Homeopathic licensing alarms doctors

So. If I cut myself , take a homoeopathic remedy and it manifestly does not work, who do I sue?
 
Perhaps there is another way to make the MHRA acknowlege our displeasure at their duplicity.

Check out this MHRA link, and as soon as products start appearing on the shelves of pharmacies with "can relieve cough" plastered all over them, report the product to the "Defective Medicines Report Centre".
In my view, a product with no active ingredient in it and which cannot do what it claims to do is "defective" and should be recognised by them as being so.

eta
Under section 4 of the pdf "A guide to defective medical products" is this statment:
“Directive 2001/83/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 6 November 2001
on the Community code relating to medicinal products for human use” specifies under what
circumstances a recall may be required in Article 117. It defines the obligations of the
competent authorities of the relevant member states and of the marketing authorisation
holder.
1. If a medicinal product proves to be harmful under normal conditions of use.
2. If a medicinal product is lacking in therapeutic efficacy.
3. If the qualitative and quantitative composition of the product is not as declared.
4. The controls on the medicinal product and/or on the ingredients and the controls at
an intermediate stage of the manufacturing process have not been carried out or if
some other requirement or obligation relating to the grant of the manufacturing
authorisation has not been fulfilled.​
Perhaps we can force a recall of the products because they fail on #2 and because for #3 they cannot show what the qualiitative and quantitative compositin of the product is.
 
Last edited:
My wife (known as ysabella on this board) suggested that the MHRA's budget be subjected to homeopathic "standards":
"No, no, no, we're not slashing your budget by 99%, we're actually increasing it!"
 
Well, there's no alcohol on drilling rigs, but I feel the need of a homoeopathic whisky, which is available straight from the tap.
 
Perhaps there is another way to make the MHRA acknowlege our displeasure at their duplicity.

Check out this MHRA link, and as soon as products start appearing on the shelves of pharmacies with "can relieve cough" plastered all over them, report the product to the "Defective Medicines Report Centre".
In my view, a product with no active ingredient in it and which cannot do what it claims to do is "defective" and should be recognised by them as being so.

eta
Under section 4 of the pdf "A guide to defective medical products" is this statment:
Perhaps we can force a recall of the products because they fail on #2 and because for #3 they cannot show what the qualiitative and quantitative compositin of the product is.
Hmm.

I notice that their online "Suspected Defect Reporting form" has "Product licence Number (from label)" as a mandatory field. Will this prevent use of the form for homoeopathic remedies that are "registered" rather than licenced?
 
Hmm.

I notice that their online "Suspected Defect Reporting form" has "Product licence Number (from label)" as a mandatory field. Will this prevent use of the form for homoeopathic remedies that are "registered" rather than licenced?
I was under the impression the homeopathics would be granted "Product Licenses of Right", in which case would they not have a product license number? (I'll look through the MHRA stuff again to check this, or tell me if I am wrong)

Either way, I think that if the MHRA receive a complaint about a defective product, they will at least have to go through the motions of looking at the case. The products will also acquire a data bank of complaints about them, whcih is bound to annoy someone somewhere.

I think that as soon as I see products appearing I will try and register a complaint, and see what the reaction is.
 
I'll certainly give it a go. I've also taken the liberty of linking back to your post from the relevant threads on badscience and UK Skeptics.
 
I'll be registering a complaint as well, as soon as I see a "registered" remedy on sale.
 
Homeopathic medicines can be prescribed on a few of the NHS scripts - don't have the details right now but will get them
But the labelling on the packaging wouldn't really be an issue on something prescribed. It only really arises as far as stuff bought OTC is concerned.
 
I liked the bit about including it in the Yellow Card Scheme: Does this include aggravations?

Well, actually its to do with "Suspected Adverse Reactions", which may seem pedantic, but an SAR includes...ta-da...lack of efficacy.

Inundate the buggers with suspected failures of efficacy. We can play them at the game they have chosen: try to steal the clothes of real medicine and find yourself being judged for how they fit.

It does, however, mean going and buying some of their useless sugar.
 
I would be careful if I were you. You might well get your fingers burnt if you play!!

If they have done this, then I am sure they will be ready to deal with any fallout that ensues!!
 
It would be one thing is they used sucrose, but most homeopathic pill's cant even be used to sweeten your tea.
Lactose pills, at least here in Germany.

How does that square with the dilutions concept and the "water has a memory" crap?
 
Lactose pills, at least here in Germany.
That was my point, lactose (sugar) pills are not good for sweetening your tea :)
How does that square with the dilutions concept and the "water has a memory" crap?
Well, the memory of the water is transfered to the lactose pills, it also makes "grafting" possible.
 
In all fairness, from what I'm reading it looks like every effort was made by the MHRA to slip this in under the wire with as little opportunity as possible for parliament, professional organizations or the public to interfere. The very line "opened their proposals to public consultation in the summer" is a good indicator of that; who's paying attention to government business in the summer? In the words of Douglas Adams, "the plans were on display [...] in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying 'Beware of the leopard'."
You have it in one. This issue was never debated by parliament, and the public consultation was kept quiet. I note that the `bodies' consulted have not been listed. I will get the list out of MHRA under FOI if I have to. I am on Colourful Radio:confused: tomorrow morning and will have a few points to make!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom