Could be...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2448632#post2448632
Or...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2480662#post2480662
Or...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2506344#post2506344
To be honest the only common definition I could find was that it was a chance to laugh at how stupid other people are, you can draw your own conclusion about the intent of the Stundies from that.
You can be as arrogant as you want, but if you're going to link to not one but three of my posts, you can sure-shooting bet I'm going to respond.
I those were the only definitions of The Stundie you could find I'm a bit shocked - it has been pointed out multiple times that they are a still evolving concept. I find it very interesting that you posted (with your third link) only two of the trial rules for The Stundie when on the very first page of that thread I clearly list a number of trial rules for April...
Let me point out some things you may have missed though...
Mobyseven said:... they deal directly with stupid things said by conspiracy theorists...
So the nominations deal with the things that are said, not the people who said them. This has been broadened to include debunkers as well, as can be evidenced by the March Finalists.
Stundie Rules said:Stundie nominations should 'stand alone'. Do not over-embellish introductions, but do provide comments. Do not use any blatant ad hominem attacks.
In other words, nominations must be about the actual thing being said and not the poster. Nominations must not even be accompanied by ad hominem comments.
From the third link again...
Mobyseven said:Make sure that nominations are being posted because of the arguments or claims being put forward and not simply because you dislike the person.
And in regards to any ad hominem attacks that are posted...
Mobyseven said:Be advised too that even if you do post such nominations here, they won't make it through to the final vote.
As for your second link - I don't think that posting the tongue-in-cheek in-joke ridden Stundie speech is entirely convincing as an argument. After all, it is a work of humor, not a strict definition of The Stundies.
Now, once again you seem to have missed my post from above. I'll repost it here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2496528&postcount=79
William, you appear to have completely ignored my analysis here. Admittedly, this could be because I pointed out your complete intellectual dishonestly and requested an apology, but I suppose it is possible you just missed it on your way through.
I would like you to address this, and if you cannot, I would appreciate an apology both for the fact you deliberately tried to lie about the context of the quote and a retraction of your accusation that this is an ad hominem.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
I would then like you to answer this question:
Is gravitational potential energy a vector?
All this requires is a yes / no answer.
If your answer is yes, then you will have to explain to us all how energy can be a vector, and how you came to this discovery that will overturn most of what we know about Newtonian physics.
If your answer is no, then I would appreciate a retraction of your accusation that, "...gravitational energy, which is vertical..." is an ad hominem attack.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Then, as you claimed to have found, "...at least two..." ad hominem attacks in the March Stundie Finalists, I would appreciate it if you could please continue to point out ad hominem attacks that are present there.
I imagine that I am not the only one who would like to see these things addressed, but I thought I'd break it down into sections for you for ease of reference.
Peace Out
Mobyseven
Would you kindly address the issues that have been raised here?