The Bush Resume

Bush resume

Mark, You might also add the "Skull and Bones Society" and the Bilderbrand Group. By the way,to all you Bush "disciples",I worked in the Miami-Dade Elections Dept and have seen first hand the offical numbers. George W.Bush DID NOT steal the 2000 Presidential election. Governor Jeb Bush did!
 
"My only purpose in bringing up Clinton is to highlight the glaring inconsistency of applying judgment differently based solely on ideology."

No, what you are doing is obfuscating the issue by constantly bring up Clinton. The issue is Bush. Clinton, you may have heard is no longer president. Any possible hypocrisy in views is irrelevant, other than of course to allow you to deflect focus and avoid the addressing the questions or issues. If you like, please open another thread about the hypocrisy and name names, i.e. who is applying judgment differently and how where and how.

For someone you like and admire, I would think Bush would deserve a better defense than to compare his failings with Clintons'.
 
Re: Bush resume

bluestraveler said:
Mark, You might also add the "Skull and Bones Society" and the Bilderbrand Group. By the way,to all you Bush "disciples",I worked in the Miami-Dade Elections Dept and have seen first hand the offical numbers. George W.Bush DID NOT steal the 2000 Presidential election. Governor Jeb Bush did!

If I went into the "Skull and Bones Society" and their homo-erotic, male bonding rituals, no one here would believe me. You do it. :D
 
Re: Re: Bush resume

Mark said:


If I went into the "Skull and Bones Society" and their homo-erotic, male bonding rituals, no one here would believe me. You do it. :D
That's the least of it......
 
Bush resume

Thanks for the effort Marcus. "Some people you just can't reach."
The book "American Secret Society" by Anthony C. Sutton is available at RIE publishing,check it out.;)
 
DavidJames said:
No, what you are doing is obfuscating the issue by constantly bring up Clinton.
Not at all. I have not avoided any questions or tried to cloud anything. I am making a simple argument. See if you can follow along.

Proposition: The attacks made on Bush are done for ideological purposes.

Premise: The attacks on bush consist primarily of rhetoric.

Premise: Those who attack Bush are inconsistent in that they have excused similar behavior from past presidents that shared the ideology of those making the attacks.

The issue is Bush.
Agreed.

Clinton, you may have heard is no longer president.
Yes I have heard, so what? It is not germane to MY argument.

Any possible hypocrisy in views is irrelevant
I am charging that the claims made against George Bush are largely spurious. Two wrongs do not make a right. (Spare me teh wright brothers joke) I have made that abundantly clear. The actions of George Bush must be judged solely on their own. But if the critics of George Bush are inconsistent in their judgments then of what value is their criticism?

...other than of course to allow you to deflect focus and avoid the addressing the questions or issues.
The statements made against bush are largely rhetorical and subjective. As I said earlier there is little objective analysis. My problem I have with the thread is the mean spirited, pompous and hypocritical nature of many of the posts. I would hope that I have a right to be critical of the thread and those who are posting.

If you like, please open another thread about the hypocrisy and name names, i.e. who is applying judgment differently and how where and how.
If you like please report me to a moderator. Otherwise don’t tell me what to do. ‘K?

For someone you like and admire, I would think Bush would deserve a better defense than to compare his failings with Clintons'.
Boy, you missed that one by a large margin. My purpose isn’t to defend Bush so much as it is to point out the hypocrisy of those posting in the thread.

Please read my posts a little more carefully.
 
RandFan said:
Not at all. I have not avoided any questions or tried to cloud anything. I am making a simple argument. See if you can follow along.

Proposition: The attacks made on Bush are done for ideological purposes.

Premise: The attacks on bush consist primarily of rhetoric.

Premise: Those who attack Bush are inconsistent in that they have excused similar behavior from past presidents that shared the ideology of those making the attacks.

Fact: Bush lied, it matters not by omission or commission, about the state of the Iraqi weapons program. This is fact, it is not rhetoric.

Fact: I haven't excused the fact that Clinton lied.

Statement: They are both fraught with ethical problems. It is, however, true, that Clinton got nobody killed, and Bush got thousands, at least, killed, as well as turned the USA into a right-wing rogue state.

Conclusion: They're both idiots.

Corrolary: Bush is worse.
 
By the way,to all you Bush "disciples",I worked in the Miami-Dade Elections Dept and have seen first hand the offical numbers. George W.Bush DID NOT steal the 2000 Presidential election. Governor Jeb Bush did!
???? Yeah, ok, we will all just take your word for it.

Could you be more obscure? How about specific alegations? Can I verify them by calling your supervisor?

And who are these Bush "disciples"?
 
jj said:
Fact: Bush lied, it matters not by omission or commission, about the state of the Iraqi weapons program. This is fact, it is not rhetoric.
Arguable but let's assume that it is true. So, you are making dichotomy? Either Bush lies and people die or Bush tells the truth and people don't die?

Truth is the first casualty of War, this of course in no way excuses the behavior of any of our leaders. But war and presidencies are complex things. By your logic all leaders during any war were idiots. I can accept that you feel that way. I have no problem with that. I don't agree but I respect that.

Fact: I haven't excused the fact that Clinton lied.
Thank you, I respect your consistency. I hope you can respect mine.

Statement: They are both fraught with ethical problems. It is, however, true, that Clinton got nobody killed
I'm afraid you need to brush up on your history. It is arguable and quite possible that Clinton killed innocent civilians for his own self-serving purposes.

...and Bush got thousands, at least, killed,
Agreed, and he saved many thousands more.

...as well as turned the USA into a right-wing rogue state.
This IS rhetoric. I'm willing to respect your opinion but I don't agree.

Conclusion: They're both idiots.
I accept that you have come to that conclusion using consistent judgment. I have no desire to rebut your alegation.

Corrolary: Bush is worse.
Subjectively based on a very small and selective subset of data.

That being said your post is by far one of the most intelligent posts made in this thread!

Thank you,

RandFan
 
RandFan said:
???? Yeah, ok, we will all just take your word for it.

Could you be more obscure? How about specific alegations? Can I verify them by calling your supervisor?

And who are these Bush "disciples"?

It's actually public information moron!
 
RandFan said:
What is public information?

Why am I a moron?

Good nic BTW.

You're right. I should not have called you a moron . I'll reserve judgement. And I think you should know that public records of election numbers are there for you. I don't have time to explain to you about politics in Florida and how the Republican Party manipulated 2000. Do your homework if you have the will to be honest! Thanks for responding, I enjoy educating children.
 
RandFan said:

Truth is the first casualty of War, this of course in no way excuses the behavior of any of our leaders. But war and presidencies are complex things. By your logic all leaders during any war were idiots. I can accept that you feel that way. I have no problem with that. I don't agree but I respect that.

When do you believe this war started? Then ask yourself whether jj meant that Bush began lieing before or after the war started. It's one thing to tell a "white lie" to protect national security when you're in a war -- it's another thing entirely to lie to justify starting the war!


I'm afraid you need to brush up on your history. It is arguable and quite possible that Clinton killed innocent civilians for his own self-serving purposes.

Specify what you mean here. Also specify exactly how it was self-serving.


Agreed, and he saved many thousands more.

Arguable in the extreme.


This IS rhetoric. I'm willing to respect your opinion but I don't agree.

International polls seem to agree with this rhetoric.


Subjectively based on a very small and selective subset of data.

How selective and small is your subset of data?
 
bluestraveler
By the way,to all you Bush "disciples",I worked in the Miami-Dade Elections Dept and have seen first hand the offical numbers. George W.Bush DID NOT steal the 2000 Presidential election. Governor Jeb Bush did!

RandFan
???? Yeah, ok, we will all just take your word for it.

Could you be more obscure? How about specific allegations? Can I verify them by calling your supervisor?

And who are these Bush "disciples"?

bluestraveler
It's actually public information moron!
I'm going to assume by public information you mean "the official numbers".

Hmmmm.... then why the headline? Why give us your credentials? How do the numbers prove that Jeb Bush "stole" the election?

Bluestraveler, when you make claims you have to be willing to back them up and not just assume that since the numbers are "public information" that you can get away without providing evidence.

So, let me make this formal. I dispute that any numbers prove Jeb Bush stole the election.

Now, it is on you to provide the numbers and provide a coherent argument that shows demonstrably that Jeb Bush stole the election. Do you think you can do that or would you rather just call me names and expect us all to take your word for it?

Thanks,

RandFan
 
bluestraveler said:
You're right. I should not have called you a moron . I'll resreve judgement. And I think you should know that public records of election numbers are there for you. I don't have time to explain to you about politics in Florida and how the Republican Party manipulated 2000. Do your homework if you have the will to be honest! Thanks for responding, I enjoy educating children.
bluestraveler, plese see the post above.

This is a skeptics forum and it is expected that if you make claims you can back them up. It is not encumbent upon me to prove your claims and I have every right to call into question any claim (that is why we call it a skeptics forum).

You have three choices.

1.) Withdraw the claim.

2.) Back-up the claim.

3.) Ignore my request but then have no credibility.

I can't think of any other option.
 
RandFan said:
I'm going to assume by public information you mean "the official numbers".

Hmmmm.... then why the headline? Why give us your credentials? How do the numbers prove that Jeb Bush "stole" the election?

Bluestraveler, when you make claims you have to be willing to back them up and not just assume that since the numbers are "public information" that you can get away without providing evidence.

So, let me make this formal. I dispute that any numbers prove Jeb Bush stole the election.

Now, it is on you to provide the numbers and provide a coherent argument that shows demonstrably that Jeb Bush stole the election. Do you think you can do that or would you rather just call me names and expect us all to take your word for it?

Thanks,

RandFan


RandFan,
I think I know what type of forum I'm in. If you have questions about 2000 do some research. I suggest you focus on Katherine Harris, State Attorney General at the time. Good luck!
 
Hi dsm,

Thank you for the questions. Reason is so refreshing.

dsm said:
When do you believe this war started? Then ask yourself whether jj meant that Bush began lieing before or after the war started. It's one thing to tell a "white lie" to protect national security when you're in a war -- it's another thing entirely to lie to justify starting the war!
Good question. Sadly the first causality is suffered before the start of hostilities. A case can be made that Roosevelt lied. The flying tigers were a lie. The Kuwaiti propaganda prior to the very first gulf war was full of lies. I can't excuse the lies but I think lying before is arguably as important as lying after the start of the war.

Assuming Bush lied, was the lie justified? That is difficult to answer. I don't know. I don't stay up late at night worrying about it. I am quite confident the war was appropriate. My own bias probably causes me to minimize any negative impact of such deception assuming there truly was deception. It is a valid point.

Specify what you mean here. Also specify exactly how it was self-serving.
Shortly after Bill Clinton got into trouble he started dropping bombs all over the place. Many civilians were killed. A number of targets and the timing of those targets have been called into question. A good argument can be made that the bombing campaigns kept the American public's mind off of the scandals and on the war. Many pundits including a number of prominent ones questioned to what extent Clinton's bombing was "wagging the dog".

Arguable in the extreme.
How? At the end of the war the prisons were opened and the first priority of many fathers and mothers was to go searching for their missing loved ones. It seemed that thousands would disappear regularly from Baghdad. Are you not familiar with Saddam's atrocities? He routinely had thousands killed. I don't know how you can make that statement.

From the US Senate
Perhaps the best documented case of Saddam's genocidal policies is the infamous Anfal campaign... According to Human Rights Watch between 50,000 and 100,000 were killed during Anfal.
So no I don't really think it is arguable at all.

International polls seem to agree with this rhetoric.
Two problems.

1.) The argument is ad-populum .

2.) At best the polls prove the sentiment of others.

I am against making any policy based solely on the perceptions of others.

How selective and small is your subset of data?
For which claim?
 
Off topic alert.

Hey Randfan my friend,
Re: the resume issue, don't feel these requests for data are directed at you, you don't have to be the Defender of the Faith.....don't want to provide data, others can pick up the slack....and if the reason to support him is "I like his style," or "his kids love him" or any damn reason you want, that's OK. We were just looking for specifics that one might put on a resume.....

(P.S. Did you ever get that invoice paid?)
 
bluestraveler said:
RandFan,
I think I know what type of forum I'm in.
Really? You could have surprised me.

It's not my claim and not my responsibility to back it up.

You have three choices.

1.) Withdraw the claim.

2.) Back-up the claim.

3.) Ignore my request but then have no credibility.
I have refuted your contention and I can't prove a negative.

I take it that you are going to refuse to prove your claim that Jeb Bush stole the election. Fine, I will mostly ignore you but I reserve the right to remind you of your refusal from time to time.

Thanks again,

RandFan.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom