Golden Bear
Scholar
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2007
- Messages
- 109
As I'm sure you are already aware, many of your questions are already addressed by my statement that I don't know the logistics. And knowing none of my answers will be adequate for you, I will briefly respond to some of them.
Seriously? Because Evil Genius either (1) knew where the airplanes would impact the buildings and planned the explosive progression accordingly, or (2) knew the planes would impact the buildings somewhere and wrote a computer program to control the detonation accordingly, starting the explosives at the impacting floors first (which the user would input).
Side note - I also love the argument that because it didn't start at the bottom and work its way up that it couldn't possibly have been controlled demolition. Like Evil Genius wouldn't know to start the demolition at the impact zone to make the entire operation look legitimate. This an argument that is used particularly well by the ostensibly authoritative NIST. From the NIST FAQ: "NIST’s findings also do not support the “controlled demolition” theory since there is conclusive evidence that: the collapse was initiated in the impact and fire floors of the WTC towers and nowhere else..." - a clearly spurious argument.
I don't know what explosive was used, so I can't answer this. I do know that many high powered explosives require an extremely high temperature detonator to start the reaction - higher even than burning jet fuel temperatures. Furthermore, many of these materials are shock insensitive. I believe an electrical charge is typically used to detonate them. Also, the risk of one or more of them being detonated in the impact is one that Evil Genius may have taken. In an attempt to keep this thread on topic, another characteristic of an Evil Genius that attempts to pull off 9/11 would be that he wouldn't necessarily be risk averse (at least not as risk averse as a rational person). Perhaps the calculated risk of having one of them going off accidentally was reduced to a level which, in Evil Genius's mind, was acceptable.
See above. Very high temperatures are needed to detonate many high powered explosives. TNT for example can be melted and cast without detonating, and it is shock and friction insensitive (no, I'm not saying TNT was used, this is just an example).
See above regarding seismic records. Closely spaced explosions would sound more like a continuous roar than separate explosions. Also, credible evidence of explosions taking place already exists: numerous eyewitness reports of "huge" explosions, and firefighters using the words "boom boom boom" to describe the noises taking place during the collapse. I would actually love to get the raw feed data (or at least HD quality data) from news agencies' footage from that day and take a hard look at the video and audio record. I think it would be very interesting. Those news reporter microphones are set up to record the things the reporters are saying and not pick up background noises - that's why they talk directly in to the microphone, then hold it near the mouth of the person they are interviewing. Picking up the sound of a distant explosion on a microphone so configured would probably require some isolation and amplification using computers.
Evil Genius would know that explosive flashes would be a dead giveaway and make sure that the explosive charges would not be visible through the windows. In many classic CD jobs, the CD itself is like a show, so flashes are probably preferred. The opposite is true here. Additionally, hiding the flashes wouldn't be particularly difficult in the Twin Towers because of the exterior columns and panelling which obscure most views into the buildings. Probably most importantly, Evil Genius also may have created the huge dust cloud to help obscure the flashes. Again, visible flashes would be one more element in the risk equation. Evil Genius must have been reasonably comfortable that this risk had been sharply reduced or eliminated.
I don't know exactly how much of the buildings fell outside their own footprint. However, the fact that some of the buildings did fall outside their own footprint is unsurprising, even if it was a classic bottom up CD, because the height to width/length ratio is far larger than your typical CDed building. The debris simply wouldn't fit inside the footprint. More importantly, in the case of the Twin Towers, the aforementioned dust cloud (which was likely created to hide what was going on underneath) would have to be created by using a large amount of explosives - much more than would be used in a traditional CD. The larger amount of explosives actually blew quite a bit of material, dust and debris outside the footprint of the building. Again, this is unsurprising and fits reasonably well within Evil Genius's plan.
Logistics - I have no idea.
I'm not sure I understand why you think this would happen and I've never heard this suggested. Perhaps you can elaborate.
Again with the logistics? Probably most of the explosives were in the core columns (which were thicker than the outer columns), but the outer columns needed to be severed too, so both. The outer columns were smaller than the core columns, so the outer columns presumably required a smaller amount of explosives.
Is this a serious question? So the entire building would be brought down - psychological effects plus avoiding the expensive task of dismantling the building after the jet impacts rendered the building unusable. Who in their right mind would rent out any space in the WTC after both buildings were hit by airplanes? Even if the building was fully repaired after the jet impacts, they would be completely empty (except perhaps the bottom few floors). As I stated in my original reply to Mackey, Evil Genius would probably assume (although he would not know for sure) that the impact of an airplane would not cause the building to collapse due to statements made before 9/11 by the construction manager that the building could withstand multiple jet liner impacts and the highly redundant structure would remain standing. Bringing the entire buildings down was a ket part of Evil Genius's plan.
WTC 7 isn't even worth discussing. It is so obviously a CD, and a classic bottom up CD at that, that if you can't see it, I can't help you.
Your request for me to provide a summary of what happened on 9/11 is curious in light of the fact that I already said I don't know what happened. There, I said it again, is everything clear now?
These all go to logistics, which you can't expect anyone without much more access to evidence than I have to answer.WTC 1 and 2
1. Where were the explosives planted?
2. How much was used?
3. What type of explosives was used?
NIST wasn't looking for traces of explosives in the debris. See their FAQ (which I can't link to until I have 15 posts) "NIST did not test for the residue of these compounds in the steel." Hmmm... Seems like an extremely simple chemical test could have put to rest this pesky explosive residue question. I guess NIST probably ran out of money before they could perform this simple chemical analysis. That works for you guys, right?4. Why were there no tracers of explosives found in the debris?
I will admit that I don't understand enough about seismic records to decide who to believe on this one. Good papers have been written on both sides, and, as this is a highly specialized field, I don't know who is right. However, I can surmise that Evil Genius would have rigged the explosives to detonate within fractions of a second of each other, thereby creating one constant seismic signal (if, in fact, the explosions were capable of contributing to the seismic signal, which I'm also not sure of).5. Why do the seismic records indicate there were no secondary explosions?
6. Why did both towers start to collapse at the precise point of the planes impact?
Seriously? Because Evil Genius either (1) knew where the airplanes would impact the buildings and planned the explosive progression accordingly, or (2) knew the planes would impact the buildings somewhere and wrote a computer program to control the detonation accordingly, starting the explosives at the impacting floors first (which the user would input).
Side note - I also love the argument that because it didn't start at the bottom and work its way up that it couldn't possibly have been controlled demolition. Like Evil Genius wouldn't know to start the demolition at the impact zone to make the entire operation look legitimate. This an argument that is used particularly well by the ostensibly authoritative NIST. From the NIST FAQ: "NIST’s findings also do not support the “controlled demolition” theory since there is conclusive evidence that: the collapse was initiated in the impact and fire floors of the WTC towers and nowhere else..." - a clearly spurious argument.
7. How did the explosives survive the planes impact?
I don't know what explosive was used, so I can't answer this. I do know that many high powered explosives require an extremely high temperature detonator to start the reaction - higher even than burning jet fuel temperatures. Furthermore, many of these materials are shock insensitive. I believe an electrical charge is typically used to detonate them. Also, the risk of one or more of them being detonated in the impact is one that Evil Genius may have taken. In an attempt to keep this thread on topic, another characteristic of an Evil Genius that attempts to pull off 9/11 would be that he wouldn't necessarily be risk averse (at least not as risk averse as a rational person). Perhaps the calculated risk of having one of them going off accidentally was reduced to a level which, in Evil Genius's mind, was acceptable.
8. How did they survive the fires?
See above. Very high temperatures are needed to detonate many high powered explosives. TNT for example can be melted and cast without detonating, and it is shock and friction insensitive (no, I'm not saying TNT was used, this is just an example).
9. Why are there no clear audible records of explosives charges going off before or as the towers collapse?
See above regarding seismic records. Closely spaced explosions would sound more like a continuous roar than separate explosions. Also, credible evidence of explosions taking place already exists: numerous eyewitness reports of "huge" explosions, and firefighters using the words "boom boom boom" to describe the noises taking place during the collapse. I would actually love to get the raw feed data (or at least HD quality data) from news agencies' footage from that day and take a hard look at the video and audio record. I think it would be very interesting. Those news reporter microphones are set up to record the things the reporters are saying and not pick up background noises - that's why they talk directly in to the microphone, then hold it near the mouth of the person they are interviewing. Picking up the sound of a distant explosion on a microphone so configured would probably require some isolation and amplification using computers.
10. Why are there no clear flashes of explosive charges going of as the towers collapse?
Evil Genius would know that explosive flashes would be a dead giveaway and make sure that the explosive charges would not be visible through the windows. In many classic CD jobs, the CD itself is like a show, so flashes are probably preferred. The opposite is true here. Additionally, hiding the flashes wouldn't be particularly difficult in the Twin Towers because of the exterior columns and panelling which obscure most views into the buildings. Probably most importantly, Evil Genius also may have created the huge dust cloud to help obscure the flashes. Again, visible flashes would be one more element in the risk equation. Evil Genius must have been reasonably comfortable that this risk had been sharply reduced or eliminated.
11. How much of the buildings fell outside their own footprint, and why?
I don't know exactly how much of the buildings fell outside their own footprint. However, the fact that some of the buildings did fall outside their own footprint is unsurprising, even if it was a classic bottom up CD, because the height to width/length ratio is far larger than your typical CDed building. The debris simply wouldn't fit inside the footprint. More importantly, in the case of the Twin Towers, the aforementioned dust cloud (which was likely created to hide what was going on underneath) would have to be created by using a large amount of explosives - much more than would be used in a traditional CD. The larger amount of explosives actually blew quite a bit of material, dust and debris outside the footprint of the building. Again, this is unsurprising and fits reasonably well within Evil Genius's plan.
12. When was the explosives planted and how much time did it take?
Logistics - I have no idea.
13. Why did the Towers not split as they collapsed?
I'm not sure I understand why you think this would happen and I've never heard this suggested. Perhaps you can elaborate.
14. Were the explosives in the core or the outer columns or both?
Again with the logistics? Probably most of the explosives were in the core columns (which were thicker than the outer columns), but the outer columns needed to be severed too, so both. The outer columns were smaller than the core columns, so the outer columns presumably required a smaller amount of explosives.
15. Why were both tower pre rigged with explosives beforehand?
Is this a serious question? So the entire building would be brought down - psychological effects plus avoiding the expensive task of dismantling the building after the jet impacts rendered the building unusable. Who in their right mind would rent out any space in the WTC after both buildings were hit by airplanes? Even if the building was fully repaired after the jet impacts, they would be completely empty (except perhaps the bottom few floors). As I stated in my original reply to Mackey, Evil Genius would probably assume (although he would not know for sure) that the impact of an airplane would not cause the building to collapse due to statements made before 9/11 by the construction manager that the building could withstand multiple jet liner impacts and the highly redundant structure would remain standing. Bringing the entire buildings down was a ket part of Evil Genius's plan.
WTC 7 isn't even worth discussing. It is so obviously a CD, and a classic bottom up CD at that, that if you can't see it, I can't help you.
Your request for me to provide a summary of what happened on 9/11 is curious in light of the fact that I already said I don't know what happened. There, I said it again, is everything clear now?