chipmunk stew
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jun 6, 2005
- Messages
- 7,448
(For those who are having trouble following along, this means "no")I will answer the question when you have given the full context of it.
(For those who are having trouble following along, this means "no")I will answer the question when you have given the full context of it.
It is nominated for the arrogance it displays.
Finalist 10 has been selected on an incorrect basis and should therefore be voided. The original nomination was on the basis that petgoat proposed that the WTC was wired with explosives by motivated junkies.
Let's keep it factual.
Well, that's just mighty big of you!I can't get back to the DU forum source because it appears to be having maintainance at the moment.
However distasteful and ad hominem I believe the Stundies to be, I will accept that the nomination is based upon the whole theory of junkies wiring the WTC and not just his assertion that junkies can be plausible and highly motivated.
The nomination is most definitely not an ad hom attack, because the stundies are not any form of refutation or counter-argument against any claims. They are a way of pointing and laughing at twoofers, and/or debunkers, for stupid comments they make.<snip>
The nomination is an ad hominem because it is attacking the people personally for perceived arrogance and none of their arguments.
One does not need historical context to recognize that Louder Than Words is facing nothing that can be even remotely compared to the challenges faced by the people they name-dropped.So now our little WR interlude appears over we can return to some analysis.
The original nomination by CW didn't really give a reason for the nomination...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2597392#post2597392
Although I did assume in my debunking post...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2655046#post2655046
....that it was because Loose Change was being arrogant by trying to compare itself to these people. As I said in that post....
"I dispute this nomination on the grounds that the relevance of these historical figures is subjective and that history has yet to judge any of the important figures in the 911 debate to the same extent."
....in other words it is actually subjective as to how great these people were (the KKK won't revere Rosa Parks and there are people who still insist that Nelson Mandela is a Communist terrorist). In addition we have not had sufficient time to analyse the history of any of the 911 movements with the same historical context as we have those figures, so it is actually premature to say that they won't ever have equal standing.
You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.[/Inigo Montoya]In your opinion it is arrogant for someone to say, "Like my heroes, I will not veer from my path". That sounds like reverence not arrogance, do you not have heroes that you aspire to be like?
The nomination is an ad hominem because it is attacking the people personally for perceived arrogance and none of their arguments.
- Person A makes claim X.
- Person B makes an attack on person A. [edit: I think this step would be more accurate as "Person A has characteristic Y."]
- Therefore A's claim is false.
The nomination is an ad hominem because it is attacking the people personally for perceived arrogance and none of their arguments.
- Person A makes claim X.
- Person B makes an attack on person A. [edit: I think this step would be more accurate as "Person A has characteristic Y."]
- Therefore A's claim is false.
[utter pedantry]I definately agree with that edit. "Person B" doesn't really enter into the argument, the argument is focused on "Person A".
Thanks Chipmunk and Horatius for responding to William's claims. I don't have time to address everything myself, and he doesn't respond to me anyway.
[utter pedantry]
There are actually three forms of ad hom:
abusive:
P1: A claims B;
P2: A is a C;
C: Therefore, B is false.
circumstantial:
P1: A claims B;
P2: A is in circumstances C;
C: Therefore, B is false.
and tu quoque:
P1: A claims B;
P2: A practices not-B;
C: Therefore, B is false.
[/utter pedantry]
Thanks Chipmunk and Horatius for responding to William's claims. I don't have time to address everything myself, and he doesn't respond to me anyway.
To be fair, he doesn't respond to me either......
Just say thanks. Or, say good job. Or, good point. Very good point. Thank you.How on earth is that a strawman?
Especially as you go on to confirm item 2 of my analysis by offering up some educational instruction.
This discussion has EVERYTHING to do with your perception of my communication skills, you're just not honest enough to say it.
What's your secret?
Dave
Well, that's just mighty big of you!
What's your secret?
Dave
The original nomination by CW didn't really give a reason for the nomination...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2597392#post2597392
You really believe that "Well history has yet to judge you so I assume you'd be OK with me comparing you to Hitler?" is an absurd outcome of applying the logic I applied to the Stundie?
You appear to have a good knowledge of logical fallacies etc.
Even more impressive if you are self taught btw (that's not meant to be condescending either - just in case I get called up for that).
@ other people
Ad hominem as logical fallacy
A (fallacious) ad hominem argument has the basic form:
Person A makes claim X
There is something objectionable about Person A
Therefore claim X is false
[utter pedantry]
There are actually three forms of ad hom:
abusive:
P1: A claims B;
P2: A is a C;
C: Therefore, B is false.
circumstantial:
P1: A claims B;
P2: A is in circumstances C;
C: Therefore, B is false.
and tu quoque:
P1: A claims B;
P2: A practices not-B;
C: Therefore, B is false.
[/utter pedantry]