If I Was An Evil Genius... Refuting Conspiracy Theories via Motive

Bolding mine. I want to emphasize this, so that someone, if not myself, gets the scoop on how this goes from Gravy.

So Mark, perhaps in a couple of weeks, after this discussion occurs, you could give us a summary? Thanks in advance.

TAM:)
What's this "NIST Report" people keep yakking about?
 
You of course know that English is the most commonly spoken language in the world, and the second most commonly spoken first language on the planet? You also do know that much of the western world speaks English as a first language, like, oh.... England? Australia? New Zealand? South Africa? Canada?
Not to mention being the international language of science. NIST employs many, many foreign-born scientists.
 
I obviously can't say anything that doesn't merit an antagonistic or sarcastic response, so I'm not going to debate with any of you about every little point.

I honestly don't know what happened on 9/11 except this: the WTC Towers and Building 7 were brought down with explosives. I don't know who knew about it, who planned it, or how the logistics of it were accomplished, but I know it happened. No, I'm not going to debate this with you right now either. Like I said, I would like to discuss some serious issues I have with the NIST Report soon, and I will, but I can't right now.

I happened upon Mackey's original post and thought it would be an interesting intellectual exercise to write a rebuttal to it, hoping to engage in an interesting discussion with Mr. Mackey about the Evil Genius hypothetical. Based on this one post I read, he seems like an intelligent, rational person, that may engage in a good discussion about his hypothetical. No, I'm not calling him an "intellectual coward" like gravy called me for not being here to discuss it. I actually hope he is watching the basketball games today instead of replying, just like I was doing when gravy called me an intellectual coward.

Instead, this quickly deteriorated into a pointless debate with you. I am never going to convince you I'm right, and you are never going to convince me you are right. I've read all of the available "debunking" materials I can find, and I still believe it was explosives. No proof or analysis I provide will be sufficient, and no proof or analysis you provide will be sufficient. I know, I know, no proof I provide will be sufficient because I don't have any proof, right? Then I sarcastically say you are very clever and provide what I think is good proof. Then you all verball assault me for having the audacity to even think for a second what I said was good evidence, and round and round we go. No thanks. A clearly pointless waste of time for both sides.

Sorry I'm not as engaging as some new members that come here to teach you a thing or two. I simply enjoyed Mackey's hypothetical exercise, and wanted to discuss it further. If I find anything else interesting to comment on around here that doesn't involve the hashed and re-hashed arguments and counter arguments, I will do so.
 
Dear Mr Bear,
There is no evidence of explosives in the WTC collapses. If there was evidence of explosives we wouldn't be having this debate.
 
I honestly don't know what happened on 9/11 except this: the WTC Towers and Building 7 were brought down with explosives. I don't know who knew about it, who planned it, or how the logistics of it were accomplished, but I know it happened. No, I'm not going to debate this with you right now either. Like I said, I would like to discuss some serious issues I have with the NIST Report soon, and I will, but I can't right now.

I would look very much forward to discussing issues you may have with the NCSTAR. Feel free to start a new thread so as not to derail this one (or derail this one, I do it all the time :)).
 
Sometimes the best way to expose the thought processes of people is to simply quote them.
I honestly don't know what happened on 9/11 except this: the WTC Towers and Building 7 were brought down with explosives. I don't know who knew about it, who planned it, or how the logistics of it were accomplished, but I know it happened.
 
I honestly don't know what happened on 9/11 except this: the WTC Towers and Building 7 were brought down with explosives. I don't know who knew about it, who planned it, or how the logistics of it were accomplished, but I know it happened...
May you never sit in a court of law accused of a crime, with your fate in the hands of twelve people like you.
 
GoldenBear, you are full of yourself. You know next to nothing about the events, yet you claim to know more than the professionals who studied them and the people here who have cared enough to learn about them.

I wrote a post about WTC insurance issues that refutes your claim of Silverstein's financial motive. It contains a lot of useful information, and links to more information. I put thought into it. You didn't even bother to read it, yet you bothered to criticize it.

You came here to tell us about an earth-shattering, unsolved crime that you believe has been committed. You have no evidence to support your claim, you believe you shouldn't have to provide any evidence, and you ignore contrary evidence when it's presented. Your behavior is childish and will be met with scorn on this site that's devoted to critical thinking.

Don't waste our time with your grossly uninformed opinions. Feel like taking this subject seriously? Then you've got a lot of work to do. Go find reliable sources and do it.
 
Someone who still believes that Silverstein made profits from 9/11 insurance is not worthy of any attention, let alone debate in my opinion.

You've got a long way to go GoldenBear
 
You came here to tell us about an earth-shattering, unsolved crime that you believe has been committed.

I came here to do no such thing. Like I said, I came to write a rebuttal to an interesting, original, thoughtfully written post and hopefully discuss it with the author. Unfortunately, that didn't happen.

I've seen how debates with you people go, and I will not be a part of it. It is a complete waste of time for both sides. I certainly won't be able to offer any arguments outside of the WTC and Building 7 you all haven't heard before and responded to, so I'm not going to debate with you about the same old things that have been discussed here a thousand times. Gravy has over 6,000 posts here. I don't know if I've written that much in the last year at the job I get paid for (and I write a lot!). He's probably got form responses ready (he obviously does for the Silverstein/insurance idea) for anything that has ever been said in support of the inside job theory. Why would I waste my time with that? More importantly, why would Gravy waste his time with that?

Regarding Building 7 and the WTC, there are no debunking materials you can point to that I haven't already read. As a scientist, these aspects of 9/11 have been the most interesting to me personally. So, once I was exposed to the idea that they may have been brought down by explosives, I spent years looking at it in my spare time - reading materials arguing for and against and looking at the raw data - and I'm convinced it was explosives. And nothing anyone here can say will convince me otherwise, just like nothing I can say will convince anyone here otherwise. Again, it would be a pointless waste of time for both sides to debate the issue. Why would any of you want to re-hash all of the old arguments over and over again? Doesn't that ever get boring?

Anyways, Mackey's post was something original in this sea of pointless debate, and I tried to write an original, thoughtful response. I didn't present the arguments I did to prove the truth of them - I presented them to give my take on the mind of the Evil Genius, had he been responsible for it, just as Mackey did. So far, the only responses have gone to the truth or falsity of two or three points I raised, indicating people cherry picked the easiest ones to refute (remember, Gravy doesn't have time to respond to the entire post, but calls me an intellectual coward for not immediately responding to one question). Congratulations everyone. No one has argued against my ideas with regards to motive of Evil Genius vis-a-vis each aspect of the "conspiracy theory" presented by Mackey. Instead, I quickly got the stock question "How many engineers support your theory? List their name and current occupation." Is that what you all mean by critical thinking? A tip to everyone: Mackey should be your example: come up with something original.
 
I've seen how debates with you people go, and I will not be a part of it. It is a complete waste of time for both sides.
This is a forum that promotes and encourages critical thinking. However, anyone can post here, provided they abide by forum rules. If you'd like to raise the level of debate to a place where you're comfortable, it's up to you. But it does take two to tango.

I certainly won't be able to offer any arguments outside of the WTC and Building 7 you all haven't heard before and responded to, so I'm not going to debate with you about the same old things that have been discussed here a thousand times. Gravy has over 6,000 posts here. I don't know if I've written that much in the last year at the job I get paid for (and I write a lot!). He's probably got form responses ready (he obviously does for the Silverstein/insurance idea) for anything that has ever been said in support of the inside job theory. Why would I waste my time with that? More importantly, why would Gravy waste his time with that?
I can't speak for him, but I'll guess Gravy performs the quite admirable tasks he does as a service in support of this forum's mission, and as a historian with an interest in factual information (and perhaps general affection for the city of New York as well).

Regarding Building 7 and the WTC, there are no debunking materials you can point to that I haven't already read. As a scientist, these aspects of 9/11 have been the most interesting to me personally.
May I ask your field of expertise?

So, once I was exposed to the idea that they may have been brought down by explosives, I spent years looking at it in my spare time - reading materials arguing for and against and looking at the raw data - and I'm convinced it was explosives. And nothing anyone here can say will convince me otherwise...
Bolding mine.

And you say you're a scientist?

...just like nothing I can say will convince anyone here otherwise.
That's where you're 100% mistaken. If you have proof, I for one will gladly assimilate it. And judging by my time on many of the sub-forums here, I'm certain others would as well.

Again, it would be a pointless waste of time for both sides to debate the issue. Why would any of you want to re-hash all of the old arguments over and over again? Doesn't that ever get boring?
Various elements of the so-called "truth movement" are actively persuing an agenda. Considering there is to date no proof for any of their varied and often conflicting claims, I'm left to wonder about some of their motives. Is this unreasonable?
 
Last edited:
As a scientist, these aspects of 9/11 have been the most interesting to me personally. So, once I was exposed to the idea that they may have been brought down by explosives, I spent years looking at it in my spare time - reading materials arguing for and against and looking at the raw data - and I'm convinced it was explosives.



I'd be interested in knowing what evidence it was that convinced you. Not to debate it or any such thing, but just as a data point. I agree that many of these debates have reached an impasse, and now I'm mostly interested in finding out why people believe as they do - what convinced them, and why that bit of evidence did the job, that sort of thing.
 
This is a forum that promotes and encourages critical thinking...If you'd like to raise the level of debate to a place where you're comfortable, it's up to you.

I tried to do this by writing a thoughtful response to the OP. Unfortunately it degenerated quickly into the mundane "How many engineers support your theory?"-type discussion. Again, is this what you call critical thinking?

May I ask your field of expertise?

Undergraduate: chemical engineering; Post: juris doctor

Side note - I particularly enjoy the "critical thinking" argument that only a civil/structural engineer is able to understand and credibly comment on the building collapses. As any engineer knows, civil engineering is one of the easier engineering disciplines, dealing in large part with understandable Newtonian physics. The more difficult engineering degrees are those in chemical and electrical engineering, where the concepts are a bit more abstract. This attack has been forcefully used in particular against Steven Jones, who has a Ph.D. in physics. You "debunkers" somehow try to argue that because he doesn't have a degree in, or work in, structural engineering, that he us somehow unable to understand, let alone write about, the scientific principles involved. This argument is laughable. Most people that have a Ph.D. in physics could sleep through a graduate civil/structural engineering degree program and come out with mostly A's. But, like any other point or argument I make, everyone feel free to completely disregard it and continually ask how many structural engineers disagree with the official story. It gets more compelling each time you ask.

And you say you're a scientist?

Yes, I am a scientist. And I have already looked at virtually all of the debunking materials available arguing against explosive demolition of these buildings, and I don't find any of it persuasive. Again, if you all do, that's fine with me. On the rational assumption that no one here will have anything to offer that I haven't already read during my own studies, I said that no one will be able to convince me otherwise. But, technically, yes, there may be someone somewhere that could say something to convince me otherwise. I just doubt it will be said here. NIST had several years and millions of dollars to convince me, and the NIST report wholly failed in its mission. The story they tell in the Executive Summary is not supported by their underlying physical tests, nor is it supported by their computer simulations. I don't have the time nor the inclination to go through and have this debate with Gravy or anyone else right now, but I will soon.
 
I honestly don't know what happened on 9/11 except this: the WTC Towers and Building 7 were brought down with explosives. I don't know who knew about it, who planned it, or how the logistics of it were accomplished, but I know it happened. No, I'm not going to debate this with you right now either. Like I said, I would like to discuss some serious issues I have with the NIST Report soon, and I will, but I can't right now.

Really? Well you are just the man to answer my questions.

WTC 1 and 2

1. Where were the explosives planted?
2. How much was used?
3. What type of explosives was used?
4. Why were there no tracers of explosives found in the debris?
5. Why do the seismic records indicate there were no secondary explosions?
6. Why did both towers start to collapse at the precise point of the planes impact?
7. How did the explosives survive the planes impact?
8. How did they survive the fires?
9. Why are there no clear audible records of explosives charges going off before or as the towers collapse?
10. Why are there no clear flashes of explosive charges going of as the towers collapse?
11. How much of the buildings fell outside their own footprint, and why?
12. When was the explosives planted and how much time did it take?
13. Why did the Towers not split as they collapsed?
14. Were the explosives in the core or the outer columns or both?
15. Why were both tower pre rigged with explosives beforehand?

WTC 7.

1. How much explosives were used?
2. Where was it planted?
3. How did they survive the damage caused by the collapse of the Towers?
4. How did they survive the fires?
5. Why did the fireman pull the fire fighting operation?
6. Why did they say the building was unsafe?
7. How did explosives, primers and detonators survive the fires for some six hours?
8. Why do seismic records show no secondary explosions inside WTC 7?
9. Why was WTC 7 left to stand for some six hours before being demolished?
10. Why did they not demolish under cover of the giant dust cloud?
11. Why did they tell the worlds media the building was about to collapse?
12. Why did they want the words media to broadcast such a clear demolition to the entire planet?
13. How did they know there would be not enough damage to WTC 7 from the collapse of the Towers to cause it to collapse immediately?
14. How did they know the fires would not cause the building to collapse?
15. When, and who planted the explosives?
16. Why was it necessary to demolish WTC 7?

I look forward to your reply along with, if you would be so kind,a complete summary of the events of 911. Just a few sentences to tell me what you think actually happened.

Once you answer my reasonable questions I wouldn’t mind asking you some more.

Ta.
 
Golden Bear:

You may have misunderstood me. When you write, "And nothing anyone here can say will convince me otherwise..." it comes as a surprise from someone who claims to be a scientist. Those who practice the various scientific disciplines are always refining their hypotheses. So for you to categorically state that your mind is closed is quite remarkable.

Other than that, I find it interesting that someone who has apparently been persuaded by certain evidence is unwilling to share it. These are not debates between opposing sides, as you seem to imply; it is a discussion of whether what you, and others say, can be supported by evidence.

And in regard to that:
Me said:
Considering the immeasurable amount of work and resources it would require to pull off an "inside job" as is being proposed by 9/11 conspiracy theorists -- not only to plan, put into place, execute, and continue to cover up for all time -- evidence for it would be fairly dripping from the trees. Yet there isn't even a drop of morning dew on a single leaf.

Too, that people who would do such a thing for some nefarious reason or reasons haven't performed any follow-up event in order to maintain and further their goals might offer to suggest these people don't exist in the first place.
 
I'm having trouble with somebody who in essence says, "you have an answer to every point I would make so why bother debating" and still seems to think he is totally right about the issue.

There is a reason why Gravy and others "always have an answer"; there are perfectly logical rebuttals to pretty much every single point that 911 CTs bring up to support their theories.
 
This is based on false logic. The fact that a large number of engineers haven’t been openly critical of the official story is not evidence that they all in fact support the official story. The same reasons above regarding journalists apply to engineers as well. The NIST scientists are also heavily reliant on government contracts to make money. Many structural engineers also rely on the government for building approvals, etc. It would be very bad for business to go around accusing the government of being in on 9/11 because it would be extremely likely that the next big building project that came in would not be approved based on such criticism alone.

I am only going to address this one point. Here is where knowingly or not, conspiracy theorists slander honorable people with zero evidence and waltz through their life blissfully slinging vile implications about people they do not even know.

If it were impossible that plane impact and fire destroyed the WTC, there would be one man that would be screaming his head off - and that is the designer, Leslie Robertson. Any structural engineer, any architect, any contractor, anyone who BUILDS things, understands that kind of pride - and I can only imagine the pride to be the designer of such an iconic structure. His office overlooked the WTC site. Is he complicit?? DO you know a single thing about the man?? I have attended presentations of his, I have seen him talk within a year of the WTC collapses, I have seen the pain in his eyes - how do you explain it that the DESIGNER of the building WOULD TELL YOU that airplane impact and fire brought it down?? He is not dependent on government contracts, or even work within the United States, do the research!! :mad:
 
An engineering degree does not make the holder immune to paranoia or insanity.

TAM:)
 
Side note - I particularly enjoy the "critical thinking" argument that only a civil/structural engineer is able to understand and credibly comment on the building collapses.
It's been my impression that more people around here demand that civil/structural engineers are the ones to make certain assertions by opinion. Assertions like, "The towers were over-designed" and "this structure should have survived the plane crash" do indeed require an advanced knowledge of structures that goes beyond the basic knowledge of most engineers and scientists. It requires knowledge of design codes and practices as well as the physics and materials science of the materials in question.
As any engineer knows, civil engineering is one of the easier engineering disciplines, dealing in large part with understandable Newtonian physics.
Drawing upon your opinion, stating it as fact, and then reporting it as the accepted truth among all engineers is a very poor logical construction. Please consider making valid arguments in the future
The more difficult engineering degrees are those in chemical and electrical engineering,
In your opinion, as a chemical engineer. This type of egotism and intellectual eliteism does not make your position any stronger, nor does it cause any of us to value your opinion more. Purporting opinion as fact will get you nowhere.
where the concepts are a bit more abstract.
Yes, finite element analysis and matrix methods for indeterminate structures are very straight forward. I don't know why it took all those graduate classes to learn this.
This attack has been forcefully used in particular against Steven Jones, who has a Ph.D. in physics. You "debunkers" somehow try to argue that because he doesn't have a degree in, or work in, structural engineering, that he us somehow unable to understand, let alone write about, the scientific principles involved.
So, a man who worked to develop cold fusion for most of his career has decided to re-devote his life to the pursuit of building collapse forensics. But, rather than submitting his findings to peer review in respected engineering journals, or collaborating with civil engineers at his own university, he decides that he knows everything he needs to know to make his claims. That would be a far better assessment of our criticism for Thermite Jones. Again, his egotism and downright intellectual dishonesty is what's at issue here. At any point during his research, he could have contacted other researchers, applied for grants, submitted papers for review or brought in outside expertise. He didn't, and frankly, his statements, his science, and his conclusions are largely invalid because of it.
This argument is laughable. Most people that have a Ph.D. in physics could sleep through a graduate civil/structural engineering degree program and come out with mostly A's.
Wow! I like how you slandered an entire profession, and how you assume that someone who has a PhD is ultimately the knower of all things! That's two wildly illogical, irrational statements in one post!

So, for your information, no, people who study physics are largely unaware of design practices, codes, methods and procedures used in modern civil engineering. While I have no doubt they would be fine with the mathematics, I have yet to meet a physicist who just knows how to desigh a reinforced concrete beam.
But, like any other point or argument I make, everyone feel free to completely disregard it and continually ask how many structural engineers disagree with the official story. It gets more compelling each time you ask.
Your ego is wearing thin.

Yes, I am a scientist. And I have already looked at virtually all of the debunking materials available arguing against explosive demolition of these buildings, and I don't find any of it persuasive.
And yet, you have no idea how explosives got into the towers, how they were detonated, who did it, why they did it or what really happened. So, rather than subjecting your fundamental belief to any form of rational criticism, you throw up your hands and declare that all of the debunking material is crap?
Again, if you all do, that's fine with me. On the rational assumption that no one here will have anything to offer that I haven't already read during my own studies, I said that no one will be able to convince me otherwise.
Your high and mighty brow beating is really annoying me.
NIST had several years and millions of dollars to convince me, and the NIST report wholly failed in its mission. The story they tell in the Executive Summary is not supported by their underlying physical tests, nor is it supported by their computer simulations.
This is the type of statement someone who had read almost nothing of the NCSTAR would say. Please prove otherwise to me.
I don't have the time nor the inclination to go through and have this debate with Gravy or anyone else right now, but I will soon.
I'm looking forward to it.
 
As any engineer knows, civil engineering is one of the easier engineering disciplines, dealing in large part with understandable Newtonian physics. The more difficult engineering degrees are those in chemical and electrical engineering, where the concepts are a bit more abstract. This attack has been forcefully used in particular against Steven Jones, who has a Ph.D. in physics. You "debunkers" somehow try to argue that because he doesn't have a degree in, or work in, structural engineering, that he us somehow unable to understand, let alone write about, the scientific principles involved. This argument is laughable. Most people that have a Ph.D. in physics could sleep through a graduate civil/structural engineering degree program and come out with mostly A's. But, like any other point or argument I make, everyone feel free to completely disregard it and continually ask how many structural engineers disagree with the official story. It gets more compelling each time you ask.


Excuse me? I suppose hydraulics and hydrology do not involve anything other than "simple Newtonian physics". Nor environmental engineering. Both areas fall under the discipline of "civil engineering". Please do not assume that since you have studied one discipline, you are qualified to speak to others.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom