided a case for your "manifesto" being useless. I would think you'd be embarrassed and want to demonstrate your superior intellect/education/or whatever it is you attribute to physicians that a nurse couldn't possibly possess. This is a forum of skeptics. Skeptics recognize ad hominem attacks used to hide incompetence.

You also resort again to a straw man argument. I'm sure I made it clear several times nurses are definitely not the same as doctors. Yet you hide behind that statement so you don't have to address the issue of nurses' superiority to doctors in many areas of patient care. Nursing is better suited to educating, comforting and assisting patients to cope with their illnesses. Medicine is better suited to diagnose, choose medical treatments and perform surgical interventions. Since the two fields overlap considerably, many of us perform in both fields.

There is a physician whom I respect tremendously working in Haiti with tuberculosis patients, some of which also have HIV. He has implemented a method of training local health care volunteers in administering DOT (directly observed therapy) for TB patients. In developing this program he has demonstrated a model of care which has been successful in the most dire circumstances. DOT for TB in a country with no public health infrastructure and high rates of HIV co-infections was a task many had thought not possible.

DOT was developed by public health NURSES who needed to deal with patients who had to take antibiotics for at least for 9 months and sometimes as long as 2 years. Doctors prescribed the antibiotics but what good were they if the patients did not complete treatment. In fact, the prescriptions if not taken for the full term actually harm the patient and put the rest of the community at risk because TB easily develops drug resistance if treated incompletely. The physician in my example was practicing nursing.

From Crickets to Condoms and BeyondDOT is currently recognized by the WHO and all public health agencies as the most effective way to treat TB especially in persons co-infected with TB and HIV.

The medical care I provide overlaps into my field of ADVANCED NURSING PRACTICE. The nursing care the physician in my example provides overlaps into his medical practice. Nurses are not doctors as well, doctors are not nurses. But we both have critical roles in the health care field. You can't treat TB effectively with either medicine or nursing alone.

You can't treat a critically ill patient without both doctors and nurses. You can't perform major surgery without nurses. Doctors haven't delegated the tasks they don't want to perform to nurses. We arrived in the field on our own, thank you. And we developed nursing care on our own as well. And whether or not you, skepticdoc, drop your foolish attitude about nursing and medicine, I have very much enjoyed this opportunity to educate a few forum readers as to just what nursing practice actually is.

.. not by DOT alone.

Don't you feel just a little bit stupid about your attitude by now, skepticdoc?

Haiti is not a developed country.

Now, who is insulting who?
 
Cave Dave, you earn more than some doctors. I know of ER/Urgent Care positions that pay $50/hr.
 
Haiti is not a developed country.
Moving the goalposts. The word you used as a criterion before was "civilized." Are you saying Haiti has not yet become civilized?

Now, who is insulting who?
Given the above, it looks as if you're insulting an entire nation -- dismissing as lacking validity with a casual, careless wave of the hand -- including doctors and nurses who are working their butts off dealing with situations you're too "civilized" to be bothered with.

[edited for wording and such]
 
Last edited:
Haiti, what a wonderful place!

You can learn about Vodoo, you can learn how to hatchet somebody with a machete, so many other "civilized" skills! (have you heard about the Tonton Macoute?)

I am so sorry for my errors.
 
Haiti, what a wonderful place!

You can learn about Vodoo, you can learn how to hatchet somebody with a machete, so many other "civilized" skills! (have you heard about the Tonton Macoute?)

I am so sorry for my errors.

Wow. Just wow.

I thought the anecdote described real healthcare workers, exposing themselves to real personal (and professional?) risks, to develop solutions for the real problems of real people, but now I know they don't count 'cause they're just a bunch of spear-chuckers anyway.
 
...but now I know they don't count 'cause they're just a bunch of spear-chuckers anyway.

No, no, no. You missed the point. They're Voodoo Machette-Swingers, not spear-chuckers.

And I can't really blame skeptidoc. I mean, he must be having trouble seeing everyone else's actual posts with all those straw men he's got standing up in his way.
 
No, no, no. You missed the point. They're Voodoo Machette-Swingers, not spear-chuckers.

And I can't really blame skeptidoc. I mean, he must be having trouble seeing everyone else's actual posts with all those straw men he's got standing up in his way.
I wounder why, when he seems to have such a penchant for little straw men, Skepdoc has such a problem with the birthplace of voodoo?
 
No, no, no. You missed the point. They're Voodoo Machette-Swingers, not spear-chuckers.

And I can't really blame skeptidoc. I mean, he must be having trouble seeing everyone else's actual posts with all those straw men he's got standing up in his way.

OK, I guess I've confused myself. Are spear-chuckers subordinate to Voodoo Machete-Swingers, or is it the other way around?
 
Haiti, what a wonderful place!
You can learn about Vodoo, you can learn how to hatchet somebody with a machete, so many other "civilized" skills! (have you heard about the Tonton Macoute?)

I hadn't realized an entire group of people could be reduced to a biased caricature of its worst elements. That explains a lot about what I read concerning America. You won't mind if I judge all doctors by the nastiest stories I've heard about them, distilled into a few pithy slurs, will you?

I am so sorry for my errors.
Not nearly as sorry as some of the rest of us are.

You may or may have an actual medical degree but as far as I'm concerned all you are doing here is trolling. Not "phishing." Trolling. You were close, but had the wrong word.
 
Haiti is not a developed country.

Now, who is insulting who?
All you can post is another straw man? I think we have sufficient evidence here that you are incapable of defending the need, relevance and/or usefulness of your "manifesto". You might consider revising it with a little more of an evidence based medicine approach. What information is useful for a GP to hand out to her/his patients? With no evidence of any benefit, your patients may just view the manifesto as tacky. I think that is how it sounded to forum members reading this thread.

And incredulously, the straw man you used provided even more mind boggling evidence of your inability to read. Your post makes absolutely no sense no matter how I interpret it. Either you are saying Haiti isn't developed in which case I find no relevance. Or you are saying it sarcastically as if I had said it. Development is relative and quite often inconsistent within countries. A statement such as, "Haiti isn't a developed country", is useless in the context of my paragraph. Which is why I made a more specific comment, "a country with no public health infrastructure." If Haiti had a public health infrastructure they wouldn't need outside assistance to develop a TB/HIV treatment program.
 
This whole thread reminds me of a joke.
The pope dies and arrives in heaven. But there's a long line in front of the Pearly Gates and he's at the end. So he goes up to the gates and says to St. Peter, "Do you know who I am?"
St. Pete says, "Yes, but up here everybody's equal, take your turn in line."
The pope goes back to the end of the line and waits. And waits.
All of a sudden a big Mercedes with MD plates comes roaring up to the gate, Pete waves, gates open and the Merc drives through.
This is enough to p!ss off the pope. He runs up to St. Peter, says,"Why did you let the doctor in and not me, the pope?"
"That was god, he only thinks he's a Doctor."
 
The Ranks in the Hospital (I'm posting the whole thing because this is a well known quote and not owned by the site in the link, IE I'm relatively certain it isn't copyrighted. I first saw it over 20 years ago.)
Surgeon:
Leaps tall buildings in a single bound
Is more productive than a train
Is faster than a speeding bullet
Walks on water
Talks with God

Internist:
Leaps short buildings in a single bound
Is more powerful than a switch engine
Is faster than a speeding BB
Walks on water if the sea is calm
Talks with God if special request is approved

General Practitioner:
Leaps short buildings with a running start and favorable winds
Is almost as powerful as a switch engine
Can fire a speeding bullet
Walks on water in an indoor swimming pool
Is occasionally addressed by God

Resident:
Barely clears a picket fence
Loses tug-of-war with a train
Can sometimes handle a gun without inflicting self-injury
Swims well
Talks with animals

Intern:
Makes high skid marks on a wall when trying to leap buildings
Is run over by a train
Is not issued ammunition
Dog paddles
Talks to walls

Medical Student:
Runs into buildings
Recognizes a train 2 out of 3 times
Wets himself with a water pistol
Cannot stay afloat without a life preserver
Mumbles to himself

Nurse:
Lifts buildings and walks under them
Kicks trains off the track
Catches speeding bullets with her teeth and eats them
Freezes water with a single glance
The Nurse IS God!!!!
 
I repeat my question:

Where else in the civilized world are the nurses the same as doctors?

I am probably wasting a little energy explaining myself to this crowd, but I believe taking care of patients, curing ailments that can be cured, and providing comfort/palliative care requires many different people and skills. From the garbage collector to the Neurosurgeon, everybody plays an important part. Skeptigirl probably agrees with that, but she is not going to admit that we both agree on this point!

Re-read the thread, the impression I get from this "skeptigirl" is that either she is a Super-Woman, or delusional.

She wrote:
"first I have a solo practice in occupational infectious disease"

I interpret that as she is the only nurse in her hospital working with employees that handle hazardous waste, are exposed to bodily fluids or have suffered needlesticks/puncture wounds.


Later she wrote:

"The medical model, and forgive me for grossly oversimplifying a very complex issue, is the practice of treating the disease. The nursing model is the practice of treating the patient."

"Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need."

"I practice in both fields. I think you may have gotten the impression I was judging one field as better than the other. Absolutely not. They compliment each other.

What are Skeptigirl two fields of practice?
Does she have a split personality, Doctor-Nurse, Nurse-Doctor?
Who does not want to be cured?!!!!!!


I asked: So, what do Doctors do?

Skeptigirl wrote:
"Surgical, pharmaceutical and similar interventions for medical problems.

Nurses do more teaching and helping the patient carry out the medical care and live with the disease if that is needed.

Both fields have considerable overlap which is why I said I was oversimplifying my description.

So, is that her limited vision of Medical Practice, or just her own justification for her anti-doctor prejudice?
Why does she want to do pharmaceutical interventions, is that the field of doctors?


I asked: So, where else in the developed western world do nurses claim to be equal to physicians? There was no answer.


Skeptigirl wrote:
"Another reason for the discrepancy however is the fact that nursing encompasses a wide spectrum of skilled workers. We don't do a good job in our profession of distinguishing between an RN with a 2 year college degree doing basic patient care and an RN with either a higher degree and/or extensive experience performing the most skilled care for critically ill patients.

We have begun to distinguish nurse specialists. Those are nurses who perform much more complex nursing in almost all fields. Such a nurse might manage chronically ill patients in a doctor's office or oversee the infection control in a hospital. The extent of specialized nursing is very wide. And as far as medicine is concerned, nurses in the USA provide medical care from family practice to anesthesia.

In my little corner of the world, there is great division and stratification of nursing duties in the hospital from PCT, to LPN, to RN, to CRN, to CCRN, to CRNA. Many times this division involves dumping the less glamorous duties to the whoever is lowest in the Totem pole, and sometimes I see LPNs that are care more about the patient and are more medically competent than RNs!


Skeptigirl wrote:
"I know Australia has the Flying Doctor Service that relies heavily on nurses practicing in advanced roles."

This started the topic of less developed areas of the world.


"Any bleeding? So if you cut your finger cutting the carrots for your stew, and it bleeds, go to the doctor.

Any pain that you have not experienced before? So the first time you go to Disneyland and your feet hurt at the end of the day and that never happened before, go to the doctor.

Any fever or chill? Go to the doctor for every single mild sore throat/runny nose if your temperature goes to 99 or higher.

Any numbness or weakness? If you fall asleep with your hand bent under you and you wake up and it is numb, go to the doctor.

Any shortness of breath? When you run the bases this spring in your first softball game of the year and you get short of breath, go to the doctor.

I only interpret this as mocking signs and symptoms of potentially serious diseases/conditions.


"Originally Posted by skepticdoc :
in the US, ... I see looming crisis in the allocation of resources for healthcare, with families of demented elderly demanding everything that Medicine can offer, expecting Medicare and the States to pay for it at the same time that Americans do not want to pay more taxes to pay for those services!
Interesting that "families of demented elderly demanding everything Medicine can offer" is the example used by the same person who claimed doctors were there to cure and a nurse advocate for assisting a patient in a peaceful death was a threat to that patient. Again, I digress but it's so satisfying to point out the hypocrisy of this person.

Where is the hypocrisy?


Skeptigirl wrote:
"I teach infectious disease precautions to health care workers. I often include examples of what I call tunnel vision. I learned it from another nurse teaching ED nurses how to assess a patient in the ED. The patient in question had an ax literally stuck in his forehead. What do you do? Unless there is an artery spurting from the ax wound (your airway breathing circulation check), you do your normal head to toe assessment of the patient. Turned out the guy also had an icepick stab wound in the heart that if it wasn't addressed first would have killed him.

So are you just repeating an anecdote? Are you also a Trauma Nurse?


Skeptigirl wrote:
"The medical care I provide overlaps into my field of ADVANCED NURSING PRACTICE. The nursing care the physician in my example provides overlaps into his medical practice. Nurses are not doctors as well, doctors are not nurses. But we both have critical roles in the health care field. You can't treat TB effectively with either medicine or nursing alone.

You can't treat a critically ill patient without both doctors and nurses. You can't perform major surgery without nurses. Doctors haven't delegated the tasks they don't want to perform to nurses. We arrived in the field on our own, thank you. And we developed nursing care on our own as well. And whether or not you, skepticdoc, drop your foolish attitude about nursing and medicine, I have very much enjoyed this opportunity to educate a few forum readers as to just what nursing practice actually is.

So do you agree that nowhere are doctors and nurses equal?


In some underdeveloped countries, they deliver care without nurses or doctors, the use people that can read and follow a protocol that has been developed to deliver medical care, they probably still have "Barefoot Doctors" in rural areas of China.

Still no doctors have replied to my first post, maybe its like Baptists at Hooter's (they don't recognize each other!) or they do not want to waddle in the mud with the forum crowd or myself! Either way I have found my answer in the physician-only forum.
 
I repeat my question:

Where else in the civilized world are the nurses the same as doctors?
OK skepticdoc, let's start with your straw man. Everyone else reading the thread seems to get it. Maybe you just need a bit of remedial reading first. After all, your impression that the nursing profession began as handmaidens to doctors did demonstrate how totally ignorant of the nursing profession you were.

Florence Nightingale is recognized as having founded the profession of nursing. It may interest you to know that
When the Crimean War broke out in 1854, she oversaw the introduction of female nurses into the military hospitals in Turkey. Initially greeted with hostility, she took quick action to improve the deplorable conditions of the wounded, dramatically reducing mortality rates among soldiers from 40% to 2%.
Nursing had nothing to do with doctors delegating less critical tasks to nurses. The point you seem to repeatedly ignore is that nurses don't just play some piddly little role under the guidance of some knowledgeable doctor. We play an equally important and knowledgeable role as hard as that seems for you to swallow. So read on, I'm not done.
While Nightingale is best known for her work during the war, some of her most valuable contributions came afterwards. ... Her first major works were two books published in 1859, Notes on Hospital and Notes on Nursing, detailing her views on health care reform gained from her experience during the war.
Note that is a major contribution to hospital nursing care, not a contribution to how nurses might better assist doctors.

She founded the Nightingale School and Home for Nurses at St. Thomas's Hospital , London in 1860, the first of its kind. The objective of the school was to produce nurses who could train others. The following year she established a training school for midwives in King's College Hospital.

... As a passionate statistician, she conducted extensive research and analysis. She published over 200 reports and pamphlets on a wide range of issues including hygiene, hospital administration and design, midwifery and health care for the poor.
Do you see assisting physicians in there anywhere?

Her vision completely changed society's approach to nursing. ...She believed that it was important to look after an individual's health, mental and physical, as well as sickness, an idea well ahead of its time.

Her voice was strong and she served as an effective advocate on a number of important health issues, particularly for trained nursing and preventive health care through proper hygiene. She could be extremely persuasive and through her contacts in the government, she influenced public policy and achieved positive health care reforms.
Women were hired to do menial tasks in the first hospitals in the United States. But that was not where nursing originated. Instead, nurses replaced those positions, beginning in the US with the efforts of Linda Richards. She did study medicine with a mentor as a teen and then had more formal training which at that time in the US was training provided by a physician. But that was just her beginning. From there she initiated changes in nursing schools and subsequently in the profession.
... ...she was hired as an assistant nurse at the Boston City Hospital. Nurses were treated as little better than maids at the hospital and she left after only 3 months because of poor health. Some months later [she began a] nurse-training program ... offered at the New England Hospital for Women and Children. The resident physician, Miss. Susan Dimock, had studied medicine since she was 15 and had trained for surgery at the University of Zurich. Linda was one of five students who sign up for the course.

After a year of training, Linda Richards, the first student to enroll, was the first to graduate from the nursing program. Her diploma is in the archives of the Smithsonian Institution in Washington, DC. ...became the night supervisor at Bellevue Hospital in New York City where she met Sister Helen, ...who had trained in the Nightingale System in London. At Bellevue Linda created a system for charting and maintaining individual medical records for each patient. This was the first written reporting system for nurses which even the famous Nightingale System adopted.

...1874 [she took] over the floundering Boston Training School. Her administrative experience with Sister Helen helped her turn the program around and it became one of the best nurse training programs in the country.

In 1877 Linda traveled to England for seven months of intensive study. She spent two months at St. Thomas's Hospital in London, the hospital Florence Nightingale had established in 1860. It was during this time that she was able to meet Miss Nightingale herself, who suggested Linda study at King's College Hospital and the Edinburgh Royal Infirmary in Scotland....

She returned to Boston in 1878 to work at the Boston College Hospital where she established a nurse training school. ... used her experience to establish the first nurse-training program in Japan. ... She stayed in Japan for 5 years before returning to America.

Linda Richards continued to establish nurse training programs and schools in Philadelphia, Massachusetts and Michigan.
The point of all this is to help you understand the problem with your attitude and your straw man is that you have yet to recognize nurses are not an extension of physicians. Our practices overlap but the nursing profession is complete in it's own right. Neither I nor my colleagues take orders from physicians. Just because you bark them out and we write them down and have a role in getting that medical care provided to the patient does not put us in some hierarchy as you believe. Medical orders are merely one of many tasks I do as a nurse. And if I feel those orders are not in the best interest of the patient, the physician and I discuss it.

So where in the civilized world are nurses the same as doctors? This question can only be answered if one clarifies what you mean by "the same". In your case you have only mentioned this comparison in terms of authority. In that case, I'd say with advanced nurses the authority is often equal. The equality in authority is dependent on the employment setting not the profession. The bottom line however is that not only can any nurse refuse to follow a medical order, in most states we are legally liable if we don't refuse and the order isn't within medical practice guidelines. Seems we have to oversee those doctors when they don't do a proper job.

I have 100% authority over what I order in my practice. There are no physicians in it. But whenever I do interact with physicians in this practice, I act as a consultant. If one doctor consults with another the primary doctor can choose to follow or reject what is advised. Most doctors follow the consultant's recommendations. The primary doctor usually wouldn't have asked had they not believed the consultant had more expertise in a particular field. When a physician requests my services as a consultant, I've not had any of them reject my opinion. And, I also have patients which physicians have referred to me. You are just wrong on this one, skepticdoc. You don't have to believe me. Just look into advanced nursing practice laws and advanced nursing practices in this country and in countries around the world.

Nurse Anesthetists are the same as doctors by the criteria you ask about.
In the United States, anesthesiology or anesthesia care is provided by two specialty groups, nurse anesthetists and anesthesiologists (physicians). Nurse anesthetists or certified registered nurse anesthetists (CRNA) are licensed professional nurses (RNs) who undergo extensive training, become nationally certified by exam after graduation, and then provide services similar to an anesthesiologist. CRNAs can be licensed and practice in all fifty states. ... As a whole, the nurse anesthesia profession is 'silent.' Very few nonmedical layman, students, or professionals know of it's existence. Usually, only medical professionals actively involved in surgical services are keenly aware of nurse anesthesia activities. Finally, nurse anesthetists train and practice in 107 different countries, as delegates from other counties participate in the yearly World Congress of the International Federation of Nurse Anesthetists. Recent studies find anesthesia care worldwide is operationally a nursing function.

History of Nurse Midwives in the USA will show you the medical care they provide.

Columbia Advanced Practice Nurse Associates, or Capna, is run by nurse practitioners—nurses who are trained to be full primary-care providers. They diagnose conditions, prescribe treatments and make referrals to specialists—everything traditional doctors do.
Sounds "the same" to me.

Founded 10 years ago as a project of the Columbia University School of Nursing, Capna has been in the vanguard of changes that have brought new respectability to nurse practitioners. In 1994 it was the first nurse-run clinic in the country to win full privileges to admit patients to hospitals. Three years later came another first: Insurance companies began compensating the practice at the same rate as physicians.

Now some experts believe that nurse-run operations like Capna may be critical to the future of health care in the U.S.
Was it my admitting privileges you called into question further on in your post?

Nurses serve as generals and on top CDC advisory panels. Nurses get PhDs in NURSING which seems to be difficult for you to comprehend. No they aren't doctors, but they're certainly equals.

MINNEAPOLIS/ST. PAUL June 10, 2004 -- Pediatric Nurse Practitioner Patsy Stinchfield, MSN, RN, CPNP of Children's Hospitals and Clinics of Minneapolis/St. Paul, has been appointed to the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices by U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Tommy Thompson.

Stinchfield, 46, becomes the first advanced practice nurse or nurse ever appointed to the 15-member ACIP. Reporting to Secretary Thompson and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the ACIP brings together the nation's leading experts on vaccine-preventable disease to guide U.S. policy on immunization. A nurse for more than 25 years and a pediatric nurse practitioner since 1987, she is the director of the infectious disease service line at Children's, which oversees infectious disease and immunology, infection control, and the Children's Immunization Project.
In other words Stinchfield oversees the physicians in that department. If you care to investigate further, be my guest.

Brig. General Kristine Campbell, on being an Army nurse:

I was the first nurse and first woman to serve in the role of combat support hospital commander. It was an all-encompassing position. I was responsible for all the people under me and their families-about 450 people. Until then, I had been chief nurse and knew how to be in charge of nursing care and staff. But as a commander I had the responsibility to keep everyone safe.
Which reminded me I hadn't even brought up the fact that many nurses are corporate CEOs or heads of the nursing departments of large medical centers. How do you view such a person as beneath you? That's nuts. I'm sure General Campbell has more than one physician she outranks.

Distinguished Doctors of Nursing
Susie Kim (2001), RN DNSc, FAAN

Dr Kim has made major contributions to nursing education and practice which have earned her international recognition. She is Professor and former Dean of the College of Nursing Science at the Ewha Women's University in Seoul, Korea and is the Director of the Research Institute of Nursing Science and the Chair of the Psychiatric-Mental Health Nursing Division.

In the field of mental health, Dr. Kim used qualitative research methodology to develop eight interpersonal caring techniques for improving self esteem. The techniques have been widely tested and proven effective for chronic psychiatric and hospice care patients in Korea.

In nursing practice, she designed and established the first community-based mental health nurse care centre in Korea. The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) recognised the effectiveness of the centre in rehabilitating long-term medical patients at an affordable cost in Korea and in other developing countries. UNDP supported her pilot project in 1996-98, which resulted in 15 additional community based centres.
I'm going to split the rest of my reply to your post off into another thread to make it easier to follow and so I can stop for now. I'll finish tomorrow.
 
Last edited:
I thought about responding to Skeptidoctroll, but fear it would pall into insignificance when compared to your own efforts.

PS - despite his claims, I see nothing in any of your posts that expresses prejudice against doctors in general. Indeed, it is Skeptidoc who sems to be full of prejudice against other members of the medical profession. I wonder what gave him such a large chip on his shoulder..... perhaps a nurse once gave him an uncomfortable enema, and he has borne a grudge ever since?
 
I see a big difference here between an educated and enlightened person and a person who lacks insight, is stuck in a time warp and may have a closed mind.

I would be happy to consult with Skeptigirl with an illness or complaint knowing that she would use evidense based medicine to help guide me to ownership of a managment plan that would work for and with me.

In Th UK, Nurse Practitioners and Specialist Nurse advisors are held in very high regard.

When the MRSA rates in UK hospitals went through the roof, who did the NHS turn to

Infectious Disease Consultants??

Pathologists??

Bacteriolgists???

No

They turned to Matrons. that's right, senior nurses
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom