planning a more formal debate internet radio show

water_bender

New Blood
Joined
Dec 24, 2006
Messages
22
i'm putting together a concept for a new (yes another) internet radio talk show that follows a more structured and formal method of debate and discussion. it will incorporate aspects of a forum/chat room as well as a live on air voice aspect. at this current time i intend to produce the show once a week, though that could increase if demand allows it.

the core of the concept is a fair, moderated debate, equally moderated requiring both sides of the debate to adhere to certain rules such as fact checking, and the exclusion of bias and personal attack. there will be two moderators, one on the side of the official story and one on the side of those that doubt the official story. each moderator will be expected to remain fair and balanced, regardless of the what side is being moderated. each show will have a specific topic of discussion, announced atleast a week or more in advance, and a supporter of each side will be asked to be 1 of the two speaking guests that week.open discussion will be encouraged in the forum the week leading up to the debate as a period of fact and information collection, there will be a live chat room during the show to offer support to the (master..haha) debaters, though it will be a rule of the debate that only factual and sourced information may be offered during the discussion (no speculation, though logical deduction can be allowed), there will be a segment that will be open to speculation, and most likely a call in segment, though the listener call in aspect may not be used at all.

i will most likely be acting as moderator for the 'truther' side, and anyone interested in being a permanent mod for the 'skeptics' side please pm me. i'll be 'interviewing' from there.

as a side note, moderators are allowed to take part in the debate as well, provided they also follow the rules. after all it will be in essence the moderators show.

any takers?

i'm open to legitimate suggestions as to the format of the show itself as well.
 
How can you have a "facts only" debate when one side, in the words of Beachnut, has no facts?

And doesn't having a moderator allocated to each side sort of defeat the purpose of having a moderator?

-Gumboot
 
no it doesn't. it provides a platform of fair moderation. i guess we can count you out for participation.
 
So, you're proposing a two-on-two debate, essentially.

And as Gumboot, paraphrasing Beachnut's favorite topic, points out, what someone like R.Mackey would accept as "facts" and what a Truther Moderator (yourself, for instance) would accept as "facts" may be rather far apart. The Alternate Conspiracists view rumor and innuendo as evidence, after all.

Assume you have yourself as Mod T(ruth), Gumboot as Mod S(keptic), and Mackey v. Ace Baker. Debate #1 would never get off the ground while everyone decides what is acceptable as a fact. Truthers ideas of facts include "well it seems obvious to me".

Besides, as fact-finding missions or educational material, debates really rather suck! Debating is an art unto itself. That's why Fetzer so cheerily accepts offers to debate and TS1234(Ace) also would accept. If they're allowed an open mike, experienced debaters know how to take control of the debate and get their non-sequiturs and ad-homs into the record and accepted by the viewers as "points". Debating is a form of sophistry. You play to the crowd, whether that crowd is an audience or a group of judges on a panel. Some are very good at it. In fact, debate teams at Universities traditionally take either side in an argument. The win is determined by who argues better - not who has the most facts.
 
water_bender:

Could you give us a run down of how the show would run? Just a preliminary idea?

Also, how are you planning to record the show? And who is going to edit the show - I assume that the show will be cooperatively by a member of the truth movement and a skeptic, so a to eliminate any possible bias from the final show?

It sounds like an interesting idea, anyway. Any idea what the first debate could be about?

Peace Out

Mobyseven​
 
simply put a fact is a fact. if you need me to link you to a dictionary definition i can, but i would hope that you are beyond that. is innuendo a fact? no. is speculation a fact? only if that speculation has an outcome that can be rendered true or false. there's one thing that so many people seem to forget. facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts. and therein lies the point to what i'm presenting. laying out the facts and making a determination as to whether that fact is a true statement or a flase one. weed out the opinions and misconceptions based on faulty logic and to put an end to theories based on non factual evidence.

might i remind you that this isnt a game. therefore there is no 'winner'. arguments arent made for points, and the only thing 'won' in the end is that those involved and those that listen will walk away with a better understanding of what is true, what is un true, what things are possible and plausible, and what things are not possible and or not plausible.

this will be (in short) a debate between 4 people, 2 of which are taking one side in general principle and the other 2 the opposing. nothing will be considered static, as noone is locked into suporting or defensing any given point. the only people allowed to directly ask questions in the debate will be the moderators. guests will be asked by either moderator questions which the guests will be expected to answer and generally adhere to. the strict guidelines of criminal witness testimony however will not be adhered to. in some cases a yes or no answer simply isnt enough to answer a yes or no question. the 'panel' of listeners and chatters may suggest points to question or offer up supporting evidence to a given question but the duty of including such things falls onto the moderator, although a guest may add info as they see fit. conjecture will not be permitted, but logical deduction will be allowed, and there will be a time a lotted for sheer speculation. at the end of a show i intend and expect for there to be a list of facts, proven to be true or untrue, as well as a list of facts that cannot be decided upon pending more evidence, lies and fallacies will be expected to ocur at some point but i intend to eagerly correct any mistakes made.

i am thinking the first debate might be to describe and examine the different theories what they claim and how within the realm reasonable there are wide diferences in opinion
 
i ant the show to be basically live. editing will be limited as i prefer original footage(even if it goes bad) so that arguments of tampering cant occur.
 
simply put a fact is a fact. if you need me to link you to a dictionary definition i can, but i would hope that you are beyond that. is innuendo a fact? no. is speculation a fact? only if that speculation has an outcome that can be rendered true or false. there's one thing that so many people seem to forget. facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts. and therein lies the point to what i'm presenting. laying out the facts and making a determination as to whether that fact is a true statement or a flase one. weed out the opinions and misconceptions based on faulty logic and to put an end to theories based on non factual evidence.
Do you have an example of one single fact from the truther side that supports the CT?

If you do, then "fact" doesn't mean wha you think it does.
 
i am thinking the first debate might be to describe and examine the different theories what they claim and how within the realm reasonable there are wide diferences in opinion

Hmm...a suggestion.

While I agree that giving a broad overview of different theories is a good tact for a first episode, there isn't really any call for debate with such a focus - any debate that occurs is going to automatically branch out into the technical aspects that would be best covered in debate on another show. For example, the WTC7 collapse, the crash at the Pentagon, etc...

Perhaps a broad overview of different theories could be offered as an introduction to the show, and the first debate topic could be something different, perhaps more specific?

Also, when you give an overview of different theories, how many different theories would be mentioned? And which ones?
 
Personally I'd run it like we do an inquiry in the UK. Each side would have a paper which would be circulated, in advance, to the other in order that they could focus on the points in dispute. Responses are then circulated. And then the debate begins.

But that's just my thought. It avoids the risk of ambush and if anyone tables a "false" fact then there's time for both sides to prepare information to rebut it.
 
simply put a fact is a fact. if you need me to link you to a dictionary definition i can, but i would hope that you are beyond that.

When you learn where the Caps key is, you can be snide and condescending. Until then, let it be.

is innuendo a fact? no. is speculation a fact? only if that speculation has an outcome that can be rendered true or false.

Ask that of Fetzer, Bermas, Griffin, Jones, Jones, Woods, Barrett, Ryan, et al These are the people who constantly recant myths and urban legends as "facts". These are the people who quote opinion pieces as "researched articles".

there's one thing that so many people seem to forget. facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts.

Now who needs the dictionary definition of "fact". If a fact is wrong, then it's not a fact! Are you trying for a Stundie?


and therein lies the point to what i'm presenting. laying out the facts and making a determination as to whether that fact is a true statement or a flase one. weed out the opinions and misconceptions based on faulty logic and to put an end to theories based on non factual evidence.

Okay.

might i remind you that this isnt a game. therefore there is no 'winner'. arguments arent made for points, and the only thing 'won' in the end is that those involved and those that listen will walk away with a better understanding of what is true, what is un true, what things are possible and plausible, and what things are not possible and or not plausible.

I'm afraid you may need that dictionary again. A debate as I was speaking of it and as it's practiced in University, College, and even High School, is a contest. You may have never heard it used that way, but there are actual competitions. Google is our friend.

this will be (in short) a debate between 4 people, 2 of which are taking one side in general principle and the other 2 the opposing. nothing will be considered static, as noone is locked into suporting or defensing any given point. the only people allowed to directly ask questions in the debate will be the moderators. guests will be asked by either moderator questions which the guests will be expected to answer and generally adhere to. the strict guidelines of criminal witness testimony however will not be adhered to. in some cases a yes or no answer simply isnt enough to answer a yes or no question.

<<snip>>

I have no problem with the rest that you're proposing, but it sounds a lot more like a panel discussion and free-for-all. With the moderators taking sides, and actually in more likelihood taking a starring role.

And, as I said, I don't see great value in debates (panel discussions, etc...). I'd far rather see a good journalist interviewing a subject on a difficult topic, or read a well-researched and documented article or paper. But, hey! That's just me. Bust a gut trying!
 
Good grief, another self important internet radio show with a handful of listeners.

No thanks.

If you have proof that 911 was a govt conspiracy then present it. No more games.
 
The lad made a proposition; I reckon we should be making suggestions as to how such a forum might work, rather than simply getting stuck into the fella.
 
Personally I'd run it like we do an inquiry in the UK. Each side would have a paper which would be circulated, in advance, to the other in order that they could focus on the points in dispute. Responses are then circulated. And then the debate begins.

But that's just my thought. It avoids the risk of ambush and if anyone tables a "false" fact then there's time for both sides to prepare information to rebut it.

That sounds like a very good idea to me. Also means there are specific talking points for the debate.

The lad made a proposition; I reckon we should be making suggestions as to how such a forum might work, rather than simply getting stuck into the fella.

Agreed.
 
Guys, I'm just expressing my personal opinion. If you want to take the bait and discuss rules of evidence with water bender and pursue this, feel free to do so.

Ya oughta know me by now, most of you.... I don't base my positions of whimsy.

Ergo, before anyone steps into this spider's web, you might want to see the lengths to which WB will take a discussion of a relatively insignificant issue. The crappy quality of the DoubleTree video. This would be like the discussions with Ace on setting up a debate according to ever-shifting rules. Only in this case, it'd be more into minute and obscure details. Remember, this is a guy who said above that facts can be both wrong and right!

Homework Assignment:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=71167

Can you establish factual vs. non-factual with someone who will not budge an inch?
 
Debate is the wrong forum for Inside Job 9/11 discussions. Water Bender, get your facts together, present them to a U.S. Attorney, and leave it up to the judicial and prosecutorial systems to determine whether a case can be made, charges made, and adjudication is warranted.

Inside Job 9/11 deals with non-facts versus facts.

Calling yourself a "truther" indicates that you have no idea what the concept of truth entails. Calling yourself an "obscurer" is much more accurate. Try it on. It'll start rolling off the tip of your tongue before you know it.
 
i am thinking the first debate might be to describe and examine the different theories what they claim and how within the realm reasonable there are wide diferences in opinion

:confused: :confused: :confused:
I think you should first learn to create a coherent sentence before appointing yourself moderator of this debate.


facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts.

So it's a fact that Abraham Lincoln was the first president of the United States?

simply put a fact is a fact. if you need me to link you to a dictionary definition i can, but i would hope that you are beyond that.

I'll do it for you.

Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1) - Cite This Source
fact /fækt/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[fakt]
–noun
1. something that actually exists; reality; truth: Your fears have no basis in fact.
2. something known to exist or to have happened: Space travel is now a fact.
3. a truth known by actual experience or observation; something known to be true: Scientists gather facts about plant growth.

Steve S.
 
Steve, Conspi; lads.

Any problems with my suggested UK PLI format? There are no unfair ambushes, particular areas of concern (eg disputed "facts") are flagged up in advance, and so on.
 
Can you establish factual vs. non-factual with someone who will not budge an inch?

That's the point of the precognitions and the responses; if anyone is blatantly misrepresenting an issue or evidence then the other team has the chance to (a) prepare their detailed rebuttal accordingly or (b) point out that it's all a sham, and drop out.
 
this is the same water-bender that is on myspace, and believes the crap in The Pentacon.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom