On Again Off Again Airfones

Sorry, the date of the email exchange was February 17, 2006.
I hope this doesn't hamper any follow up investigation that might take place.;)

No that is perfect, thanks SWING.

So the email proves nothing, except that as of 2006 there are no Airfones on AA's 757s. It has no relevence to the airfone status on AA 757's for 2001.

So toss the email out as useless.

TAM:)
 
This is evidence that was obtained by an organization we support with a little help from us.

I believe it is significant.

You can choose not to but we have provided evidence and you have not.


So what are your plans for further investigation of this new evidence? Are you planning on locating the rest of the section of the manual? Are you planning on calling AA?

Do you think it's good practice for any legitimate investigative team to simply declare this as evidence without doing any further research?
 
I have asked you a question four times now, you now not answered. The question required a simple yes/no answer. It is in response to this post, you hate pseudo-sceptics and you people who simply say everything is fake.



Are you claiming the phone calls from the victims to their families were not real yes or no?

Phone calls, fake or real ?

I have answered you 4 times.

I do not have evidence to definitively answer this so I will leave you to speculate the possibilities for yourself.

You can keep demanding that I speculate this for you but I will not.
 
i did answer your question Lyte. i thought you were a researcher. When you first asked it, I said to you that I DO NOT need to do any research of my own, as I believe the official explanation on this matter.

TAM:)
 
The language used by the AA CSR doesn't lead me to believe that he is much of an authority on anything. "the pilots are able to stay in constant contact with the Air Traffic Control tower."

Not true. They are only in contact with the tower for takoffs and landings. Other ATC facilities (TRACON's and Centers) are in contact with the pilots the bulk of the time.

This guy sounds like a typical CSR who repeats what someone tells him. We are to take HIS WORD that there were no operable seat phones on AA77???

Quote:
Dear Mr. XXXXXXXX:

Thank you for contacting Customer Relations. I am pleased to have the opportunity to assist you.

That is correct we do not have phones on our Boeing 757. The passengers on flight 77 used their own personal cellular phones to make out calls during the terrorist attack.

However, the pilots are able to stay in constant contact with the Air Traffic Control tower.


Sincerely,
Chad Kinder
Customer Relations
American Airlines
 
The document also states that any maintenance to the system would need to be done by Claircom employees and not AA employees. If the system was rendered inactive and the phones themselves did not work...why would any maintenance be needed. Perhaps this document outlines the deactivation of one system and the installation of another one perhaps?

I have asked a similar question to Lyte at least 3 times. He has chosen to ignore it.
 
The follow up call: After reading the two letters to Kinder, RB asked if he had indeed written the reply. Kinder answered that he could not specifically recall having written it---he writes so many letters, he explained, and this one would have been written over a year earlier. But, he added: “That sounds like an accurate statement.” Kinder indicated, in other words, that it was a letter he might well have written, because what it said---that AA 757s in 2001 did not have onboard phones, so the passengers on AA 77 had to use cell phones---was, to the best of his present knowledge, accurate.

Sorry, the date of the email exchange was February 17, 2006.
I hope this doesn't hamper any follow up investigation that might take place.;)

Is his email address available publicly, or was there an inside source, that obtained his email?

TAM:)
 
The document also states that any maintenance to the system would need to be done by Claircom employees and not AA employees. If the system was rendered inactive and the phones themselves did not work...why would any maintenance be needed. Perhaps this document outlines the deactivation of one system and the installation of another one perhaps?


Well the manual does say that, but we worked on Airfones all the time(including system removal as I noted above) and only called Verizon when we needed parts. The part I find odd about the account is actually replacing the handsets(because ..................?) on the deactivated aircraft.
 
I don't think you understood what we are talking about. I am saying that the Jan 28, 2007 at the top is the revision of the document, meaning that it has been changed recently.

Unless you are admitting that you are wrong and this is obviously not evidence.

No.

"Software Release:" was probably the revision number for the document"

Wrong.. it was revision date for the software being used to look at the document according to source..

"and that the redacted area next to the term "Software Release:" is probably the actual software release number. It would make more sense as a standard format for a controled document."

This part is correct.
 
Are you referring to James or me? It was James who questioned the guy's motive which adds nothing. I simply provided plausible answers.

Do you still believe jetfuelA changed colors?;)


The following email content was confirmed by the authors.



Those work order documents are precisely what the article refers to as conclusive confirmation.

So conclusive proof? Not really. Is it leaning in that direction, sure appears that way.
So you have proof cell phones do work in flight, that checks with my actual use. Darn, we do not need seat phones.

You still have problems with fuel being like a cloud? Too bad, gee water is clear, Jet fuel is clear, and when you dump them in air, they sometimes form a white cloud. Like fog, like clouds, after many people showed you proof, you ignore. Very truthy of you. Why are truthers unable to comprehend simple ideas? I think your truth movement ideas are fogging your ability to think and make rational decisions.

But if you want to break the big news on this story you need to understand what ECOs are, you need some revision dates and how they are annotated on manuals like the topic manual, and you need to prove cell phone cannot work in flight.

Cell phones do work in flight, I have used them in 2001 and before. But it I can make anything work.
 
Originally Posted by Lyte Trip
Yep.

And we have evidence showing they were deactivated before that.
Quote:
Work Order ECO-F0878 dated prior to above 757 AMM page could not be located. [/QUOTE
]"deactivated by ECO-FO878" (first line of Doc)
This is the doc that gives the deactivation date. You can't find it. You said so.

Care to address this?
 
This is very similar to the Citgo deal with the Pentagon. All Lyte has to do is have a witness who sees something else, and all the other eye witnesses and physical evidence is assumed to be faked, with no explanation needed.

Here, it appears that all he has to produce is this 'document' that really doesn't show anything except that the airphones were inactivated at one time prior to 911, and he can handwave away all the phone calls that were made from the plane that day without having to explain how they could have been faked; that's just not his concern now that he has 'proof' they were impossible.

I sense a pattern here.
 
I have answered you 4 times.

I do not have evidence to definitively answer this so I will leave you to speculate the possibilities for yourself.

You can keep demanding that I speculate this for you but I will not.

Avoiding the question does not constitute an answer. You have claimed that the phones were not working, I have asked you a simple follow question from your claim, it requires you to make a simple one word answer, you have failed to answer.

If you think for one second questions like this will not be asked of you in future you are mistaken.

One final chance to savage some form of dignity for you.

Based on your claim that the phones were not working are you claiming the phone calls from the victims to their families could not have taken place? YES or NO.
 
Is his email address available publicly, or was there an inside source, that obtained his email?

TAM:)
The email exchange was from a separate source, not the AA mechanic. I do not know if it is public. Perhaps it would be best to call American Airlines.

This guy sounds like a typical CSR who repeats what someone tells him. We are to take HIS WORD that there were no operable seat phones on AA77???
Yet you accept the word of other spokesman in other news, such as articles Arkan posted, regarding dates of airphones? A bit hypocritical, eh?
I would expect you take his word in support of the official story, I suppose.
 
Last edited:
Ok, what is the big deal here?? If you look at the evidence that was provided at the Moussoui trail, it was clearly stated that the calls made were from cell phones.

2 from Renee May. (one did not connect) One lasted 158 seconds
Barbra Olsen, and 5 other calls to unknown numbers.

There was never any question about where that calls came from! Unless Im missing something??
 
Ok, what is the big deal here?? If you look at the evidence that was provided at the Moussoui trail, it was clearly stated that the calls made were from cell phones.

2 from Renee May. (one did not connect) One lasted 158 seconds
Barbra Olsen, and 5 other calls to unknown numbers.

There was never any question about where that calls came from! Unless Im missing something??

Well that means that Lyte and Pilots are allowing Moussaoui to remain in prison, even though they have evidence that proves that the evidence admitted and accepted into his trial was FAKED.

I think for the sake of that poor innocent man in prison, that Lyte and Rob should immediately bring this evidence to Moussaoui's lawyer, so he can be freeded...

TAM:)
 
No.

"Software Release:" was probably the revision number for the document"

Wrong.. it was revision date for the software being used to look at the document according to source..

"and that the redacted area next to the term "Software Release:" is probably the actual software release number. It would make more sense as a standard format for a controled document."

This part is correct.

How do you know this? Do you have a document that explains AA's online manual revision dates and software revision dates? Can you explain why AA hasn't revised their AMM in 6 years? The FAA would surely love to hear about that...

And can you please respond to this:

"What you need is:

Engineering Authorization(EA)/ Engineering Order(EO) documents. EO/EA compliance reports saying when individual aircraft (ship 644) were complete, or even logbook history documents. All of the above should be available to your source."


Can he get this or not? I could have all of the above info for any aircraft in my employers fleet within minutes(and I'm not even at work right now!). Don't believe me? Try me.
 
Based on your claim that the phones were not working are you claiming the phone calls from the victims to their families could not have taken place? YES or NO.

Your entire "suggestion" is just that. He isn't claiming anything in regards to the phone calls authenticity in this thread, only the question of whether airphones were a method of communication on that particular flight.
 
Apathoid, where do you think the documentation on flight 77 and 93 would be right now, concerning what was installed on board and what was not? Would that be in the hands of the FBI do you think? would AA have copies of the maintenance records for that particular flight, even 6 years later?

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom