How about brodski's airplane example? I'd appreciate it if you responded to that. It might make your viewpoint more clear.Not lost on me at all. And the things you point out are perfectly normal everyday overrides with rather little chance of fatality resulting.
It'd be nice if you could define "non-normal override", and how it differs from a normal override.Here'd be a non-normal override. You're 2 miles from your home which is at the bottom of a canyon. Your run uphill takes you to the top of the ledge which, if you'd just jump off, would peel 1.85 miles off your trip back.
That aside, the example you give clearly doesn't fit into the same category as the activity the woman engaged in. That is - the quality of jumping off a cliff that is different from forcing yourself to get out of bed in the morning, is that jumping off a cliff is obviously dangerous. This quality is not shared by drinking too much water. So just as a good incentive can get an intelligent person to override their instincts and get out of bed, so a good incentive could get an intelligent but uninformed person to override their instincts and enter that contest.
You started talking about "overrides" when people pointed out that drinking water and inhaling it are two different things so you can't equate the obvious fact that you can drown to the not so obvious fact that you can die from drinking too much water.
From what I read, you suggested that you don't concider her stupid not because it's obviously dangerous to drink too much water, but rather because her instincts would discourage her from doing so. She would have to actively overcome those.
The problem with this arugment, as was pointed out in the post you responded to, is that we do things all the time that require us to overcome our instinctive responses.
So now you're suggesting that those "normal overrides" are of course not stupid. Okay. What are? "Non-normal overrides"? Why? Because they are obviously dangerous, as in your jumping off a cliff example?
The problem here is that once again what she did wasn't obviously dangerous.
But there's a second problem: Some things that are obviously dangerous aren't stupid: I've jumped off a 20 meter cliff, because I knew full well that the water below was deep enough. Yet at the time I was terrified and had to overcome a serious survival instinct in order to jump. Even as I was falling I shouted out "Oh ****!!" the first time, anyway.
Was that stupid? Stupid enough that you'd have laughed if by some freak chance I'd died?
I don't see how "overriding a basic life instinct" is necessarily stupid. I could come up with examples all day of people doing just that in safe ways. Sometimes even not so safe ways, but where they know the risks. Here's an example. Is he being stupid?If you choose to jump, you'd do a stupid thing. You'd override a basic life instinct. Please don't try it. We need you here.![]()
I ask this in seriousness in order to try to understand the criteria that you're using to determine that this woman is stupid.