rjh01
Gentleman of leisure
None of the guest book entries appear to mention her psychic ability.
Then came the retort one has come to expect from her devout believers:$ylvia had me pegged as dead, but i was alive all along.
gOD bLESS sYLVIA bROWNE!!!1 iF IT WASNT FRO HER DIRECT INVOLVMENT sHAWN hORNBEK WOULD BE MISSING STILL OR EVEN DEAD!1!! SCEPTICS SAY NO PSYCHIC HAS EVR HELPING INVESTIGATERS BUT THIS IS PROVE THAT THEY ARE WRONG AGAIN!1! gOD bLESS sYLVIA bROWNE!!1!
I was reading the guestbook, and it's your garden-variety 'sheeple' flocking to defend their spiritual teacher.
A couple of recent comments I found amusing, along with the entire web site:
This was the only unfavorable comment yet to be deleted and was from a more skeptical mindset:
Then came the retort one has come to expect from her devout believers:
Perhaps I use a broader definition of "trolling" than you do, Dustin.Most of the things posted on that guest book were simply satirical pithy comments, Not "trolling".
Based on this definition, skeptics going over to a Sylvia Browne fan forum/guestbook to post "satirical pithy comments" would be trolls."A troll is a person who approaches a board with the specific intention of stirring things up, either with no particular motive or provocation in mind, other than to be purely destructive or if the motive or provocation is against the ethos of the board. For example, a neo-nazi approaching a Jewish forum with the intention of attacking the members, purely because the neo-nazi knows the forum to contain Jewish members, may be considered a troll."
I didn't defend the site. I criticized skeptical trolling of it. But I will defend their right to have the site focused however they choose it to be. Is it brave of them to squelch dissenting voices? No. But it is their right. It is their sandbox.All of the posts posted on the forum that show any sign of criticism of Browne are instantly deleted. The site is totally locked down from any skepticism and is completely censored. I don't know how you could be defending such a site.
I link to Browne's own web site, the Novus Spiritus (her "church") web site, and the web sites of her publishers. I am not afraid of anyone reading those sites. I put out my point of view on the subject. I show the facts as I see them. If someone wants to read other opinions before making up their minds, they are welcome to do so. I would encourage them to do so.Nonetheless linking it on your site. Bad idea.
Dustin said:Why is it that the "believers" all have bad grammar and typing skills?
I agree. Best to take the High Road.I'm with RSL on this......Logic, science and reason are the best tools we have. Descending to a level of petty insults and mockery don't compare.
Thank you and God Bless, or as my romanian parents would say "Daurf a si aivlyS."
I agree with RSL on this too.
I think a better tactic might be to comment constructively on any 'proofs' that are posted. Perhaps ask reasonable questions that will gently guide readers to realise that not everything is as magical as it may seem.
Flooding the site in the way you have been merely racks up its hit rates, confirms the opinion of many believers that skeptics are all rude, aggressive and abusive, and achieves nothing at all if the comments are being continually removed anyway.
Well, what's with the skeptics wanting to go pee in their pool?
The site is set up to sing Browne's praises, not debate the topic.
http://www.gosylviabrowne.com/
Has anyone seen this? Sylvia has a link to this site on her main page now.
Thank you for this! I hope I'll be back to blogging this weekend. This is a Dim Bulb Award for sure.
I signed the Guestbook as "slezabelle. " I'm all for taking the highroad and all, but I'm too undisciplined and nettlesome to let this go by without a poke.![]()