So, You're Living In A Police State.

b4 9/11 and the patriot act we could drive around with as much rust as we wanted to!

Ill tell you what kind of freedom I have lost and I'm pretty pi**ed off about it. The freedom in NJ to have rust on your motor vehicle!!! Yup one of my trucks failed for a spot of rust! But being the rebel that I am I'm still driving with a "failed' inspection sticker!! it's like........ Well like.... um.. like being a tax protester!! only different! So I'm thumbing my nose at NJDMV. I may even get a Che Guevara bumper sticker and place it right above that spot of rust behind my extended cab!
 
Didn't UN and Human Rights organisations have had plenty of access to it, and did visit it in a number of occasions?
In a word, no. There was limited access to some but not all detainees and the rules were nothing could be reported on about the visits or something like that.

You can probably check on this yourself.
 
I think your points are valid Gumboot.
The problem is the people at Gitmo are not being treated as they would under the Geneva convention. I've seen Hogan's Heroes.

Five years and still no trial, military or otherwise. I'm not saying David Hicks is innocent, just that without a trial we have no way of knowing.

Larry Lovage has it right.

This is not the forum for this debate though, so I won't say any more.
 
You can probably check on this yourself.

I will. But the fact that they did make a very grim report on GITMO makes me think they did have access to the base.

Without a trial, how do you know?

From his Wikipedia entry, he doesn't seem to have a clean record. I agree that his case is taking too long, and now alot longer because of the Supreme Court's decision, but I have no sympathy for guys like him and I think he shouldn't be set free.

The problem is the people at Gitmo are not being treated as they would under the Geneva convention.

The problem with the Taliban and Al Qaeda is that they do not fight according to any conventions.
 
Originally Posted by Brainache:
The problem is the people at Gitmo are not being treated as they would under the Geneva convention.

Originally Posted by Pardalis:
The problem with the Taliban and Al Qaeda is that they do not fight according to any conventions.


Pard, that just doesn't follow. You are falling for the Bush admin's mis-information campaign. Bush claims [you name it] is different therefore it gives Bush the right to throw out the Constitution. NO it doesn't. That's why the Supreme Court has ruled against the President's actions.

Look at this site for a few excerpts from the military tribunals to give you idea what kind of evidence the US has on these poor saps.
the Supreme Court agreed, ruling that the tribunals had violated federal law and the Geneva Conventions. Soon afterwards, the Pentagon announced it would begin to follow the conventions’ protections for detainees. These excerpts were taken from the thousands of pages of tribunal transcripts released this spring under the Freedom of Information Act.
 
It was bad intelligence from the RCMP that caused Arar's turmoil in the first place.

The US deported Arar based on that flawed intelligence.

And he had citizenship in two countries Canada and Syria. And Canada is known as a very liberal country and they tell us they don't want him. What should we have done with him, taken him into Manhattan and dropped him off on the corner?
 
Pard, are you willing to give up the values our country stands for in order to have "security"? I'm not.

And why are the terrorist threats today any more dangerous than the "communist" threats we were fighting during the Vietnam War?

Bush uses fear to increase his authority. I believe we need to deal with the threats in our lives including the insane actions of terrorists. But one, I don't believe that our priority should be to spend hundreds of billions on a threat which killed 3,000 people 5 years ago while we are fine with 40,000 car accident deaths every year, and two, I don't believe the actions Bush is taking prevent more terrorism. They don't have squat to show for the spying or torture or detentions or deportations. Bush came up with a few vague claims in the State of the Union speech and this time even the mainstream news shot the claims down. They have nothing to show for their actions, nothing.

We all know by now the war in Iraq has made things worse, not better. Only a few di-hards still believe that war is over anything except an oil supply for Bush's cronies.

I wasn't aware we 'are fine' with deaths from automobile accidents. I thought there was a huge system of police patrols, laws, safety regulation, traffic courts, emergency services, safety barriers and signs and many other things to regulate traffic, lessen traffic accidents and injuries from them.
 
Anyone who makes any claims about the US (or any other liberal western nation) being a police state has quite clearly never lived in, nor talked to someone who has lived in, an ACTUAL police state.

Such people are insulting those that have and still are experiencing the ACTUAL horrors and misery of a REAL police state.

Americans seriously have no idea just how good they have it.

-Gumboot

(No, I have never lived in a police state either, but I have many good friends who have, and I have actually listened to what they have said, and I am very aware that their experiences exceed anything I could imagine).

I had the extreme pleasure of taking lunch with a couple Cambodian people who survived Pol Pot. Now there is a way to change your world view in a matter of hours
 
There's no need for our police state to be identical to some other country's. Ours is run by neocons, so it's all about incompetence and corruption. In the neocon version of fascism, the trains don't even run, much less run on time. But--after six years of right-wing rule--the U.S. has in fact degenerated to a nascent, loosey-goosey police state. If we still have some of our freedoms, it's because neocons can't do anything right. If they had more time, they would have done better.

Free speech now occurs only in zones. You have to think twice about what library books to take out. You are almost certainly being spied on--probably illegally. The unelected President has the power to "disappear" people. The worst and most hated President in U.S. history attaches statements to bills explaining why he'll do just what he pleases. He likes to flip us the bird. Torture is national policy. Habeus corpus is under attack. The Treasury is being handed over to large corporations. Money is hemorrhaging out of the country. Until the last election, the government could be counted on to do the precise opposite of what everybody wanted...

My friends, this is police-state stuff. Sure, it isn't exactly Hitler or Pol Pot. You can't expect neocons to run a tight ship. But they definitely had a police state building up fast for six years. Thank God it's over.
 
Last edited:
<snip> After WW2 the British did not repatriate German POWs until they were convinced they had relinquished their Nazi ideology. Some Germans remained POWs for decades, and one particular German; Rudi Lux, was never repatriated, and died in Britain in 2004, technically still a POW (he even continued reporting to a local police station until 1961). <snip>
-Gumboot

The fact that he was an ex POW may not have been the reason for reporting to the police. It could have been just because he was an alien (I mean non-British).

My father was born in Holland, and his parents emigrated to England when he was a baby. He lived in England for the rest of his life, but he was never naturalised, and retained his Dutch citizenship. In the late 1960's we visited relatives in Holland, and when we got back to England, at Dover, we were delayed at immigration because he was an alien, and didn't have what he called his "police book" with him, to show he had right of domicile. I think the fact that he was in an English registered car, with an English wife, and two English children with him persuaded the immigration officials that he could re-enter the country.

As an aside, during WW2 he was forced to leave his house, wife and daughter because he was not allowed to live in a sensitive area (USAF base and RAF Bomber Command nearby) because he had relatives in a German occupied country.

Dave
 
Pard, that just doesn't follow. You are falling for the Bush admin's mis-information campaign. Bush claims [you name it] is different therefore it gives Bush the right to throw out the Constitution. NO it doesn't. That's why the Supreme Court has ruled against the President's actions.

I agree, and the Supreme Court's decision is the authority in the matter, so I accept it.

But on the other hand, was 9/11 respectful of Geneva conventions? Are the constant car bombings respectful of Geneva conventions? And what about the beheadings of innocent civilian prisoners?
 
Lesse, now:
Captured, carrying a loaded weapon, with a bunch of other guys carrying loaded weapons, all of whom had been shooting at US troops is kind of a dead giveaway...
And that's why I don't understand the demands for legal defenses and trials. Such perks are unprecedented for enemies captured on a battlefield, yet people sqwauk as if the Bush admin. is doing something that hasn't been done for the entire history of the US.
 
And that's why I don't understand the demands for legal defenses and trials. Such perks are unprecedented for enemies captured on a battlefield, yet people sqwauk as if the Bush admin. is doing something that hasn't been done for the entire history of the US.

I get the feeling that there are an awfully large number of innocents out there who think war is like "Capture the Flag", or paintball.
Like, you score points for capturing a guy, they you let him go so you can score more points --
Or something...
All I know, if somebody is shooting at my troops, I want him out of action before he gets lucky enough to kill one of my guys. If he gives up and surrenders, I da*n sur am not going to turn him loose to try again!
 
There's no need for our police state to be identical to some other country's.

Yeah but the people making the "police state" claim are obviously using that expression to cause fear in people's mind, because it refers to other "police states" we all know about.
 
The fact that he was an ex POW may not have been the reason for reporting to the police. It could have been just because he was an alien (I mean non-British).

My father was born in Holland, and his parents emigrated to England when he was a baby. He lived in England for the rest of his life, but he was never naturalised, and retained his Dutch citizenship. In the late 1960's we visited relatives in Holland, and when we got back to England, at Dover, we were delayed at immigration because he was an alien, and didn't have what he called his "police book" with him, to show he had right of domicile. I think the fact that he was in an English registered car, with an English wife, and two English children with him persuaded the immigration officials that he could re-enter the country.

As an aside, during WW2 he was forced to leave his house, wife and daughter because he was not allowed to live in a sensitive area (USAF base and RAF Bomber Command nearby) because he had relatives in a German occupied country.

Dave


Aha, but was he from Holland or the Netherlands? And if the latter, can you guess what I'm going to say about having an "English" registered car?

But that's just my personal bugbear, as you all know.....:boggled:
 
And he had citizenship in two countries Canada and Syria. And Canada is known as a very liberal country and they tell us they don't want him. What should we have done with him, taken him into Manhattan and dropped him off on the corner?
Where is your information Canada told the US to send this guy to Syria? I am not aware that is what occurred. Canada gave the US bad information on the guy but there is no evidence they denied him entrance into Canada or told the US to send him to Syria.

This guy was on his way home and was merely changing planes in the US. Why didn't Canada just arrest him?

Sending him to Syria was part of the US special renditions. You might want to read a bit more about what this country has been doing to people.
 
I wasn't aware we 'are fine' with deaths from automobile accidents. I thought there was a huge system of police patrols, laws, safety regulation, traffic courts, emergency services, safety barriers and signs and many other things to regulate traffic, lessen traffic accidents and injuries from them.
With those things in place that you mention, we have more than 40,000 deaths a year. If you took the money we are spending because 3,000 people were killed 5 years ago and used it to make the roads safer you could bring the fatality rate down considerably.
 
I had the extreme pleasure of taking lunch with a couple Cambodian people who survived Pol Pot. Now there is a way to change your world view in a matter of hours
The day after I finished Haing Ngor's book, A Cambodian Odyssey, Surviving the Killing Fields he was murdered in an LA alley. That was a moving experience.

No one is claiming the US is over the edge. I for one am just pointing out how easy it would be to get there if people continue to ignore the kind of actions Bush has been taking. Claiming it can't happen here is foolish.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom