Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

What's evidence got to do with it? You freely admitted that you favor circumcision for "jewish" boys, for, well, no good reason. Because that's how you think jewish boys ought to be.

Where does evidence come into this?


Go stuff your strawmen somewhere else.

Does circumcision lead to a greater incidence of cancer? Is there a non-negligible chance my son's penis might fall off?

"I have seen no evidence" does not translate to "No evidence could convince me." Your beliefs about my beliefs are wrong, are not appreciated and paint you as an immovable fundamentalist far more than me.


Oh? And just how do you know what your child's will is? Did you ask him? What was his response?


My child's will is whatever I decide it is. I substitute my judgment for him because he is incapable of making a judgment. I know my child's will with exactly the same certainty as I know my own. The two things are the same.


You are not exercising your child's will, you are exercising your own. It may make you feel better to imagine it's what your child really wants, but it makes you no less of a monster.


Well, at least I'm a monster in good company.


So when a Jehovah's Witness refuses a blood transfusion for his infant child, he's exercising his child's will? Do you mean to say that every JW child that died because their parents refused them treatment wanted it that way? I hope not, because that would just be patently insane.


Yes and yes. Your statement that this is "insane" is only true if we accept as objectively true your subjective beliefs. If we accept the JW's beliefs as objectively true, it is you who become "insane." You, after all, would lock your child out of heaven for eternity in order to secure a few more years on earth.


uhh.. oh, man.. you know what, I'm just going to drop it. It's obvious to me you're just too far gone to be reached.


The feeling is mutual.
 
Translation: I am not deluded. They actually are my delusions.


Don't put words in my mouth. I share religious beliefs with millions of people all over the world. This exempts me from the definition of delusion. Spitzer, M. (1990) On defining delusions. Comprehensive Psychiatry, 31 (5), 377-97



Oh I see what's going on here, you think the world is a court of law, and that what's legal is what's right. That's not an uncommon fallacy.

Sorry Loss Leader, I was thinking about the real world, not the fantasy world you live in where what's "legal" is what's "right".

My guess is you prefer the legal definition of yourself, which is law-abiding citizen, to the "real world" definition of yourself, which is inhumane, atavistic, ignorant, barabaric monster.

You seem to be missing an important point here, and that is that nothing about Nazism was illegal. Hitler's rise to power and subsequent oppression and murder of the Jews was perfectly legal in the Nazi state. According to your logic, there was nothing wrong with it, because it it was in accordance with the law.

Care to rethink your assumption that legal = right?


My word, you know absolutely nothing about law.

I'll do this for the lurkers because it's obvious that you are just too far over into your issue to care:

Does legal equal right? Well, we know from Osmosis' example that it can't always. After all, the Nazi's weren't right. So, when are we justified in believing that legal and right are at least vaguely in the same area as each other?

The answer is to look at how the thing became legal. In a society where laws are made by a dictator, the chance that the laws are just is pretty small. The laws will probably just help the dictator stay in power. The same is true of an oligarchy. Even where laws are made by majority will, there is a chance the majority will use the occassion to crush the minority.

Laws should be arived at democratically, judiciously and with reference to agreed upon definitions of human rights.

Now, the law that allows me to substitute my judgment for my incompetent son - is that a just law? It is certainly the law of a democratic land (my country, the USA). And it didn't come about yesterday: the concept of substituted judgment has evolved through the common law for as long as there has been common law. And it allows minorities to practice their beliefs even when the majority might not make the same decision. It also allows for a husband and wife to control their own home and raise their own children in a manner they believe is appropriate.

Why allow people to hold different beliefs? The simple answer is because your beliefs, no matter how sincerely you hold them, may be wrong. Very rarely can we know any objective truth when it comes to interpersonal relationships. Allowing a plurality of practices to co-exist broadens our chance of stumbling on the right one and lessens our chance of accidentally supressing the right one.

As the rules regarding substituted judgment are not just legal but are legal within a political framework that is just, we are correct in equating legal with right in this instance.

Seriously, Osmosis, read a book.
 
Last edited:
...As the rules regarding substituted judgment are not just legal but are legal within a political framework that is just, we are correct in equating legal with right in this instance...

LOL!:D

So the laws in the US are right because the political framework is just. Explain these then.
 
LOL!:D

So the laws in the US are right because the political framework is just. Explain these then.


Just exactly how much straw do you have over there?

I never said or implied that all laws in the US are right because the political framework is always just. You, however, have read my statement exactly that way.

Here's what I did say just one post ago:


Now, the law that allows me to substitute my judgment for my incompetent son - is that a just law? It is certainly the law of a democratic land (my country, the USA). And it didn't come about yesterday: the concept of substituted judgment has evolved through the common law for as long as there has been common law. And it allows minorities to practice their beliefs even when the majority might not make the same decision. It also allows for a husband and wife to control their own home and raise their own children in a manner they believe is appropriate.

As the rules regarding substituted judgment are not just legal but are legal within a political framework that is just, we are correct in equating legal with right in this instance.


I bolded the part where what I said and what you claim I said most differ. The laws about substituted judgment are just, that's the absolute sum total of what I said.

Why are they just?

1. They are the laws of a democratic nation.

2. They were developed over a long time.

3. They have respect for the rights of minorities.

4. They have respect for the rights of families.

Obviously, there have been many laws in the US that were not just. Obviously, not all laws in the US are just.

But in this instance, they happen to be.



In the future, read for comprehension. Don't just assume that every single thing a person says is wrong just because you happen to disagree with him on one point.
 
Don't put words in my mouth. I share religious beliefs with millions of people all over the world. This exempts me from the definition of delusion. Spitzer, M. (1990) On defining delusions. Comprehensive Psychiatry, 31 (5), 377-97

It may exempt you from the definition of delusion, but certainly does not exempt you from the reality of delusion.

The only thing that keeps your beliefs out of the definition of delusion is the fact that a lot of people believe the same, and that seems to me to be a very shallow distinction. Personally, I'm inclined to think a delusion is a delusion regardless of how many people share it.

My word, you know absolutely nothing about law.

Perhaps, but I would never resort to such a relativistic concept to defend my position anyway. And which law, exactly?

Is gay marriage "wrong" in some states and not "wrong" in others? Does one's ethical integrity depend on which side of a particular political boundary one happens to be standing on? I don't think so, I think those lines are imaginary.

Admittedly, it is very convenient to be able to hide behind law as a way to avoid having to deal with questions of ethics.

Now, the law that allows me to substitute my judgment for my incompetent son - is that a just law?

That depends on what substitutions are allowed. That you can consent by proxy to necessary medical treatments is a good thing. That you can consent by proxy to unnecessary ritual genital mutilation for the worst reasons is a very bad thing.

Why allow people to hold different beliefs? The simple answer is because your beliefs, no matter how sincerely you hold them, may be wrong.

This isn't about what you believe, it's about what you do. Incidentally, you just made an anti-circ argument. Why shouldn't you permanently mutilate your children for your beliefs? Because your beliefs could be (and probably are) wrong.

Very rarely can we know any objective truth when it comes to interpersonal relationships. Allowing a plurality of practices to co-exist broadens our chance of stumbling on the right one and lessens our chance of accidentally supressing the right one.

Another appeal to relativism. The problem I have with this is the part where you make the leap to "therefore it's fine for me to mutilate my children for no good medical reason." I just can't come up with any ethical defense of that position, your legalistic defense notwithstanding.

Seriously, Osmosis, read a book.

I have read many books, is there one in particular you recommend?

I have just one question at this point: can you, without making reference to legal definitions, justify your assertion that your child's will and your own are one and the same?
 
Loss...
You can explain why you agree with the law, and maybe even have a case. But you've repeatedly implied that your desires are your child's desires, as though it's some kind of objective "truth" when it is not.
Explaining what the law is, and why you agree with it, does not actually superimpose your desires into your child in objective reality. It's simply a societal function and nothing more.

You can legally do all kinds of weird things to your kid, and claim "Legally, my will is theirs!"...and it doesn't make it literally true.
 
Why are they just?

1. They are the laws of a democratic nation.

2. They were developed over a long time.

3. They have respect for the rights of minorities.

4. They have respect for the rights of families.

Obviously, there have been many laws in the US that were not just. Obviously, not all laws in the US are just.

But in this instance, they happen to be.

I see a problem here, and that is that you are trying to use the definition of "just" (as it happens to be defined in books on American law) to defend a practice that is patently unjust.

Your legalistic mental gymnastics just can't rescue you from this ethical issue. Law is supposed to be based on ethics, not the other way around.


ETA: what kellyb said
 
Last edited:
osmosis said:
Law is supposed to be based on ethics, not the other way around.

Unless you're living under a theocracy, or believe that laws are divinely inspired. The belief that the law comes right from the mouth of god will, of course, create a mentality that is reversed.
 
It may exempt you from the definition of delusion, but certainly does not exempt you from the reality of delusion.


In that case, I feel perfectly justified saying that you, Osmosis, are a giant, steaming archipelago. I realize that you do not fit the definition of "archipelago" as a body of water studded with islands, or the islands collectively themselves. However, you fit the imaginary definition I just made up in my head of "archipelago."


Incidentally, you just made an anti-circ argument. Why shouldn't you permanently mutilate your children for your beliefs? Because your beliefs could be (and probably are) wrong.


You have misunderstood me, then. What I said was that society allowing a plurality of practices among its members increases the chance that one of them is actually right. I did not say that I can act however I want because there's some chance I may accidentally be right. My *not* circumcising my son would only contribute to the plurality in America if someone else then *did* circumcise his son. The best way to ensure a plurality is for people to follow their own beliefs. So, I'll follow my own beliefs and let others follow theirs.


I just can't come up with any ethical defense of that position, your legalistic defense notwithstanding.

Of course you can't. You see no value in continuing long-standing religious traditions that do not impact the overall health of anybody. Once you assign that a value of zero, there is no reason to circumcise a child. But if there is value in it, you are wrong. Since we cannot *know* whether you are right or wrong and since no one is coming to much in the way of harm, it is better to allow a plurality of practices.


I have read many books, is there one in particular you recommend?


Start with this one and work your way up.


I have just one question at this point: can you, without making reference to legal definitions, justify your assertion that your child's will and your own are one and the same?


Your question has no meaning. The "legal definitions" have evolved over centuries, coalescing the moral, ethical and practical concerns societies have had about incompetent individuals. These arguments are the same as the "legal definitions." They cannot be separated. It would be like me asking you to define ice cream without reference to freezing, sugar, eggs or milk.
 
It's simply a societal function and nothing more.


I don't understand your statement. There is nothing more than a societal function. The legal definition is all there is.

Of course, my thoughts are not physically my child's thoughts. Of course the firing of neurons in my brain is not physically identical to the firing of neurons in his brain.

But in this instance we are dealing with nothing other than interpersonal relationships. Physics has nothing to do with it. It is only a question of law. When the issue is how two or more people relate to each other, the legal definition and the "societal function" is all the reality that there can be.
 
I see a problem here, and that is that you are trying to use the definition of "just" (as it happens to be defined in books on American law) to defend a practice that is patently unjust.


The problem, actually, isn't that the practice is "patently unjust." The problem is that you believe the practice is "patently unjust."

But simply claiming that something is injust does not win the day. This is a social and political issue. You are required to actually convince people that it is injust.

Can you?

I'll tell you why I think you can't. The concept that a parent can substitute his will for his child is really, really old. It is entombed in cases from the earliest days of this country, from the days of the Norman conquest, back from the days of Roman law, back as far as western law has roots. It is really stuck in there very firmly. Actually, the very concept that a parent can ever be *stopped* from imposing his will on his child is maybe only a hundred and fifty years old. Before that, suggesting such a thing would have been seen as utterly insane.

Then you have the concept of religious freedom. Now that's a lot newer but it has taken a firm hold of the American psyche. Remember that plurality of opinions stuff? It's all true. In the absense of objective truth, one person's subjective beliefs are going to have to be pretty compelling to impose them on an entire nation.

You, of course, have the state's interest in the welfare of children but you've still got quite a mountain to climb. The state's interest has to be so compelling that it outweighs the considerations on my side of the equation. Remember, children have been allowed to *die* because the parents had a greater interest in the question than the state. Does circumcision which causes no lasting medical harm to a child lose because it causes no lasting medical benefit? I doubt it.

So file suit against a hospital that performs circumcisions. Call your local Congressperson. Get a ballot initiative together. If the practice is "patently unjust," you should have no problem.

I, however, would bet on you to lose.

If the people of the US, their government and their courts all think that justice is served by allowing Jews to circumcise their children, exactly where does the "patently unjust" aspect reside?

The answer is that it resides only in your head.
 
Last edited:
Loss Leader said:
I don't understand your statement. There is nothing more than a societal function. The legal definition is all there is.

No, there's objective reality. When you hear your baby screaming while being circumcised, clinging to legal definitions will have no power to change the objective reality you'll be faced with, that the last thing your baby wants is to have parts of his penis cut off. Your legal authority to impose your will upon your child has no bearing on "truth" or "actuality" regarding the desires of your child.

The reality of the situation is that babies rather dislike having their foreskins removed, to put it very mildly. (I'm fighting the urge to use 'emotive language' that would be entirely more accurate).

But in this instance we are dealing with nothing other than interpersonal relationships.
Human rights and bodily integrity is a lot more than an interpersonal relationship. Ignoring those issues doesn't make them go away.

Physics has nothing to do with it. It is only a question of law. When the issue is how two or more people relate to each other, the legal definition and the "societal function" is all the reality that there can be.

In all reality, you could have compassion for your baby. You could choose to care about his actual will, his feeling, and his personal rights.
You could choose to abandon an archaic ritual.
In reality, it is his body, not yours.
 
No, there's objective reality. When you hear your baby screaming while being circumcised, clinging to legal definitions will have no power to change the objective reality you'll be faced with, that the last thing your baby wants is to have parts of his penis cut off.


Actually, I found my first son screamed like a banshee just at being held down. His cries didn't intensify at the moment the Mohel made the cut.

As to what my eight day-old son wanted. He didn't "want" anything. He knew comfort and discomfort and nothing else. I have had occassion to make him remarkably uncomfortable for his own good since then. You should have heard him wail when they had to put in an IV.

But that discomfort was for his own good. And, whether you choose to believe it or not, his circumcision was for his own good. Just because you put zero value on maintaining an ancient tradition linking my son to his past does not mean that the objective value is zero. It only means you don't agree.


Your legal authority to impose your will upon your child has no bearing on "truth" or "actuality" regarding the desires of your child.


He had no desires. He was eight days old.


The reality of the situation is that babies rather dislike having their foreskins removed, to put it very mildly. (I'm fighting the urge to use 'emotive language' that would be entirely more accurate).


He also screamed the first time we gave him a bath. As people have lived fine lives without bathing, should I have respected his bodily integrity then, too?


In all reality, you could have compassion for your baby. You could choose to care about his actual will, his feeling, and his personal rights.
You could choose to abandon an archaic ritual.


You insult me, Kelly. You insult me more deeply than I have ever been on this message board. Let me make this perfectly clear: The well-being of my children is my only concern. I mean that it is the only concern I have in my life. I care about nothing else and I devote myself night and day to ensuring that they have the absolute best lives possible. When my son feels pain, I feel pain. When he suffers a setback, I die inside. My boy had three brain surgeries in ten day. So, watch your language when you describe wh I do and do not care about.

I had my son circumcised (and will have my newborn son circumcised) because I believe it is in their best interests to be permanently connected to their history.


In reality, it is his body, not yours.


In every way that counts, you are wrong.
 
In that case, I feel perfectly justified saying that you, Osmosis, are a giant, steaming archipelago. I realize that you do not fit the definition of "archipelago" as a body of water studded with islands, or the islands collectively themselves. However, you fit the imaginary definition I just made up in my head of "archipelago."

rofl! that's actually very funny, and would be totally appropriate except for one little thing: common usage. Common usage of the word "delusion" tends to omit the part that excludes shared/cultural delusions. Under common usage, a delusion is a delusion regardless of how many people share those delusions.



The best way to ensure a plurality is for people to follow their own beliefs. So, I'll follow my own beliefs and let others follow theirs.

By all means, follow your own beliefs, except where those beliefs have permanent consequenses for someone else, especially someone who can't possibly understand those beliefs or even speak a word of protest as you slice off parts of their genitals.

How is it pluralistic to make such decisions for your child? If you're allowed your own beliefs, why isn't he? All you're doing is superimposing your own will upon his. Nothing pluralistic about that.


You see no value in continuing long-standing religious traditions that do not impact the overall health of anybody.

Correct, I see no value in any traditions in and of themselves. Some traditions may have value, but that must be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. Nothing has any value simply because it is traditional.


Once you assign that a value of zero, there is no reason to circumcise a child. But if there is value in it, you are wrong. Since we cannot *know* whether you are right or wrong and since no one is coming to much in the way of harm, it is better to allow a plurality of practices.

I disagree. Since we cannot *know* whether I am right or wrong, it is best NOT to permanently alter another human being.

The plurality argument allows you to do whatever you believe only insofar as you're not imposing those beliefs on others.

Start with this one and work your way up.

That was a cheap shot.. oh well, I still laughed. I wonder, does condescension make you feel superior?

Your question has no meaning. The "legal definitions" have evolved over centuries, coalescing the moral, ethical and practical concerns societies have had about incompetent individuals. These arguments are the same as the "legal definitions." They cannot be separated. It would be like me asking you to define ice cream without reference to freezing, sugar, eggs or milk.

Actually, my question does have meaning, just not a meaning I would expect you to embrace, because once the question is correctly answered, the central fallacy of your position soon becomes evident.

That fallacy is that something doesn't exist except as defined in a book of (American) law. If that were true, then you would indeed be correct in your assertion that your will IS your son's will.

Unfortunately for your position, however, it isn't true. Your will is not your son's will, despite what your textbook says.
 
Obviously, there have been many laws in the US that were not just. Obviously, not all laws in the US are just.

But in this instance, they happen to be.

Now I understand. It is the almighty Loss Leader that has decided for all of us that because a particular law currently allows followers of a religion he subscribes to to mutilate their male children's genitals, it is just.

It used to be legal in the UK (until quite recently) to beat children. This had been going on a very long time. The UK has been a democracy for a long time too. Therefore by your reasoning, we should allow parents to beat their children if they want to, since we can never know if their ideas on suitable punishments might be right.

But those upstart politicians thought they knew better than The Word Of God (TWOG) and eventually banned it. I suppose you believe they'll be going to hell for defying TWOG?

BTW, If you read the link I added to an earlier post, you'll notice it was some Christians who recently wanted the ban repealed, so they could follow TWOG with respect to punishing their children. I mean, who are we humans to say beating children is wrong if your God said it's the right thing to do?

Do you believe in 'An eye for an eye' too?
 
Sorry guys, this discussion is too fast and too weird for me nowadays.

Thank you for sharing your opinions, everyone.

During this discussion I became an anti-circumcisionist.
 
Now I understand. It is the almighty Loss Leader that has decided for all of us that because a particular law currently allows followers of a religion he subscribes to to mutilate their male children's genitals, it is just.

I took it to mean something along the lines of, if enough people believe it is just, then it is just.

He seems to be denying the possibility that there is any objective standard to which anyone can be held accountable. There's no right or wrong, only belief. We can talk all day and all night about ethics and rights, he can simply refuse to acknowledge that any such things actually exist!

It used to be legal in the UK (until quite recently) to beat children. This had been going on a very long time. The UK has been a democracy for a long time too. Therefore by your reasoning, we should allow parents to beat their children if they want to, since we can never know if their ideas on suitable punishments might be right.

Exactly, but why stop there? Essentially his line of reasoning allows a parent to do ANYTHING to their child. ANYTHING. The parent doesn't even have to actually believe it's in their child's best interests, only to claim to do so. After all, who can say what someone does or doesn't believe..
 
...
It used to be legal in the UK (until quite recently) to beat children. This had been going on a very long time. The UK has been a democracy for a long time too. Therefore by your reasoning, we should allow parents to beat their children if they want to, since we can never know if their ideas on suitable punishments might be right.

...

...Exactly, but why stop there? Essentially his line of reasoning allows a parent to do ANYTHING to their child. ANYTHING. The parent doesn't even have to actually believe it's in their child's best interests, only to claim to do so. After all, who can say what someone does or doesn't believe..

You know that the reason beating children is not allowed is because it is considered harmful to the child with no benefit to the child.

You know that spanking children is allowed (despite it being merely a milder form of beating) because it is not considered so harmful to the child that it outweighs any benefit to the child.

You know that circumcision has not been shown to be considered harmful to the child with potentially a variety of benefits to the child (small medical benefits, large societal benefits).

Nobody has been able make such a proof in the 3000+ years that circumcisions have been performed.

A parent is allowed to make a whole variety of decisions for children with the child themselves having little to no say. Where the legal system gets involved in contradicting the parent is only where the law sees a particular decision as being more harmful than good for the well being of the child. Since circumcision is not seen by the law as being more harmful than good, then it is not against the law.
 
Last edited:
I'm fast using the control F function.

Heh. Quick-Draw Skeptigirl. ;-)

Posts in a forum sometimes require time before what is being communicated is sorted out. One who falsely assumes another is being disingenuous, doesn't allow for that sorting out to occur. One who is offended by another person simply because they hold a different view, or because they won't come around to a viewpoint being expressed, will find a lot of things to be offended about on a forum.

Really? Which one am I? :confused:

I don't think you're disingenuous. I think, firstly, as Linda has pointed out, that you are posting things without seeing how they read to everyone else, or at least to many of us. It isn't just me.

I also think that I don't care a bit that you have a different point of view. Linda has a different point of view than me too. So have many others. I haven't had this problem with anyone else.

What I disliked, and as I said before, the lecturing style undoubtedly had an effect on that (point taken, not your intent, I get it), was the continual attempts on your part to define my viewpoint within your particular worldview of "what doctors and nurses are like". And it was frustrating. Because every time I say "No, I would never do that. Yes, we are trained to do that", all I would get back would be another generalization.

What am I supposed to say to that? It's like the old argument in "Persuasion" about marriage. "You will think differently when you are married!" "No I won't!" And they say, "Yes, you will,", and there's an end on't.

You're an NP. I'm a medical student. We have different experiences and different opinions. Those are givens. But if you are stating that we are reading things into your words that you don't mean, then I think I am justified in pointing out when you are doing the same--and you're missing what I am saying, as you just pointed out. Your greater experience does not negate that.

skeptigirl said:
I find if I take offense to other people's positions, then discussions become total wastes of time. And if I worry about pleasing everyone, such as we do in face to face interactions, I'd be much more limited in what I felt I could say.

Where are you suddenly going with this?

I was offended because you appeared to me to be making extremely unjustified insinuations about medical training and doctors. Linda has tried, and has done far better than I would have, to point out why that is. And you haven't answered her questions. You just keep giving further anecdotal evidence. I appreciate that you're agreeing with her, but then you keep going back to the "differences of training" or "differences of philosophy" things. I agree with Linda there as well--I don't think that's helpful.

This suddenly conciliatory position is a little startling to me. Look, I'm not trying to gain some huge victory, I'm not trying to prove some point about what a smart medical student I am, and I, particularly now that the conversation seems to have turned in a nasty direction regarding religious beliefs, am not thinking this thread is going anywhere constructive any more. So forget all that, all right?

"Worrying about pleasing everyone" is not something I do either. You certainly don't have to "please" me. But if you want to have a civil dialogue with me, you do need to understand that what you are saying is apparently not communicating the message you had in mind, and can be taken as offensive.

skeptigirl said:
I know I had no offensive feelings in what I was saying. I'm willing to continue a discourse to clarify any mistaken offense. Beyond that, some people on forums are going to be offended no matter it is a misunderstanding. While that's regretful, it isn't something I often get very bothered about.

I am not terribly easily offended. Since you have been through so many of my posts lately ;) , perhaps you will note that I didn't really get annoyed until your post where you talked about doctors making decisions and giving orders and nurses advocating and helping, etc.

Do you see what Linda was trying to show you? Do you see how that could be taken as meaning "and doctors don't have these qualities"? Can you go so far as to admit we may not be completely 'round the bend for not being able to read your mind and suss your deeper philosophy, based on the words that were actually there? :cool:

skeptigirl said:
As far as my mis-characterizing your position, are you not aware you mis-characterized mine repeatedly?

Yeah, the one about "you think circumcision is a good thing" was undisguised hyperbole.

skeptigirl said:
One of the differences on forums is people are posting replies over a number of days sometimes. With in person interactions, discussions are often much shorter. The person who misunderstands what you say goes off believing you said something you didn't. And you may never know that. I never ceased to be amazed at what people believe I said in my infectious disease classes when I ask them later what they remember. It's the nature of human communication.

No, you can't really use that in this situation. I mean, you're right, of course, memory is a very fallible thing. But you have the words to look back on here.

Look, if this is about the whole apology thing, forget it. I don't expect it. Forget the circ thing. Would you please just try and understand the point that this is not about a single misunderstanding or a semantic argument? You have softened your response considerably towards me in both this response to me and the one to Linda, and please believe me, I appreciate it.

skeptigirl said:
You still have a physician who sees her practice as all her decisions. If the family has a religious belief, find another doctor. If the family wants baby to look like Dad, find another doctor. If the family feels more kids in the jr high locker room will be circumcised and they prefer to spare little johnny the teasing (apparently this could go either way), find another doctor. All because Dr Hawk is in control and has decided what she choses to do in her practice.

But this is still infuriating. This is glib and condescending. And this is a really serious oversimplification of my position. You're right--I don't think a doctor should have anything to do with religious decisions. I'm not a rabbi. I don't think it's my business or any kind of good medical practice to make the baby look like dad. I'm not a plastic surgeon. And if the current trends continue, as you point out, which kid might be teased is pretty up in the air. (All kids get teased anyway, about something.)

None of which is because "I am in control." It is because these are not medical decisions at all, let alone mine to make, and because absent a strong medical reason to undertake the procedure, my belief is that a permanent alteration of someone's anatomy should not be made at a time that the person can't contribute to the decision. You seem to define your role as an advocate as toward the parents. I see it as being both to the parents and to the infant. The evidence specifically on UTI appears to have convinced you. It's certainly a consideration. I'm not sure about it. So yes, if a parent's main concern is UTI, maybe that's something to consider. But I can't promise that the child will be protected from sepsis--you know that. That is why I find the question more difficult than, say, vaccination.

I do think--and some of the adult males on this forum feel far more strongly than I do about this, obviously, and in both directions!--that the procedure itself is not particularly harmful. But what I also think, and this I do feel strongly about, is that the decisional process is ethically problematic because in newborn circumcision, the infant does not have a say in the process. And when there is no medical justification, and from all I know the medical justification is at best equivocal, I do think the infant's eventual right to choose is important. I also think that this viewpoint is becoming more common, but that's just my personal experience. I don't think I have any business performing something that the parents see, for example, as a religious procedure. If you call that a difference in semantics, okay. But it's there that you get into all the fooferaw about comparisons to other religious rituals (that shall remain nameless) that we (collectively) *don't* do. Why don't we do them?

Because we don't believe they're medically indicated.

Does that help you see where I'm going with this? I have no interest in fighting with you or getting all huffy or anything of the sort. But when you say I'm misinterpreting you, and then turn around and write something like that, it really is hard not to take it personally.

Sheesh, I'm a medical student. I'm never in control. :boggled:
 
Last edited:
The problem, actually, isn't that the practice is "patently unjust." The problem is that you believe the practice is "patently unjust."

But simply claiming that something is injust does not win the day. This is a social and political issue. You are required to actually convince people that it is injust.

Can you?

I'd rather be right than "win the day". My power of pursuasion is separate and distinct from my ability to reason. Whether or not I am right has nothing to do with whether I can convince you I am. Reality is not determined by belief.

Actually, the very concept that a parent can ever be *stopped* from imposing his will on his child is maybe only a hundred and fifty years old. Before that, suggesting such a thing would have been seen as utterly insane.

At least we're heading in the right direction. Yes, this concept that a baby has inalienable rights that even their parents cannot breach is a fairly new one. But it's out there, and as we become more advanced as a society, I believe we will continue in this direction until there comes a day when the law does reflect the fact that a baby is not an object to be owned, but a human being. When that day comes, you will be regarded as a criminal.

So file suit against a hospital that performs circumcisions. Call your local Congressperson. Get a ballot initiative together. If the practice is "patently unjust," you should have no problem.

I disagree. It seems to me that I could be 100% correct and still not convince a single religious person that there are ethical issues that can transcend their superstitions. If I press the matter, they can always resort to relativism, as you have.

If the people of the US, their government and their courts all think that justice is served by allowing Jews to circumcise their children, exactly where does the "patently unjust" aspect reside?

In another country, perhaps?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom