Medical and Healthcare phishing

I've always had a bit of a fondness for it myself - how I wish I could say that I was still an adolescent, giggling or otherwise :o On the other hand, I'd certainly have drawn the line at multiple exclamation marks.

This thread has been an interesting read and, to be fair, skepticdoc's manner seemed very strange from the outset. I initially put it down to a language barrier problem at first, but that seems increasingly unlikely.

What do you find strange?
 
I know that most of my patients are believers, and many would be very upset, if they knew that I was an agnostic. My question to this forum is: What would be the gain in changing my manifesto? You could tell me that I am pandering to my patient's belief system, but if it helps somebody who is depressed to gain a little glimmer of hope by reinforcing their religious belief, what is wrong with that?

Upset? Once again, you do not seem to understand that your patients in all likelihood don't care what your beliefs are. To care, they would need to either consider you more of an authority on religious topics than themselves and their ministers/rabbis/etc., or to think that you will not take good care of them because of your lack of faith. The first is extremely unlikely. The second happens sometimes, and the way to combat that is not to pretend that you are of the same faith they are, but to show by your words and actions that their welfare is the foremost in your mind.

Changing your manifesto (leaving aside the question of whether the manifesto is useful in the first place) to remove the refences to God would actually help you not offend all those people who don't believe strongly, or whose religion is not monotheistic.

And yes, I believe that it's wrong to patronize your patients. I'm an atheist psychologist-in-training, and I am currently seeing a severely depressed person. A part of this person's long-standing depression stems from the fact that he can't decide whether God is a loving god or not, and if he is loving, whether he has passed the boundary beyond which even God cannot love him. He hasn't asked and I haven't volunteered my views (I would not hide them if asked). Instead, we explore what about him there is to love, and how he can make life better. And I strongly believe that if I'd brushed off this concern with a "God really loves you" statement, no matter how emphatically and lovingly delivered, that would have been useless at best, and more likely, very destructive to his self-image, because it would mean me claiming to know better than he does. And with his self-esteem issues, that's the last thing he needs.

P.S. Skeptigirl, I have enjoyed your posts very much, both for the information presented there, and for the way they were written.
 
Last edited:
Upset? Once again, you do not seem to understand that your patients in all likelihood don't care what your beliefs are. To care, they would need to either consider you more of an authority on religious topics than themselves and their ministers/rabbis/etc., or to think that you will not take good care of them because of your lack of faith. The first is extremely unlikely. The second happens sometimes, and the way to combat that is not to pretend that you are of the same faith they are, but to show by your words and actions that their welfare is the foremost in your mind.

Changing your manifesto (leaving aside the question of whether the manifesto is useful in the first place) to remove the refences to God would actually help you not offend all those people who don't believe strongly, or whose religion is not monotheistic.

And yes, I believe that it's wrong to patronize your patients. I'm an atheist psychologist-in-training, and I am currently seeing a severely depressed person. A part of this person's long-standing depression stems from the fact that he can't decide whether God is a loving god or not, and if he is loving, whether he has passed the boundary beyond which even God cannot love him. He hasn't asked and I haven't volunteered my views (I would not hide them if asked). Instead, we explore what about him there is to love, and how he can make life better. And I strongly believe that if I'd brushed off this concern with a "God really loves you" statement, no matter how emphatically and lovingly delivered, that would have been useless at best, and more likely, very destructive to his self-image, because it would mean me claiming to know better than he does. And with his self-esteem issues, that's the last thing he needs.

P.S. Skeptigirl, I have enjoyed your posts very much, both for the information presented there, and for the way they were written.


1. Remember that we are on earth to serve God; listen to His messages in its various forms; don't hesitate to ask for His help.

2. Develop your potentials and skills to the fullest extent possible, God gave them to you to help others.


I mention God only twice.

I couldn't tell anybody God loves you because I could not justify or rationalize it myself. I was somewhat a believer in the Baha'i faith when I wrote it. So far I can tolerate the words as they stand, I accept the Spinoza concept of God. Maybe I will eliminate the listen, ask for help parts. The Bhuddist ideas are also a little acceptable to me, is it really a Godless religion?

I am struggling with the question of why I am here? Why do I think?

I choose the easy way out; thinking that there may be a purpose, but I will never know it with any certainty. If there is nothing, I won't know anyhow!

I read the Dawkins/Adams idea of the shrinking puddle of water, and I would like to know from the lurkers/posters, How can you ever promote or teach that idea to the majority of humans? It is like an intellectual dirty little secret to me. If we are nothing, how can I justify even the concept of Medical Care?

Remember the origin of the thread? I still would like to know how other physicians and healthcare providers have coped with the questions. The discussion between Nurses and Doctors is not very important at all, it has been just a distraction from the real issue.

Whether we accept it or not, what we are now had some basis in religious beliefs and either forcing them unto others or killing others that had a different belief. Many of the reported miracles of JC were related to health or life, and unfortunately many individuals and even physicians still believe in the power of prayer, despite the most recent study. I personally feel that there are some activities: meditation, listening to music, waves crashing or lapping at the shore, a brook's trickle, and even prayer (for some individuals), that can be relaxing and enjoyable, and maybe even healthy for the individual who is performing them. If you enjoy doing it, go right ahead as long as you don't force it unto anybody that does not like it!
 
I am fairly certain that my opinion doesn't count to you, since I am not a healthcare provider, but if you cared to actually read what I wrote, you would see what my philosophy is in dealing with such issues. It doesn't make much of a difference how many times you actually mentioned god when your very first statement is "Remember that we are on earth to serve God." The subtext that I, and probably many others, get from that is "Hey, you and I both believe in the same way, because I can remind you what we are supposed to believe in." And that's dangerous, simply because if the person reading this manifesto has a different understanding from yours, he or she gets the clear message that his/her experiences and thoughts are not welcome. As people have tried to point out to you repeatedly, yes, people who are ill are often troubled and want the comfort of religion, but that means that they want to talk about what religion is to them, not to you. By putting this statement up front, you may very well be shutting them off from the very thing they want - to be heard.

And then there's this statement: "If we are nothing, how can I justify even the concept of Medical Care?" Well, are you nothing? I certainly don't feel like nothing. I feel like I am present, and like there are other real people existing in the world around me. To me, that's enough of a justification to want to have the best possible relationships with those other people, and to the extent that I have the skills to help people, a good relationship involves using those skills.
 
Is that an honest question?

skepticdoc said:
...how can I justify even the concept of Medical Care?

Do you honestly want a good answer to that question?

Are you really going to read my response and consider my suggestions?

If you are willing to read, and I mean REALLY read, two (of four) very short, very inexpensive books, then I can make a recommendation that may help you.

Ayn Rand.

Yeah, THAT Ayn Rand. The Devil incarnate to many people.:D

Two of her books, both of them collectoins of essays, each about 7/16" thich in paperback, findable in used-book stores and libraries.

The two I recommend to help you out of your philosophical conundrum are:
Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology 1979
and
The Virtue of Selfishness 1964

If you can get through these, I recommend two others:
For the New Intellectual 1961
and
The Romantic Manifesto 1969

These books are each comprised of a dozen or two fairly brief essays, most by her, but several written by others who shared her POV.

Now, I will give you fair warning: if you try try to use the Evelyn Wood Speed Reading method (which, judging by the evident difficulty you have had comprehending complex, nuanced sentences in this thread so far, you may have been using), you will doubtless come away without a clue about what she was attempting to impart. I strongly recommend that you only attempt to read these when you have time, without interruption, to fully read at least one entire essay, and you should have a dictionary at hand so that you can avoid misunderstanding her meaning. (She wrote with *extreme* precision and nuance in her choice of words, and _close_ won't cut it.):D

Since I seriously doubt that you will actually take my advice on this (after all, who am I but a lower-caste grease-monkey and "barbershop philosopher", in your esteemed eyes?), maybe some other lurker or poster will be inspired to investigate these profound works.:)

Will s'doc deign to take my advice and read these?

We'll see.

Won't we?:D :D


Cheers
Dave

edit: punctuation
 
Last edited:
Wow. Are you being intentionally obtuse or are you really that thick?

If you had read skeptigirl's statement in the context of her post (and subsequent posts) you'd understand what she was saying. Everyone else did. Sometimes doctors get tunnel vision -- they want to fix the problem of the day and sometimes don't consider the big picture or the longer term "quality of life" issues for the patient. Somes fixing the immediate problem, as in the example skeptigirl gave of her father's treatment, is not the wisest thing to do when the complete situation is evaluated.

From the start of this thread, you've been very hostile to skeptigirl and for no good reason. I too have doubt's that you're a real MD. Unlike skeptigirl, you haven't presented any medical knowledge that convinces me that you're even a medical professional. Your simplistic manifesto, your inability to understand what people are saying, and to respond like a reasonable person, make me doubt that you are even that well educated.

For all the personal feelings going about, I am reasonably sure he's a doctor, and an MD at that.
If I'm wrong, I'll be rather surprised.

On a slight tangent: I have a hard time understanding what people say, more often than I care to admit. I'll tend to ask if I don't know, even if it seems phenomonally obvious or really stupid of me. ("what do you mean chocolate or vanilla ice cream?")
Yes, that's also how trolls operate, I'll concede that.
 
Last edited:
I am fairly certain that my opinion doesn't count to you, since I am not a healthcare provider, but if you cared to actually read what I wrote, you would see what my philosophy is in dealing with such issues. It doesn't make much of a difference how many times you actually mentioned god when your very first statement is "Remember that we are on earth to serve God." The subtext that I, and probably many others, get from that is "Hey, you and I both believe in the same way, because I can remind you what we are supposed to believe in." And that's dangerous, simply because if the person reading this manifesto has a different understanding from yours, he or she gets the clear message that his/her experiences and thoughts are not welcome. As people have tried to point out to you repeatedly, yes, people who are ill are often troubled and want the comfort of religion, but that means that they want to talk about what religion is to them, not to you. By putting this statement up front, you may very well be shutting them off from the very thing they want - to be heard.

And then there's this statement: "If we are nothing, how can I justify even the concept of Medical Care?" Well, are you nothing? I certainly don't feel like nothing. I feel like I am present, and like there are other real people existing in the world around me. To me, that's enough of a justification to want to have the best possible relationships with those other people, and to the extent that I have the skills to help people, a good relationship involves using those skills.

You are a healthcare provider if you are a psychologist in-training.
 
...
On a slight tangent: I have a hard time understanding what people say, more often than I care to admit. I'll tend to ask if I don't know, even if it seems phenomonally obvious or really stupid of me. ("what do you mean chocolate or vanilla ice cream?")
Yes, that's also how trolls operate, I'll concede that.
It wasn't an issue of asking for clarification or an explanation of something perhaps obvious to most. The issue was skepticdoc refusing to answer anyone who challenges his claims when he had no defense of his own statements.

Challenger: "Nurses provide nursing care. Nursing care is unique and includes an enormous field beyond merely following doctor's orders"

S'doc: "Why don't you go to med school if you want to be a doctor"

Challenger: "Nursing is a profession. It isn't a subset of medicine"

S'doc: "What is the issue?"


That is the example, not a mere clarification of terms or statements. If you were to tease out s'doc's discussion of nurses you'd be hard pressed to find anything (other than an insincere, "everyone is important"), which includes any discussion of nursing as an independent profession. Not a reply, not a defense of his statements, rather, all you'll find are repeated versions of, "all nurses do is take medical orders".

As to thread hijacking, the only hijacking here came from skepticdoc himself. Everything off topic was initiated by him. The topic is pretty broad anyway. It was a general call for other health care providers to come join a discussion. The manifesto was not in the thread topic. Though I'm happy to continue discussing it and the rest of what has come up here.

Edited to add: I may sound upset but I'm not in the least. Nor do I have negative feelings toward S'doc. He's just naive. That's not something which upsets me at all. I have posted what I have here because I am a very enthusiastic defender of the nursing profession, because I am very confident in my own practice, and I know there is a public misconception about what nursing actually is. So this was an opportunity to explain it to others. The fact skepticdoc doesn't get it isn't important.
 
Last edited:
Thank you Avita, for the compliment.

Regarding the manifesto...The first question to ask is, what is the purpose of it? If you don't know what the purpose is, how can you measure if it meets that purpose? This is the era of evidence based medicine. We don't get as good of results if we do things because they seem important but never bother to actually analyze if they are useful and if they achieve what we set out to achieve.

I already mentioned this in my response to why I thought the list of symptoms in the manifesto was useless. Not that s'doc attempted to answer my questioning how such a list was going to improve patient outcomes. But I'll repeat it once more and try to make it simpler so someone unfamiliar with medicine can understand.

Purpose of listing symptoms: To educate the patient about symptoms that indicate the need to see a doctor.

Measures of success: The patient seeks care appropriately.

Past experience with such lists: General lists are too vague to be useful to a patient. What they already have in the way of common sense must still be used to interpret the list. Thus the general list does nothing to affect outcome.


Educational campaigns that do provide lists of symptoms which might act as indicators to seek medical attention are useful. But they contain directed lists of symptoms to seek care for, not general lists.


On the religious comments in the manefesto:

Once again, what is the purpose? This one I have to guess because I am at a loss.

Is it to provide false information to the patient so the question of the provider's religion does not interfere with care? If so wouldn't a nice picture of Jesus on the clinic wall suffice?

Is the purpose to give the patient healthy lifestyle guidelines or encouragement? Then why put anything religious in there at all? If I'm already religious do I need my doctor to encourage me to pray? The failure of prayer study just published indicates prayer isn't going to improve one's health. Do I need to have a guilt trip to motivate me to develop my potential? God gave me xyz and for that reason I should...?

...I couldn't tell anybody God loves you because I could not justify or rationalize it myself. I was somewhat a believer in the Baha'i faith when I wrote it....
Yadda yadda yadda and on and on all about s'doc's beliefs, latest ponderings of the meaning of life and so on. So is the manifesto a means of exploring his own spirituality or something to improve patient outcomes? And why would it be justifiable to imply you believe when you don't, but not justifiable to imply God loves you when you don't believe that either?


Remember the origin of the thread? I still would like to know how other physicians and healthcare providers have coped with the questions. The discussion between Nurses and Doctors is not very important at all, it has been just a distraction from the real issue.
Giving up on defending your inaccurate statements about nurses following orders? What a surprise.


Whether we accept it or not, what we are now had some basis in religious beliefs and either forcing them unto others or killing others that had a different belief. Many of the reported miracles of JC were related to health or life, and unfortunately many individuals and even physicians still believe in the power of prayer, despite the most recent study. I personally feel that there are some activities: meditation, listening to music, waves crashing or lapping at the shore, a brook's trickle, and even prayer (for some individuals), that can be relaxing and enjoyable, and maybe even healthy for the individual who is performing them. If you enjoy doing it, go right ahead as long as you don't force it unto anybody that does not like it!
And this applies to the manifesto how?
 
Last edited:
Thank you Cave Dave.

I will look into Ayn Rand, I found the website www.aynrand.org, maybe I will find some answers there too.
You're welcome, skepticdoc. My screen name needs no space in it, however.:)

That website is, I believe, the official Ayn Rand Institute site, and, though they may _claim_ to be the final authority (due to her last will and testament), is by no means (IMHO) the sole source of reliable information on the works of Ayn Rand. There are too many to list now (even the small percentage I know of).

I should have mentioned in my previous post that you should not expect simple answers to specific issues in her works: this is an entire self-consistant philosophy; it provides guidelines for making moral decisions of your own and should not be approached as an oracle supplying ready-made dicta.

One further warning: when she writes of the evil of altruism, I interpret this as meaning that _forced_ altruism, or when one is intimidated into self-sacrifice, is the true evil; if one freely chooses to give of oneself to another, then that is ones legitimate choice. Some may not agree with my interpretation, but I think I can defend my views.

I truely hope you will investigate Objectivism and consider it's implications in everyday living. I believe (from your questions and self-reported history) that you are seeking an internally consistant philosophy that will resonate with your life, and I suspect this might fit the bill.

(Damn, that almost sounds like religious Proselytizing! :eek: :jaw-dropp Apologies all around.):D

Let me know how it goes fo you.:)

Cheers
Dave
 
I have no ideas of grandeur, I am pretty sure that all the questions that have been raised in this thread have been raised by many others in the last several thousands of years. Only recently have we been able to exchange ideas quickly between people that are geographically separated. Nobody has been able to come up with the definitive answer.

Again, thanks!

I like this forum in spite of the doctor bashing because it makes anybody challenge all their beliefs. I look at The Amazing one as somebody that decided to be a crusader for truth, and everybody else here is trying to be a good disciple spreading the "gospel", the Forum may be our little worship temple with many rooms to accommodate the differences in opinion.
 
Doctor bashing! This forum is quite definitely not given to that, and there are some very good doctors among the regular posters. However, you won't find people kow-towing to you and putting up with self-aggrandsing crap just because you're a doctor. Shame, that.

Rolfe.
 
Oh, please stop, don't make me cry!!! ( please see post #149 ) LOL!
 
Last edited:
Clarification

skepticdoc said:
To Skeptigirl:

Before I unleash my wrath against you, I need to know a couple of things.

Are you practicing in the USA?

Would you have sent Randi to the undertaker with nursing comfort?

Do you wish to engage in a discussion regarding Medicine and Evolutionary theory? If you do let's start a new thread.

skepticdoc said:
So, what do Doctors do?

What does atheism have to do with Medicine? Do you think that Evolution has anything to do with Medicine?



So, what is wrong with that?

I think I understand what you are trying to say, but it is not coming out right. I know of Oncologists that create false hopes and "torture" patients with chemo, instead of just arranging for palliative care. Most people want to be "cured", "made better" or just made more comfortable. In the Netherlands some even want to be "put out of their misery" (euthanasia?).



So, who decides the complicated treatment plan? In the USA many physicians just go for the big money and delegate some of the most menial aspects of medical care to nurses, some of these nurses then think they know as much as doctors!

Some doctors perform at the level of nurses and diminish the caliber of the profession. I know of nurses and assistants that realize that there is more to know and then go to Medical School, they make excellent physicians!

If anybody has a "chip on her shoulder" it you, skeptigirl. I would too, if I misrepresented myself in the Forum.

True medical practice involves both prevention and treatment, both have to be based on SCIENCE, not opinion or faith or lack of.

I think I may have only one or two "friends" in this thread, after a PM message, I will try to quiet the "tempest in a teapot".

I am both an American Board Certified Anesthesiologist and Family Physician, I respect the nurses that work with me in the hospital. I wish Skeptigirl could get her peer's judgements on my relations with them, you will just have to take my word that most nurses like to work with me ( you can't pease everybody, medical work cannot be a popularity contest ).

I quoted myself to make it easier to whoever cares to re-read my early posts that started the tempest. We all are animals that have developed hierarchies in almost anything that we do, ours are a little more complicated than, for example Wolve's.

And for whoever thinks I am turning soft, or giving up, please refer to post #149! LOL!!!
 
One further warning: when she writes of the evil of altruism, I interpret this as meaning that _forced_ altruism, or when one is intimidated into self-sacrifice, is the true evil; if one freely chooses to give of oneself to another, then that is ones legitimate choice. Some may not agree with my interpretation, but I think I can defend my views.
That's pretty much the accepted interpretation, since all of her examples of "evil altruism" are invariably forced and collectivist in nature; and all her villians were collectivists and their supporters. She considered collectivism to be one of the biggest and most pernicious evils of the modern world, and devoted quite a lot of writing to that end; and being that she grew up in the former Soviet Union, that's not surprising.

"Collectivism means the subjugation of the individual to a group -- whether to a race, class or state does not matter. Collectivism holds that man must be chained to collective action and collective thought for the sake of what is called 'the common good'." -- Ayn Rand

There's a good collection of similar quotes here: http://freedomkeys.com/collectivism.htm

Interestingly, she was staunchly anti-racist, due in large part to it's collectivist nature.
 
... I wish Skeptigirl could get her peer's judgements on my relations with them, you will just have to take my word that most nurses like to work with me ( you can't pease everybody, medical work cannot be a popularity contest ).

I quoted myself to make it easier to whoever cares to re-read my early posts that started the tempest. We all are animals that have developed hierarchies in almost anything that we do, ours are a little more complicated than, for example Wolve's....
You cannot find much in the way of doctor bashing in my posts. Only that doctors are better at some things and nurses better at others. We have overlapping professions, and both professions use skills and treatments developed by the other. Health care problems are best treated with variable amounts of participation from both fields.

Your problem is not with popularity, it isn't with how pleasant or not you are to work with. For those assessments I have little data. Your problem, using your own statements as evidence, is your almost complete lack of recognition that there is a body of knowledge called nursing science, and your complete lack of recognition that nursing care is separate from medical care and is of equal importance.

You can have your own subjective opinion about value of medicine vs the value of nursing. That is an individual's prerogative. For every scenario you cite a physician's importance there are equivalent scenarios where nursing interventions are of greater significance. Physicians save lives. Guess what, so do nurses as well as EMTs and Paramedics. But judging importance is purely an individual preference.

It's when you get to the next conclusion, that nurses are subordinate to physicians that you cannot support your conclusion. Legally a nurse can refuse to carry out any medical order and only his/her employer could fire or discipline the nurse for that.

Nurses are not under the medical hierarchy. We have our own hierarchy and the two professions interact. Some medical care provided by doctors includes nursing care and some nursing care provided by nurses includes medical care. Guess what, doc? Newsflash. I practice medicine. No doctor oversees my practice. I have a license to do so. I have malpractice that covers the medical decisions I make. I get reimbursed for practicing medicine. And I have a nursing degree. How about that?

The third problem you have is replying to posts as if half or more of what was written isn't there. Trouble with that is everyone else can read for themselves.

So when I say your manifesto has some significant problems and list those problems, you go on about some imagined "tempest". You bring up foolish statements you made and claim those statements merely set off a bit of anger. Are we to conclude then that nothing I posted was of any significance? That I merely am upset with s'doc? Ah...but then what to do with the actual post skeptigirl wrote? Ignore it. Hide behind a straw man of claiming the girl is merely upset with her status in life.

I don't think other people reading the thread see it that way s'doc. I think they may even be waiting for you to respond to my post asking what the purpose of your manifesto is and how does it accomplish that purpose.
 
I copied the concept from our child's pediatrician.

Nobody in my residency program had any criticism. At least not to my face!

No patient has ever complained.

A few have praised it and have shared it with friends and family.

Only in this forum it has been viewed negatively.

I only posted it to try to relieve the rumors/concerns that I am not a physician, and stirred up the tempest, BTW "tempest in a teapot" are not my words.

If you were a male I would think you are viewing this as a "pissing" contest in the medical field. Chill out!!!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom