Well if there is no crazy conspiracy theory....

why not just contact the news desk for that station to get a clarification?

Why can't the TRUTHERS do soemthing so simple as to fact check and corroborate what they are using as evidence by contacting the people who made that video?
 
TC have you tried contacting the reporter? Do you know the station that the reporter was from? Do you know her name?

As someone who used to work in TV news, let me give you an opinion of what probably happened. The director knew the reporter was going to be talking about the debris, and called up the tape of the debris shot from the helicopter. When she began talking about the crater he began fast forwarding to the footage of the main crater, but realized that the tape was still on the air and stopped. It just happened to be where the garage/shed was, with a dark spot on the ground.

BTW the closest NBC affiliate I was willing to spend the time looking for, and also was a channel 5 was WTAP in West Virginia. There is a point in the tape where the crawl talks about a "StormTeam 5" forecast for the area.

ETA:Arrus808 just beat me to the obvious question.
 
Something worth pointing out that I don't think has been brought up (but please excuse me if it has) -- not only does the reporter not know what video is being shown, I don't even think the debris field is a live feed. After watching the vid a few times, it became clear to me that she is broadcasting from the crash site much, much later in the day. It's dark behind her, the truck headlights are on, and she references events from earlier in the day - Tom Ridge's fly over, etc. She says that there are currently 100s of personnel on scene, but the video shows no activity at all. I think it's clear that the helicopter shot is relatively soon after the crash, and the producer decided to show that video during the reporter's broadcast while neglecting to throw up a "recorded earlier" tag.
i could probably dig up a bit more on this - I'll have to look into it. I'm sure there's some reference as to when Ridge's fly over occured.
Good catch.
 
Where do you get the 50 foot dimension, and where did anyone state that the soil was spongy concrete?


I stated that there was a layer of softer soil on top of a hard layer of broken rock.(which I gathered from having actually seen the reclaimation process of a open seam coal mine) Can you envision what that is or not?

"spongy concrete" :

Initial reports were that the plane burrowed into the ground at a 90 degree angle, because of the "soft" dirt the plane burrowed down into the ground. The excavation went as deep as 50'. Version #2 states the ground was solid and the plane didn't penetrate but in fact "vaporized" for the most part which is odd because of one of the data recorders being recovered from about 25' deep.

I can envision it perfectly, what I can't seem to find is all this "broken rock" in the aerial shots or in the excavation shots. Do you have any images that support your claim?
 
"spongy concrete" :

Initial reports were that the plane burrowed into the ground at a 90 degree angle, because of the "soft" dirt the plane burrowed down into the ground. The excavation went as deep as 50'. Version #2 states the ground was solid and the plane didn't penetrate but in fact "vaporized" for the most part which is odd because of one of the data recorders being recovered from about 25' deep.

I can envision it perfectly, what I can't seem to find is all this "broken rock" in the aerial shots or in the excavation shots. Do you have any images that support your claim?
Please cite sources for your claims of "version 1" and "version 2" reports.
Additionally, please provide substantiating evidence to support your claim of "I would say the average JREF'er fires off about 20 insulting posts to each one with some subtance " or retract the statement.
 
Show your evidence, please. Those grainy low-res photos don't cut it.

But grainy highly compressed images proves it not. Got it.





And you can't say with any degree of certainty that there is a crater there.

Are you saying what is there is a shadow and if so what caused it?

If it is not a shadow and an actual part of the plane please feel free to explain how such a large piece survived the impact and somehow got a couple hundred feet away from it.

Why wasn't this "object" (if it is not a crater) used for evidence in the trial against Mossaoui?


Show your proof for this statement, please.

You are seeing what you want to see, and disregarding anything that doesn't fit your delusion.

You are lying to yourself.

ETA: Also, it appears that you have -manipulated- cropped both photos. Yes or no?

My proof is in the first post. At the bare minimum I have presented evidence that there is something there whether it is a crater as I believe or an object, what it isn't though is a shadow which seems to be the general consensus around here.

I have cropped both images, and circled the area in question. I have not done anything to lighten or darken or enhance them in any way shape or form though.
 
Something worth pointing out that I don't think has been brought up (but please excuse me if it has) -- not only does the reporter not know what video is being shown, I don't even think the debris field is a live feed. After watching the vid a few times, it became clear to me that she is broadcasting from the crash site much, much later in the day. It's dark behind her, the truck headlights are on, and she references events from earlier in the day - Tom Ridge's fly over, etc. She says that there are currently 100s of personnel on scene, but the video shows no activity at all. I think it's clear that the helicopter shot is relatively soon after the crash, and the producer decided to show that video during the reporter's broadcast while neglecting to throw up a "recorded earlier" tag.
i could probably dig up a bit more on this - I'll have to look into it. I'm sure there's some reference as to when Ridge's fly over occured.


Ridge was there around 6PM that day. Which is weird because if you look at KT's aerial shot being "debunked" elsewhere it looks as though there is no one else around.

Why isn't there any footage of the Flight93 print from the day of? Why would the news consider this "object" to be more important than the airplane imprint a couple hundred yards away?
 
But grainy highly compressed images proves it not. Got it.
Good, I guess.

Are you saying what is there is a shadow and if so what caused it?

If it is not a shadow and an actual part of the plane please feel free to explain how such a large piece survived the impact and somehow got a couple hundred feet away from it.

Why wasn't this "object" (if it is not a crater) used for evidence in the trial against Mossaoui?
It looks like a bush in both Gravy's pic and the one from Killtown's site. The shadow is from where the bush interrupted the flow of photons emanating from the sun.

My proof is in the first post. At the bare minimum I have presented evidence that there is something there whether it is a crater as I believe or an object, what it isn't though is a shadow which seems to be the general consensus around here.
Agreed that in your OP you have shown that 'something' is there. And the general consensus appears to be an ATV, not a shadow.

I have cropped both images, and circled the area in question. I have not done anything to lighten or darken or enhance them in any way shape or form though.
But by cropping and circling, you admit to editing them.
 
Last edited:
You cannot possibly tell what that object is from that footage.

If you think you can, you're imagining it.

-Gumboot

I assumed it was the plane's engine that reportedly broke away from the fusilage and rolled downhill.

This is from Popular Mechanics:

Experts on the scene tell PM that a fan from one of the engines was recovered in a catchment basin, downhill from the crash site. Jeff Reinbold, the National Park Service representative responsible for the Flight 93 National Memorial, confirms the direction and distance from the crash site to the basin: just over 300 yards south, which means the fan landed in the direction the jet was traveling. "It's not unusual for an engine to move or tumble across the ground," says Michael K. Hynes, an airline accident expert who investigated the crash of TWA Flight 800 out of New York City in 1996. "When you have very high velocities, 500 mph or more," Hynes says, "you are talking about 700 to 800 ft. per second. For something to hit the ground with that kind of energy, it would only take a few seconds to bounce up and travel 300 yards." Numerous crash analysts contacted by PM concur.
 
But grainy highly compressed images proves it not. Got it.
No. An image can do one of three things:
1) Support you claim
2) Refute your claim
3) Be neutral in evaluating your claim

Are you saying what is there is a shadow and if so what caused it?
No shifting the burden. You claim it is a crater. Prove it.

If it is not a shadow and an actual part of the plane please feel free to explain how such a large piece survived the impact and somehow got a couple hundred feet away from it.
Your argument from personal incredulity holds no value. If the image element in question is not a shadow, and is part of the plane, then you must show that it could not have gotten in to that position as a result of the crash.

Why wasn't this "object" (if it is not a crater) used for evidence in the trial against Mossaoui?
Red herring. We have not established, to everyone's agreement, what the image element is, or is not. It is fruitless to try to evaluate its qualitative value in the trial if we don't even agree as to what the element is.

My proof is in the first post. At the bare minimum I have presented evidence that there is something there whether it is a crater as I believe or an object, what it isn't though is a shadow which seems to be the general consensus around here.
You presented an image, and your opinion as to what it contained. You have provided no substantiating evidence to support your assertions.
 
I have cropped both images, and circled the area in question. I have not done anything to lighten or darken or enhance them in any way shape or form though.

Not entirely true, TC. You also saved it as a gif, which changes the color palette and can effect the tone of the image depending on the settings.

So now we have the original photo (where ever that is), Killtown's posted images (which are apparently not the original digital files, since the camera data has been stripped from the file), and then your gif file. Compression on compression on compression. And who know's how much more compression there was between the original and Killtown's.
 
Something worth pointing out that I don't think has been brought up (but please excuse me if it has) -- not only does the reporter not know what video is being shown, I don't even think the debris field is a live feed. After watching the vid a few times, it became clear to me that she is broadcasting from the crash site much, much later in the day. It's dark behind her, the truck headlights are on, and she references events from earlier in the day - Tom Ridge's fly over, etc. She says that there are currently 100s of personnel on scene, but the video shows no activity at all. I think it's clear that the helicopter shot is relatively soon after the crash, and the producer decided to show that video during the reporter's broadcast while neglecting to throw up a "recorded earlier" tag.
i could probably dig up a bit more on this - I'll have to look into it. I'm sure there's some reference as to when Ridge's fly over occured.

me said:
Firstly, she is describing a large crater. Not even on planet X would the splotch be considered large, let alone a crater. Secondly, she is giving a live interview from the field and not commenting on the video that the viewers are being shown. How do I know this? She says something to the effect of "I hope you all are seeing it as I'm talking about it" and earlier, about 30 seconds in, she says "I dont know whether or not you all can see pictures of this...." Thats because she has no idea what is being shown and the producers just continued showing the helicopter footage and even fast forwarded to your small "crater" as she was describing the actual crater.

I brought this up on the first page and I did so because I believe TC jumped to the conclusion that the black thing was a crater because the reporter was describing a crater as the splotch was being shown. However, its pretty obvious that she's talking about the actual crater and not the black thing.

Oh and TC didn't bother acknowledging this point.

TC, what say you? Do you admit that you are wrong about this reporter commenting on the footage being shown?

If there was no audio in that clip, would you still think the splotch is a crater?
[preemptive reply]
Really?
[/preemptive reply]
 
I brought this up on the first page and I did so because I believe TC jumped to the conclusion that the black thing was a crater because the reporter was describing a crater as the splotch was being shown. However, its pretty obvious that she's talking about the actual crater and not the black thing.

Oh and TC didn't bother acknowledging this point.

TC, what say you? Do you admit that you are wrong about this reporter commenting on the footage being shown?

If there was no audio in that clip, would you still think the splotch is a crater?
[preemptive reply]
Really?
[/preemptive reply]

Right - and I agree with your assessment. My main point was that not only was she not seeing the video that the viewers were seeing, but that her reporting was easily a good 8 hours after the debris field video was taken from the copter. Later on the first page, TC's comment that "she is reporting from the scene, on the ground." implies that she's on scene near the splotchy burned object, and at the time of the video being taken, when clearly she isn't.

And TC still hasn't acknowledged your point. Well, TC? How about it?
 
Why won't 1 person answer why there was a need to stamp "JREF" on a Flight 93 image. I don't stamp "Terrorcell" over 9/11 images, they are not mine and this pic is not JREF's.

Looks like you are familiar with Alex Jones! No wonder you fall for no facts make up a body of work syndrome typical of an Alex Jones follower.

Jref in the photo or not in the photo means you have hot linked photos! Not allowed. You have not read the rules. You are a CT guy hopelessly devoid of facts or rational thought.

Good luck. What is the purpose of your first post? You did not state the objective or subject or much of anything.

I do not know where you are going, or what you are doing with you "facts".

What is your objective?
 
Looks like you are familiar with Alex Jones! No wonder you fall for no facts make up a body of work syndrome typical of an Alex Jones follower.

Jref in the photo or not in the photo means you have hot linked photos! Not allowed. You have not read the rules. You are a CT guy hopelessly devoid of facts or rational thought.

Good luck. What is the purpose of your first post? You did not state the objective or subject or much of anything.

I do not know where you are going, or what you are doing with you "facts".

What is your objective?

I answered this, and even provided an example for him. Never did get an acknowledgement, though.
 
[Edit: Whoops. Already said. ]
i could probably dig up a bit more on this - I'll have to look into it. I'm sure there's some reference as to when Ridge's fly over occured.
Actually, this just came up in the Killtown's new "smoking gun" for flight 93, debunked thread. His flyover occurred at about 6:15pm.
 
I don't know, where's all the debris that was scattered about? You state this as the next image as if it were taken minutes apart but the lack of scraps on the ground means it was taken much later.
Can you really not understand why more debris would appear in a photograph taken looking down the road than across the road? The pictures were taken by the same person at the same time. They are timestamped. You should speak with the homeowner if you have further questions about who swept up the black stuff.
 
So what is causing the "shadow" seen in the news footage?
Shadow? Huh? Please explain why it isn't debris such as the remains of the flaming seat cushion that we know was pulled from a roof...and guess where the nearest roof in the direction of the crash momentum is?

Please tell us why that is not a rational explanation.
 
What would be the cause of the crater?
There is no crater. You are imagining it. Do you understand what I am saying?

The plane did not come apart in flight. It hit the ground with all systems operating normally. Do you understand?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom