GoSylviaBrowne

I was reading the guestbook, and it's your garden-variety 'sheeple' flocking to defend their spiritual teacher.

A couple of recent comments I found amusing, along with the entire web site:

This was the only unfavorable comment yet to be deleted and was from a more skeptical mindset:

$ylvia had me pegged as dead, but i was alive all along.
Then came the retort one has come to expect from her devout believers:

gOD bLESS sYLVIA bROWNE!!!1 iF IT WASNT FRO HER DIRECT INVOLVMENT sHAWN hORNBEK WOULD BE MISSING STILL OR EVEN DEAD!1!! SCEPTICS SAY NO PSYCHIC HAS EVR HELPING INVESTIGATERS BUT THIS IS PROVE THAT THEY ARE WRONG AGAIN!1! gOD bLESS sYLVIA bROWNE!!1!
 
The webmaster seems to be deleting anything too long to read also. There were a few posts that were a few paragraphs long that did nothing but praise Browne and they were erased also...
 
I was reading the guestbook, and it's your garden-variety 'sheeple' flocking to defend their spiritual teacher.

A couple of recent comments I found amusing, along with the entire web site:

This was the only unfavorable comment yet to be deleted and was from a more skeptical mindset:

Then came the retort one has come to expect from her devout believers:

Why is it that the "believers" all have bad grammar and typing skills? :confused:
 
My first reaction was to go post there as a bleever in a manner similar to what was there already, but that was obviously sarcastic. Then my rationality got the better of me. You see...

Sylvia WANTS skeptics to post there! It's a little trap! It's there so she can gather all the "evidence" she needs to say that "skeptics just want to badmouth me!". It's just baiting us, trying to encourage responses. You just need to realise that Sylvia reads THIS forum too, so she knows exactly what is going on.

And so I decided that I would leave it all well alone. No touchy. Not even browse to it.

And so should ALL of us!
 
Most of the things posted on that guest book were simply satirical pithy comments, Not "trolling".
Perhaps I use a broader definition of "trolling" than you do, Dustin.

From the Wikipedia article:

"A troll is a person who approaches a board with the specific intention of stirring things up, either with no particular motive or provocation in mind, other than to be purely destructive or if the motive or provocation is against the ethos of the board. For example, a neo-nazi approaching a Jewish forum with the intention of attacking the members, purely because the neo-nazi knows the forum to contain Jewish members, may be considered a troll."
Based on this definition, skeptics going over to a Sylvia Browne fan forum/guestbook to post "satirical pithy comments" would be trolls.

All of the posts posted on the forum that show any sign of criticism of Browne are instantly deleted. The site is totally locked down from any skepticism and is completely censored. I don't know how you could be defending such a site.
I didn't defend the site. I criticized skeptical trolling of it. But I will defend their right to have the site focused however they choose it to be. Is it brave of them to squelch dissenting voices? No. But it is their right. It is their sandbox.

Nonetheless linking it on your site. Bad idea.
I link to Browne's own web site, the Novus Spiritus (her "church") web site, and the web sites of her publishers. I am not afraid of anyone reading those sites. I put out my point of view on the subject. I show the facts as I see them. If someone wants to read other opinions before making up their minds, they are welcome to do so. I would encourage them to do so.

To pretend those sites don't exist, to act like there is no other point of view, is as much head-in-the-sand behavior as their deleting posts that they don't agree with.

In Mr. Randi's commentaries, he frequently links to sites with opposing viewpoints, such as the site promoting the Sniffex. Do you think this is a bad move on his part? I don't. As skeptics, we can't try to hide what the other side says. We criticize them for doing that very thing. We shouldn't be doing it ourselves.
 
I think we all know that gosylviabrowne is [poorly] designed to perpetuate her lies, and I would not be surprised to find it trying to discredit RSL directly at some point in the not-too-distant future; you don't need to be psychic to foresee that.

I disagree with the negativity expressed in regard to adding this site on stopsylviabrowne.com. I think it's worthwhile, and will continue to allow people to see yet more evidence of how utterly delusional, not only The Spiritual One is, but equally, her followers.

Dustin said:
Why is it that the "believers" all have bad grammar and typing skills?

That was rhetorical I'm sure. ;)
 
Last edited:
I'm with RSL on this.

Trolling might make us feel good by poking fun at their foolishness, but it really contributes nothing productive. People who might feel some sympathy to Brown on account of misinformation would not necessarily be persuaded to sympathise with our mudslinging.

Logic, science and reason are the best tools we have. Descending to a level of petty insults and mockery don't compare.

Athon
 
I'm with RSL on this......Logic, science and reason are the best tools we have. Descending to a level of petty insults and mockery don't compare.
I agree. Best to take the High Road.

But, I gotta admit this guestbook entry gave me a chuckle:
Thank you and God Bless, or as my romanian parents would say "Daurf a si aivlyS."
:D
 
I agree with RSL on this too.
I think a better tactic might be to comment constructively on any 'proofs' that are posted. Perhaps ask reasonable questions that will gently guide readers to realise that not everything is as magical as it may seem.

Flooding the site in the way you have been merely racks up its hit rates, confirms the opinion of many believers that skeptics are all rude, aggressive and abusive, and achieves nothing at all if the comments are being continually removed anyway.
 
I agree with RSL on this too.
I think a better tactic might be to comment constructively on any 'proofs' that are posted. Perhaps ask reasonable questions that will gently guide readers to realise that not everything is as magical as it may seem.

Flooding the site in the way you have been merely racks up its hit rates, confirms the opinion of many believers that skeptics are all rude, aggressive and abusive, and achieves nothing at all if the comments are being continually removed anyway.

The site's author has indicated that anything remotely negative (and I think here negative is defined as anything not gushing over Sylvia) will be removed immediately.
 
I'd rather see the Go site get as little traffic as possible.

BTW, you can get a 505 error for LOTs of reasons--including too much traffic on a server-side script.
 
Come on guys, let's not blow this out of proportions. We were having some good old internet fun for half an hour yesterday. A new website on a questionable topic with a public guestbook always has and always will attract a fair amount of trolling and sillyness. No matter if skeptics, psychics, gamers, trolls or university graduates are involved. The unwanted comments get deleted, and that's it.
 
This could just be another way of collecting what she likes to call 'affidavits' - testimonials about her awesomeness to use as 'evidence' of the good she does should the time come (for example, in a court case...).

However, I must say I am amazed there wasn't already a fan site or several, given her alleged popularity. I am trying to work out why and I'm wondering if it's because she trades almost entirely on new customers rather than repeat business? If she had a huge and dedicated, loyal fan base, why weren't there fan sites before?

Anyway, as far as the the creation of this new site goes, it's exactly what I would have done myself in her shoes, it's a smart move. If you can demonstrate that there are large numbers of people dissatisfied with Sylvia's actions, the sensible thing for Sylvia to do is demonstrate the reverse in the same format.
 
Thank you for this! I hope I'll be back to blogging this weekend. This is a Dim Bulb Award for sure.

I signed the Guestbook as "slezabelle. " I'm all for taking the highroad and all, but I'm too undisciplined and nettlesome to let this go by without a poke. :D


Ha ha!
I signed right after you as sylvisisgr8!!!
 
I signed the guestbook using this name. I wrote out a serious message, in the hopes that some of her more open-minded fans actually read it. Let's see how long before the admins kill it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom