Evil Genius?
This is my first post here at JREF. Initially I was under the impression that the posters here were the same as posters over at SLC – nothing but ad hominems with little substantive analysis. While ad hominems are likely a fact of life here too, I was intrigued enough by this post to write a rebuttal.
To get a couple of matters out of the way at the outset: Yes, I believe 9/11 was likely an inside job perpetrated by criminal elements of the U.S. government. No, I will not marshal any evidence to support my belief, so don’t ask (or waste your breath asking, I don’t care). Most of you seem like capable people that can go look at the evidence and decide for yourselves. If you have looked and still don't believe what I believe, that’s fine with me. I’m not going to go out of my way here to try and convince you. What I will do is try and point out flaws in the reasoning and analysis of some official story defenders without attacking the posters themselves. Ad hominems are wholly unproductive in any setting.
The Problem of Genius
The natural consequence of this is for the Truth Movement to vastly underestimate the capacity of Evil Genius.
In this well-written post, you have probably overestimated the capacity of Evil Genius. The first mistake is your use of the moniker “Genius” to describe the planner(s) of 9/11. While many people may assume that those who rise to power in this country are the best and brightest we have to offer, this simply is not the case. In reality, most people that come to power in this country get there because they have one or a combination of the following attributes: (1) born into or otherwise gain access to a large amount of money, (2) born into a family that has political connections, (3) adept at making and maintaining political connections, (4) reasonably good at public speaking [As an aside, the obvious exception would be our current leader. However, although he may not be what is thought of traditionally as a good public speaker, he generally comes across in most of his public speeches as likeable, ie. the kind of guy you would want to go have a beer with.], (5) appear reasonably likeable on the surface, (6) have a natural gift for leadership, (7) born into or otherwise gain access to a large amount of money. Yes, I know I listed money, twice, but money runs politics in this country.
Notice that nowhere is super-intelligence listed there (again, look at our current leader). Of course they need some modicum of intelligence in order to succeed politically. However, it hardly takes a “genius” to rise to positions of power in the U.S., and, I would argue, the most important considerations are money and political connections. In fact, judging your intelligence from this post alone, I would say you are probably more intelligent than many, if not most, of the people that run this country. Thus, I think you may have given too much credit to the Evil Genius which is the topic of this post.
You also failed to pay homage to the fact that Evil Genius is a real person, who conspired with real people, and people make mistakes. Some of the problems you have highlighted, even if the plan was perfect on paper, could be explained as mistakes being made by the person/people tasked with a particular aspect of the plan.
Assuming an Evil Genius would willingly entertain complexity and risk, with no direct path to financial gains, is folly.
Actually, the perpetrators would very likely have realized direct financial gains, to wit: Larry Silverstein’s collection of several billion dollars of insurance money on a very short term investment; the post-9/11 wars and related defense spending generating billions of dollars to defense contractors. Also, people who seek positions of power are not only money hungry – they are also power hungry. If 9/11 was an inside job, it gave those in power exactly what they covet – more power over the people.
 |
As an aside, consider the wealth of Evil Geniuses presented in the James Bond 007 movie franchise.* The genre is replete with improbable megalomaniacs, each with a plan more intricate than the last -- so intricate, in fact, that it winds up leaving critical loopholes that allow the hero to escape, and inevitably dooms the project itself. This stereotype is so laughable that numerous parodies exist as a result, notably the recent Austin Powers series. It goes without saying that a true Evil Genius would behave quite differently.
Indeed, the most accurate Evil Genius portrayed was featured in the ultimate movie of the series, "Goldfinger." This villain was realistic in that he attempted a plot that was within his means, and indulged in only a few superfluous embellishments. It is not a coincidence that this movie contained the only workable evil plot of the entire series.** It is also not a coincidence that its antagonist, Auric Goldfinger, was not defeated by James Bond at all, but rather brought down by a turncoat in his acceptably small operation.
*: No nasty letters, please. I am a fan, even of the Dalton movies, if grudgingly.
**: Honorable mention to Octopussy, some elements of which were small and elegant enough to be plausible, in my opinion. |
Perhaps 9/11 was an example of life imitating art. The biggest loophole/smoking gun generated by the complex 9/11 plot was, obviously, WTC 7.
Evil Genius At Large
I propose to the readership that I am at best an adequate Evil Genius, and at worst hopelessly overmatched by the supposed mastermind of September 11th.
See above. You are probably more intelligent than most of those that have positions of power in this country. In my rebuttal below, I will refer to Evil Genius as Evil Genius (even I protest to the term “genius” being used – see above), but I will not give Evil Genius as much credit as you have.
Claims, Motive, and the Mark of Genius
1. No Planes Hit The Towers3
It’s very interesting and telling that you began with the ridiculous straw man “no planes” argument. I know it is great cannon fodder for official story defenders, but surely you of all people are smart enough to realize that no one with half a brain thinks that no planes hit the towers.
2. 767's Couldn't Have Destroyed The Towers4
This argument supposes that the Evil Genius would know this ahead of time, and would thus have to have weakened the buildings or employed a secondary attack to finish them off -- because the towers did in fact fall, eventually.
Actually, Evil Genius probably did know that 767’s couldn’t have destroyed the towers because the construction manager stated as such in an interview prior to 9/11. In fact, I seem to remember this man stating that the towers could withstand multiple jet plane impacts (thereby negating your “secondary attack to finish them off” argument) because it would be like a pencil poking a hole in a screen door, implying that the highly redundant structure would redistribute the loads accordingly.
Rubbish. A true Evil Genius would simply upgrade to 747's. Why not?
Assuming for the sake of argument that 747’s would result in the destruction of the Towers (a point I do not concede), the destruction that would most likely occur would not be desired by the Evil Genius. If a 747 were to plow into the side of the building and cause it to collapse, the most likely mechanism for building collapse would be for the section above the impact zone to fall over, similar to the felling of a tree. This would cause far more damage than the Evil Genius desired because surrounding buildings could have been damaged far more than they already were. Many of these surrounding buildings may not have been insured against terrorism, and the owners would have come to the government looking for either monetary compensation or answers about why this happened. Obviously the owners of the uninsured damaged/destroyed buildings would have to be paid off, thereby vastly increasing the cost of the operation. Moreover, the entire falling section might have caused a catastrophic breach of the “bathtub” underneath the WTC, flooding Manhattan. Luckily for Evil Genius, ground vibrations can be more easily controlled using explosives. See www dot controlled-demolition dot com/default.asp?reqLocId=7&reqItemId=20030317140323 (describing the CD of the Kingdome). Finally, there would still be a section of the building that would remain standing. This would have to be brought down using controlled demolition. Evil Genius would surely realize that the CD of the standing section would be scrutinized with respect to its effect on the surrounding area. The WTC Towers were full of asbestos, which means an explosive-driven CD may not receive approval from the city (to guard against spreading toxic dust, including asbestos, all over lower Manhattan). Therefore, Evil Genius would likely have been forced to foot the bill for taking the remaining sections apart, piece by piece, which is an extremely expensive proposition, again increasing the cost of the operation. In sum, 747s would not be preferable due to uncertainties introduced into the operation with respect to cost, success, and damage to the surrounding area.
3. Fires Couldn't Have Destroyed The Towers5
See above. It would have been simple to concoct an equally compelling story in which the Towers were finished off at once, either through a larger aircraft or a successful truck bombing, after the 1993 attempt. If there was any risk of the planned attack mode failing to achieve the desired effect, the solution is simply to escalate -- not to complicate the scheme with pre-placement, which is time-consuming, prone to discovery, more expensive, and requires more workforce and more expertise.
See above. To summarize – a bigger airplane may not have done the job properly. A truck bombing, while perhaps simpler, would not have achieved the psychological effects desired by Evil Genius. If 9/11 was an inside job, Evil Genius would want the public to be scared out of their minds of the evil terrorists wanting to do us harm. The most effective way to affect people psychologically in this age of television is to have something visually spectacular for the people to witness and remember forever. Detonating a truck bomb would likely finish off the Towers very quickly, likely before anyone could catch it on camera. One could argue that Evil Genius could arrange for a film crew to happen to be in the area at the time, but they would likely only shoot it from one angle, and there wouldn’t be time between airplane impact and building collapse with the accompanying images of the standing, burning towers for people to see and remember (and symbolically adorn all kinds of remembrance paraphernalia). Another problem with the truck bomb would be the considerations listed above vis-à-vis surrounding destruction. A truck bomb taking out the base of the building would certainly cause the upper section to fall over like a tree, causing massive destruction to the surrounding buildings. Again, Evil Genius would want as much predictability to the operation as possible. Bringing the buildings straight down using CD minimizes uncertainties in the operation (at the same time recognizing the risk inherent to CD that explosives would be discovered before the operation commenced). Evil Genius could have decided that he could more accurately determine the risks of discovery prior to the operation (by controlling security in the WTC), and this outweighed the risk uncertainties regarding that would happen in the aftermath of a truck bomb attack. Predictability regarding the aftermath of the attacks would have been key to the attacks themselves.
4. WTC 7 Collapsed, But Wasn't Hit By A Plane6
If WTC 7's demise was a requirement, an Evil Genius would have made certain that it withstood crippling damage rather than relying upon chance dispersal of flaming wreckage. A fifth plane would be the obvious solution. If one can hijack four, why not five?
WTC 7 is the biggest puzzle of 9/11. Neither NIST nor anyone else can credibly explain its collapse due to fire because it bears a striking resemblance to classic controlled demolition. However, at the same time it does seem like Evil Genius would have had the good sense to make it look like a natural result of the events of the day. One particularly good option would be to demo it while Manhattan was enveloped in dust and debris from the Twin Towers. Perhaps this was the actual plan but something went wrong. Maybe people were still in the building that Evil Genius didn’t count on being there. Maybe they “pulled” the trigger at the correct time but it didn’t fire for some reason (people make mistakes). Maybe it was like a nuclear missile silo scene, where one of the guys won’t turn his key because he has second thoughts about the repercussions of his actions. Any number of plausible explanations, most having to do with human error, can be put forth to explain why it wasn’t pulled at the appropriate time.
You also suggest that another plane could have been used to hit WTC 7. Perhaps Flight 93 was headed for building 7, but was shot down (see discussion below). I know the popular assumption is that 93 was headed for the Capitol. However, it was so far away when it crashed that all they had to do was turn the airplane a little to the north and it’s headed for New York. We will never know for sure, but it is a plausible scenario. Evil Genius perhaps couldn’t decide what to do about the now-explosive laden yet undamaged building 7 until it was too late and decided it still had to be brought down.
I don’t know for sure, but I would imagine that the task of dismantling a building rigged with explosives which are already wired together would be far more dangerous and time consuming than actually rigging the building itself. Also, Evil Genius may realize that ground zero is going to be crawling with people and reporters for many months after the attacks, making it much more difficult to dismantle the explosives. Maybe Evil Genius (and even you) could have come up with a better option, but like I said at the beginning, I don’t give Evil Genius as much credit as you do. People can make mistakes and make wrong decisions.
5. Osama bin Laden Is A CIA Patsy7
This is the most intricate argument. Several possibilities:
1. Created by the Evil Genius: Too risky, too long-term. Such an infamous figure loose in the Islamic world would have been exposed. This also requires a plan of over 20 years duration, which is simply not needed.
Wrong. This is almost the best option for Evil Genius. Bin Laden could not further his aims by revealing he is in bed with the U.S. government. His whole message is anti-US, and he could obtain more credibility in the Islamic world than taking full credit for the 9/11 attacks. If he conceded that he required help from the US government, it would be like saying “I’m not good enough to pull it off on my own.” Regardless, the absolute best option for Evil Genius is to contract bin Laden to take credit for it, then kill him. His legend and message live on, and there is no risk of him spilling the beans on Evil Genius.
[*]
Genuine, but Contracted by the Evil Genius: Exposes the Evil Genius to unnecessary risk. bin Laden can further his aims by revealing his connections after committing Sept. 11th. Better options exist for the Evil Genius.
5. Don't Pin This on bin Laden At All: Best option. If bin Laden is real and the specter of terrorism furthers the Evil Genius's aims, let him continue with no interference or assistance. Manufacture a simpler competitor, one without the notoriety and under better control. As we have seen since with figures such as al-Zarqawi, this doesn't take very long at all.
This is the worst option. If bin Laden is real and the specter of terrorism, who could be a better fall guy? This is especially true if Evil Genius is reasonably comfortable with the prospect that he can kill bin Laden whenever he wants to.
6. The Pentagon Wasn't Hit By A Plane8
The Pentagon may have been hit by a plane. I don’t know for sure either way, and I think it is entirely possible that a plane did hit the Pentagon. This is not essential to the question of whether 9/11 was an inside job.
7. Planes Were Remote Controlled9
No Evil Genius would enact a plan that required remote control, simply because of the technical risk involved. If for whatever reason aircraft were required but no sacrificial pilots were available, some simpler variant would be found:
- At the very least, use fly-by-wire aircraft
- Use aircraft with the most advanced autopilots, such as the 777
- Do not choose single building targets, but rather aim aircraft at broader areas, achievable without requiring control beyond simply pointing it in the general vicinity
- Bailout at low speed, perhaps over the ocean, leaving the aircraft to accelerate on its own toward the target
Evil Genius would almost certainly insist on having the airplanes controlled remotely. Leaving the job to a suicide pilot is extremely risky because he may have second thoughts at the last minute or be a terrible pilot. By contrast, a pilot operating the airplane by remote control isn’t going over in his head whether he is ready to die while he is trying to fly the plane into the building. I also don’t agree that the technical risk would be too great (indeed it is likely far less than the risk inherent in using an amateur suicide pilot). Any airplane operated remotely would be outfitted with the military’s most advanced remote technology, which is likely far superior to anything on the civilian 777.
8. NORAD Was Stood Down10
The surest way to arouse suspicions of the military, which stands the best chance of anyone of stopping the Evil Genius, is to mess with its processes. Such a risk would be foolish in the extreme.
Wrong. Military people are trained to follow orders. If Evil Genius had one high level general inside NORAD capable of issuing a stand down order, it is a rather simple matter to implement this aspect of the operation. A stand down order could be plausibly explained to the general’s underlings and colleagues afterwards because multiple war games were going on at the time of the attacks. Amid the confusion, including fake radar blips being inserted onto the radar screens, the general could plausibly explain that he didn’t want to add to the confusion by ordering more airplanes into the sky. Afterwards, maybe the general is reprimanded for making the wrong decision in hind sight, but the punishment is likely a slap on the wrist because the investigative body finds that the general made the decision he in good faith thought was right at the time.
Rather than stand down NORAD, if interception was a risk, the Evil Genius would compensate by reducing the intercept window available even further than was done on September 11th. NORAD cannot possibly react instantaneously, no matter how sophisticated it becomes. Furthermore, apart from beating NORAD, it could also be confused with false signals, or overwhelmed with additional aircraft. Either option is superior, both in risk and effect, to that of forcing NORAD to stand idle.
Again, you are giving too much credit to Evil Genius, in that Evil Genius may not have been able to reduce the strike window down to a length that was acceptable enough to risk not standing down NORAD. Evil Genius would rather eliminate all risk by standing down NORAD than even accept the minute risk that NORAD could shoot down one of the airplanes. Here again, something could go wrong and one of the flights get delayed for some reason, giving NORAD an opportunity to intercept. Finally, there needed to be a window between the first and second strikes on the WTC Towers so the second strike could be caught on camera for the desired psychological effect.
9. Flight 93 Was Shot Down11
It isn't clear to me what value Flight 93 being shot down or not adds to the story. Supposing it was, it isn't clear what value there is to hide this fact. If the shoot-down was part of the plan, but had to be hidden, the Evil Genius would take steps to ensure the shootdown was not observed, and wreckage not recovered. The aircraft could have been shot down over a large lake or the open ocean. The FDR and CVR would certainly have been disabled by innocuous means -- power or data lines severed in a way consistent with poor maintenance.
More likely, the shooter was not part of the conspiracy. In that case, the aircraft would have been flown as to give NORAD the maximum chance to intercept and destroy the aircraft. This was not done either.
If the aircraft was shot down to give the illusion of the "Hero Story," when in fact no such on-board heroics existed, the shoot-down is totally incongruous. The plane would simply have been crashed on purpose.
Another option exists – the shooter was not part of the conspiracy and shot the plane down according to standard procedures or just because of his gut feeling that this plane was going to be used as a missile just like the two WTC planes. The Hero story was concocted after the fact. In any case, what happened to Flight 93 isn’t critical to the theory that 9/11 was an inside job. The destruction at the WTC complex is by far the most important.
10. Flight 77 FDR Is Inconsistent12
I should point out that there is no evidence that it is, in fact, inconsistent. However, this is perhaps the most obvious case of underestimating the Evil Genius. Why an incorrect FDR would have been planted in the rubble, when no FDR or one too damaged for readout (like its companion, the CVR) would suffice, is totally inexplicable. Likewise, if spoofing an FDR was somehow required, the Evil Genius had resources at its disposal to spoof it correctly.
And as pointed out in 6, there is no compelling reason not to crash the Pentagon. Simplest approach is to crash a fully-functional aircraft and not adjust the FDR in any way.
As I said, it’s entirely possible that an airplane did crash into the Pentagon, and that the FDR is genuine. However, if an airplane did not crash into the Pentagon, and this story was made up, an FDR would actually be pretty good proof for most people than an airplane did crash into the Pentagon. Also, you are again giving too much credit to Evil Genius, and those helping him. Not only would the person faking the FDR need to have the requisite skill to do it, that person must also be trusted by Evil Genius as a person that would go along with the cover up. In other words, Evil Genius may not have been able to get the best person for the fake job because the best faker (or even a really good faker) may not have gone along with the cover up. Regardless, the Pentagon is an open question, and again the WTC is far more important.
11. Telephone Calls From the Planes Were Faked13
This is another strawman. Whether the calls were faked or not has no bearing on whether 9/11 could have been an inside job. Again, the destruction at the WTC is more important.
12. The Follow-Up Anthrax Attack Proves Government Involvement14
The anthrax attacks were clumsy and ineffective in the eyes of an Evil Genius. The lack of coordination is startling. Had this been part of the Conspiracy, there are several better uses:
- Carry spores on the planes, contaminating the impact zones and making cleanup much more difficult
- Mail spores to high-ranking government officials at the same time, not a week afterward
- Mail spores to a broader distribution and higher profile individuals -- an out-of-date address for the National Enquirer? Are you serious?
As others have pointed out, the anthrax attacks were intended by Evil Genius to intimidate key congressmen and members of the press into not investigating 9/11 for fear of their life. Carrying spores on the planes would not help Evil Genius because a quick cleanup operation and destruction of evidence was one key to success. The spores were mailed a week after 9/11 to prevent investigation of the events the previous week. You are again giving too much credit to Evil Genius – so he didn’t mail spores to the people you would have mailed them to. Big deal. Also, mailing spores to the out of date address for National Enquirer could have been a misdirection move by Evil Genius to make it look like it wasn’t a direct attack on those that could investigate 9/11.
13. The News Is All Corrupt15
First, there has been some limited mainstream U.S. and foreign media coverage of the open questions regarding 9/11. However, the question of why it hasn’t gotten more attention in the mainstream media is admittedly a puzzling question. Maybe some journalists may not want to damage the economy or U.S. stature in the world by exposing 9/11. This is a legitimate concern because, if it became generally accepted that 9/11 was an inside job, there may be dire consequences to the U.S. economy and U.S. stature in the world, and there would certainly be a Constitutional crisis. These journalists may not want to put our country through that pain. Others may not be willing to believe our government would do something so evil (many in the general public also fall into this category). Still others may not be intelligent enough to look at all of the evidence and come to the correct conclusion. Some fear being labeled a “kook” and/or losing their job. Finally, there have been several scandals involving journalists being paid to report certain things. We have no reason to believe there is not more of this going on that we don’t know about. If Evil Genius has the resources to pull off 9/11, he probably also has the resources to pay off and/or intimidate key editors and journalists to maintain the cover-up.
14. All The Engineers In the World Are Corrupt16
This is based on false logic. The fact that a large number of engineers haven’t been openly critical of the official story is not evidence that they all in fact support the official story. The same reasons above regarding journalists apply to engineers as well. The NIST scientists are also heavily reliant on government contracts to make money. Many structural engineers also rely on the government for building approvals, etc. It would be very bad for business to go around accusing the government of being in on 9/11 because it would be extremely likely that the next big building project that came in would not be approved based on such criticism alone.
15. The Towers Were Destroyed By Nuclear Devices17
16. Holograms Fooled Everyone18
17. Beams from Space Destroyed The Towers19
These are obvious strawmen. As with no planes, surely you are smart enough to know that no one really believes any of this.
Conclusions
In other words, if a single word of the Truth Movement's claims is true, then it should be frightened indeed. The Truth Movement cannot even imagine what such individuals could accomplish, if they are correct. As a consequence, the Truth Movement stands no chance whatsoever to detect, interpret, predict, or prevent any ongoing or future conspiracy.
I readily admit that, assuming 9/11 was an inside job, the Truth Movement is probably fighting a losing battle. You are absolutely correct that the Evil Genius has such vast resources at his disposal, that it will extremely difficult, if not impossible, to expose the conspiracy. However, I think most that believe 9/11 was an inside job are doing what they think is right, and hoping for the best.