If I Was An Evil Genius... Refuting Conspiracy Theories via Motive

@The Almond

I'm not saying that a PhD in physics is a know it all and can immediately tell you about the materials sciences, building codes, etc. that are involved in structural engineering.
You did say that, but it's nice that you're willing to retract such a statement as an absurdity.
I'm saying it is not an outlandish proposition that they would be able to learn (and I would argue easily learn) the principles involved by spending some time studying.
You're probably right that a physicist is capable of learning, but I would argue conversely that a structural engineer is capable of learning quantum mechanics. Your proposition relies on the rather unfounded statement that all physicists are smarter than all structural engineers. That's not supported by any evidence, and it nothing short of a below-the-belt jab at structural engineers.

Also, I wouldn't have to be so critical of structural engineers if you all didn't overestimate their importance to such a degree.
Every single structural drawing and plan in the United States bears the signature of a structural engineer. Yes, they're important. Yes they know things. Yes they're professionals.
Obviously they are very smart people, but they are not the only ones that can understand the problem presented here. One of my friends in college was in the civil engineering program, and I helped him with his homework in his classes on several occasions. He went on to do post graduate work at MIT (although we lost contact after he left to go study there and I don't know if he actually obtained a graduate degree from MIT). I'm not presenting this example to say I'm smarter than him. I'm merely saying that I, for one, am a non-civil engineer that is capable of understanding civil engineering principles.
Anecdotal evidence really doesn't help your case here.
Someone with a PhD in physics is probably even more likely than me to be able to understand the principles involved.
So, the hundreds of PhDs who reviewed or contributed to the NCSTAR, who by your own admission are more capable of understanding the physics involved than you are, are not viable resources because...?
 
It's good to have another Engineer on here who also doesn't tow the orthodox line.

Ah, the pesky orthodoxy of research and reliance on evidence over completely uninformed opinion! The orthodoxy of being able to say, "Oops, I got that wrong. Thanks for your correction."

William, when you are able to demonstrate how this "orthodoxy" has led us astray, please do so. Until then, it's just an empty accusation.

Fair enough?
 
Of course, NIST didn't explain anything that happened after "collapse initiation", so none of you really have an authoritative report to rely on that explains what happened after collapse initiation. Well, NIST did devote about one quarter of one page (out of a total 10,000) to the events after collapse initiation, so I guess you could refer to that. Unfortunately that tiny section contains nothing but circular logic and conclusory statements that aren't even supported by a single calculation.

I think Gravy did a great job of responding to much of your post, but I wanted to mention that the entirety of the National Construction Safety Team Act is reprinted at the end of NCSTAR 1. If you could please point out to me the section where the Congress directs NIST to study events after collapse initiation, I would greatly appreciate it.
 
Your proposition relies on the rather unfounded statement that all physicists are smarter than all structural engineers. That's not supported by any evidence, and it nothing short of a below-the-belt jab at structural engineers.

Pssst, Golden Bear, he's a Structural Engineer! ;)

Don't make him mad, have you seen what these guys get like when they're mad!

Just Kidding.
 
Ah, the pesky orthodoxy of research and reliance on evidence over completely uninformed opinion! The orthodoxy of being able to say, "Oops, I got that wrong. Thanks for your correction."

William, when you are able to demonstrate how this "orthodoxy" has led us astray, please do so. Until then, it's just an empty accusation.

Fair enough?

I have outlined my position on both of these points this in several of my posts now Gravy. I don't want to take over another thread with discussions about me. Despite my egomaniac tendencies I do rather think I'm hogging the limelight too much now.
 
Pssst, Golden Bear, he's a Structural Engineer! ;)

Don't make him mad, have you seen what these guys get like when they're mad!

Just Kidding.

Come come now! You'll notice that the entirety of my statements on this forum make no insinuations or accusations against chemical engineers as a whole. I can see no reason why Golden Bear should make such insinuations against civil engineers.

And technically, I'm not a structural engineer. I'm a civil engineer who specializes in concrete and masonry design. Those people get to write SE after their names, and my business cards got lost in the mail.
 
Come come now! You'll notice that the entirety of my statements on this forum make no insinuations or accusations against chemical engineers as a whole. I can see no reason why Golden Bear should make such insinuations against civil engineers.

And technically, I'm not a structural engineer. I'm a civil engineer who specializes in concrete and masonry design. Those people get to write SE after their names, and my business cards got lost in the mail.

It's a moot point because everyone knows that Mechanical Engineers are superior to both.

I'm a civil engineer also, except when I get mad.
 
Ok, Gravy. What exactly does having one of the trusses fail after 1.5 hours prove, in your mind anyway? And how does 3 or 4 inches of sagging magically become more than 40 inches of sagging? I recognize that a longer truss will sag more, but that is a bit extreme. Also, if you look at the graph showing the sagging truss, most of the sagging occurs very close to one side of the truss, instead of the middle of the truss where you would expect. I'm not suggesting the maximum sag should be right in the middle, but reasonably close to the middle, and certainly not all off to one side.

In any event, the inward pulling forces on the exterior columns could just as easily been caused by explosives. If the core columns are cut just below the impact floor, the still attached core structure will no longer have any support underneath it, fall downwards, and pull the outer columns (which it is still attached to via the trusses) inward as seen in the pictures in your post.

Finally, thank you for proving my point and providing the entirety of NIST's analysis after collapse initiation. I like this one in particular: "The potential energy released by the downward movement of the large building mass far exceeded the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb that through energy of deformation." A few calculations to support this bald assertion would be nice. Maybe even an estimate of the potential energy released or the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb the energy? No? Now that's what I call an authoritative report.

Here's another good one: "The story immediately below the stories in which the columns failed was not able to arrest this initial movement as evidenced by videos from several vantage points." If I were being paid to investigate this disaster, I would definitely wonder why the intact columns underneath the impact zone, undamaged by fire or impact mind you, "failed to arrest [or even resist] this initial movement". The statement "as evidenced by videos" is superflous and merely tells us what we already knew: what happened. It does nothing to tell us why it happened.

NIST ignored everything after collapse (again, except for these few conclusory unsupported statements) because they knew they couldn't explain it using fire and damage plus gravity alone.

It is axiomatic in physics that a falling body will follow the path of least resistance. Which would resist the falling block of upper stories the most, the intact steel structure beneath the impact zone or the air surrounding the building? The only possible way the upper block of stories would fall down through any of the lower structure is if it fell perfectly symetrically and straight down on top of the lower structure. (Even if this extremely improbable event of perfectly symetrical falling did occur, it is likely that the intact lower structure would provide enough resistance to arrest the downward movement of the upper floors.) Any irregularity in the resistance provided by the intact lower stories would cause the building to fall off to one side because the air around the falling upper floors would provide very little resistance - certainly not enough resistance to keep the upper stories upright and falling straight down. (Side note - We can all at least agree that the lower intact structure would provide much more resistance to movement of the upper floors than air would provide, right? Or do I need to provide calculations for that one?)

The probability that asymetrical damage and asymetrical fire would cause perfectly symetrical downward movement of the upper floors to occur is beyond any rational belief. In fact, we know it didn't. The upper block of floors on one of the towers started to tilt before or during its fall, which means it certainly could not have fallen straight down, perfectly symetrically onto the lower structure beneath. This irregularity in resistance between the lower structure and the air around the upper floors would have expressed itself and the upper block of stories would have continued to tilt, fall off to one side, through the air, which provided the path of least resistance. Think about it - a falling block of floors which is tilted when it impacts the lower structure has part of the floor block hanging out over the edge of the intact structure below at impact. This means that air is the only thing resisting the fall of this overhanging portion of the upper floors. The portion of the floor block encountering more resistance from the intact structure will fall slower than the portion of the floor block encountering less resistance from the air, which will cause the floor block to tilt even more, and fall off to the side through the air.

Of course, in reality the upper floors did follow the path of least resistance: The lower intact structure didn't provide any resistance because the columns were being progressively cut using explosives. It is the only logical explanation as to why the upper floors didn't fall off to the side through the air.
 
Ok, Gravy. What exactly does having one of the trusses fail after 1.5 hours prove, in your mind anyway? And how does 3 or 4 inches of sagging magically become more than 40 inches of sagging? I recognize that a longer truss will sag more, but that is a bit extreme. Also, if you look at the graph showing the sagging truss, most of the sagging occurs very close to one side of the truss, instead of the middle of the truss where you would expect. I'm not suggesting the maximum sag should be right in the middle, but reasonably close to the middle, and certainly not all off to one side.

In any event, the inward pulling forces on the exterior columns could just as easily been caused by explosives. If the core columns are cut just below the impact floor, the still attached core structure will no longer have any support underneath it, fall downwards, and pull the outer columns (which it is still attached to via the trusses) inward as seen in the pictures in your post.

Finally, thank you for proving my point and providing the entirety of NIST's analysis after collapse initiation. I like this one in particular: "The potential energy released by the downward movement of the large building mass far exceeded the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb that through energy of deformation." A few calculations to support this bald assertion would be nice. Maybe even an estimate of the potential energy released or the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb the energy? No? Now that's what I call an authoritative report.

Here's another good one: "The story immediately below the stories in which the columns failed was not able to arrest this initial movement as evidenced by videos from several vantage points." If I were being paid to investigate this disaster, I would definitely wonder why the intact columns underneath the impact zone, undamaged by fire or impact mind you, "failed to arrest [or even resist] this initial movement". The statement "as evidenced by videos" is superflous and merely tells us what we already knew: what happened. It does nothing to tell us why it happened.

NIST ignored everything after collapse (again, except for these few conclusory unsupported statements) because they knew they couldn't explain it using fire and damage plus gravity alone.

It is axiomatic in physics that a falling body will follow the path of least resistance. Which would resist the falling block of upper stories the most, the intact steel structure beneath the impact zone or the air surrounding the building? The only possible way the upper block of stories would fall down through any of the lower structure is if it fell perfectly symetrically and straight down on top of the lower structure. (Even if this extremely improbable event of perfectly symetrical falling did occur, it is likely that the intact lower structure would provide enough resistance to arrest the downward movement of the upper floors.) Any irregularity in the resistance provided by the intact lower stories would cause the building to fall off to one side because the air around the falling upper floors would provide very little resistance - certainly not enough resistance to keep the upper stories upright and falling straight down. (Side note - We can all at least agree that the lower intact structure would provide much more resistance to movement of the upper floors than air would provide, right? Or do I need to provide calculations for that one?)

The probability that asymetrical damage and asymetrical fire would cause perfectly symetrical downward movement of the upper floors to occur is beyond any rational belief. In fact, we know it didn't. The upper block of floors on one of the towers started to tilt before or during its fall, which means it certainly could not have fallen straight down, perfectly symetrically onto the lower structure beneath. This irregularity in resistance between the lower structure and the air around the upper floors would have expressed itself and the upper block of stories would have continued to tilt, fall off to one side, through the air, which provided the path of least resistance. Think about it - a falling block of floors which is tilted when it impacts the lower structure has part of the floor block hanging out over the edge of the intact structure below at impact. This means that air is the only thing resisting the fall of this overhanging portion of the upper floors. The portion of the floor block encountering more resistance from the intact structure will fall slower than the portion of the floor block encountering less resistance from the air, which will cause the floor block to tilt even more, and fall off to the side through the air.

Of course, in reality the upper floors did follow the path of least resistance: The lower intact structure didn't provide any resistance because the columns were being progressively cut using explosives. It is the only logical explanation as to why the upper floors didn't fall off to the side through the air.
And when will you be publishing your earth-shattering paper in a lowly engineering journal to wow all those intellectually inferior structural and civil engineers? You have all the answers, right?

eta: "perfectly symetrically and straight down" - you really don't know much about this subject, do you?
 
Last edited:
Back it up, GoldenBear. You want to move to yet another subject, without showing any ability to deal with the claims you've already made? That's a common conspiracist tactic that we reject here.

Fifth time: What did Larry Silverstein hope to "get away with," when the insurance and loan contracts were in writing and were legally enforceable?

Answer the question, GB. You brought it up.

Then we'll move to the next topic. I'm not going to engage with you if you can't support your claims.
 
I will, however, respond to this. Sometimes things catch my eye and I can't resist.

GoldenBear said:
In any event, the inward pulling forces on the exterior columns could just as easily been caused by explosives. If the core columns are cut just below the impact floor, the still attached core structure will no longer have any support underneath it, fall downwards, and pull the outer columns (which it is still attached to via the trusses) inward as seen in the pictures in your post.


The inward bowing of the exterior columns on both towers took place gradually, over many minutes. The problems with the south side of the north tower were reported by a NYPD aviation unit 20 minutes before collapse.

Is any of this sinking in, GB?
 
Last edited:
Having read this entire thread, I completely understand why any skeptic would take issue with Golden Bear's posts. What kind of a critical and rational thinker declares that nothing will ever convince him that his unsubstantiated beliefs might be wrong?

If Golden Bear is really a "scientist" as he claims, the prior point is even more clearly made by the engineers and scientists among the membership here as Golden Bear could and would legitimately be viewed as an embarrassment to your professions in light of his declaration that nothing will convince him that his unsubstantiated beliefs may require modification. What kind of scientist would ascribe to such a ridiculous position?

I have to add, regrettably, that if Golden Bear is really a lawyer as he claims, he could and would legitimately be viewed as an embarrassment to my profession as well, in light of his declaration that nothing will convince him that his unsubstantiated beliefs are wrong. That's tantamount to saying that no manner and no amount of evidence would ever convince him that his existing view of the strength or weakness of his case may require modification. What kind of lawyer would ascribe to such a ridiculous position?
 
What kind of lawyer would ascribe to such a ridiculous position?
I suspect GB isn't really a scientist or a lawyer, he just plays one on the internet. Thus his reluctance to actually discuss anything in detail.
 
I suspect GB isn't really a scientist or a lawyer, he just plays one on the internet. Thus his reluctance to actually discuss anything in detail.

Anyone else think that his nick(sock?) was specifically chosen to annoy(mock?) Gravy?
 
I suspect GB isn't really a scientist or a lawyer, he just plays one on the internet.

Ouch. Ad hominems with no substantive rebuttal. Can you seriously not tell from the quality of my writing that I'm a lawyer? Very few of you have found the time to respond substantively, but instead lob ad hominems my way at will. Great job on the "critical thinking" everyone. Gravy is the only one that even takes a shot substantively, and I very much appreciate that compared to the rest of you. Why would I come on here and just make up my credentials? Fine - those of you that don't believe my credentials, just think that I'm a car salesman that happens to be a good writer.

@Wildcat - My reluctance to discuss anything in detail? Why don't you try responding substantively instead of accusing me of lying about who I am. Yeah, you're right, I flip burgers at McDonald's. Can't you tell.

@LashL - I would never call another lawyer an embarassment to the profession for believing or not believing in the so called "conspiracy theories". There are several lawyers at my firm whom I greatly respect, and who I think are great lawyers, that don't believe these theories have any credence. Again, I say that's fine with me. But to call me an embarrassment to the profession for coming here and presenting my views in a coherent, succinct fashion is itself an embarrassment to the profession. Shame on you.

I guess the ad hominems never stop around here, and the substantive discussion rarely gets any traction.

@Gravy - I don't care whether you are right or wrong about Larry Silverstein benefitting personally. Let's assume for purposes of this discussion that you are right - I honestly haven't looked into it enough to try and debate you about it. Can we move on to the WTC please? Although I don't agree with your calling me "childish" or an "intellectual coward", you at least offer some substance to your posts, which is more than can be said for most here. I guess they leave the real debating to you.
 
To get a couple of matters out of the way at the outset: Yes, I believe 9/11 was likely an inside job perpetrated by criminal elements of the U.S. government. No, I will not marshal any evidence to support my belief, so don’t ask (or waste your breath asking, I don’t care).



I only have one question I'd like to ask. I hope you'd be kind enough to answer.

If you do not have evidence that 9/11 was carried out by elements of the US Government, why do you believe it was?

And welcome to the forums. :)

-Gumboot
 
Seriously? Because Evil Genius either (1) knew where the airplanes would impact the buildings and planned the explosive progression accordingly, or (2) knew the planes would impact the buildings somewhere and wrote a computer program to control the detonation accordingly, starting the explosives at the impacting floors first (which the user would input).

So the explosives survived the impact of the planes?
 
If you do not have evidence that 9/11 was carried out by elements of the US Government, why do you believe it was?

I didn't say I had no evidence; I said I wouldn't marshal it for you folks. You all have access to the same information that I do. Like I've said before: if you have looked at the available materials, both for and against the so called conspiracy theories, and you still believe airplane damage plus fire completely destroyed the Twin Towers and Building 7, that's fine by me. Nothing I can refer to outside my own head will change your mind. I can only give you my own take on what happened. The data is the same, the evidence is the same. It's just how you interpret it that matters.
 
Anyone else think that his nick(sock?) was specifically chosen to annoy(mock?) Gravy?
That would be difficult, since I don't care a fig about the team. I just wear the hat because it fits and isn't filthy. :)
 
@William Rea - I appreciate your comments. I wasn't trying to bash civil engineers or structural engineers, just trying to bring them back down here with the rest of us. A little hyperbole was necessary to check the undeserved angelic halo attributed to them by most here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom