America- In the age of no primary radar

3rd, Can't be exact here, but definitely enough time, the first call went out when AAL11 was over Albany and had turned southbound along the Hudson River, the second call was made 20 NM South of Albany, a third call was made 50 Nm south of Albany with the exact Lat/Longs, the next call was 30 north of JFK, another call at 16 NM north of JFK, and the final call with radar lost 8 NM North of JFK.

Cheap Shot, again welcome to the forum.
The calls you refer to: are these phone calls made from Boston Center to Otis Tower giving coordinates of flight 11? Also, was this information relayed to the pilots?
Could you place a time each call was made?
It all is a bit technical for me to follow, but I will try to keep up.
 
Yeah we had them or at least I heard we had them. The day care center is next door, I heard they had to evacuate, due to a bomb threat there. We also had a tractor trailers outside on the highway and it was broken down, they had the state troopers tell him to move immediately. We had a suspected aircraft that was supposedly heading for the center, and the center was evacuated. Most people don't know about that. I believe at least one other center was evacuated. I was the 4th to the last person to leave during the evacuation, when I went outside the FBI had already grabbed some of the tapes, and their was the local SWAT team in the parking lot, they were all leaving.

We thought everybody had left, but there were some guys in the bottom of the building who never heard the speaker system to evacuate. One of them came up stairs and boy was he surprised that no one was there. We all came back in about 20 minutes. The plane that was reported to be aimed at us was 140 Nm southeast of us a Coast Guard aircraft that originally was unidentiified, but that we had identified 10 minutes before we evacuated. There was so much more stuff going on than most people know. Nothing that I precieve as a CT item, but I'm sure others could interpret it the other way. To this day I have no idea what happened with the bomb threats. I don't know if any of them were uncovered.

At what time was the bomb scare and evacuation?

One way to interpret the bomb scares would be to blame other AQ operatives in America who tried to disrupt a military response to the hijackings.
 
At what time was the bomb scare and evacuation?

One way to interpret the bomb scares would be to blame other AQ operatives in America who tried to disrupt a military response to the hijackings.

More likely run of the mill lunies getting their kicks by vicariously joining in on the attacks.
 
More likely run of the mill lunies getting their kicks by vicariously joining in on the attacks.

Cheap Shot indicated the evacuation was after the crash of the first two planes so you are probably right.
 
More likely run of the mill lunies getting their kicks by vicariously joining in on the attacks.



It probably wasn't even that. There was a lot of SNAFU flying around that day, it wouldn't surprise me if a hijacked aircraft threat somehow became a threat to an ARTCC.

-Gumboot
 
Cheap Shot indicated the evacuation was after the crash of the first two planes so you are probably right.


senario:

out of work, bored, luuny sitting on the couch watching "Good Morning America" sees the cut to live coverage of the first tower burning and gets excited

luuny sees second plane ram second tower and whoops in glee at having his normal routine broken with some action

luuny decides he has to do something so he looks up a phone number for ATC and calls in a bomb threat

chuckling, luuny continues watching TV hoping that there will be some mention of his 'prank'
 
Cheap Shot, again welcome to the forum.
The calls you refer to: are these phone calls made from Boston Center to Otis Tower giving coordinates of flight 11? Also, was this information relayed to the pilots?
Could you place a time each call was made?
It all is a bit technical for me to follow, but I will try to keep up.

The calls about Lat/Longs were made to NEADS. The infor wasn't relayed to the pilots becasue they had not yet departed, they were still on the ground at Otis.

At least a dozen calls were made to NEADS from 8:36 to probably 8:52, which is about when were notified the first tower was hit. We didn't know for several minutes that the tower was hit. There were also calls made to Otis checking on the status of the fighters when they were going to get off.
 
At what time was the bomb scare and evacuation?

I beleive we evacuated around 9:40 to 9:50. As far as when the bomb scare was called in I don't know, I know when we evacuated we were supposed to go to the corner of the parking lot where the Day Care Center is. Instead we were told to go to another building about a 1/4 of mile away or the Holiday Inn which was two streets away. The majority of people went to the Holiday Inn, I went to the other building and no one was there so I went back and sat out front of the parking lot waiting to go back in which I did about 15 minutes later.
 
It probably wasn't even that. There was a lot of SNAFU flying around that day, it wouldn't surprise me if a hijacked aircraft threat somehow became a threat to an ARTCC.

-Gumboot

I agree with Gumboot here, I think things got so twisted that people were mistaking a plane hitting the building and interpreting it as a bomb scare. I never heard who actually received the bomb threat at the day care center.

The same thing I beleive happend with the ghost AAL11 flight, so much information being passed around, some of it from 15 minutes before which now was already old news.

The majority of the people out there didn't even know what what an ARTCC was prior to 9-11, and a lot still don't. Unless you have one in your town, you probably never would, there is only 23 of them out there. There could have been a couple of loonies who called, but I beleive most of these bobm scares were from misconstrued information.
 
Cheap Shot,

Sorry for all these questions.. feel free to tell if these bother you. You just have so much first hand knowledge on the day's events.

What I'm interested in is, do you know anything about this incident or the destroyed tape?

http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A6632-2004May6

"Six air traffic controllers provided accounts of their communications with hijacked planes on Sept. 11, 2001, on a tape recording that was later destroyed by Federal Aviation Administration managers, according to a government investigative report issued today.


It is unclear what information was on the tape because no one ever listened to, transcribed or duplicated it, the report by the Department of Transportation inspector general said."
 
Cheap Shot,

Sorry for all these questions.. feel free to tell if these bother you. You just have so much first hand knowledge on the day's events.

What I'm interested in is, do you know anything about this incident or the destroyed tape?

http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A6632-2004May6

"Six air traffic controllers provided accounts of their communications with hijacked planes on Sept. 11, 2001, on a tape recording that was later destroyed by Federal Aviation Administration managers, according to a government investigative report issued today.


It is unclear what information was on the tape because no one ever listened to, transcribed or duplicated it, the report by the Department of Transportation inspector general said."


Hopefully Cheapshot can fill us in, but what I know of the tape is basically:

1) The tape was a recorded interview made with ATC controllers immediately after 9/11
2) The tape was made to aid those ATC controllers in writing up a formal account of events later
3) The tape was made under the condition that it would later be destroyed
4) The ATC controllers submitted their written accounts of the day's events to the FBI as per procedure
5) The tape was destroyed

-Gumboot
 
That is basically correct. We did not do that at Boston Center I kind of wish we did, because even today to get everything in order, timeline vs events is very difficult. I taked to a couple of those guys in New York, and when the media got a hold of it they turned it into a conspiracy. The controllers involved feared that anything they said would be used against them later by the FAA or other agencies or the public. There was no requirement for them to make this tape, but once it was made management could not guarntee that this tape would not be used agaisnt them so they all agreed on destroying the tape. It was misconstrued by many CTs and media people that they had some how destroyed air traffic recorded tapes which is against the law. These were not those types of tapes. Just a regular old cassette tape.

Knowing what we know now I'm sure everyone would like to have them, but if it was your career on the line and no one was going to guarntee that these tapes would not be used against you, then you might make the same decision they did.

I wasn't asked to give a statement until about three days after the event, by then I couldn't get anything in order, just to much info.

Management in the FAA wasn't as bad then as it is now, with the union issues, but I have seen numerous instances in the past where a controller should have got an award for a save, only to get disciplined for using poor phraseology while in the process, so he had to to get a PIP (Performance Improvement Plan)

I apoplogize for rattling on to much sometimes
 
Thanks for your story again, CS. I know CT's abuse the tape issue, which is very unfortunate. Very good reading your posts, no need to apologize.
 
http://www.thetruthseeker.co.uk/article.asp?ID=4173

I am new to these posts, so by looking at spitfire's last comment (picture) I assume this has been gone over before, sorry for getting involved in that one. Good posts reference Pete Zyleski, good friend of mine went to the academy together, he retired back in March I beleive. I'll look forward to some new stuff on the threads.

Pete Zalewski may be a friend of yours. You may have had a good time at the academy with him. But Zalewski is lying through his teeth when he states "absolutely not" when asked if he suspected a hijacking after observing AAL11 go NORDO, turn off its transponder and go off course.

I am not suggesting Zalewski is a bad person, or that he had anything to do with 9/11. I have nothing but sympathy and pity for him. He didn't ask to be in that situation, and most of us, myself included, would have responded to the situation the same way he has.

I have no idea what kind of pressure he was put under. My understanding is that FBI agents were in the ZBW building within minutes of the attack. And of course, those agents were under the orders of the senior official of the FBI command post, who just happend to be the Master of Disaster himself.

It's easy to imagine the technique. Even the most experienced, skilled, confident controller has the same heart-sinking feeling when there's an incident, or accident, or even a mere error: Was it my fault? Did I screw up? The federal agents brought the controllers involved to a room and perhaps suggested all those dead people in the burning buildings were their fault. In such a situation, we'd all be on our knees and in tears. Then the nice FBI man whispers in our ear that everything will be all right, if we just all spout the official line-- and that line was that no hijacking was suspected until the voices of the hijackers were heard. This story is not true, of course, but in such a confused situation, we'd all rejoice at the chance to exonerate ourselves (even though we did nothing wrong) and get out from under such enormous pressure.

That no hijacking was suspected from the get go is ridiculous. Any controller will tell you that it is an extremely radical, very disturbing event for a plane to go NORDO, then turn off its transponder, then be observed turning around. That neither Zalewski nor his supe would have reacted as if a hijack was possible is simply incredible. If Cheap Shot is indeed a real controller-- a supposition I am starting to doubt more and more with each of his posts-- then he knows what I am saying here is true.

What about Glenn Michael, Cheap Shot? Is he your Academy buddy too? He is the one who stated to the media that a hijack was suspected immediately. Is he a liar, or is Zalewski? Common sense and any knowledge of ATC procedures clearly show that Richards was telling the truth.




Shortly after flight controllers ask Flight 11 to climb to 35,000 feet, the transponder stops transmitting. A transponder is an electronic device that identifies a plane on a controller’s screen and gives its exact location and altitude. Among other vital functions, it is also used to transmit a four-digit emergency hijack code. Flight control manager Glenn Michael later says, “We considered it at that time to be a possible hijacking.” [Christian Science Monitor, 9/13/2001; MSNBC, 9/15/2001; Associated Press, 8/12/2002] Initial stories after 9/11 suggest the transponder is turned off around 8:13 a.m., but Pete Zalewski, the flight controller handling the flight, later says the transponder is turned off at 8:20 a.m. [MSNBC, 9/11/2002] The 9/11 Commission places it at 8:21 a.m. [9/11 Commission, 6/17/2004] Colonel Robert Marr, head of NEADS, claims the transponder is turned off some time after 8:30 a.m. where the Flight 11 hijack was first detected a.m. [ABC News, 9/11/2002]

Some new to this thread may be wondering, what difference does it make when the plane was suspected to have been hijacked? The answer is that the sooner it was thought to have been hijacked, the more absurd the official story is that the NEADS fighters did not have time to scramble for this flight, or the other three.

But I want to make it clear how I think the stand down was orchestrated. I have already stated I do not think Pete Zalewski or any other controllers were culpable for anything. I also want to point out that I do not blame the ordinary soldiers in the Air Force, including the fighter pilots themselves. Nor do I think there was any stand down order from some high government official like the President, Vice-President, or Secretary of Defense. This is commonly suggested by such truthers as D.R. Griffin, but there is no evidence it happened.

The stand down was carried out by a small number of highly placed officers within the NORAD command structure, who chose to be loyal to the foreign government that executed the 9/11 attacks. These officers were in key positions to gum up the communications between civilian ATC and the fighters sitting in their planes waiting for orders to defend the USA. Who these officers were we may never know, but I believe if more people knew that this is the likely scenario, more of those involved in the events of that day would come forward and tell the truth of what happened, instead of reiterating the fraudulent official story in hopes of covering their own rear ends.
 
Last edited:
The stand down was carried out by a small number of highly placed officers within the NORAD command structure, who chose to be loyal to the foreign government that executed the 9/11 attacks. These officers were in key positions to gum up the communications between civilian ATC and the fighters sitting in their planes waiting for orders to defend the USA.



Who then? You're accusing people of mass murder. Let's hear your evidence.

Was it General Arnold? Commander of NORAD CONR region? The guy who said NEADS should scramble fighters without authorisation?

Was it Colonel Robert Marr, Commander of NEADS? The guy who ordered Otis to Battle Stations as soon as the call came through from Boston ARTCC? The guy who immediately called General Arnold for scramble authorisation?

Was it Major Kevin Nasypany, the NEADS MCC, who passed on Marr's orders, and managed the various elements on the NEADS floor?

Or was it ID Tech Master Segeant Maureen Dooley? Afterall the ID Techs are responsible for communication between the FAA and the military. Maybe it was Dooley's two ID Techs; Senior Airman Stacia Rountree and Tech Sergeant Shelley Watson?

Maybe it was Tech Sergeant Jeremy Powell, who took the call from Boston ARTCC at 0837 that morning?

Perhaps the weapon team were at fault, led by Major James Fox? Afterall, they were the ones speaking directly with the fighters. They gave the scramble authenticate codes, and coordinates.

Who was it, A-train? Which of these people is guilty of mass murder and treason? They'd be executed, for what they did. That's a pretty serious charge to lay on someone without evidence.

-Gumboot
 
Last edited:
My understanding is that FBI agents were in the ZBW building within minutes of the attack.
Source?

Of course not.

This is what the CT's do. They either make up lies or repeat other lies hoping that no one will notice.

"My understanding is..."

LMFAO.
 
Source?

Of course not.

This is what the CT's do. They either make up lies or repeat other lies hoping that no one will notice.

"My understanding is..."

LMFAO.

Here is my source:

...In the telephone conversation I had with [deputy in public affairs at FAA headquarters] Laura Brown in 2004, she told me that immediately after 9/11, the FAA was required to turn over all its records from that day to the FBI. Although it was not unusual, she added, for the FAA to turn over its records after a major disaster, they were normally turned over to the National Transportation Safety Board. This time, however, they had to be turned over to the FBI. It was, moreover, not only the tapes from FAA headquarters that were taken by the FBI. A Christian Science Monitor story two days after 9/11, referring to tapes made at Boston Center, said: "Those tapes are now presumed to be in the hands of federal law-enforcement officials, who arrived at the flight-control facility minutes after Flight 11 crashed into the World Trade Center." (Is this not suspiciously just?) .....

"Debunking 9/11 Debunking," by David Ray Griffin, p. 86

So my source is not only Griffin's book, but the Christian Science Monitor.

Still laughing your FAO?
 
yes I am...even more so now that you have stated your "sources"...

LMFAO

TAM;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom