On the nature and scope of the Truth Movement

R.Mackey

Philosopher
Joined
Apr 21, 2006
Messages
7,854
Abstract

An informal, ad-hoc analysis of threads on the JREF Forum suggests that the self-described "Truth Movement," consisting of those who promote alternative explanations of the September 11th attacks, is neither growing nor demographically significant. The analysis further suggests that the composition of the "Truth Movement" is indistinguishable from that of other widely discredited conspiracy theories, implying that the "Truth Movement" itself is a psychological phenomenon without basis in fact. The author concludes that the "Truth Movement" may be viewed as a homogeneous component of the greater Conspiracy Theory phenomenon, and thus may be expected to remain approximately constant over long periods of time, modeled as a noise component in sociological data.

Introduction

Readers who view the "Conspiracy Theories" wing of the JREF Forum will note the overwhelming preponderance of September 11th threads. Indeed, this discussion area was created specifically in response to those theories. While other conspiracy theories are also suitable topics for discussion here, they make up a tiny minority.

This raises an interesting question: Just how big is the "Truth Movement?" How many people are involved? And who are these people? Those within the Movement have a keen interest in this question, as the size and demography have a direct impact on their financial livelihood as purveyors of goods and services to the Movement. Those outside are often puzzled by this surprisingly vocal segment of the population, and unsure how to react to their spurious and often deeply insulting charges.

Summary of Previous Investigations

Those in the Movement have made several claims about the movement's size, frequently as an argumentum ad populum, and less frequently as a kind of veiled threat. Indeed, this contention is not entirely unsupported by evidence. The typical claim is that "84%" of Americans are either part of or are sympathetic to the Truth Movement, reflecting an oft-quoted survey conducted by Zogby. This survey does indeed suggest that the general opinion of American citizens regarding Sept. 11th is one of distrust and a keen interest in thorough investigation. However, the polling agency is quick to indicate that the sponsors, an organization within the "Truth Movement," are applying their own interpretation to those data.

For those not in the "Truth Movement," the poll is widely held to be an outlier, either misinterpreted by the Movement or inconsistent with other observations. The author notes that the specific results, cited above, may be interpreted in numerous ways, and Question 25 of the Zogby poll may be deliberately misleading in that WTC 7's collapse was investigated -- not by the 9/11 Commission, but by NIST -- prior to the date of the survey, and remains under investigation to this day. More significantly, this poll is the only one commonly cited by the Movement, and their conclusions on its basis are significantly different from that of other, similar polls with different questions or conducted in other countries.

Another similar poll discussed here suggests that perhaps a third of Americans are sympathetic to the Movement, and only 16% have similar beliefs -- a far cry from the 84% number claimed above. And while these numbers may seen significant, they are considerably lower than poll results on belief in UFOs, and therefore may not be particularly surprising.

If the Movement's interpretation of the Zogby poll is correct, to be consistent with these other polls one would have to make the following inferences:

  1. American citizens are dramatically more likely than non-Americans to believe their own government was responsible
  2. A significant proportion of American citizens that blame the United States government also blame Saddam Hussein for conspiring with Al-Qaeda to conduct the attacks
The author views both inferences as suspect. The "Truth Movement" posits that, in the United States, government suppression is preventing American citizens from learning information that damages the 9/11 Commission hypothesis. If this were true, one would expect the Zogby poll results to be comparable to or lower than similar results taken abroad, but this is not the case.

Similarly, other polls show an evolution of opinion over time, notably the Harris poll results demonstrating belief of Iraq's complicity in the attacks declining sharply. A more recent Zogby poll is consistent with these results, but shows 37% of Americans still believe Saddam was involved. If the second inference is correct, all of those changing their minds would now have to support the "Truth Movement," and a significant core of supporters (a minimum of 25%) within the Movement would still also blame Saddam Hussein. There is no evidence to support either of these positions.

Besides the poll information, there is a plethora of evidence suggesting the "Truth Movement" is dramatically smaller than it claims. The largest public demonstration to date was in New York City on the fifth anniversary of Sept. 11th, and attracted an estimated 1,000 people, or less than 0.01% of the average daily population of New York City. More typical demonstrations include the Boston Tea Party and recent Calls To Action, mustering numbers of supporters in the single to low double digits. Attendance at meetings and conferences, such as the upcoming "Accountability" Conference, is comparable to that of UFO conventions (and, I note with amusement, speaker Jim Marrs will appear at both conferences). "Truth Movement" website traffic is easily measurable, bounded, and approximately static.

On this basis, we are prepared to reject the "84%" hypothesis out of hand. However, the question remains -- how large is the Movement? And who are these people?

Method

While it may not be possible to separate the Truth Movement from the large body of people who are distrustful of or angry at the United States Government, we may attempt to characterize the "Truth Movement" on the basis of its activity. Comparison of the "Truth Movement" demography to other off-beat theories, such as beliefs in UFOs, naturally suggests a correlation between the "Truth Movement" and other conspiracies. This theory, namely that the Movement is simply another facet, produced by the same people as all other popular conspiracies, should be tested if at all possible.

In the interest of time, the author has chosen participants in the JREF Forum as a representative sample of the "Truth Movement" activities and population. Posts and posters in the Forum were analyzed as follows:

Thread Density

  1. All threads in the first ten pages of the Conspiracy Theories sub-forum, frozen at 08:00 AM PST on 16 February 2007, were collected and sorted according to content.
  2. Only the initial post of the thread was considered.
  3. Threads were binned regardless of the thread starter's affiliation to the Movement.
  4. Threads with multiple, overlapping conspiracy categories were binned only once, according to the poster's key argument and conclusions.

Poster Affiliation
  1. All posters who initiated threads in the entire 60-page record of the Conspiracy Theories subforum, frozen at 08:00 AM PST on 16 February 2007, were collected.
  2. Posters were pre-sorted to include only those showing signs of sympathy to the "Truth Movement" from the thread title.
  3. Posters were sorted according to two criteria: Whether or not the poster is in fact sympathetic to the "Truth Movement," and whether or not the poster professes a belief in another conspiracy theory.
  4. Posters are considered sympathetic to the "Truth Movement" if an individual post on the JREF Forum could be found where the poster claimed a firm disbelief in the official story of Sept. 11th, without trace of sarcasm or later retraction.
  5. Posters are considered believers in additional conspiracy theories if an individual post or reliable link can be found demonstrating belief in an additional, distinct conspiracy.
  6. Aliases on other message boards are considered acceptable linkages only where well proven by admission of the poster in question.
  7. No posters were rejected on the basis of low post count, familiarity to the author, or other factors, as a means of controlling selection bias.

The author acknowledges that this method is not without the potential for errors, and some subjectivity applies to classifying what constitutes a truly distinct conspiracy belief.

The author retains a list of links specific to each poster considered as documentation for each and every decision. This list will not be published, out of respect for individuals and to avoid the perception of slander or well-poisoning, but this list is available for independent review by neutral parties upon request and mutual non-disclosure agreement.

Results

A total of 300 thread titles were examined as described above. The thread totals by category are as follows:

  • Holocaust Denial: 2
  • D. Cooper Hijacking: 1
  • 7/7 Attacks: 2
  • Anthrax Attacks: 2
  • JFK Assassination: 2
  • Anna Nicole Smith: 1
  • Port Arthur Massacre: 1
  • Santa Claus: 1
  • Aqua Teen Hunger Force: 1
  • Moon Landings: 1
  • Zionist Conspiracy: 1
  • NWO / General Paranoia: 4
  • Sept. 11th: 253

Additionally, a total of 40 posters were classified according to the method described above. These 40 posters were sorted as shown below, employing the shorthand "Truther" to refer to a poster sympathetic to the "Truth Movement."

  • Truthers with Other Conspiracy Beliefs: 27
  • Truthers Without: 8
  • Total Truthers: 35
  • Non-Truthers: 4
  • Hoaxers (indeterminate): 1
  • Total Non-Truthers: 5

As seen above, there were four posters initially thought to be members of the "Truth Movement" that, upon closer inspection, merely expressed doubt or rational questions without stating a belief. A fifth member posed as a whistleblower, but later admitted his posts were a fabrication and claimed complete opposition to the "Truth Movement." These five individuals have been excluded from further study.

Among the 35 posters confirmed as supporters of the "Truth Movement," 27 demonstrated conclusive beliefs in separate conspiracies or enveloping paranoia well beyond the confines of the Movement itself. The other conspiracies are widely varied but nearly all "typical," including those surrounding assassination of popular figures and politicians, the alleged illegality of personal income tax, the "Illuminati" and New World Order, and anti-semitism.

For the remaining eight posters, we are unable to find any definitive evidence of belief in other conspiracy theories. While some of these may also have additional conspiracy leanings, undetected due to low volume of posts, recent arrival, or focus on a particular issue, we must consider these posters a distinct population within our sample.

Discussion

The thread density at the JREF Forum is slanted overwhelmingly towards the Sept. 11th conspiracy theories, totalling over 80% of all threads and outnumbering all other conspiracies combined by over ten to one. While there is likely to be a strong selection bias owing to the combative nature of the "Truth Movement" in general, and adversarial relationship with several Movement sites in particular, it is reasonable to conclude that, at this point in time, the Sept. 11th conspiracies are the most popular of all conspiracy theories.

Of greater interest is the "background noise" of other conspiracy theories. A surprisingly wide range of topics were found, but each with an approximately equal and almost negligible signal. Combined with the observation above, this leads us to make the following hypothesis:

  • The many possible conspiracy beliefs are not uncorrelated or separable.
  • If the conspiracy beliefs were truly separable, one predicts that belief in any given conspiracy would be a strong function of its plausibility and familiarity.
  • Poll evidence does not suggest that Sept. 11th conspiracy theories are any more popular or more plausible than other conspiracy theories.
  • Therefore, we reject that Sept. 11th conspiracies are separable from others, and instead hypothesize that the "Truth Movement" is made up of the same people.
  • The apparent surge in popularity comes at the expense of other conspiracy activities, viz. the total population of conspiracy believers is approximately fixed.

Further evidence for this hypothesis comes from the observation that, of the posters observed, 27 out of 35 or nearly 79% were found to have strong connections to different conspiracies. When taken in conjunction with the poll results mentioned previously, we conclude that belief in any conspiracy theory is a strong determiner of belief in Sept. 11th conspiracies. This conclusion is consistent with all of the available evidence, and further consistent with the fact that, for those outside the Movement, there appears to be no evidentiary basis whatsoever for such beliefs.

While we admit the limitations of the small sample size and its potential for bias, we are struck by the overwhelmingly clear result of even this entirely ad-hoc investigation. We cannot escape the conclusion that the hard core of the "Truth Movement" are little more than traditional conspiracy theorists, colloquially known as "CTs," for whom opinion is shaped not by fact or study so much as fashion and mental disability. Further and more careful analysis is required to more accurately determine the extent of this effect.

The data do, however, indicate a small but visible minority within the Movement that show no clear patterns indicating conspiracy-minded thinking. This study lacks sufficient data and controls to properly estimate its magnitude, or speculate as to its origins. We suggest that this group may indeed base their opinions on logical and factual arguments, and should be addressed in a manner wholly different from common-or-garden "CTs."

Conclusions

A brief survey regarding the popularity of the so-called "Truth Movement," referring to people who believe in fundamentally different explanations of the September 11th attacks, lends no credibility to claims of popularity coming from the Movement itself. Instead, we find that a lower estimate, that perhaps 30% of American citizens harbor such suspicions, and that a smaller fraction of roughly 15% actually share these beliefs, gives good agreement between the various opinion polls and expectations when compared to other fringe beliefs, including those predating September 2001.

The "Truth Movement" itself, consisting of believers who also engage in activism, are seen to comprise a vastly smaller fraction in the United States. While a rigorous estimate of its numbers are beyond the scope of this survey, it gives every indication of being comparable in scale to other, well-seasoned fringe groups. Furthermore, an analysis of individuals confirms a strong correlation between the Truth Movement and enthusiasts of these other conspiracy theories.

These observations are consistent with claims that the "Truth Movement" is not based on fact, but is merely an artifact of human social psychology. While there is evidence for a minority inside the Movement that is new and likely to respond to reason, the majority bears all the hallmarks of an ordinary fringe group, and is thus likely to persist indefinitely regardless of any attempt to educate or understand its members.

As no other fringe group has achieved anything of value or undue concern, we speculate that the "Truth Movement" is no different, but is destined to remain a mere cultural curiosity.

Disclaimer

All opinions stated above are mine alone. I do not represent the JREF or any agency, private, public, or otherwise.

Acknowledgements

The author wishes to express his appreciation for all scientists and investigators addressing the real threats of terrorism, and to those seeking, against all odds, to educate those propagating rumours, lies, and myths about the September 11th attacks. In particular, the author wishes to acknowledge www.911myths.com, http://screwloosechange.blogspot.com/, http://www.pointlesswasteoftime.com/911truth.html, all of those in Team JREF Ninja Wave, and posters MarkyX and Gravy, mere mention of whom is anathema to the "Truth Movement."
 
Last edited:
I am awestruck by that post Mr Mackey.

I wonder what would be the reaction to a post like that over at Loose Change?

Or if someone were to do a similar breakdown of the threads there...
 
1223345ae8908e1bf1.gif

And another one bites the dust...
 
Nominated!

The discussion of opinion polls was great. If Truthers were right in their inflated claims of how many Americans agree with them, then there'd be two polarised factions - one believing still that Saddam caused 9/11, the other believing that the US government caused it, with the actual cause squeezed out (OBL/Al Qaida) completely. The point about flipflopping beliefs - that previous adherents to the Hussein theory would then have to become MIHOPPers and blame Bush - was especially interesting. The numbers don't add up to support the Truther contention at all.

I've done similar exercises on an even more informal basis of analysing posters at Holocaust denial, racist and White Nationalist forums, and found similar general correlations. However, the overlap between active WN forum posters and 9/11 Truthers is much less than the overlap demonstrated here between Truthers and CTists. There are a great many WNs and neo-Nazis who do not also espouse 9/11 Truther conspiracies. That is arguably as embarrassing for the Truthers as the fact that there is also a significant faction who share both sets of views. It means they're dumber than the neo-Nazis.
 
That was very interesting, Mack. Thanks for taking the time and effort.

I agree with ache that a similar study of posters in a CT-sypathetic forum would be a really useful comparison. But LC is rather ruthlessly edited, isn't it?
 
One of the admitted limitations is using the JREF Forum as a population sample... but I couldn't come up with anything better. Selection bias is bad enough without adding asymmetric and vengeful moderation on top of it.

We actually have a better archive of Loose Change Forums over here than they do.
 
Mackey old boy, good to see my tax dollars hard at work.

What is your definition of "Conspiracy Theory"?

Does this definition exclude such conspiracies as the CIA-backed coup in Iran? Iran-contra? The OCT of 9/11? etc.
 
One of the admitted limitations is using the JREF Forum as a population sample... but I couldn't come up with anything better. Selection bias is bad enough without adding asymmetric and vengeful moderation on top of it.

But that just means an analysis of LCF means that one gets pure, undiluted, 100% proof woo. To be sure, there will be a few Loosers who get culled by their own side, but these would be fewer and farther between than the bird-flu firebreak slaughter of interlopers that is practiced at LCF.

On the other hand, I think it likely that the true colours of a Truther will come out under the stress of trying to justify their belief systems outside of a playpen. They have this remarkable habit of assuming that if they raise an 'outside' point on Zionism, Bush, etc, that everyone will fall over to agree with them. Boy, they must be repeatedly disappointed to find that not only does the sane world not share their views on Controlled Demolition, it also tends to regard theories about world domination by the hidden puppetmasters to be totally Dagenham Heathway*, as we used to say in East London.

*Dagenham Heathway = three stops past Barking on the District Line.
 
Mackey old boy, good to see my tax dollars hard at work.

What is your definition of "Conspiracy Theory"?

Does this definition exclude such conspiracies as the CIA-backed coup in Iran? Iran-contra? The OCT of 9/11? etc.

No tax dollars were spent in this effort. All effort was done using my own materials and on my own time.

As indicated in the paper, what constitutes a conspiracy theory is open to some interpretation. However, I will confirm that not a single subject was flagged as believing in other conspiracies on the basis of Iran-Contra or any Iranian Revolution. I am confident that, without exception, the linkages found would be deemed "incredible" or "thoroughly debunked" by an average neutral observer. With only a single exception, every linkage conforms to a common conspiracy myth. That lone exception, while unique, is so vast and incredible in scale that it may safely be counted as a conspiracy theory.
 
Since when has Iran-contra been admitted? I suppose they finally admitted the CIA overthrow of Iran, but clearly spent many decades denying that one, and dismissing it as a "conspiracy theory". Same with the existence of "Stealth Bombers". Same with the FDR foreknowledge of Pearl Harbor. These days, FDR foreknowledge is presented as fact on the History Channel. Eventually so will the 9/11 inside job, after the perps are all dead and gone.

I launched into a similar line of reseach a while back here on JREF. My method was to seperate people into the categories of net tax-payers vs. net tax consumers. I was curious as to whether net tax-consumers were more likely to support government propaganda than net tax-payers. I strongly suspect they are, as people know "where their bread is buttered".

This thread touched so many raw nerves that it eventually led to one attorney member advising me to break laws and not pay taxes. Knowing that attorneys are sworn to a code of conduct, and that this was clearly a violation of that, it touched a raw nerve in me. I said I'd have nothing to do with this forum and went away for a while. Eventually the tremendous value of the various research assistants here overcame the annoyance factor, so I came back.
 
I am confident that, without exception, the linkages found would be deemed "incredible" or "thoroughly debunked" by an average neutral observer.

What is an average neutral observer? Does this mean that in the general population, the majority of them support the opinion? Is that not argument ad populum?
 
What is an average neutral observer? Does this mean that in the general population, the majority of them support the opinion? Is that not argument ad populum?

No more than a general election is argumentum ad populum.

There is no rigorous scientific test for what constitutes a conspiracy theory. Therefore, using popular opinion as a discriminator is not a logical fallacy.
 
Since when has Iran-contra been admitted? I suppose they finally admitted the CIA overthrow of Iran, but clearly spent many decades denying that one, and dismissing it as a "conspiracy theory". Same with the existence of "Stealth Bombers". Same with the FDR foreknowledge of Pearl Harbor. These days, FDR foreknowledge is presented as fact on the History Channel.
Sure it is.

Eventually so will the 9/11 inside job, after the perps are all dead and gone.
Sure it will.

I launched into a similar line of reseach a while back here on JREF. My method was to seperate people into the categories of net tax-payers vs. net tax consumers. I was curious as to whether net tax-consumers were more likely to support government propaganda than net tax-payers. I strongly suspect they are, as people know "where their bread is buttered".

This thread touched so many raw nerves that it eventually led to one attorney member advising me to break laws and not pay taxes. Knowing that attorneys are sworn to a code of conduct, and that this was clearly a violation of that, it touched a raw nerve in me. I said I'd have nothing to do with this forum and went away for a while. Eventually the tremendous value of the various research assistants here overcame the annoyance factor, so I came back.
Bully for you.

Oh, still no proof of your claims, I'll wager? You might one of these years want to attempt to understand why that is.
 
Are you on Al Qaeda's payroll?

Just asking, of course ...

Of course he is. No one would post this much about 9/11 for free, would they? At least, that's the conclusion we must arrive at if the twoofer's are correct.

Should we start calling him Al Shillda?
 
I said I'd have nothing to do with this forum and went away for a while. Eventually the tremendous value of the various research assistants here overcame the annoyance factor, so I came back.

So that's your excuse for being a dishonourable liar? R.Mackey is just too valuable?

Thanks a lot, Mackey! Now look what you've gone and done!




:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom