Medical and Healthcare phishing

From Wikipedia: In Internet terminology, a troll is someone who comes into an established community such as an online discussion forum, and posts inflammatory, rude or offensive messages designed to annoy and antagonize the existing members or disrupt the flow of discussion (see Anonymous Internet posting).

I extend an invitation to read my posts in the Skeptic Forum, I use the same Forum name. Skeptigirl has joined the Skeptic Forum under a different name to follow me, or to harass me, not sure yet of her intentions.

Could her actions be considered trolling?

The best defense against a charlatan is to use their own words against them.

The facts as I see them are:

1) it takes many different kind of workers to take care of the medical needs of humans

2) a Cardiologist saved my life by performing an angioplasty in my blocked coronary, nurses helped him, but he did the most important part

3) a Surgeon saved my life by removing my appendix when I was in 7th grade, nurses helped him, but he did the most important part

4) Doctors write orders for nurses to follow in the hospital.

The only regret I have is using the wording of wrath when Skeptigirl posted: "Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need." I probably should have ignored that post.

I should have also acknowledged the care and skills of the Nurses and Orderlies that took care of me most of the time after my lifesaving procedures.
 
Thought I'd delurk to post some mid-thread scoring:

skeptigirl: Excellent posts, good points, etc. My medical knowledge is limited to knowing aspirin works on some headaches so I have learned a lot. Score=1.

skepticdoc: Narrow-minded, poor reading skills, pedantic. Has not imparted any knowledge. His manifesto did, however, provide a modicum of humor. Score=.00001

Carry on....
 
...

Could her actions be considered trolling?
No, and you'll have to go to the skeptic forum thread to read why. But I am glad you weren't happy to see me in the skeptic forum.

The best defense against a charlatan is to use their own words against them.
Irony meter is climbing. ;)

The facts as I see them are:

1) it takes many different kind of workers to take care of the medical needs of humans

2) a Cardiologist saved my life by performing an angioplasty in my blocked coronary, nurses helped him, but he did the most important part

3) a Surgeon saved my life by removing my appendix when I was in 7th grade, nurses helped him, but he did the most important part
You might have lived after the appy without a nurse, if you didn't have any complications. And after an angioplasty there isn't much to do in the way of nursing unless the femoral artery fails to stay closed. But if that artery opened and there wasn't a person there trained in what to do, you'd be dead. OTOH, in those particular examples I agree, though with reservations about which criteria you judge 'important' by. As if those examples represent all medicine and all nursing...I don't think so. In the example you used above where the family wanted everything done for their demented family member, nursing care would be more important. You should be happy about that. You think it's delegating work doctors don't want to do. Actually, it's called nursing care, not delegated medical care.

In the ICU after coronary bypass surgery, I guarantee you that you need both the surgeon and nurse. Neither is more important since you cannot have bypass surgery without nursing care. Ask any cardiac surgeon.

4) Doctors write orders for nurses to follow in the hospital.
No, you have this one wrong. Doctors write orders for patients' medical care. Nurses caring for patients in hospitals are instrumental in seeing to it the patient gets the medical and nursing care they need.

The only regret I have is using the wording of wrath when Skeptigirl posted: "Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need." I probably should have ignored that post.
More avoidance of the real issues, s'doc. This is not one of the issues.
 
Thought I'd delurk to post some mid-thread scoring:

skeptigirl: Excellent posts, good points, etc. My medical knowledge is limited to knowing aspirin works on some headaches so I have learned a lot. Score=1.

skepticdoc: Narrow-minded, poor reading skills, pedantic. Has not imparted any knowledge. His manifesto did, however, provide a modicum of humor. Score=.00001

Carry on....

Well, TG I don't have to worry about you grading me for a class lol!!!
 
So what specifically is the issue?

For all those that are chipping in, please share with the audience what are your definitions of Nurse and Doctor.
 
Why is it that as soon as anyone types "lol", I simply assume that they are a giggling adolescent, and ignore the rest of their posts?

Rolfe.
 
For skepticdoc and anyone else who didn't get the bit of Latin I posted: "Verb sap sat est" is short for the Latin phrase "Verbum sapienti sat est," or "A word to the wise is sufficient."

I ought to've added a footnote with the translation.

[edit] Hey, don't doctors learn a fair chunk of Latin in school? They certainly used to. "Verb sap" is pretty simple stuff, not on the order of complex medical Latin such as "Catapultam habeo. Nisi pecuniam omnem mihi dabris, ad caput tuum saxum immane mittam." *shrug* Go figure.
 
Last edited:
As a physician I am in a constant tug of war between the system and the patients. It is very frustating to deal with the insurance companies, the demands/expectations of the patients and trying to do what is the best scientific/ethical decision for another person in or outside of the hospital.
I can understand your frustration. It seems to be shared by many physicians (and patients) in these days of managed care when you can't always do/have the procedure that seems best.

We love life, we have two Corgis, two cats, one conure, one lovebird and an ornamental pond with over fifty Koi
While this does endear you to me a little bit, I still don't forgive your treatment of skeptigal nor your condescending attitude.

(this just for you dear Supercorgi, how did you become involved?).
Involved with what? Corgis or this thread?

Intellectually I am probably a reductionist atheist, I don't even fall for the "we are startdust" ideas, even fecal matter came from "starstuff".
If you are in fact an atheist, why don't you start revising your manifesto by removing all the references to god? You have 3 items that directly refer to god and then another item where you refer to souls.
 
Why is it that as soon as anyone types "lol", I simply assume that they are a giggling adolescent, and ignore the rest of their posts?

Rolfe.
Hey Rolfe, look at the dorsum of my right hand, my third finger is extended, and the 2nd, 4-5th fingers are flexed.
 
I can understand your frustration. It seems to be shared by many physicians (and patients) in these days of managed care when you can't always do/have the procedure that seems best.


While this does endear you to me a little bit, I still don't forgive your treatment of skeptigal nor your condescending attitude.


Involved with what? Corgis or this thread?


If you are in fact an atheist, why don't you start revising your manifesto by removing all the references to god? You have 3 items that directly refer to god and then another item where you refer to souls.
The thread.

Most of my patients are religious, I am a closet agnostic/atheist (just like Skeptigirl does not mention her beliefs to her patients/clients).

I would like to meet any primary care physicians who is openly an atheist activist. I have the impression there are none, this is one of the reasons why I started this thread.
 
So what specifically is the issue?

...
The correct English here is are the issues.

Sorry, you'll have to actually read the previous posts. Everything is very clearly stated there. Of course, you will first have to broaden your tunnel vision of the health care field in order to actually recognize those issues.

I will give you a hint about that tunnel vision. It is tied to your condescending attitude which, BTW, is not covered up by a brief acknowledgment of the value of other members of the health care system.
 
Why? Does that gesture have some meaning in your culture?
It's a rude gesture that's generally used as an indication that one is emotionally incontinent and unable to reply more effectively. Its approximate meaning as I read it is "I am forced to concede but am displeased about it so here's a dose of contempt," but I suspect the gesturer usually thinks he or she is conveying some other message.
 
The thread.

Most of my patients are religious, I am a closet agnostic/atheist (just like Skeptigirl does not mention her beliefs to her patients/clients).

I would like to meet any primary care physicians who is openly an atheist activist. I have the impression there are none, this is one of the reasons why I started this thread.
This is an interesting rationale. So your "manefesto" includes deceit? It implies you are a theist when you aren't?

It's one thing to avoid conversations on politics and religion on the job. It's quite another to pretend or mislead someone that your religion and politics match theirs.

Here's another situation where you would benefit from a little nursing education. One does not need to hold the same views as your patient to counsel or comfort them in any particular situation. Patients in such situations usually need just to be listened to. They need empathy. Their crisis is not helped by pretending to hold their views. In fact, why are your views even important to that patient at that time? They aren't.

Listening skills are what you need to help that patient. You learn a tad about that in medicine when you learn to absorb the nuances of a patient's medical history. Nurses learn the same but look for more than just the medically focused information that the history and nuances contain. The famous film we all watched in my nursing school was, "Mrs. Reynolds Needs a Nurse." It's a short film of a woman in the hospital pressing her call button every minute with all sorts of demands. (One of those patients whom you are so fond of.) Then it turns out the patient had an underlying fear of her upcoming surgery and the anxiety was expressed in constant calling for the nurse.

The second half of those listening skills is to then guide the patient in recognizing the real cause of the anxiety and believe it or not, merely empathetic listening to the patient tell you how they feel does wonders. There may be some information you can provide which allays a fear but giving information about your personal politics or religion, especially insincere information, is totally useless to that patient.
 
It's a rude gesture that's generally used as an indication that one is emotionally incontinent and unable to reply more effectively. Its approximate meaning as I read it is "I am forced to concede but am displeased about it so here's a dose of contempt," but I suspect the gesturer usually thinks he or she is conveying some other message.
Thank you for your explanation. That's quite clear.

Rolfe.
 
The thread.
I added my input to the thread because I found your attitude and behaviour shameful. I added my comment to you because what you were saying to and about skeptigirl was unjust and insulting. As a member of this forum, I'm entitled to add my comments to any thread on this board as long as I adhere to the membership rules.
 
I added my input to the thread because I found your attitude and behaviour shameful. I added my comment to you because what you were saying to and about skeptigirl was unjust and insulting. As a member of this forum, I'm entitled to add my comments to any thread on this board as long as I adhere to the membership rules.
Thank you, now I have a better perspective about you.
 
anecdotes

I have a patient that happens to be a nurse, she is slightly obese, and complained of some shortness of breath, and a choking sensation in her neck. Her physical examination was unremarkable, her pulse oximeter was normal. Something made me order a CT of the chest and abdomen, it revealed a hepatic cyst and a cancerous renal mass. Her life was saved by the surgeons who operated on her, my intuition that there was something else going on, and that her insurance company did not question the need for a CT scan.

I have in the hospital, a 91 year-old patient, whose daughter is the wife of a minister. He had a fever and a rattly cough, and his chest x-ray showed bilateral pneumonia. His daughter already had arranged for a do not resuscitate order, and I will do whatever his daughter wants me to do for his medical care. I am his servant, the subordinate of my patient and his family, I can provide information to the best of my ability, but I have to follow their decisions. I think I know my place in the hierarchy.

I know that I don't know everything, I can not prove or disprove the existence of God. I know that most of my patients are believers, and many would be very upset, if they knew that I was an agnostic. My question to this forum is: What would be the gain in changing my manifesto? You could tell me that I am pandering to my patient's belief system, but if it helps somebody who is depressed to gain a little glimmer of hope by reinforcing their religious belief, what is wrong with that?

There are some healthcare practitioners that work in specialized fields, and do not have to deal with day to day boring life issues. In primary care, we have to deal with this every day.

Most healthcare workers ignore the fact that most of the healthcare advances do not come from medicine, do not come from nursing, they come from advances in sanitation, keeping the drinking water separate from the sewage, adequate housing, adequate nutrition, and the existence of hope.
 
Why is it that as soon as anyone types "lol", I simply assume that they are a giggling adolescent, and ignore the rest of their posts?

Rolfe.
I've always had a bit of a fondness for it myself - how I wish I could say that I was still an adolescent, giggling or otherwise :o On the other hand, I'd certainly have drawn the line at multiple exclamation marks.

This thread has been an interesting read and, to be fair, skepticdoc's manner seemed very strange from the outset. I initially put it down to a language barrier problem at first, but that seems increasingly unlikely.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom