It has become clear to me that the Stundies Nominations are being misrepresented in the Finals thread so I will add some clarification starting with...
Because of the title
"[Kevin Barrett discusses his vacat...'research field trip'...]" and the original nomination in which ref nominates it on the grounds
"Kevin Barrett, who really did his groundwork before he went to Morocco to find the alive hijacker. He is working hard to find him:"
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2609944#post2609944
you might think the Stundie nomination was for Kevin Barrett having a jolly but no, after being challenged on that basis it turns out the
REAL AND IMPORTANT nomination was really for
dreaming of interviews with elusive still-living suicide hijackers. So I have retitled the finalist for the sake of clarity.
Okay, keeping it factual, let's take a look at the instant replay:
This Stundie worthiness of this nomination is disputed on two grounds...
1. Our interpretation of whether it is a field trip or a vacation is not Kevin Barrett's problem.
2. If using scene setting language is Stundie worthy then we'd better start nominating every author that ever existed.
This made it through to the finals for two reasons - that the trip Kevin Barrett describes sounds far more like a holiday than a business trip, and most importantly for the line,
"dreaming of interviews with elusive still-living suicide hijackers."
The hijackers are dead, William. Not elusive.
Request to void the nomination is denied.
"you might think the Stundie nomination was for Kevin Barrett having a jolly but no, after being challenged on that basis it turns out the
REAL AND IMPORTANT nomination was really for
dreaming of interviews with elusive still-living suicide hijackers."
Please note the equivocation here. Billy refers to "The Stundie nomination", and alleges that it was made on a different basis from that which was posted. Of course, in the post by Mobyseven that Billy is getting his information from, Mobyseven clearly indicates that he is discussing the reasons the nomination "made it through to the finals".
Everyone here knows that the Stundie awards are a two-stage process, in which nominated posts are then whittled down to the select 20 that Mobyseven feels are the "best". There are some rules that govern which posts should be nominated, and one result of those rules is that some nominations are automatically disqualified. However, beyond those automatic disqualifications, there are no rules that dictate which posts Mobyseven must allow, or not allow, through to the finals. He is free to make his judgements on any basis, and (and
this is the important bit), there is no rule that his reasons have to be co-terminous with the reasons of the original nominator.
So, Billy's objection is irrelevant, on it's face.
Having summarily dismissed the objection, I find it enlightening to address its merits, as an exercise for the student.
Billy asserts: the "
REAL AND IMPORTANT nomination was really for
dreaming of interviews with elusive still-living suicide hijackers."
Of course, what Mobyseven really said was, "This made it through to the finals
for two reasons - that the trip Kevin Barrett describes sounds far more like a holiday than a business trip, and most importantly for the line,
"dreaming of interviews with elusive still-living suicide hijackers.""
While he does use the term "most importantly", that does not take away from the fact that there are two reasons for the nomination to be forwarded to the finals. For Billy to entirely disregard the first reason, and arbitrarily declare the second reason to the be the "REAL" reason is disingenous at best.
On the issue of the term "most importantly", we must also consider that this is a vague, relative term. It implies a ranking of the reasons, but with no quantification as to what "most" means, we can say nothing more about its relative importance than, "It is greater than 50% of the whole" (as there are only two reasons listed). Without any evidence to indicate how much more than 50%, we have no basis to conclude that this was the "REAL" reason. One must then seek the input of the original author as to his intent in using "most", and it is clear from Mobyseven's quoted post that the interpretation of his intent provided by Billy is erroneous.
And there is at least one more basis for determining that Billy's objection is erroneous. Consider the emphasis he places in his objection: "
REAL AND IMPORTANT nomination was really for
dreaming of interviews with elusive still-living suicide hijackers."
He hits the word "dreaming", as if it was the dreaming itself that was the problem. However, lets recall what Mobyseven really said:
and most importantly for the line, "dreaming of interviews with elusive still-living suicide hijackers."
The hijackers are dead, William. Not elusive.
Clearly, from the second line, which Billy manages to fail to mention, it was
the subject matter of the dreams that Mobyseven found most objectionable, not simply the mere fact that he was dreaming. And as we all know, delusional beliefs about the nature of reality, expressed in internet posts, are prime fodder for Stundie nominations.
So there.