Morgan Reynolds and Rick Rajter Release Their No-Plane Paper

It seems to be clear: This person isn't insane. Why do we find him, who took a strong position against workers rights for all of his career, now as "a part of" a grass roots movement attacking other members of it and presenting absurd theories on FoxNews?

There has to be a better explanation than "nuts".
Rather than disparage "critical thinkers" everywhere, perhaps you'd like to tell us what you think?

Going solely by the basis of the paper presented here, Mr. Reynolds is publicly promoting a shameful (c.f. Roadrunner graphics) and laughable (shot down by Steven Jones) position. Either idiocy or willfull deception, I don't know which. That much is not really open for debate. But I haven't made any judgment about the rest of the man's character, not yet anyway.
 
Newtonian laws of motion combined with physical evidence prove no Boeing airliners crashed on September 11, 2001 at any of the four designated sites. The government's story is a provable, gigantic lie although various possibilities remain open about what really happened.

Newtonian laws! WOW - they used laws they do not understand to prove they do not understand them.

Can MIT remove Rick's degree?

rife with injuries (to his brain?) during his undergraduate years, Rick's determination led him to such accomplishments as MVP of the indoor track team,

sorry, how did he graduate from MIT with any degree and write a paper with an insane person?

Okay, who knows this clown?

Why would the Scholar turn down a paper? This one fits as well as any of their flying pig papers do.

Has anyone out there seen a piece of straw in a telelphone pole?
 
A base line of your argument is that the conspiracy theorists are completely wrong because they take Operation Northwoods and other incidents as an indication that the US Government might sacrifice their own citizens for "higher" purposes. And now you want to make me believe that Morgan Reynolds went nuts right in time to "support" the 911 Skeptics? I think "ignorant" is a term in favor of you - we should name it "hypocricy" as it is.

That's the problem with the truth movement. One man's genius is another man's spook. All of the big players are for the most part crazy(or at the very least has some mental instability). James Fetzer would certainlly qualify. Steven Jones and Griffin have papers full of simple stupid holes and sloppy errors. If you want to be taken seriously why continue to make these mistakes.

Go over to the Liberty Forum where Morgan Reynolds had one of his first interviews. Shill remarks are tossed all over. "Alex Jones is a shill" on one forum, Mike Rivero a shill because he believes a plane hit the Pentagon. Paul Thompson was accused at his latest showing of being to soft.
Honestly if I wanted to be a shill I would come up with a more plausible, not something that boarders on flat earth.

The real problem is paranoia rules the Truth movement!
 
Last edited:
Either idiocy or willfull deception

Yeah, who knows? I was not the one making fun of Reynolds, R.. I'm the one who tries to put a perspective on it. You are intelligent enough to figure out why i didn't say "he is a con artist". And you are intelligent enough to see why i say it now ;)

@the others: please simply answer my questions: Why did Reynold leave the Bush Administration and why does he spread these laughable theories now? I demanded a better answer than "he just went nuts" and i still do.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, who knows? I was not the one making fun of Reynolds, R.. I'm the one who tries to put a perspective on it. You are intelligent enough to figure out why i didn't say "he is a con artist". And you are intelligent enough to see why i say it now ;)

@the others: please simply answer my qustions: Why did Reynold leave the Bush Administration and why does he spread these laughable theories now? I demanded a better answer than "he just went nuts" and i still do.
Be that as it may, if you're "demanding" an answer, I'd like to hear your ideas.

I honestly don't know. The human brain is a complex and mysterious thing.
 
I stopped reading around the time they started talking about the Road Runner. He thinks the Pentagon was fake because there was no silhouette but he thinks the WTC was fake because there was a silhouette?

From everyone's favorite USG stooge Alexander Cockburn....

http://www.counterpunch.org/cockburn09092006.html

One notorious “deductive” leap involves flight 77, which on 9/11 ended up crashing into the Pentagon. There are photos of the impact of the “object” -- i.e., the Boeing 757, flight 77 -- that seem to show the sort of hole a missile might make. Ergo, the nuts assert, it WAS a missile and a 757 didn’t hit the Pentagon. As regards the hole, my brother Andrew -- writing a book about Rumsfeld and the DoD during his tenure -- has seen photos taken within 30 minutes of Pentagon impact clearly showing outline of entire plane including wings. This was visible momentarily when the smoke blew away
 
Yeah, who knows? I was not the one making fun of Reynolds, R.. I'm the one who tries to put a perspective on it. You are intelligent enough to figure out why i didn't say "he is a con artist". And you are intelligent enough to see why i say it now ;)

@the others: please simply answer my questions: Why did Reynold leave the Bush Administration and why does he spread these laughable theories now? I demanded a better answer than "he just went nuts" and i still do.

Sorry....but he's nuts. Im off for a while...
 
Be that as it may, if you're "demanding" an answer, I'd like to hear your ideas.

I honestly don't know. The human brain is a complex and mysterious thing.

True. Late stage mental deterioration is not at all uncommon. The implication that his mental collapse is directly related to one's preconceived pet conspiracy theory is not a position I endorse. I read and heard enough about his beliefs to say that he coo coo for coco puffs. Why? I'll leave that to the mental health experts, not the CTers working backwards from their "theory".
 
I asked for an explanation for Reynolds's behaviour. A top official of the last Bush Administration spreads absurd theories about 911 on Fox News. You chimed in and told me that it is possible that Reynolds just in time went nuts. I told you that this is a weak explanation if you apply the standard of evidence that you demand from others to yourself.

What part of that did you not understand?
I don't attempt to explain Reynolds' behavior, because I have nothing on which to base an explanation. I merely pointed out that he may actually be nuts. I didn't say that he was nuts, nor did I say that he "just in time" did anything. That's your misrepresentation of my words.

So, you're suggesting that Reynolds is attempting to take political potshots at the Bush administration by saying that no airliners were involved in the attacks of 9/11?

Is that rational? If he has an axe to grind, wouldn't the rational thing be to say "I was Chief Economist in W's Labor Department, and here's a list of the lousy things I saw the administration do..."? Childlike, do you think that his "no planes" position makes the Bush administration look bad, and not Morgan Reynolds? And if that is his intent, is that position in any way rational?

Or would that be a very, very nutty way for a person to imagine that they are taking revenge on an enemy?
 
Childish, if you have ideas share them..

If you want to adress me, say "Empress", please.

R., so you take Gravy's line and tell me that Reynoldys went nuts? You don't think it is obvious or even possible that he does a COINTELPRO-Job? Of course i don't have the right to "demand" answers but i am interested in your honest impression on this.

@Gravy: I think his behaviour is rational and the outcome of it is exactly what he intents.

edit: thanks mortimer
 
Last edited:
R., so you take Gravy's line and tell me that Reynoldys went nuts? You don't think it is obvious or even possible that he does a COINTELPRO-Job? Of course i don't have the right to "demand" answers but i am interested in your honest impression on this.
I said no such thing. I said I honestly didn't know. He might be nuts, or he might have a complex motivation.

Please, as much as I dislike others putting words in my mouth, I would avoid putting them in yours. Would you care to elaborate your thoughts so that we don't have to guess? Thanks.
 
Ah. So now "no planes" is a rational position. Sorry, but I'm getting off at this exit. See ya later.

Pathetic.

R., I gave you two hints so far - i indirectly said that he is "a con artist" and asked you if you don't think that he might do a "CONITELPRO-Job". Isn't that clear enough?
 
Pathetic.

R., I gave you two hints so far - i indirectly said that he is "a con artist" and asked you if you don't think that he might do a "CONITELPRO-Job". Isn't that clear enough?

C'mon, it's a simple question. Is there some reason why you won't tell us what you think? Stutter? Confidentiality agreement?

I can't give you an honest impression if all you give me is hints. So, please, let's hear it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom