Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I disagree because consumers purchase a bottle of cough medicine, not a bottle of cough medicine ingredients. To my knowledge, not a single brand (including generic brands) of cough medicine has been proven to be efficacious in a controlled study. If I'm wrong, please cite the study.

The review you keep referring to included these controlled studies showing effectiveness. I do not know if these include OTC preparations, although some are funded by manufacturers, so one could guess that they do. The distinction is irrelevant, anyway.

Adams R, Hosie J, James I, Khong T, Kohn H, Smith I, et al. Antitussive activity and tolerability of moguisteine in patients with acute cough: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Adv Ther 1993; 10: 263-271

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=retrieve&db=pubmed&list_uids=9232667&dopt=Abstract

Robinson RE, Cummings WB, Deffenbaugh ER. Effectiveness of guaifenesin as an expectorant: a cooperative double-blind study. Curr Ther Res Clin Exp 1977; 22: 284-296

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=retrieve&db=pubmed&list_uids=3057962&dopt=Abstract

http://www.chestjournal.org/cgi/con...a752036a4ec8b1edb4cba934&keytype2=tf_ipsecsha

The review stated two were fixed preparations (i.e. "cough medicine"):

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=retrieve&db=pubmed&list_uids=713817&dopt=Abstract

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=retrieve&db=pubmed&list_uids=344089&dopt=Abstract

Linda
 
The relevant question is not that, but whether homeopathy works, at least in some cases. In my opinion, the jury is still out on that question.

Well of course Homeopathy works "in some cases". Doing absolutely nothing works in some cases too (common cold for example). Considering administering a solution diluted to 30C is in fact doing nothing, I would bet both treatments are just as effective.

LLH
 
The review you keep referring to included these controlled studies showing effectiveness.

And let us not forget that Rodney has mentioned his only source of information on this, apart from the review I provided, is a WebMD article which seems a rather dodgy summary of:

a) a conversation with someone who's own lit review seems to replicate the findings of the one I posted

b) a med professor who says actually OTC cough medicines do work, and

c) a 'holistic and integrative medicine specialist' who prefers "magic" cures with zero evidence for efficacy, such as acupuncture for coughs.

Yet, Rodders demands better and better studies from others in reply to his quick web search and cursory glance at a somewhat ropey article.
 
And let us not forget that Rodney has mentioned his only source of information on this, apart from the review I provided, is a WebMD article which seems a rather dodgy summary of:

a) a conversation with someone who's own lit review seems to replicate the findings of the one I posted

b) a med professor who says actually OTC cough medicines do work, and

c) a 'holistic and integrative medicine specialist' who prefers "magic" cures with zero evidence for efficacy, such as acupuncture for coughs.

Yet, Rodders demands better and better studies from others in reply to his quick web search and cursory glance at a somewhat ropey article.

<blush>

Rereading your posts, I realize I wasn't following this thread as well as I thought.

I missed that Rodney is arguing that psuedoephedrine performs differently depending upon the graphics on the outside of the bottle.

I have been disappointed in the quality of the material presented by WebMD. That particular (dodgy) summary is typical.

Linda
 
I'm still not following you, could you explain more fully? The brand does not affect the chemical action of the constituents.
It could not be any simpler: Please provide me with the name of an OTC cough medicine that has been proven to produce an effect above placebo so that I can buy some the next time I develop a cough.
 
It could not be any simpler: Please provide me with the name of an OTC cough medicine that has been proven to produce an effect above placebo so that I can buy some the next time I develop a cough.
Please provide us with the name of a single homoeopathic component of an OTC homoeopathic cough medicine that has been proven to produce an effect above placebo.

And if you want to back up your argument, please also provide us with a mechanism that would prevent the ingredients of non-homoeopathic cough medicines that have been demonstrated to have an effect above placebo to fail to have this effect as a component of an OTC cough medicine.

Ta.
 
It could not be any simpler: Please provide me with the name of an OTC cough medicine that has been proven to produce an effect above placebo so that I can buy some the next time I develop a cough.

Vicks Medinite
Vicks 44-D
Robitussin DM
Dimetapp DM
Benylin Adult Formula Cough Suppressant
Triaminic Cough
Tylenol Cough and Cold

Linda
 
Vicks Medinite
Vicks 44-D
Robitussin DM
Dimetapp DM
Benylin Adult Formula Cough Suppressant
Triaminic Cough
Tylenol Cough and Cold

Linda
So a study or studies has specifically concluded that? Which study(ies)?
 
(IANAD) I'd say Rodders has some sort of cognitive disorder. Psychologists, please - what is it called when someone is able to operate functionally (read, write, etc) but fails to absorb information that relates directly to their own enquiries?

I'd call it "deliberate trouble-making", myself...
 
It could not be any simpler: Please provide me with the name of an OTC cough medicine that has been proven to produce an effect above placebo so that I can buy some the next time I develop a cough.

Okay, read the links provided by fls (Linda) at the top of this page... see what ingredients were the most effective (dextromethorphan, guaifenesin, etc). Then read the labels (especially since store brands are cheaper and have the same active ingredients).

But here is what I do when I have severe cough (as recommended by my family doctor who believes in the cheapest most effective treatments):

Take a couple diphenhydramines... this is generic Benadryl. Then take a cup of water. Put into it a tablespoon of honey, a tablespoon of lemon juice and a stick of cinnamon. Put it in the microwave and heat it up... let it sit for a moment (or alternatively you can put the honey, lemon juice and cinnamon stick in the cup and put hot water over them).

Sip the the hot soothing liquid slowly... The diphenhydramine will make you very sleepy (and according to my doctor, cause the muscles in your throat to relax). Then go to bed.

You may have to repeat in four hours.

During the day, make sure you have hot soothing liquids to sip. This could include tea, the non-alcoholic toddy described above, hot lemonade, plain hot water with lemon juice, chicken soup or (one of my favorites) Hot and Sour Soup from our local Chinese restaurant. You could, of course, heat up your favorite homeopathic remedy... but frankly I do not care much for drinking plain hot water.

If your cough persists more than two weeks and/or you are coughing up thick yellow ropes of mucus streaked with blood plus you have severe pain in your chest go see a real doctor. When the latter happened to me (had a sudden high fever in the evening, woke up with no fever but the worst cough you could imagine) I had bacterial pneumonia. I missed about six weeks of 8th grade (on the way home from the medical center my mother stopped by the school and picked up my books and assignments, I homeschooled myself for over Spring break, and was caught up when I got back to school after Easter).
 
I provided references in my post at the top of this page.

Linda

Where in these references are any of the below cough medicines that you listed mentioned?

Vicks Medinite
Vicks 44-D
Robitussin DM
Dimetapp DM
Benylin Adult Formula Cough Suppressant
Triaminic Cough
Tylenol Cough and Cold
 
Okay, read the links provided by fls (Linda) at the top of this page... see what ingredients were the most effective (dextromethorphan, guaifenesin, etc). Then read the labels (especially since store brands are cheaper and have the same active ingredients).

But here is what I do when I have severe cough (as recommended by my family doctor who believes in the cheapest most effective treatments):

Take a couple diphenhydramines... this is generic Benadryl. Then take a cup of water. Put into it a tablespoon of honey, a tablespoon of lemon juice and a stick of cinnamon. Put it in the microwave and heat it up... let it sit for a moment (or alternatively you can put the honey, lemon juice and cinnamon stick in the cup and put hot water over them).

Sip the the hot soothing liquid slowly... The diphenhydramine will make you very sleepy (and according to my doctor, cause the muscles in your throat to relax). Then go to bed.

You may have to repeat in four hours.

During the day, make sure you have hot soothing liquids to sip. This could include tea, the non-alcoholic toddy described above, hot lemonade, plain hot water with lemon juice, chicken soup or (one of my favorites) Hot and Sour Soup from our local Chinese restaurant. You could, of course, heat up your favorite homeopathic remedy... but frankly I do not care much for drinking plain hot water.

If your cough persists more than two weeks and/or you are coughing up thick yellow ropes of mucus streaked with blood plus you have severe pain in your chest go see a real doctor. When the latter happened to me (had a sudden high fever in the evening, woke up with no fever but the worst cough you could imagine) I had bacterial pneumonia. I missed about six weeks of 8th grade (on the way home from the medical center my mother stopped by the school and picked up my books and assignments, I homeschooled myself for over Spring break, and was caught up when I got back to school after Easter).
Thanks for the tip. The point I'm making, however, is that it's not enough to assume that ingredients that have been shown to be marginally effective in treating a cough will combine to produce an efficacious cough medicine. The only way to demonstrate whether a cough medicine is efficacious is to do a controlled test of it versus a placebo.
 
It could not be any simpler: Please provide me with the name of an OTC cough medicine that has been proven to produce an effect above placebo so that I can buy some the next time I develop a cough.

The brand does not matter, read the active ingredients. They are what counts. When you put the same thing into a different bottle or pill it does not act differently.
 
(IANAD) I'd say Rodders has some sort of cognitive disorder. Psychologists, please - what is it called when someone is able to operate functionally (read, write, etc) but fails to absorb information that relates directly to their own enquiries?

I'd call it "deliberate trouble-making", myself...

The normal name for such behavior is trolling.
 
Thanks for the tip. The point I'm making, however, is that it's not enough to assume that ingredients that have been shown to be marginally effective in treating a cough will combine to produce an efficacious cough medicine. The only way to demonstrate whether a cough medicine is efficacious is to do a controlled test of it versus a placebo.

And the point you are missing is that say pseudo-ephedrine is pseudo-ephedrine, and how ever many mg of it is that many mg of it. It does not matter who's name is on the label.
 
Thanks for the tip. The point I'm making, however, is that it's not enough to assume that ingredients that have been shown to be marginally effective in treating a cough will combine to produce an efficacious cough medicine. The only way to demonstrate whether a cough medicine is efficacious is to do a controlled test of it versus a placebo.

The studies (RCT's) that I referenced tested single and multiple-component cough medicines. The brand name preparations that I listed were either the specific brand name preparation used in the study, or were the same as the formulation used in the study.

Linda
 
The studies (RCT's) that I referenced tested single and multiple-component cough medicines. The brand name preparations that I listed were either the specific brand name preparation used in the study, or were the same as the formulation used in the study.

Linda

So you're saying that Vicks Medinite, Vicks 44-D, Robitussin DM, Dimetapp DM,
Benylin Adult Formula Cough Suppressant, Triaminic Cough, and Tylenol Cough and Cold were specifically tested in these studies? Where are these brand names mentioned in the studies?
 
So you're saying that Vicks Medinite, Vicks 44-D, Robitussin DM, Dimetapp DM,
Benylin Adult Formula Cough Suppressant, Triaminic Cough, and Tylenol Cough and Cold were specifically tested in these studies? Where are these brand names mentioned in the studies?

I would like to hear your rational for why the brand name matters.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom