Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

The issue is how many would wish that they had had it done as infants, not those who get it done as adults.

True, but I'm arguing that this is inconsequiential, seeing as one state (uncircumcised) is 100% reversible and the other is not. So, the (my guess) relatively few adults that wish they'd had it done as infants can still get it done at the expense of some discomfort, while the already circumcised adults who wish they weren't can never get full functionality back.

From everything I can tell there are marginal costs and benefits on both sides, and it is just that the anti circ side makes massive appeals to emotion and often refuses to look at science since this is not about real risks and benefits but a PRINCIPLE.

I see the appeals to emotion on both sides. And yes, principle, the one about being allowed to choose, plays a part in my stance on this, but there's also the very pragmatic wish to err on the side of caution - in the case of my (hypothetical) newborn son, he'll hopefully have much better data in 18 years, and can make a more informed decision.

So for everyone who argues that there are huge costs, well then think this, if you reversed the costs vs benefits of the procedure would it make sense to make everyone uncircumcised?(if the procedure produced an uncircumcised state), if people argue yes then they simply do not seem have an evidence based decision.

I don't quite follow this. But I think I can try for a more clear statement of my own position:

- If it ain't broken, don't fix it.
- If you want to fix it, despite the data being unclear, the benefits of doing so small, the drawbacks of doing so not well examined, the procedure a risk (albeit small), be sure it's your own foreskin you fix, not someone else's.
 
I find your phrasing unusual; Isn't it more strange that a procedure that has such marginal benefits in the developed world has been supported for so long by physicians?

I guess it depends upon how strongly physicians feel about their role in shaping cultural traditions? Or maybe it reflects the fact that we all tend to be products of our environment? The idea that physicians can refuse requests for treatment is relatively recent. I'm trying to think of something relatively equivalent....maybe growth hormone supplementation?

What I'm trying to understand is where your limit is. What act performed towards a child leads you to conclude that it should not be tolerated?

Why is this of interest to you? My personal threshold is quite low, but my public threshold is much higher. I tend to be someone that is reluctant to impose my opinions onto others, so I usually require a moderately strong reason to do so. Plus my ethical consideration of others is strongly influenced by medical ethics, which promotes more of a hands-off, self-autonomy attitude than is usually acceptable to the general public.

E.g., is a Jehovah's witness withholding blood from their child a private matter?

Not if it's life or seriously health-threatening.

Or ritual practices that do not result in significant long term harm to a child, such as performed by some followers of particular religions?

Maybe. It really depends upon the nature of the harm. I use a hierarchy of death, disability, disease, discomfort, dissatisfaction. I think that in most cases, I would find the first three adequate reasons to interfere. The last two would depend upon the details.

What about removing the toenails of infants to avoid ingrown toenails?

If this were a general practice, there should be research performed to look at the overall benefit (i.e. advantages and disadvantages).

NB: I'm not trying to argue that these are equivalent to circumcision, just putting them forward to try to understand where your limit is. Give another example if you think these are inappropriate.

I don't know why you'd be interested in my limit except to show that it's unreasonable. I'm perfectly willing to concede that you think I'm unreasonable to save you the trouble.

My position is that circumcision should only be performed to a child when it is medically indicated, with very few exceptions (such as regions of the world where there is a high incidence of HIV). I am not anti-circumcision - it has its place. I think it is fortunate that the vast majority of men who were circumcised as infants are happy (if not down right enthusiastic!) about their state.

So the state should intervene? Or at the very least, we should be able to brand the parents with a scarlet M (for Mutilator)?

Linda
 
We should add the following:

The rate of infections due to circumcision is INFINITELY GREATER in circumcised children than non-circumcised children.

The rate of infant deaths due to circumcision is INFINITELY GREATER for circumcised infants than for non-circumsized infants.

So the question is, what is the tradeoff between a 4 four increase in penile cancer vs an infinite-fold increase in deaths?

Yes, these types of complications are rare, but then, as Z says, "So just because a disease is rare, we shouldn't bother taking steps to reduce our chances of getting it - or, more importantly, our children's chances?"
Thought I'd check in to see where this discussion was going and I find no one challenging these claims. You cannot support those false claims. I looked at volumes of research on this. It happens to be the second thread in this forum and we had a similar discussion on Skepchick. Circumcision decreases the rate of urinary tract infections though it is not by a great amount. UTIs are much more frequent and risky in uncircumcised boys than complications from circumcisions, though both are rare. It has been evaluated in terms of risk benefit by numerous researchers.

The rate by which infection is decreased in a healthy child in a low risk country is equivocal regarding whether evidence based medicine should recommend circumcision in a Western country. Technically, it is slightly better medically to circumcise. But given the cultural influences, it isn't a strong enough reason medically to recommend going against cultural beliefs in a low HIV risk situation.

Given high rates of HIV there is a strong evidence based medical recommendation to circumcise infants. And that again is what the medical research shows.

I'll repost the literature sources I posted in the other threads.

The state should not intervene in any case. It seems inappropriate considering the nature of the decision. However in countries facing high rates of HIV every effort to educate parents to the benefit of circumcision should be made. (Though it appears Linda is looking at the opposite intervention.)
 
Last edited:
Miss Anthrope, you show me any evidence that men who contract AIDS are overwhelmingly men who have not been circumcised, and you may rest with a clear conscience. Otherwise, you have no reason.
I'm assuming this has been addressed. But in case it hasn't, the evidence that circumcision decreases the risk of HIV is unequivocal, meaning it has been shown without a doubt to decrease the rate of HIV infection, including the mechanism which the foreskin increases the risk of acquiring HIV. There are HIV receptor cells in the foreskin.

The question is which infants (and/or adults) have a great enough risk of HIV to warrant recommending circumcision.
 
...
The HIV angle is just silly. "Well, we can give a mediocre reduction in risk in spreading HIV if we slice of the protecting covering for the glans, which contains a large portion of his body's nerve endings." Or you could just tell him to WEAR A CONDOM. That would protect him from all the STIs and even from paying for a baby. And it wouldn't reduce his pleasure, and lob off a piece of him without consent and with out anesthetic.
This is incorrect. You either haven't read the research or you have added some misinformation to it.
...We find anything done to a female unthinkable, but for males we don't even give it a second thought (This is from an white, Christian, American POV). Culturally accepted practices that are just stupid are still just stupid.
Show me the research any surgical intervention regarding the clitoris is medically beneficial and I'll look at it. Otherwise your analogy and assumptions here are false.
 
This seems to be a pretty dispassionate overview. Apparently there are good arguments on both sides.
This citation is out of date. It cites the
In 1975 the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) stated in no uncertain terms that "there is no absolute medical indication for routine circumcision of the newborn." And in 1983 the AAP and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) restated this position.
That indicates the conclusions are also out of date.
Circumcision -- Medical Pros and Cons At A Glance

* Inability to retract the foreskin fully at birth is not a medical reason for a circumcision.
* Circumcision prevents phimosis (the inability to retract the foreskin at an age when it should normally be retractable), paraphimosis (the painful inability to return the foreskin to its original location) and balanoposthitis (inflammation of the glans and foreskin).
* Circumcision increases the chance of meatitis (inflammation of the opening of the penis).
* Circumcision may result in a decreased incidence of urinary tract infections.
* Circumcision may result in a lower incidence of sexually transmitted diseases.
* Circumcision may lower the risk for cancer of the cervix in sexual partners.
* Circumcision may decrease the risk for cancer of the penis.
* There is no absolute medical indication for routine circumcision of the newborn.
I do believe all the "may result"s are now confirmed though I'll have to recheck on the cancer risk. The last statement, "there is no absolute medical indication", is flat wrong.
 
You're cultural bias is showing. We only consider the former a controversial medical procedure because it happens in our culture.

I think that in cultures where neither happens, both would seem equally cruel.

Especially since in not all cultures where they "circumsize" the labia, do they remove the ability for the women to enjoy sex.
I'm going to admit to a cultural bias and say in this case it is appropriate. There is no reason culturally to inflict any surgical procedure on any infant from circumcision to ear piercing. If OTOH, there is a medical reason like preventing HIV in a culture where HIV is devastating the population, then there is a reason.
 
Well, the percentage of circumcised men is very low in Portugal (and most of Europe, I think), and we are definitly not dropping like flies due to infections.

Face it, all the excuses for circumcision are just that, excuses. If 70% of all males in the world are uncut, I guess the medical angle for circumcision goes down the drain. It's a barbaric cultural practice, probably started as one more way for "holy men" to enforce their power over the population. It's depressing that in the 21st century, when we can do things that would put the ancient gods to shame, learned people stand to defend a ritual that should have been left in the Dark Ages.
Are you that oblivious to the plight of the nations experiencing the full force of the HIV pandemic?
 
The evidence for it being of some benefit is at best limited, at worst non existent. The truth is that by not getting it done until later, you're not putting your child under any realistic risk of ill health or impoverished well being.

Athon
Your facts are wrong. Apparently you haven't kept up on the research.
 
...
I am always amazed by how objectivity seems to fly out the window on this issue.

Linda
As am I.

These are the same people who pride themselves on being grounded in an evidence based world. But when the evidence doesn't fit their world view, be it politics or something like circumcision, then you see the same behaviors as woo believers, evidence be damned, I believe!
 
Well...Frankly, a penis, already pretty funny looking, is 1000000 times uglier with the foreskin.
And a number of we females prefer a circumcised penis. I have no excuses, citations or explanations, I like them bald. Wrinkly skins are just not attractive. It's purely aesthetic, and not the least bit scientific. If a beautiful (inside) man were not circumcised however, it would never be a deal breaker.

Combining circumcision with female genital mutilation (as in the OP) is kind of silly. The two procedures are so far removed from each other. This post should be split asunder as each subject should have it's own post.
It is easy to see why an emotional appeal finds an analogy. but medically, there is none.
 
... BTW, since breast cancer is more prevalent than penile cancer, do you defend mastectomies for every teenager? The absolute benefit would be much greater than the "moderate to tiny"....
These are false analogies. They may sound good to a non-skeptic, but a good skeptic can see right through them.

Here's my analogy: You are comparing trimming fingernails to a finger amputation.
 
HIV? Well, show me the rates of decrease in HIV transmission in children having sex. Otherwise, I'd wait until my child is of an age that we could discuss that so they can choose to have it done to themselves. Perhaps in their teenage years (not to mention that plain old condoms do a far better job in new sexual relationships).

I'm seriously dubious of a 4 fold decrease in UTI's in neonate males. Can you link the full study? It just doesn't make a lot of sense. Even so, what numbers are we looking at here? Does it still balance removing that decision from the child? ...

I'm not saying there's zero benefit. I just don't see the figures as that convincing that I would take away that decision from my kid. ...
Athon
In just the USA, your argument about waiting until the child has a chance to influence the decision would not necessarily be wrong.

But if you stop being so egocentric and take a seriously hard look at countries with high rates of HIV, as a parent, it would be negligent not to make this decision for your child before the child was old enough to actually be ready to make an informed decision. Consider asking your teenager to choose if they wanted to be vaccinated when they hated shots. Are they mature enough to choose that shot? Some yes, some not. Are they old enough to be sexually active? About 80% before high school graduation are if you go by the stats. So in a country with a high risk of HIV, and even in a population at high risk of HIV, the parent who would wait until the child was mature enough to decide for himself would be failing to do everything reasonably possible to protect that child from HIV.
 
Don't forget though that this is the same branch [WHO] that advocates acknowledging homeopathy as a legitimate treatment method.

Yeah yeah... I know that's ad homimin (sp?)

But I like to counter one fallacy (appeal to authority) with another.

:blush:
Could you cite a source for that claim? I find it hard to believe that the WHO supports homeopathy.
 
Pardon me?

I said my son was circumcised because of severe phimosis. I have an absolutely clear conscience based on the fact that his foreskin could not be retracted and both the pediatrician and urologist said it wasn't going to fix itself, and would indeed cause many problems for him. I have a clear conscience because I feel that his having this done at a month old rather than at age seven at the latest was much better for him...
And my son was circumcised because I thought it was better according to the medical evidence, and I've not met a circumcised man that wasn't sexually satisfied and I have no moral qualms whatsoever about my decision. As it turns out, I had not heard of this controversy before I made that decision. However, after an extremely thorough review of the medical literature, I have no regrets about my decision.
 
:rolleyes:

"The evidence that neonates feel pain and suffer as much or more than do older children and adults is conclusive and generally accepted today."....
I have little doubt infants experience pain. After having assisted in many an unanesthetized circumcision, I would never suggest a baby be circumcised without an anesthetic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom