Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

And it's interesting to note, just after WWGHA asks how to link to a non-internet video, KT posts, but does not correct WWGHA's interpretation of KT's post. So even KT himself agrees with our interpretation!

Busted on "normal videos", busted on "energy vectors". Care to try for a third strike?

That was his third strike. remember the "what truthers say it fell faster than free fall?" debate?
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2437317&postcount=110
 
What's up with all this, William? First you apparently made up an intervening post in a message board that never existed. Then you attributed stuff to a paper that doesn't actually say what you claim. Then you claim not to be able to find the quote one of the other posters cites, even though it's right there on page 4 (page numbers, not PDF page) of the paper and Acrobat Reader has a search function.

Also, the page 14 that you cited does not discuss vector components, it talks about energy and conservation of energy.

You also seem to have force and energy confused or something.

Are you being dishonest with the material you're claiming to use as sources, or are you simply confused?
 
Are you being dishonest with the material you're claiming to use as sources, or are you simply confused?



Now now, none of that false dichotomy stuff! It could also be that he's just not very bright.
 
Let's not be too harsh on William. I'm sure he intends to come here and post an apology for trying to mislead us and also admit that he was wrong about the gravity thing, after all that's what sincere, honest, serious thinkers like William do when their errors are pointed out.

He probably got lost on his way to the forum or something. I'm sure he has a perfectly reasonable excuse.:rolleyes:
 
2. The "normal" video link requested could easily be a link to a bit torrent for the original video, we don't know.



The above comment expresses precisely the same ignorance that resulted in Killtown's nomination.

You can't have a bit torrent of an original video.

In order to get the video in any sort of digital file format, it has to be digitised, and in the process it is compressed - uncompressed DV weighs in at about 1 GB for every 15 seconds of footage.

The original video is magnetic information on a tape. You cannot "link" to that.

-Gumboot
 
He probably got lost on his way to the forum or something. I'm sure he has a perfectly reasonable excuse.:rolleyes:


Well, I'm going out of town for a few days. Perhaps by the time I return, he will have found his way back, and his honour, and posted an admission of his errors.
 
William, you weren't trying to be intentionally deceptive just to spite us, were you?






[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/9902461490b17b08d.jpg[/qimg]

Link from Googles cache.​



I don't see Jarroyo's post anywhere, do you William?


Moreover, Killtown actually quoted WWGHA's post in his response so it is abundantly clear that he was responding to WWGHA's post and not to Jarroyo's post, as William Rea claimed.

Tsk tsk.
 
In comment to your post, I am being told that energy has no vectoral element so it appears that whilst it is apparent that everyone knows that gravitational energy makes stuff fall down this is simply not so. I also infer that thermal energy doesn't flow from hot to cold since it has no sense of direction.

In case you're wondering, this is exactly why I haven't started that "other thread" I mentioned elsewhere. If you didn't learn in Physics 101* about vector dot products and why kinetic energy is a scalar, then I don't even want to begin trying to explain the torques and cross products that are necessary to discuss rotational motion (ie, "the "tipping" of the top sections of the WTC towers.)




* or for that matter, Physics 102 or Calculus 201** (or whatever the equivalent was at the school you got your engineering degree at)

** or for that matter high school physics - I learned it at the age of 16, along with two hundred and fifty other high-schoolers.
 
The above comment expresses precisely the same ignorance that resulted in Killtown's nomination.
You can't have a bit torrent of an original video.
In order to get the video in any sort of digital file format, it has to be digitised, and in the process it is compressed - uncompressed DV weighs in at about 1 GB for every 15 seconds of footage.
The original video is magnetic information on a tape. You cannot "link" to that.
-Gumboot

DV = Digital Video. Even through he wasn't specific I don't think anyone would interpret video as anything but a digital video format. If Killtown was nominated on that basis then I'm afraid it is an even weaker nomination than even I first thought. I don't believe that anyone would ask for a link to audio on the internet implying they wanted to link to a cassette tape.

I am working under the premise that you are perhaps being ironic with the above post so will not make any further serious comment on it.
 
It's on page 5 of the pdf. Search on "inertia force", it was the first hit I got.
This is the full paragraph:
And the page you reference doesn't seem to be refering to vectors. It is discussing energy, but that's not the same as vectors. Do you know what a vector is? Focre is a vector, it has magnitude and direction. Energy is a scalar, it has only a magnitude.
This is pretty basic stuff.
Totally aside from that, the passage I quoted shows quite clearly that the vectors that you highlighted in the figure are not "energy vectors", they are force vectors, as defined above. You might be able to find some other reference to support your position, but you simply must acknowledge that that figure does not support your position.

The figure referred to in your quote is not Figure 2. I would appreciate if you could address figure 2 with your answer.

@ the forum.

I should have made it clearer earlier in the thread but failed to do so which is an oversight on my part. I am NOT trying to prove that energy as defined by classical physics is a vector, as I have said numerous times in the thread already. I am saying that energy has a vectoral quality, specific examples being that gravitational energy can only be released in one direction which is commonly referred to as vertical, that thermal energy only flows from hot to cold.

Energy is scalar as far as the scientific and engineering community is concerned. I will expect the same latitude from you on this as was expected by the forum when I started using engineering terms on here and was slated for using them in the strictest engineering sense.

I am however saying that the nomination for a Stundie was unfounded because there is a lack of understanding of the strictest sense of scientific language in the nominated quote. I fully take on board the rather ridiculous quotes around it but, they weren't nominated were they.
 
In case you're wondering, this is exactly why I haven't started that "other thread" I mentioned elsewhere. If you didn't learn in Physics 101* about vector dot products and why kinetic energy is a scalar, then I don't even want to begin trying to explain the torques and cross products that are necessary to discuss rotational motion (ie, "the "tipping" of the top sections of the WTC towers.)
* or for that matter, Physics 102 or Calculus 201** (or whatever the equivalent was at the school you got your engineering degree at)
** or for that matter high school physics - I learned it at the age of 16, along with two hundred and fifty other high-schoolers.

I was hoping to enjoy an exchange of posts with you because you came across as very reasonable in the previous couple of posts we exchanged. I am afraid to say that this post has reversed that opinion which is a little sad.
 
Well, I'm going out of town for a few days. Perhaps by the time I return, he will have found his way back, and his honour, and posted an admission of his errors.

Be reassured that if I am wrong I apologise, I have a record for doing this on the forum, in fact I believe that I am probably one of a handful of people on here with the humility to do so when proven wrong.

@ forum

I am also on vacation for a few days so it would be appreciated if the thread is not filled with posts mocking me for not answering posts within a period of time that is considered acceptable. Thank You.
 
Not sure I agree with your claim that Killtown was responding to an intervening post--note the word "normal" in quotes, which Jarroyo never uses. On the other hand, it certainly could be argued that Killtown was asking for a link to a site selling a "normal" video. So I think you're right that this should not have been included in the list.

Thank you for your reasoned response, it is very welcome and absolutely in keeping with how I'd like the thread to be.

I was sure when I visited the thread that I read it exactly as I quoted. I cannot get back into the original thread on LCF to check it again (it appears to be closed down). Without any further evidence to back me up I have no option but to agree with your analysis completely. Thank you for pointing this out in a very rational manner and please accept my apology for initially misleading you.

I fully agree with you that this apparent discrepancy on my part does not invalidate the rational argument that asking for a link to "normal" video does not qualify the nomination.
 
DV = Digital Video. Even through he wasn't specific I don't think anyone would interpret video as anything but a digital video format. If Killtown was nominated on that basis then I'm afraid it is an even weaker nomination than even I first thought. I don't believe that anyone would ask for a link to audio on the internet implying they wanted to link to a cassette tape.

I am working under the premise that you are perhaps being ironic with the above post so will not make any further serious comment on it.

You're kidding right? Someone asks for a link to a "normal" video, which by the context given refers to a non-internet video, and you dismiss this on the grounds that you think that it is unlikely they would really ask for that?

Do you know what an argument from incredulity is?

And why have you not addressed that fact that you falsified the cotext of the quote in the hope that we wouldn't find out? You blatantly lied!
 
Thank you for your reasoned response, it is very welcome and absolutely in keeping with how I'd like the thread to be.

I was sure when I visited the thread that I read it exactly as I quoted. I cannot get back into the original thread on LCF to check it again (it appears to be closed down). Without any further evidence to back me up I have no option but to agree with your analysis completely. Thank you for pointing this out in a very rational manner and please accept my apology for initially misleading you.

I fully agree with you that this apparent discrepancy on my part does not invalidate the rational argument that asking for a link to "normal" video does not qualify the nomination.
http://66.102.9.104/search?q=cache:...k+to+a+normal+video"&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=2&gl=us
 
You're kidding right? Someone asks for a link to a "normal" video, which by the context given refers to a non-internet video, and you dismiss this on the grounds that you think that it is unlikely they would really ask for that?
Do you know what an argument from incredulity is?
And why have you not addressed that fact that you falsified the cotext of the quote in the hope that we wouldn't find out? You blatantly lied!

I think it is unwise to argue that he was asking for a link to a "video tape" when the context of digital video quality degredation had already been raised in prior posts. I know for certain that this discussion is present in the thread because it's there in the google archive.

I believe I already addressed your last paragraph.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2496233#post2496233
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom