Side note - I particularly enjoy the "critical thinking" argument that only a civil/structural engineer is able to understand and credibly comment on the building collapses.
It's been my impression that more people around here demand that civil/structural engineers are the ones to make certain assertions by opinion. Assertions like, "The towers were over-designed" and "this structure should have survived the plane crash" do indeed require an advanced knowledge of structures that goes beyond the basic knowledge of most engineers and scientists. It requires knowledge of design codes and practices as well as the physics and materials science of the materials in question.
As any engineer knows, civil engineering is one of the easier engineering disciplines, dealing in large part with understandable Newtonian physics.
Drawing upon your opinion, stating it as fact, and then reporting it as the accepted truth among all engineers is a very poor logical construction. Please consider making valid arguments in the future
The more difficult engineering degrees are those in chemical and electrical engineering,
In your opinion, as a chemical engineer. This type of egotism and intellectual eliteism does not make your position any stronger, nor does it cause any of us to value your opinion more. Purporting opinion as fact will get you nowhere.
where the concepts are a bit more abstract.
Yes, finite element analysis and matrix methods for indeterminate structures are very straight forward. I don't know why it took all those graduate classes to learn this.
This attack has been forcefully used in particular against Steven Jones, who has a Ph.D. in physics. You "debunkers" somehow try to argue that because he doesn't have a degree in, or work in, structural engineering, that he us somehow unable to understand, let alone write about, the scientific principles involved.
So, a man who worked to develop cold fusion for most of his career has decided to re-devote his life to the pursuit of building collapse forensics. But, rather than submitting his findings to peer review in respected engineering journals, or collaborating with civil engineers at his own university, he decides that he knows everything he needs to know to make his claims. That would be a far better assessment of our criticism for Thermite Jones. Again, his egotism and downright intellectual dishonesty is what's at issue here. At any point during his research, he could have contacted other researchers, applied for grants, submitted papers for review or brought in outside expertise. He didn't, and frankly, his statements, his science, and his conclusions are largely invalid because of it.
This argument is laughable. Most people that have a Ph.D. in physics could sleep through a graduate civil/structural engineering degree program and come out with mostly A's.
Wow! I like how you slandered an entire profession, and how you assume that someone who has a PhD is ultimately the knower of all things! That's two wildly illogical, irrational statements in one post!
So, for your information, no, people who study physics are largely unaware of design practices, codes, methods and procedures used in modern civil engineering. While I have no doubt they would be fine with the mathematics, I have yet to meet a physicist who just knows how to desigh a reinforced concrete beam.
But, like any other point or argument I make, everyone feel free to completely disregard it and continually ask how many structural engineers disagree with the official story. It gets more compelling each time you ask.
Your ego is wearing thin.
Yes, I am a scientist. And I have already looked at virtually all of the debunking materials available arguing against explosive demolition of these buildings, and I don't find any of it persuasive.
And yet, you have no idea how explosives got into the towers, how they were detonated, who did it, why they did it or what really happened. So, rather than subjecting your fundamental belief to any form of rational criticism, you throw up your hands and declare that all of the debunking material is crap?
Again, if you all do, that's fine with me. On the rational assumption that no one here will have anything to offer that I haven't already read during my own studies, I said that no one will be able to convince me otherwise.
Your high and mighty brow beating is really annoying me.
NIST had several years and millions of dollars to convince me, and the NIST report wholly failed in its mission. The story they tell in the Executive Summary is not supported by their underlying physical tests, nor is it supported by their computer simulations.
This is the type of statement someone who had read almost nothing of the NCSTAR would say. Please prove otherwise to me.
I don't have the time nor the inclination to go through and have this debate with Gravy or anyone else right now, but I will soon.
I'm looking forward to it.