Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

Actually it is the work that gravitational energy does on the mass that makes stuff fall down.

No, gravity is a force. Gravitational potential energy is the measure of the work done by that force. The force does work, which is measured as energy. The energy is not doing any work, it is a measure of work.

You might use the words interchangeably, but that doesn't make you right.
 
Be reassured that if I am wrong I apologise, I have a record for doing this on the forum, in fact I believe that I am probably one of a handful of people on here with the humility to do so when proven wrong.

Then why is this not happening?

Instead you are presenting what can only be called desperate arguments where you try to redefine terms that are in no need of redefining.
 
Okaaaay, this isn't too pathetic William. I guess you zoomed right on past my post in the thread where I:

- posted a screencap of nomination post and the posts on either side.
- provided a link to the thread.

It's quite clear that Killtown was not responding to Jarroyo....

1) The steel and concrete are not the facade of the building. The Facade is aluminum. The wings and tail section were in fact completely destroyed by the steel beams and concrete slabs. If you watch a normal video (not an internet video) of the plane hitting, you will see that after the plane 'disappears' there is in fact a cloud of shredded plane skin falling downward outside of the building on the same side that it hit.

2) Now please answer this question - How do you explain the smooth, solid appearance of the world trade center's facade (when we all know it is not smooth and solid) in these pictures and videos?

1) link to a "normal" video?

2) Example?

That's the entirety of the context. Now please apologize for your behavior.
 
Last edited:
So you'd say that the Earth and the planets are held "vertically" in orbit then?
Not a direction.

If I take a bar of steel and increase the thermal energy in one end of it you're saying the thermal energy will not flow to the other end of the bar?
 
Contradicting someone is not an argument. If my analysis is wrong I would prefer you to educate me as to how it is wrong. If energy does not do work a mass then what is the conversion process for potential to kinetic energy?

Energy never does any work because it is simply a measure of the work done by something, or the potential work that could be done by something - i.e. the energy stored in a system.

With GPE, the potential energy is the energy that could be released if gravity were allowed to act freely on an object in the absence of a restraint. As I said in my post above, gravity is a force that is doing work, and the energy measures are a measure of the potential energy that is stored in the system, or the kinetic energy that is being released by the system.

You simply equated energy with the element of the system doing the work when it is not. It's a mistake of terms, nothing else.

It's a crude explanation (I am not a physicist), but it should be adequate to clear up the confusion, I hope.

Your metal bar example also shows a misunderstanding of the terms involved. Simply because a situation involves a direction, that doesn't mean that every term involved is also directional. If I'm in a car and I travel at 50 mph to the north, that doesn't mean that my speed is suddenly a vector. Similarly, because the temperature of a steel bar being heated tends towards equilibrium does not mean that the measure of energy involved is expressed as a vector.
 
Okaaaay, this isn't too pathetic William. I guess you zoomed right on past my post in the thread where I:
- posted a screencap of nomination post and the posts on either side.
- provided a link to the thread.
It's quite clear that Killtown was not responding to Jarroyo....
That's the entirety of the context. Now please apologize for your behavior.

As has been posted before in the thread, he could just as easily have been asking for a link to purchase a "normal" video. As I've stated, that does not even mean that "normal" video even refers to a magnetic media. You are basing the whole argument on your interpretation of what Killtown means in defiance of any actual facts. I am pointing out that whilst alternative interpretations are viable the nomination does not hold.

Not an "internet video" could simply mean not a video that is suitable for bit streaming real time over the internet. A video downloaded at high resolution from a bit torrent is not an "internet video", it is a video downloaded from the internet. When I download high definition MP4 or avi files I don't refer to them as internet videos, do you?

I only have to show doubt, you have to show absolute proof that you KNOW exactly what Killtown meant.

This is all assumption on the part of the nominee.
 
Last edited:
I think it is unwise to argue that he was asking for a link to a "video tape" when the context of digital video quality degredation had already been raised in prior posts. I know for certain that this discussion is present in the thread because it's there in the google archive.

I believe I already addressed your last paragraph.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2496233#post2496233

WWGHA @ LC Forums said:
If you watch a normal video (not an internet video)

Killtown @ LC Forums said:
1) link to a "normal" video?

Why are we still even having this discussion, William? This is open and shut - WWGHA defines a 'normal video' as 'not an internet video'. Killtown then asks for a link to a video that is, by definition, not on the internet!

You cannot link to something that isn't on the internet, William.

And you have not yet addressed my last point. You willfully and knowingly lied about the context of that post in an attempt to strengthen your argument and hoped that I wouldn't notice.

At the very least, I would appreciate an apology for falsifying and lying about the context of the post.

I would also like an apology in regards to your accusation that the Killtown quote is an ad hominem attack and for you to retract that accusation.

These are very simple things to do, and it would certainly be an act of good faith that you can indeed recognise when you are incorrect.
 
If I take a bar of steel and increase the thermal energy in one end of it you're saying the thermal energy will not flow to the other end of the bar?

If you heat one end of a metal bar, yes the other end will also heat up due to the conductive nature of metal.

And you know what? I guarantee it won't matter how you orient the bar, it will still heat up, doesn't matter if you point the bar up, down, sideways, at an angle between these, anything. Because the heat is not a force being applied in a specific direction.

The air near the surface of the bar will also experience a temperature increase. What do you make of that?

I would also appreciate a retraction of your accusation that the "gravitational energy...which is vertical" is an ad hominem attack.
 
Why are we still even having this discussion, William? This is open and shut - WWGHA defines a 'normal video' as 'not an internet video'. Killtown then asks for a link to a video that is, by definition, not on the internet!

You cannot link to something that isn't on the internet, William.

And you have not yet addressed my last point. You willfully and knowingly lied about the context of that post in an attempt to strengthen your argument and hoped that I wouldn't notice.

At the very least, I would appreciate an apology for falsifying and lying about the context of the post.

I would also like an apology in regards to your accusation that the Killtown quote is an ad hominem attack and for you to retract that accusation.

These are very simple things to do, and it would certainly be an act of good faith that you can indeed recognise when you are incorrect.

The necessary apology already happened.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2496233#post2496233

I will not withdraw the ad hominem accusation because to my satisfaction it is proven so you are correct that it is open and shut. If you do not agree then I have no problem with that but I would prefer if you would make the point and let it stand rather than berating me for not doing something completely wrong like apologising for being right.

Indeed these things are very simple to do for everyone when they have mislead either intentionally or unintentionally.

I refer you to my previous answer.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2496364#post2496364
 
As has been posted before in the thread, he could just as easily have been asking for a link to purchase a "normal" video. As I've stated, that does not even mean that "normal" video even refers to a magnetic media. You are basing the whole argument on your interpretation of what Killtown means in defiance of any actual facts. I am pointing out that whilst alternative interpretations are viable the nominations does not hold.

Not an "internet video" could simply mean not a video that is suitable for bit streaming real time over the internet. A video downloaded at high resolution from a bit torrent is not an "internet video", it is a video downloaded from the internet. When I download high definition MP4 or avi files I don't refer to them as internet videos, do you?

You are really clutching at straws here. You are reading more into the quote than exists, rather than dealing with the given context.

Stop posting highly unlikely hypotheticals, stop trying to change the meanings of words to suit your definition, and just man up and apologise.

I only have to show doubt, you have to show absolute proof that you KNOW exactly what Killtown meant.

That's just about the dumbest thing I've ever heard. We can never provide 'absolute proof' that we know what ANYONE means. The truth movement could for all we know be a huge practical joke and everyone involved is in on it. But the balance of probabilities says that this probably isn't the case. Similarly, given the context of the Killtown quote, it is an entirely reasonable and significantly more probable assumption than any other proposed scenario that the one in which Killtown is unthinkingly asking for a link to a non-internet video is the correct interpretation.

This is all assumption on the part of the nominee.

Yes. And given the context of the quote, this is a perfectly valid assumption. Covered above.
 
As has been posted before in the thread, he could just as easily have been asking for a link to purchase a "normal" video. As I've stated, that does not even mean that "normal" video even refers to a magnetic media. You are basing the whole argument on your interpretation of what Killtown means in defiance of any actual facts. I am pointing out that whilst alternative interpretations are viable the nominations does not hold.

I only have to show doubt, you have to show absolute proof that you KNOW exactly what Killtown meant.

This is all assumption on the part of the nominee.


You have a link to the thread now. What was Killtown's response to:

The very next post by WWGHA said:
1) How the hell do I Link to a video that is not on the internet?? Get out your loose change DVD, i am pretty sure the videos playing in the menu will have a few examples of what i mean.


Was it:

"Whoa wait.... dude, dude - I was asking for a link to purchase some magnetic media or maybe a DVD, ie "normal" videos. I am not so stupid as to ask for a link to a DVD track or a VHS cassette. But I am so stupid as to not be able to use Google to find a link to purchase some "normal" media - so I have to ask you for the link in a manner that makes me look like I'm simply asking to be able to view a normal video with a single mouse click, kinda like I do with internet videos. Sorry for the confusion"

or was it...

"The videos are fake, what else do you need to know?"


Wiliam Rea said:
I simply did not feel inclined to answer you.

Why is that not surprising, considering this piece of deception:





================================================== ===
Actual context of the posts in the thread cut and pasted from LCF...

Originally Posted by Jarrayo in LCF

Excellent observation Amputees.

Obviously the WTC wall is not a giant solid smooth mass. Strangely in the video, it seems so. Why?

Because this video was recorded by who-knows what camera (could have even been a crappy one, such as a camcorder), I doubt the person who recorded gave the original footage to the person who posted it on the internet, so most likely he recorded it from a TV. After that, he send it to the computer. After that he compressed it by an enormous degree to allow fast internet replay. And after that it was posted on YouTube (or GoogleVideo) where it looses even more resolution. And after that someone made a screen capture of the already crappy footage and in most cases blew up the image to focus on the plane.

If you know about videos and graphics, you'll know that every step of the translation of the recording makes the video loose resolution. So the NPTers are basing their "evidence" on already faulty videos.

Response by Killtown

1) link to a "normal" video?

2) Example?

================================================== ==
 
Last edited:
You are really clutching at straws here. You are reading more into the quote than exists, rather than dealing with the given context.
Stop posting highly unlikely hypotheticals, stop trying to change the meanings of words to suit your definition, and just man up and apologise.
That's just about the dumbest thing I've ever heard. We can never provide 'absolute proof' that we know what ANYONE means. The truth movement could for all we know be a huge practical joke and everyone involved is in on it. But the balance of probabilities says that this probably isn't the case. Similarly, given the context of the Killtown quote, it is an entirely reasonable and significantly more probable assumption than any other proposed scenario that the one in which Killtown is unthinkingly asking for a link to a non-internet video is the correct interpretation.
Yes. And given the context of the quote, this is a perfectly valid assumption. Covered above.

Again I politely ask you to stop berating me to make an apology that is not deserved. The scenarios I present are just as likely in the context with the facts we know. Again I politely ask to stop telling me I am wrong and show me I am. the nomination was not mine, you are the prosecution so prove the case beyond reasonable doubt. I have given plenty of reasonable doubt.
 
You have a link to the thread now. What was Killtown's response to:
Was it:
"Whoa wait.... dude, dude - I was asking for a link to purchase some magnetic media or maybe a DVD, ie "normal" videos. I am not so stupid as to ask for a link to a DVD track or a VHS cassette. But I am so stupid as to not be able to use Google to find a link to purchase some "normal" media - so I have to ask you for the link in a manner that makes me look like I'm simply asking to be able to view a normal video with a single mouse click, kinda like I do with internet videos. Sorry for the confusion"
or was it
"The videos are fake, what else do you need to know?"
Why is that not surprising, considering this piece of deception:
================================================== ===
Actual context of the posts in the thread cut and pasted from LCF...

Originally Posted by Jarrayo in LCF

Excellent observation Amputees.

Obviously the WTC wall is not a giant solid smooth mass. Strangely in the video, it seems so. Why?

Because this video was recorded by who-knows what camera (could have even been a crappy one, such as a camcorder), I doubt the person who recorded gave the original footage to the person who posted it on the internet, so most likely he recorded it from a TV. After that, he send it to the computer. After that he compressed it by an enormous degree to allow fast internet replay. And after that it was posted on YouTube (or GoogleVideo) where it looses even more resolution. And after that someone made a screen capture of the already crappy footage and in most cases blew up the image to focus on the plane.

If you know about videos and graphics, you'll know that every step of the translation of the recording makes the video loose resolution. So the NPTers are basing their "evidence" on already faulty videos.

Response by Killtown

1) link to a "normal" video?

2) Example?

================================================== ==

Again, I will politely point out that I will not be berated by aggressive posting into making a false apology. I am on record in this thread for apologising for an unintendedly misleading post.

I have calmly and politely explained my rational position on it and again I politely point out that because I was incorrect about the posting does not make me incorrect regarding the central tenet of the incorrect nomination.
 
Energy never does any work because it is simply a measure of the work done by something, or the potential work that could be done by something - i.e. the energy stored in a system.

With GPE, the potential energy is the energy that could be released if gravity were allowed to act freely on an object in the absence of a restraint. As I said in my post above, gravity is a force that is doing work, and the energy measures are a measure of the potential energy that is stored in the system, or the kinetic energy that is being released by the system.

You simply equated energy with the element of the system doing the work when it is not. It's a mistake of terms, nothing else.

It's a crude explanation (I am not a physicist), but it should be adequate to clear up the confusion, I hope.

Your metal bar example also shows a misunderstanding of the terms involved. Simply because a situation involves a direction, that doesn't mean that every term involved is also directional. If I'm in a car and I travel at 50 mph to the north, that doesn't mean that my speed is suddenly a vector. Similarly, because the temperature of a steel bar being heated tends towards equilibrium does not mean that the measure of energy involved is expressed as a vector.

JonnyFive, as you can see I have my hands full with the other subject but I will get right back to you. I will have to sign off soon for a few days anyway so it may take some time.
 

Let's see what you said...

William Rea said:
I was sure when I visited the thread that I read it exactly as I quoted.

Let's see what you originally posted...

William Rea said:
Actual context of the posts in the thread cut and pasted from LCF...

So you claimed that you had directly cut and pasted the following from Loose Change Forums. Do you now admit that you were lying about this?

William Rea said:
Originally Posted by Jarrayo in LCF

Excellent observation Amputees.

Obviously the WTC wall is not a giant solid smooth mass. Strangely in the video, it seems so. Why?

Because this video was recorded by who-knows what camera (could have even been a crappy one, such as a camcorder), I doubt the person who recorded gave the original footage to the person who posted it on the internet, so most likely he recorded it from a TV. After that, he send it to the computer. After that he compressed it by an enormous degree to allow fast internet replay. And after that it was posted on YouTube (or GoogleVideo) where it looses even more resolution. And after that someone made a screen capture of the already crappy footage and in most cases blew up the image to focus on the plane.

If you know about videos and graphics, you'll know that every step of the translation of the recording makes the video loose resolution. So the NPTers are basing their "evidence" on already faulty videos.

This post occurs a full four posts before WWGHA's post. Also, you have reproduced it here with incredible fidelity. I would in fact say that it would have been impossible for you to reproduce Jarrayo's post with such remarkable fidelity (it is in fact, identical), typos still intact, without actually viewing the thread it comes from.

In fact, it would seem that you DID cut and paste this post directly from the Loose Change Forums. However, you did NOT cut and paste any of the posts that occur between this one and the post for which Killtown was nominated. This includes the one in which WWGHA replies to Killtown.

I would posit that it would be very difficult to miss WWGHA's reply to Killtown, especially as Killtown quotes it in the post he was nominated for.

In fact, Killtown even numbered the paragraphs in WWGHA's post and responded in order of the numbers.

William Rea said:
Response by Killtown

1) link to a "normal" video?

2) Example?

Here you have completely failed to mention that Killtown actually quoted WWGHA in his post, numbered his paragraphs and responded accordingly. As I have already established that you must have been on the actual thread to reproduce Jarrayo's post with cut-and-paste fidelity, this means that you have deliberately edited out of this post Killtown's quoting of WWGHA!

That is not some accident or mistake, William. That is deliberately changing the facts and trying to mislead the people here.

Not only that, but in your attempt to reproduce the context of the thread so accurately you ALSO somehow missed the exchange between WWGHA and Killtown that occurs after Killtown's nominated post...

Why Won't God Heal Amputees @ LC Forums said:
1) How the hell do I Link to a video that is not on the internet?? Get out your loose change DVD, i am pretty sure the videos playing in the menu will have a few examples of what i mean.

2) Look at the pictures in this thread, and the videos they come from! Look at practically any video on the internet of the second airplane hitting the tower.

Does Killtown correct WWGHA and explain that what he really wanted was a bittorrent link to a high quality MPEG4, or a link to a site that sells such videos? No - he simply dismisses all the videos that WWGHA has suggested are fakes...

Killtown @ LC Forums said:
The videos are fake, what else do you need to know?

So my question is this - why did you leave these out? Could it be because they support the idea that Killtown was asking for a link to a video that is not on the internet?

So you'll have to do better than a halfway there apology for accidentally misleading us.

Apologise for what you actually did. Apologise for deliberately lying to us in an attempt to strengthen your position, by editing the context of the quote from Loose Change and by omitting highly relevant contextual information from the thread in question.

I will not withdraw the ad hominem accusation because to my satisfaction it is proven so you are correct that it is open and shut. If you do not agree then I have no problem with that but I would prefer if you would make the point and let it stand rather than berating me for not doing something completely wrong like apologising for being right.

A question - why is this an ad hominem? How are we attacking the person here? We have ridiculed a request that he made, we have not insulted him as a person.

And another question - if you are so certain that this IS an ad hominem, then why did you deliberately edit the post in question (omitting the WWGHA quote from Killtown's post) and deliberately omit highly relevant contextual information (such as WWGHA post immediately preceding and following Killtown's nominated post)?

Indeed these things are very simple to do for everyone when they have mislead either intentionally or unintentionally.

Well, you have intentionally attempted to mislead the members of the JREF forums and also possible lurkers. An apology for what you actually did would go a long way to restoring your credibility. And a withdrawal of your accusation would go even futher in restoring your credibility.
 
And it's interesting to note, just after WWGHA asks how to link to a non-internet video, KT posts, but does not correct WWGHA's interpretation of KT's post. So even KT himself agrees with our interpretation!

Busted on "normal videos", busted on "energy vectors". Care to try for a third strike?

I don't know what facts you have based this assertion on because Killtown makes no subsequent comment regarding Amputees "normal" video question. Interestingly, Amputee doesn't press him any further so on the same basis as your argument I will infer that Amputee doesn't agree with his own question.

He only goes on to say that the video files in the suggested source are probably fakes. That is the only fact that can be derived from it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom