Horatius
NWO Kitty Wrangler
- Joined
- May 9, 2006
- Messages
- 29,691
I’ve excerpted a few comments from this thread to introduce a new meta-topic. Take a look, and then meet me down the page.
This raises a question we’ve dealt with here before, but never explicitly. That is, how can we determine, solely on the basis of their postings, how competent a particular poster is in the area of expertise they claim? We have a list of peoples’ alleged areas of expertise, but how do we know they are for real?
There was another thread on “Looking for Truth in Credentials”, which quickly devolved into the usual back-and-forth on science and evidence. I’m hoping this thread will avoid that, and address a more fundamental issue, not necessarily applied to 9/11 or CTs, although my examples will almost all be from this forum.
As a start, I’ll mention two complementary aspects of a person’s knowledge, which leads me to accept them as being an expert (or at least, well educated) on the topics they discuss: Broad knowledge, and detailed knowledge. That is, knowing a lot about varied aspects of the topic, while also being able to go into detail on a specific aspect. Compare the discussions of Truthseeker1234 and R.Mackey. A typical TS1234 post:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2423529#post2423529
Compared to R.Mackey:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2430207#post2430207
TS1234 posts a lot of vague generalities; misusing terms, and supports his whole thesis with a video and a photo. R.Mackey provided a fairly comprehensive run-down of all the relevant topics, cites his sources, and uses terms precisely. Just on this basis alone, it’s clear to me that R.Mackey is simply more knowledgeable on the subject, and if you trust his honesty, you can trust his conclusions. No so much for TS1234, though.
There are other examples of this, which I’ll likely post later, but I thought I’d see what others think of this question. What is it about a poster that leads you to accept the legitimacy of their expertise?
I like how CTers demand a professional analysis... and yet when I (a professional) offer my analysis, they dismiss it out of hand.
The engineers at Skywalker Sound could produce a 500 page analysis that demonstrates it is false and the CTers would still dismiss it.
-Gumboot
Because you're about as skeptical as a baby with a tit in its mouth.
Cut the crap.
Hit a nerve did I Scooby? Perhaps you'd like to present your expert analysis of the video? That is, assuming you actually have any expertise.
-Gumboot
You have not presented any expert analysis. You aren't even an expert in the faking of videos.
You don't even know who I am...
-Gumboot
Exactly my point.
So you want an expert in faking videos? As in an expert in making a video that is not say like a news cameraman or editor but say something like a hollywood cameraman?
The information I am presenting is not reliant on my identity. Regardless of if I am a forensic sound analyst for the NSA (I'm not) or a corn farmer (I'm not) the features described in this video continue to be in this video. I am merely identifying them.
Albert Einstein himself could claim that 9/11 was an inside job, and the evidence would still prove him wrong.
-Gumboot
This raises a question we’ve dealt with here before, but never explicitly. That is, how can we determine, solely on the basis of their postings, how competent a particular poster is in the area of expertise they claim? We have a list of peoples’ alleged areas of expertise, but how do we know they are for real?
There was another thread on “Looking for Truth in Credentials”, which quickly devolved into the usual back-and-forth on science and evidence. I’m hoping this thread will avoid that, and address a more fundamental issue, not necessarily applied to 9/11 or CTs, although my examples will almost all be from this forum.
As a start, I’ll mention two complementary aspects of a person’s knowledge, which leads me to accept them as being an expert (or at least, well educated) on the topics they discuss: Broad knowledge, and detailed knowledge. That is, knowing a lot about varied aspects of the topic, while also being able to go into detail on a specific aspect. Compare the discussions of Truthseeker1234 and R.Mackey. A typical TS1234 post:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2423529#post2423529
Compared to R.Mackey:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2430207#post2430207
TS1234 posts a lot of vague generalities; misusing terms, and supports his whole thesis with a video and a photo. R.Mackey provided a fairly comprehensive run-down of all the relevant topics, cites his sources, and uses terms precisely. Just on this basis alone, it’s clear to me that R.Mackey is simply more knowledgeable on the subject, and if you trust his honesty, you can trust his conclusions. No so much for TS1234, though.
There are other examples of this, which I’ll likely post later, but I thought I’d see what others think of this question. What is it about a poster that leads you to accept the legitimacy of their expertise?