Has anyone ever heard of a thing called COINTELPRO?

No, again you miss it's simplicity - what you do is act under the assumption that anyone who is embarrassing, disruptive, argumentative, unpredictable, etc is just that - disruptive.

Who cares what their speciality is? It's reason enough - you don't need them. This is normal in any organisation, it puts its house in order. Of course this does not protect against future attempts to disrupt, but each can be dealt with once it is recognised.

But in order to identify someone as disruptive and argumentative, you need seem agreement as to what they're disrupting and arguing against. That's why you need a coherant theory as to what actually happened, for which you need (wait for it) evidence.

That's why there's no need for COINTELPRO. There was never an agreement as to what happened in the first place. No intellegence there to counter.
 
But in order to identify someone as disruptive and argumentative, you need seem agreement as to what they're disrupting and arguing against. That's why you need a coherant theory as to what actually happened, for which you need (wait for it) evidence.

That's why there's no need for COINTELPRO. There was never an agreement as to what happened in the first place. No intellegence there to counter.

Is it your contention that the US Govt is not infiltrating dissident groups?
Because this has already been demonstrated to be the case, with two specific recent examples. It's a no-brainer.
 
I think I cracked the code.

I think I've finally realised what Scooby's trying to do with this rambling, drip-fed, innuendo-laden and relevance-free post. It's not an accusation - it's a confession.

Just look at the evidence. A COINTELPRO agent, spreading lies and false rumors about the movement he claims to be a member of, is stricken by guilt and remorse. He can't admit to his peers that he's a traitor to their cause, but he needs to talk to someone. He can't make an outright, open confession, because the mysterious "disappearance" is sure to follow. All he can safely do is find a place where others like himself are sure to be listening, then drop hints, ever so delicately, revealing clues to what he really is - a COINTELPRO agent trying to disrupt the movement by spreading rumours of COINTELPRO agents within the movement. Look back on the thread - how can you not see the evidence?

Don't worry, Scooby. Your secret is safe with us.

Dave
 
Is it your contention that the US Govt is not infiltrating dissident groups?
Because this has already been demonstrated to be the case, with two specific recent examples. It's a no-brainer.

No, my contention is that infiltrating groups is not necessarily the same as COINTELPRO (not that I'm saying groups have been infiltrated either), and that since the 9/11 movement has never had a coherhant stance on what happened anywhere, there's nothing for a COINTELPRO action to do anyway.
 
No, my contention is that infiltrating groups is not necessarily the same as COINTELPRO (not that I'm saying groups have been infiltrated either), and that since the 9/11 movement has never had a coherhant stance on what happened anywhere, there's nothing for a COINTELPRO action to do anyway.

OK, so we have established that the US Govt is infiltrating dissident groups and that this is a known COINTELPRO method, and it seems you agree, albeit back handedly.

I agree with you that infiltrating groups is not necessarily the same as COINTELPRO. COINTELPRO was much more than that - infiltrating groups was only part of it.

As for your perception that there is no coherent stance within the 911 Truth movement, this is only true of a cursory glance. It is also, interestingly enough, one of the desired effects of any COINTELPRO operation used against a group, so it is interesting that you have this misconception.
 
As for your perception that there is no coherent stance within the 911 Truth movement, this is only true of a cursory glance. It is also, interestingly enough, one of the desired effects of any COINTELPRO operation used against a group, so it is interesting that you have this misconception.

So, trying to read between the lines of your post, is your position that there is a coherant 9/11 CT position and that this is being intentionally obfuscated by government agents?

If so, could you clarify what this coherant position is?
 
Scooby said:
As for your perception that there is no coherent stance within the 911 Truth movement, this is only true of a cursory glance. It is also, interestingly enough, one of the desired effects of any COINTELPRO operation used against a group, so it is interesting that you have this misconception.

So, by cursory you think everyone here has blatantly skimmed over 9/11 twoof, and in doing so carelessly missed the important details within?

The twoof movement reads like a tabloid newspaper, and that deserves little to no time when reading or credibility; however, making the assertion that we're all lacking details is yet another played out reach.

The only truth in the truth movement is this: it has no cohesion within it's ranks and all their claims fall, not virtually, but at freefall speed right down the chitter.

*Throws you a Scooby Snack layered with clarity.

Chew it over extremely carefully, and then say "COINTELPRO and 9/11 Twoof movement" in your head a few times; maybe you'll finally connect: no coherhant stance on 9/11 and waste of time and resources.
 
Last edited:
I think I've finally realised what Scooby's trying to do with this rambling, drip-fed, innuendo-laden and relevance-free post. It's not an accusation - it's a confession.

Just look at the evidence. A COINTELPRO agent, spreading lies and false rumors about the movement he claims to be a member of, is stricken by guilt and remorse. He can't admit to his peers that he's a traitor to their cause, but he needs to talk to someone. He can't make an outright, open confession, because the mysterious "disappearance" is sure to follow. All he can safely do is find a place where others like himself are sure to be listening, then drop hints, ever so delicately, revealing clues to what he really is - a COINTELPRO agent trying to disrupt the movement by spreading rumours of COINTELPRO agents within the movement. Look back on the thread - how can you not see the evidence?

Don't worry, Scooby. Your secret is safe with us.

Dave
Or perhaps he's a COCOINTELPRO agent, trying to disrupt our COINTELPRO organization, distracting us just long enough for the Truthiness Movement to get reorganized and back on track. Little does he know, our COINTELPRO organization also employs COCOCOINTELPRO agents, so his efforts are being wasted.
 
Well, now I've set the scene, I can lay out the big picture.

See we have a situation where it is safe to assume that attempts to disrupt dissident groups are in progress, and have been for some time, using methods similar to COINTELPRO in the 60's and 70's. If anti-war and peace groups are being infiltrated, then it would be no stretch of the imagination to assume that other groups are also being infiltrated, including the '911 Truth' movement. Indeed Dr Pepper warns specifically about this in his recent speech. Certainly this is the conclusion of many people within the ‘movement’, and ultimately it's up to them - it is after all, their movement. You want to be skeptical - get your own.

Which brings us back to Scholars for 911 Truth, who it seems have suffered just such an attempt to disrupt and discredit their group last year. This is a long story but merits detailed attention. It provides a useful case study, regardless of it’s origins. The end result is now two websites, and what appear to be two groups or 'Factions' of Scholars - "Scholars for 911 Truth" http://911scholars.org/ and the new "Scholars for 911 Truth & Justice". www.stj911.org

The dispute started between co-founders Jim Fetzer and Steve Jones and was initially over unscientific content being posted to the website under the banner of science. This was not the original intention of the organisation but it seems that none of the members, some 300 by now, had any control over the content of the site which was being solely administered by Jim Fetzer. This certainly got out of hand and became counter-productive, causing division within the group and the public posting of grievances on the website's main page by Fetzer, most of which is still there and provide strange reading ...

Faction Freezes Society's Web Site: Scholars for 9/11 Truth Threatened
All,
The situation with Scholars has taken an ominous turn, where we have been frozen out of the Scholars web site and posting and updating has been made impossible, which can only have been done by Fred Burks, who has possession of the domain names, or Alex Floum, who may still control the password. It looks like a nice example of the lack of scruples to which I drew attention in my most recent message to the membership. I find this quite distressing... http://911scholars.org/SiteThreatened.html

More in sorrow than in anger . . .
"Con men are successful because they are so smooth that their sounds are often mistaken for sincere speech. That is surely the case with Fred Burks. Here he promotes the continuation of the abuse of the society's email list with a specious pitch for "voting" in order to replicate an illegal, null and void effort of the recent past. Apparently, the results were not what they wanted, so they are going to do it all over again. As they know, Scholars has members but is not run by its members...." http://911scholars.org/SorrowAnger.html

The end result was a split, with a large majority of members voting to create a new distinct group and distance themselves from both Jim Fetzer, and the theories that he allowed to be promoted on the website - namely that the World Trade Center was destroyed by a space beam-weapon, and that no planes were used at all on the day - everything was done using Holograms. Some people have elected to remain members of both 'factions'.

The end result is a choice presented at www.st911.org, where links are found to each factions website - one based on scientific research, the other purporting to be based on scientific research but now containing information about holograms and 'space beam-weapons'.

It's all very odd, accusations have been flying around about people being disinfo artists, utter nonsense is being peddled as science by one group and defended with vigour. There has been for some time speculation here and there as to whether or not Jim Fetzer could deliberately be trying to cause this disruption by supporting these theories. They certainly were bogus theories. And he certainly was insistent about supporting them. He did indeed create this 'dirty laundry' and then proceed to wash it all in public, all very counter-productive.

I've got to be honest I was skeptical about all this, maybe the guy is just a stubborn idiot or something, people were talking about pride being involved. Perhaps he doesn't realise the damage he is doing. But then there was this interview with Steve Jones on Fetzer's show back in January I came across - which I present in response to the hypothetical question ... "Is it possible that Jim Fetzer could be deliberately trying to discredit and disrupt the work of Prof Steve Jones? ... Could he?"

http://www.911podcasts.com/files/audio/JimFetzer-StevenJones_20070117.mp3

I don't think Jones gets to say a word until over 20 minutes into the show, and you get the impression he’s been there a while, and it goes rapidly downhill from there. Fetzer's approach seems to be to ask a question, interrupt early, and then talk over Steve Jones for as long as possible. Zero content if you listen carefully - a 'show about nothing'. They then lose Steve Jones, Fetzer talks, mentions the carpet in his basement at one point, talks about the ’explanandum’ and the ’totality of the collapse’, Jones returns to no avail, high comedy parts of it - Fetzer compares the surgical precision of the hole in Building 6 with the removal of his kidney as evidence that explosives might not be the only cause – ”not all hole’s are caused by explosions – take for example my kidney operation …” Shocking. Fetzer continues to repeat baseless assertions for most of the interview, Jones struggles valiantly to inject content. The whole thing degenerates towards the end of the 2 hours, with Fetzer turning the volume down several times on a bloodied and broken Prof Jones. I don’t think I’ve ever heard a guest treated so badly in a supposedly ‘friendly’ interview about such a serious topic.

Prof Jones does however get to make a key point – that the need for further research is over, as they now have enough evidence to establish that a crime has been committed and a new investigation can be demanded, a coherent position of late within an emerging core of the 911 Truth community, firmly backed by Prof Jones’ work and that of others. He highlights this fact in a recent paper on the Justice website which raises a pertinent and timely question …

What is the Goal in the 9/11 Truth Community? Debates, or Justice?
http://www.stj911.org/jones/focus_on_goal.html

This is further evidenced by the recent 911 Accountability conference in Arizona, much of which is archived here … http://www.citizensadvocate.net/ where this paradigm shift was well represented. There has also been the recent vote on a new investigation in Vermont, indicating the more direct nature of the activities occurring lately.

As for Fetzer, to be honest I was still skeptical about all this, but I had a look at some of Judy Woods work on her site and wasn’t impressed. There was a song lurking there somewhere that stank to high heaven, yup, it’s still there …

JWood.jpg


Judy Would
a 9/11 truth song by ace baker.


What if you knew about a complicated crime?
One that was beyond the reach of ordinary minds?
Would you stand up defending all that's right and good?
Well Judy, Judy, Judy, Judy would

What if the criminals could threaten your career?
Would you disregard the easy road, and climb up through the fear?
Would you call out from the mountain even if you could?
Well Judy, Judy, Judy, Judy would

How is a tower like a tree?
What does this mean to you and me?
Can we solve this mystery?
Can we find the energy?
Can we get our mind around disintegrating walls . . .
. . . with billiard balls?

What if your television tortured every truth?
What if your story got all twisted and abused?
Would you simplify the picture when the world misunderstood?
Well Judy, Judy, Judy, Judy would

(How is a tower like a tree?)
Judy, Judy, Judy, Judy would
(Where was the hidden energy?)
La la la la la la la la la la la la
(Can we solve this mystery?)

Judy Wood


http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/JudyWood/JudyWould.html

I mean Jesus wept it hardly knocks the pants off you does it? It’s not exactly Eminem’s “White America”.

So then DC911 Truth managed to pin down Judy Wood and Dr Greg Jenkins got to ask her a few questions about the origins of her space beam-weapon theory. It’s an informative interview, judge for yourselves …

“Dr. Judy Wood is the lone 'scientific' pillar behind the theory that directed energy beams demolished the world trade center towers. Dr. Greg Jenkins, a physicist, poses a few simple questions to Dr. Wood regarding her research. The full interview was left uncut to allow the viewer to fully and accurately assess the credibility of Dr. Judy Wood and her work.” http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-558096240694803017

This is the origin of the space beam-weapon theory, and it’s fullest explanation to date. The whole thing is discussed in great detail in the following Visibility 911 radio shows, they seem to have an excellent handle on the situation …

"This broadcast features an interview with New York 9-11 activist and documentary film maker John Albanese, producer of Everybody's Gotta Learn Sometime and the soon to be released Disinformation in the Information Age, due out February 19, 2007. Topics include disinformation, the unconstitutionality of COINTELPRO activities by the government, and specific individuals, who by their own actions and deeds, make them suspect of dubious intent. You can also check out John's website by clicking here, where you can also find contact information to get in touch with John."
http://media.libsyn.com/media/visibility911/visibility911_albanese.mp3

"This broadcast welcomes back to the program, Jim Hoffman. Jim has co-authored a book Waking Up From Our Nightmare; The 9/11/01 Crimes In New York City and co-produced the video 9/11 Guilt; The Proof Is In Your Hands with Don Paul, and runs the websites wtc7.net and 911research.com. Jim has written extensively on the topic of dis-information within the 9-11 truth movement. His articles include:

The Pentagon No-757-Crash Theory: Booby Trap for 9/11 Skeptics
The Pentagon Crash: What the Physical Evidence Shows
Sifting Through Loose Change
ScholarsFor911Truth: Muddling the Evidence"
http://media.libsyn.com/media/visibility911/visibility911_hoffman.mp3

Some interesting points are made, in particular, although there may be reasons for Judy Wood believing in her work, what does seem strange and is hard to explain, is why other people do. These include Fetzer and Morgan Reynolds among others. But it seems that two distinct factions have emerged, one small group promoting endless debate and Holograms who’s credibility rests on Judy Wood, and the other calling for a new investigation based on the work of David Ray Griffin and Steve Jones. It seems all the no-plane and hologram websites are linked to this small faction also. There’s some interesting talk of enough evidence for a civil liberties case to be made. But I think the main thing is that there is an awareness of the problem, knowledge of its methods, and, as Scholars for 911 Truth and Justice have demonstrated – ways that it can be dealt with. And this film coming out looks well worth a watch … “Disinformation in the Information Age”.

Of course I’d say people should give it all a once over and make their own minds up, I think it’s an interesting facet to watch, the emerging coherent position is to just let them speak and discredit themselves whatever their motives. I think it’s working well. I’d certainly recommend keeping tabs on the situation as there is sure to be more controversy to come.
 
Well, scooby it's an epic post which I'm sure you put alot of effort in, but ultimately the bickering between 'truthers' is your problem not ours.

Maybe you should post this over on LCF. They might care.
 
And so the great revelation arrives, not with a bang, but with a whimper.

The thing is, Scooby, that everyone here knows all this, as it's all been reported on the Screw Loose Change blog, and everyone here knows that accusations of COINTELPRO are flying around the truth movement, and every skeptic here takes the much simpler explanation that:
(a) All the arguments of the truth movement are unfounded, so when they start attacking each other they're well provided with ammunition, and,
(b) people with oversized egos have hissy fits with each other.

But if you truly want to believe that the disintegration of the truth movement through factional squabbles is proof of its success, then I doubt whether any rational argument will succeed in disabusing you of that notion.

Dave
 
Of course I’d say people should give it all a once over and make their own minds up, I think it’s an interesting facet to watch, the emerging coherent position is to just let them speak and discredit themselves whatever their motives. I think it’s working well.
In that regard, you and I are very much on the same page.
I’d certainly recommend keeping tabs on the situation as there is sure to be more controversy to come.
The thing you don't seem to get, though, is that it's only interesting to those of you who are immersed in Truthy culture, and somewhat less so to those of us who, for one reason or another, are fascinated by Truthy culture. No one else even knows who Fetzer and Jones are, much less that they're feuding. They simply don't care. And if they have heard of them, they think of them as that kooky thermite guy and that batshyte insane beam weapon guy.
 
I, too, am very interested in the consensus that COINTELPRO has caused the "Truth" Movement to fail to reach. Surely such a consensus would include either definitive answers, or a clear consensus of "we don't know," on each of these questions:

1. What damaged the Pentagon on September 11th?

2. What caused three World Trade Center buildings to collapse on September 11th?

3. Apart from anyone actively involved in planning the attacks, who in the U.S. Government, military, and law enforcement services had advance warning of the attacks?

4. Who planned the operation?

5. What was the intended purpose of the operation?

6. What happened to the airline passengers?

Care to lay it out for me, Scooby?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Well, scooby it's an epic post which I'm sure you put alot of effort in, but ultimately the bickering between 'truthers' is your problem not ours.

Maybe you should post this over on LCF. They might care.

Still not skeptical eh?
 
And so the great revelation arrives, not with a bang, but with a whimper.

The thing is, Scooby, that everyone here knows all this, as it's all been reported on the Screw Loose Change blog, and everyone here knows that accusations of COINTELPRO are flying around the truth movement, and every skeptic here takes the much simpler explanation that:
(a) All the arguments of the truth movement are unfounded, so when they start attacking each other they're well provided with ammunition, and,
(b) people with oversized egos have hissy fits with each other.

But if you truly want to believe that the disintegration of the truth movement through factional squabbles is proof of its success, then I doubt whether any rational argument will succeed in disabusing you of that notion.

Dave

Here we go again, borrowing onus and claiming to speak for everyone. None of the questions raised by the 911 truth community have been adequately dealt with by the 911 Commission or the NIST Report or any official explanation. And nobody has been held accountable for the at least criminal negligence of the day. This is what is being pursued by the 911 Accountability group, as a method of enabling a new investigation. No fancy claims are being made. I don't frequent the Loose Change forums, so I can't comment on what has been said there.
 
Third Request

Again, scooby, if you're claiming the "COINTELPRO" is obscuring legitimate arguments with fake ones, then please, help us all, and take this opportunity to restate the real ones.

Why won't you do this? Don't you realize this will thwart the "COINTELPRO" agents?

Scooby Doo, where are you??

Still waiting, scooby.

You just now claimed there were all kinds of important questions that hadn't been "adequately dealt with." I'm still waiting for even a single valid question.

Let's hear your best.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom