Former Novus & Sylvia folks-Do you still believe in the paranormal?

Miss Anthrope

Illuminator
Joined
Oct 23, 2006
Messages
3,575
First let me say kudos to you former members of Novus and believers in Sylvia. I think it's commendable that you became skeptical of Sylvia and examined her claims.

In the spirit of the skeptical nature of this board, I would like to invite you to discuss and examine any current beliefs in the paranormal you still hold.

Do you still believe in psychics?
Do you believe in spirit guides, out of body experiences and the like?
 
I really shouldn't post anything here because I am not a former anything.
Just wanted to say Thank You for asking a question that has been causing my newbie fingers to itch.
 
I really shouldn't post anything here because I am not a former anything.
Just wanted to say Thank You for asking a question that has been causing my newbie fingers to itch.

You're welcome, and like our fishy friend said, newbies should definitely feel free to jump in wherever they like!
 
I had one response to a PM I sent out. Basically the person declined to post because they don't want to get into it, the reason being their "skin isn't that thick". This was a polite and sincere reply.

I started this thread because I am a little perplexed. While I think those that have turned on Sylvia deserved a much more delicate approach, I feel uneasy about giving supernatural beliefs a pass completely.

It's an odd feeling, a queasy feeling. Almost like I'm a little embarrassed to have to bring it up.

I'm not full of ire, and I'm not looking to bait these folks. I'm looking for them to bravely examine their beliefs in the same way they did for Sylvia. And I also feel that it is a little odd to just embrace "our enemies enemy" for that sake alone. As a site devoted to skepticism, we should challenge the woo regardless of the source.

While I struggle to put my finger on it, I can say my general sense is that I'm a little eeked out that the little statements of "I still believe" have been ignored--and on occasion commended--by skeptics who would come down hard on anyone not condemning Sylvia, such as SylviaRox. Granted, these people have not been hostile and should not be responded to in a hostile way.

An example: On the Psychic Reading for Darat thread, one of the people invited to post on the thread said "Don't let the disbelievers get you down" to this self proclaimed psychic, and it basically got a pass. I do understand an even tempered and civil approach is a good thing, but a complete pass?

I am uncomfortable with the complete hands off approach I've been seeing. I was uncomfortable starting this thread, but I felt I needed to speak up and ask the question.
 
Last edited:
I started this thread because I am a little perplexed. While I think those that have turned on Sylvia deserved a much more delicate approach, I feel uneasy about giving supernatural beliefs a pass completely.

For my part the old adage "choose your battles" comes to mind. Some of these nice folk are taking a big step into a larger world, as it were. I don't feel it is necessary to cram all the figurative 12 steps down their throat at once. We are not enforcers of a skeptic dogma, and to not let them proceed at their own pace would be doing so, IMO.

Allowing- to some extent encouraging- disagreement is at the heart of skepticism, scientific inquiry, free speech and intellectual integrity. In that context, why shouldn't "don't let the disbelievers get you down" get a pass?
 
For my part the old adage "choose your battles" comes to mind. Some of these nice folk are taking a big step into a larger world, as it were. I don't feel it is necessary to cram all the figurative 12 steps down their throat at once. We are not enforcers of a skeptic dogma, and to not let them proceed at their own pace would be doing so, IMO.

Allowing- to some extent encouraging- disagreement is at the heart of skepticism, scientific inquiry, free speech and intellectual integrity. In that context, why shouldn't "don't let the disbelievers get you down" get a pass?

You have good points, and honestly I don't disagree with them. I'm just coming from a different place. It's been gnawing at me.

I definitely understand what it's like letting go of this stuff. For me it amounted to my whole childhood and part of my identity as a young adult. I'm not trying to cram, but I do want them to look at it.

Snipped for the sake of keeping things simple.
 
Last edited:
I don't feel it is necessary to cram all the figurative 12 steps down their throat at once. We are not enforcers of a skeptic dogma, and to not let them proceed at their own pace would be doing so, IMO.

I agree with Piscivore: let's tackle one issue at a time. For now, the former NS associates have come a long way. I am mighty proud of them for that.
 
I don't believe that God or faith can be scientifically proven or disproven and to argue it is mute in my opinion. Thin skinned or not. ;)
I do question everything and I don't fall for just anything.

And no, I don't believe in psychics and many of the things that you all call woo.
If God falls into the woo category, then yes, I am a woo.
Oh well...

If, at the moment of my death and I believed in God and I find that there really was no God, it did no harm. If at the moment of my death and I were an athiest and found out there was a God? Still no harm.
What mattered was how I conducted myself while I was here for that is what will exist of me when I am gone.
ConspiRaider is right, life is beautiful without God if you have open eyes and minds.
(paraphrasing for lack of want to search the thread he stated it in)

I never questioned anyone's faith or beliefs in here and am quite accepting of everyone in here. I don't care what people's beliefs are, I care what the people are like.

I do believe that regardless of our beliefs, we simply came here to right a wrong and join forces to help bring a woman who is doing alot of harm to justice and to get others to know that it was safe to give Robert any information they had to help him.
Robert never cared about our faith and was grateful for our assistance.
 
I don't believe that God or faith can be scientifically proven or disproven and to argue it is mute in my opinion. Thin skinned or not. ;)
I do question everything and I don't fall for just anything.

And no, I don't believe in psychics and many of the things that you all call woo.
If God falls into the woo category, then yes, I am a woo.
Oh well...

If, at the moment of my death and I believed in God and I find that there really was no God, it did no harm. If at the moment of my death and I were an athiest and found out there was a God? Still no harm.
What mattered was how I conducted myself while I was here for that is what will exist of me when I am gone.
ConspiRaider is right, life is beautiful without God if you have open eyes and minds.
(paraphrasing for lack of want to search the thread he stated it in)

I never questioned anyone's faith or beliefs in here and am quite accepting of everyone in here. I don't care what people's beliefs are, I care what the people are like.

I do believe that regardless of our beliefs, we simply came here to right a wrong and join forces to help bring a woman who is doing alot of harm to justice and to get others to know that it was safe to give Robert any information they had to help him.
Robert never cared about our faith and was grateful for our assistance.

TBT, I specifically put this in the General Skepticism and The Paranormal sub-forum and did not ask about your belief in God. If I wanted to go that route, I would have posted in religion and asked about God.

I did not start this thread to insult you. I had a general unease but also a curiosity and a desire to discuss this with you. I used to be heavily into what I call woo myself. You answered the question, no, you do not believe in psychics, so, that's that. GOOD!

ETA: And I want to thank you for your very kind PM TBT.

Now, according to a very hostile PM I got from someone, you all can now now say I am responsible for one of those mentioned in the OP for leaving the forum.
 
Last edited:
I do believe that regardless of our beliefs, we simply came here to right a wrong and join forces to help bring a woman who is doing alot of harm to justice and to get others to know that it was safe to give Robert any information they had to help him.
Robert never cared about our faith and was grateful for our assistance.
Very much so, TBT.

I want to make it clear to the ex-NS people here that you do not need to explain your beliefs or defend them in order to post here.

Miss A., I understand your curiosity, but I would imagine that most of the ex-NS people are here to support what I am doing, and are not interested in defending their beliefs, which is exactly what they would be asked to do by some here, should they try to explain those beliefs to you.

But I can tell you that, of the ex-NS people who I correspond with, it runs the gamut. Some still believe strongly in the gnostic system which Novus was supposed to be about. Others do not. Some still believe in psychic powers (just not Sylvia's). Others do not.

Hope this helps.

Edited to add: I wrote this before seeing Miss A's post just before this one.

Whoever decided to leave the forum, I hope you will continue to correspond with me.
 
Last edited:
Uhg, what a lousy rock and hard place I am in now.

Ask questions, appear to be requiring answers and sabotage Robert's efforts?
Don't ask questions.

I find myself in quite a conflict over this.

Somebody wise PM quick, stop me from posting my stream of consciousness.
 
Last edited:
Miss Anthrope,
I wasn't insulted...I am a curious person by nature as well so I thoroughly understand it.
I have to admit that it did feel somewhat like "come inside said the spider to the fly".
I wasn't sure if God fell into the woo category so I just wung it!

It is extremely difficult to decipher the written word without seeing someone's facial expressions or knowing their personality so those of us who choose this form of communication are left with our own imagination as to what someone meant. I don't think anyone left the group because of this thread...
I think a few of us started to feel like a cattle farmer in a vegetarian recipe exchange forum a while ago and feel that there are other ways we can help Robert.
But I can only speak for myself and another that I know of...

Peace.:cool:
 
First let me say kudos to you former members of Novus and believers in Sylvia. I think it's commendable that you became skeptical of Sylvia and examined her claims.

In the spirit of the skeptical nature of this board, I would like to invite you to discuss and examine any current beliefs in the paranormal you still hold.

Do you still believe in psychics?
Do you believe in spirit guides, out of body experiences and the like?
Hey Miss A -

It's a good pair of questions.

I was former woo, but I was out of it by the time Sylvia and friends got dug in. I plead youth for being woo-woo, and the relentless stream of woo-turds that spit themselves across the country and the world in the 1970s. Very difficult to resist, especially since the woo was coming from so many angles, concurrently.

Got past it all, and today I'm about as hardnosed a skeptic on two legs as can be found.
 
Well Miss A I'm gonna get right into the tight spot with you.
I do NOT believe any former or current believer of anything needs to defend their beliefs to post in this forum.
But if what they are posting is their beliefs then former whatever or not they should be prepared to defend them.
Just because they can be useful to Mr. Lancasters very worthy cause does not mean they should be treated any differently than anyone else on the forum.
I also think that some of the formers have somehow linked SSB site and JREF forum site. They are not the same thing.
I have read some statements from some of the formers that Miss A did not mention that made me wonder why no response was given.

"Allowing- to some extent encouraging- disagreement is at the heart of skepticism, scientific inquiry, free speech and intellectual integrity. In that context, why shouldn't "don't let the disbelievers get you down" get a pass?"

Because in that context it's almost demanded that someone say what do mean disbelievers?
If some people are coming to this forum to meet psychics and get readings done and promote such then they should be prepared to defend whatever they post. No matter who it is!
If some people are are coming to this forum to help Mr. Lancaster with his SSB site then they should be prepared to defend what they post as well.
As am I.
 
Well Miss A I'm gonna get right into the tight spot with you.
I do NOT believe any former or current believer of anything needs to defend their beliefs to post in this forum.
But if what they are posting is their beliefs then former whatever or not they should be prepared to defend them.
Just because they can be useful to Mr. Lancasters very worthy cause does not mean they should be treated any differently than anyone else on the forum.
I also think that some of the formers have somehow linked SSB site and JREF forum site. They are not the same thing.
I have read some statements from some of the formers that Miss A did not mention that made me wonder why no response was given.

"Allowing- to some extent encouraging- disagreement is at the heart of skepticism, scientific inquiry, free speech and intellectual integrity. In that context, why shouldn't "don't let the disbelievers get you down" get a pass?"

Because in that context it's almost demanded that someone say what do mean disbelievers?
If some people are coming to this forum to meet psychics and get readings done and promote such then they should be prepared to defend whatever they post. No matter who it is!
If some people are are coming to this forum to help Mr. Lancaster with his SSB site then they should be prepared to defend what they post as well.
As am I.

I do not believe that you will find among the posters of former NS people any detailed talk about their beliefs. I am sure that you will find mention that although we despise the actions and fraudulent, harmful behavior of Sylvia, we have ALWAYS had the distinction of understanding the difference between the philosophy and Sylvia.

For those who have never been in this situation, it may be difficult for you to understand that there IS a difference. I am not here to debate it, or even defend it. I am just stating that from experience, there is so totally a difference.

The members of this forum have always shown us respect even when they have disagreed with any of our statements. This behavior has allowed me the opportunity to explore many of the other boards here. One must remember that it WAS the questioning and skeptical nature of us, NS people, that brought us to this point. We were skeptical, and when we were able to get around some of the communication blocks, AND read RSL, and of course, the JREF forums, it was a no brainer for us.

As to Miss A's questions. No, I don't believe in too much anymore, and what I do believe in is now in a constant state of flux. We are trying to right a very egregious wrong here, and it is a battle that I have chosen wisely.

I will not argue with you, nor am I leaving the forum. There are MANY bright folks here, and since there is no rule that says, "One must defend everything that they believe in" to be here...well, I will trust that I am still welcome.

Sylvia NEEDS to be stopped. I would venture to ask this question to all who have come to this thread. What is more satisfying to you....actually doing something to stop HER....or picking apart the remnants of her former church people who have left HER to truly STOP her.

Just a thought.
 
Miss Anthrope, really living up to her name

I'm going to have to take a risk here. I'm risking becoming a virtual pariah on this board for what I am about to post. But I feel with my whole heart I must say say my peace. Even if all the joy that is the JREF experience is a thing of the past because of it.

I have been asked by RSL to refrain from asking such questions because it may undermine his efforts.

Before I begin, I will confess my utmost respect and admiration for Robert Lancaster. He is a gentleman among men. I have never seen such a fine example of great, well tempered debunking as I have encountered with SSB. I fully support his site and efforts 100%. I understand his rationale in making the request. I love that he posts here. I love that former Sylvia supporters are supporting these posts and "seeing the light".

I do take issue with being told what I can and cannot ask. This is not the official message board for SSB. I felt like asking the questions. I am not always the most gentle of posters, and I am most certainly not always right. But my OP was NOT hostile. And it certainly was an appropriate question in the General Skepticism and Paranormal forum. It would have been an interesting discussion for me to see the OP play out.

I feel like I have just been told there are sacred cows here, and that I am in direct violation of the very "skeptical dogma" Piscovore alluded to above. I cannot ask such skeptical questions on the JREF board or I will be undermining Robert's hard work.

I'm sorry, I have a real problem with that.
 
I do not believe that you will find among the posters of former NS people any detailed talk about their beliefs. I am sure that you will find mention that although we despise the actions and fraudulent, harmful behavior of Sylvia, we have ALWAYS had the distinction of understanding the difference between the philosophy and Sylvia.

For those who have never been in this situation, it may be difficult for you to understand that there IS a difference. I am not here to debate it, or even defend it. I am just stating that from experience, there is so totally a difference.

The members of this forum have always shown us respect even when they have disagreed with any of our statements. This behavior has allowed me the opportunity to explore many of the other boards here. One must remember that it WAS the questioning and skeptical nature of us, NS people, that brought us to this point. We were skeptical, and when we were able to get around some of the communication blocks, AND read RSL, and of course, the JREF forums, it was a no brainer for us.

As to Miss A's questions. No, I don't believe in too much anymore, and what I do believe in is now in a constant state of flux. We are trying to right a very egregious wrong here, and it is a battle that I have chosen wisely.

I will not argue with you, nor am I leaving the forum. There are MANY bright folks here, and since there is no rule that says, "One must defend everything that they believe in" to be here...well, I will trust that I am still welcome.

Sylvia NEEDS to be stopped. I would venture to ask this question to all who have come to this thread. What is more satisfying to you....actually doing something to stop HER....or picking apart the remnants of her former church people who have left HER to truly STOP her.

Just a thought.

Why did you quote my post in yours?
Nothing I posted had anythig to do with what you posted.
 
An example: On the Psychic Reading for Darat thread, one of the people invited to post on the thread said "Don't let the disbelievers get you down" to this self proclaimed psychic, and it basically got a pass. I do understand an even tempered and civil approach is a good thing, but a complete pass?

I am uncomfortable with the complete hands off approach I've been seeing. I was uncomfortable starting this thread, but I felt I needed to speak up and ask the question.

I addressed this in a PM with Miss Anthrope but will address it here publicly as well because I am the one who made the post she is referring to.

In the particular thread that Miss Anthrope is referring to I responded to her in that thread with the following:

No, I wasn't implying that the disbelievers are not awesome. They were two separate thoughts...
1. Some of the people here are awesome.
2. Don't let the disbelievers get to you.

I could only state that some of the people here are awesome because it is only SOME of the people who I've come to know. Does that imply that all aren't awesome? Maybe they are - maybe they aren't. I don't know everybody personally in this community so I can't say with absolute certainty that everyone here is awesome - and we may all have varying definitions of the term "awesome" anyway.

When I said, 'don't let the disbelievers get to you" - it was based on my own personal experiences and the responses to some of the things I have said in the very short time I've been a member of this community. Because from my own personal experience, some of the "disbelievers" did get to me when I first began posting here. Why? Because I was not used to having my every word scruntinized as it was here. So yes, some of you did get to me. This was my very first experience being in a skeptics community and it was quite an eye opener for me. While I can honestly say that there have been many discussions that I've thoroughly enjoyed reading (and not just about SB and SNS), I was finding myself in quite a learning phase (and yes, that was a good thing for me) but because of the responses I was reading, I knew that for me personally, I was not at a point where I could feel comfortable jumping into those discussions. My statement was to caution the other poster based on my own personal experience that to remain here would require getting a little thicker skinned than maybe they were - because I know I had to.

Because my response to Miss Anthrope apparently was not satisfactory (otherwise she would not have brought it up again in this thread as she did), I sent her a PM to address it privately. And also told her that I would not be responding to her questions in this thread because how I feel about psychics, or out of body experiences, or anything else in the paranormal realm was not my purpose in coming to this community. I understand how the majority of you feel about those topics and have no desire to have my thoughts on those subjects, whatever they may be, picked apart and analyzed as that is not the reason I joined this community. I have the utmost respect for the purpose of this community and realize that while I'm also a skeptic, I have no desire to defend my beliefs. I came here for the express purpose of supporting RSL in his efforts and as a result of this thread, I have come to realize that I don't need to be involved in the discussions in this community to support RSL.

So while I will continue to come here to read the discussions, my support of Robert will take place outside of this community.

ST
 
Last edited:
Sylvia NEEDS to be stopped. I would venture to ask this question to all who have come to this thread. What is more satisfying to you....actually doing something to stop HER....or picking apart the remnants of her former church people who have left HER to truly STOP her.

Just a thought.

The sole purpose of the JREF forum is not exclusively stopping Sylvia Browne. It is a wonderful cause, don't get me wrong. I am offended that it is being implied that this is all black and white, one or the other.

My intention was NOT to pick you guys apart.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom