HIV/AIDS, Facts, Myths, what is true?

robinson

Banned
Joined
Aug 9, 2006
Messages
6,067
Based on what just is, the facts, it is possible that everybody is correct. Regarding HIV/AIDS.

That sounds crazy, doesn't it?

Let me explain why this might be so, you can peek inside my thought process here.

If these are the facts, then everybody is correct. A big if, and one that should be determined, in my view.

HIV is a new retrovirus.
HIV resembles very old retroviruses.
HIV damages the immune system in some people.
HIV is harmless in some people.
HIV mutates all the time, and there are multiple types.
HIV is spread by, sex, blood, and organ transplants.
HIV is found in chimps and monkeys.
HIV doesn't make chimps and monkeys sick.
HIV is hard to detect in infected people.
HIV is impossible to detect in some people.
HIV can be combined with other retroviruses in a lab.
HIV isn't just one retrovirus.
HIV is limited by certain drug treatments.
HIV is not killed by any drug treatment.
HIV vaccines don't work because of rapid mutation.
HIV is passed from mother to child, sometimes.
HIV combined with drug use and homobisexual behavior almost always leads to AIDS.
HIV can be stopped from spreading.
HIV has shown up in isolated Indian Tribes that have had no contact ever with the outside world.
HIV can be detected in healthy dogs blood, using standard tests.
HIV is very difficult to isolate from infected serum.
HIV is easy to clone and grow in vivo.
HIV has made some people very very wealthy.
HIV has been fought about since it was "discovered".
HIV is not allowed to be debated by the ruling class.
HIV is a political, economic, social issue, as well as medical.
HIV does not act like any known retrovirus.
HIV is different in Africa than it is in America and Europe.
HIV statistics for many countries are estimates, and they have been shown to be wrong.
HIV test, in some cases, are not accurate.
HIV is known to damage CD4 receptor cells, and invade other tissue. How this happens is still not known.
HIV is a Pandemic.
HIV, by causing AIDS, is a minor cause of death.
HIV is the source of a lot of death.
HIV is a harmless passenger virus.
HIV is spread by heterosexual sex.
HIV is mostly spread by homobisexual sex and drug use.
HIV was spread through the blood supply before it was known about.
HIV can be spread by infected vaccines.
HIV has been found in tissue samples from a long time ago.
HIV was unknown before 1979.
HIV resembles retroviruses used in cancer research.
HIV is not able to infect non-primate mammals.
HIV is found in dogs, cats, pigs and rats, and in mosquito guts.
HIV is not spread by mosquitos or any other insect.
HIV is not spread by eating it.
HIV is spread by mothers milk.
HIV is spread by needlestick accidents.
HIV is almost never spread by needlesticks.
HIV was around for years before it was detected.
HIV has almost never infected a Surgeon or Doctor, except by sex or I.V. drug use.
HIV can survive in blood stored for use, for a long time.
HIV can't survive outside the body for long.
HIV is found in sperm and seminal fluid.
HIV is very hard to detect in sperm or seminal fluid.
HIV is spread through oral sex.
HIV is almost never spread by female to female sex.
HIV is in saliva.
HIV is not spread by kissing.
HIV can't reproduce without human DNA.
HIV reproduces in Chimps and Monkeys.
HIV infections began in New York City and San Fransisco.
HIV was late in infecting Africa.
HIV is theorized to have started in Africa.
HIV can't be contracted from lab monkeys or chimps/
HIV is believed to have started from monkeys and chimps infecting Africans.
HIV isn't the same as SIV, SV40, or any other retrovirus.
HIV was not made in a lab, or spread by medical procedures.
HIV can be joined with other organisms, (Chimeras), and many kinds of HIV have been created for research.
HIV is easy to modify in a lab.
HIV couldn't be created by science.
HIV strains are created by scientist to study it.
This is by no means a complete list.

If those are true, and I have read numerous sources that say those are facts, then the issue isn't black or white. What is true, is the heart of the matter. This isn't a simple issue by any definition. Except to those who think they know it all.

I would like to know if those statements are true. I'm sure most of them are. Even the ones that don't make sense.

Language is going to be a factor obviously.
 
These are wrong.

HIV is found in chimps and monkeys. You mean SIV. Although HIV can infect chimps.
HIV doesn't make chimps and monkeys sick. You mean SIV, see above.
HIV isn't just one retrovirus. Maybe you are confusing with HIV-2, HTLV-I and HTLV-II? For most purposes people mean HIV-1 when they say HIV.
HIV can be detected in healthy dogs blood, using standard tests.
HIV has made some people very very wealthy.
HIV is not allowed to be debated by the ruling class.
HIV does not act like any known retrovirus.
HIV is a harmless passenger virus.
HIV can be spread by infected vaccines.
HIV resembles retroviruses used in cancer research. Which viruses specifically?
HIV is found in dogs, cats, pigs and rats, and in mosquito guts. Perhaps in mossy guts.
HIV reproduces in Chimps and Monkeys. Chimps only.
HIV infections began in New York City and San Fransisco.
HIV was late in infecting Africa.
HIV can't be contracted from lab monkeys or chimps/
HIV was not made in a lab, or spread by medical procedures. It was spread by infected factor VIII clotting factors in haemophiliacs.
HIV can be joined with other organisms, (Chimeras), and many kinds of HIV strains are created by scientist to study it. Only parts of HIV can be genetically engineered with other viruses/bacteria.
 
HIV has been fought about since it was "discovered". Uh, hard to fight something before it's discovered, right?
HIV is not allowed to be debated by the ruling class. Watch out for the black helicopters.

 
This conversation was going on, somebody suggested a split, I started a thread. I imagine some are tired of it, or don't consider it worth talking about. In which case, don't post. :)

"The study of history is a powerful antidote to contemporary arrogance. It is humbling to discover how many of our glib assumptions, which seem to us novel and plausible, have been tested before, not once but many times and in innumerable guises; and discovered to be, at great human cost, wholly false." -Paul Johnson

But I think it is best if interested parties look for themselves. Here are a few links. The keen observer may notice the problem with the numbers right away. All of these contain data on Cuba and HIV/AIDS
http://data.unaids.org/pub/EpiReport/2006/07-Caribbean_2006_EpiUpdate_eng.pdf
http://www.who.int/hiv/amds/case1.pdf
http://indexmundi.com/cuba/hiv_aids_deaths.html
http://www.nationbynation.com/Cuba/Population.html
http://soc.enotes.com/world-fact-book/cuba-cu
http://hivinsite.ucsf.edu/global?page=cr02-cu-00&post=19&cid=CU
http://www.workers.org/2007/world/lavender-red-101/
http://www.thebody.com/content/art32967.html
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=1303008
http://ipsnews.net/hivaids/new_2612_2.shtml
http://www.globalexchange.org/countries/americas/cuba/3613.html
http://www.hartford-hwp.com/archives/43b/011.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Cuba#HIV_and_AIDS

Now in case the point is pointless, which may be the case, you never know sometimes, I'm trying to show how I come to my current opinion, and that is what it is of course, my opinion on HIV and AIDS and drugs and sexual behavior and politics and bad science and perhaps a few other issues.

I sort of share some views with most of the contributers here, except for the trolls that don't provide any input except derision and insults, they go on my filter list. Not worth one minute of my time.

Based on my experience, if you want to educate somebody, you show them how you did it.

Like the brake job analogy. I had my 17 year old do brakes last weekend, he never did them on this particular car model, but it went just fine. We would have done a clutch but it was problematic, so a friend who IS a master mechanic was called, and it went smoothly.

I wouldn't take my car to a mechanic I don't know personally, unless there was no choice, based on past experience. Some mechanics are crooks, just like some Doctors are quacks, or incompetent. Some researchers are crooked, some are just bad researchers, some are really really good.

We are people, they are people. people make mistakes, people can be wrong. In fact, it is certain we will be wrong at some point. Everybody can even be wrong.

I agree with Randi, - "Authority does not rest with scientists, when emotion, need, and desperation are involved. Scientists are human beings, too; they can be deceived and self-deceived. ...Scientists can be wrong — sometimes, very wrong. The history of science is replete with serious errors of judgment, bad research, faked results, and simple mistakes, made by scientists in every field."

But I have no doubt that HIV causes some people to have immune problems, that some people develop AIDS, and die. Most of these people will be drug users or homobisexual. Almost all women get HIV from men. Some medications prolong life and decrease suffering from AIDS. Some medications reduce babies chance of infection. People with infectious or opportunistic disease benefit from sanitation, good food, low stress, proper medical treatment, and certainly from the truth, that just because you have HIV, it is not guaranteed you will get AIDS, or that you will die horribly, far before your time. This is based on my research, my mind, the time I spent finding out for myself. If you have information that will change my mind, I will change my mind. I have many times over the last fifty years'

My opinion-
This is the lesson from the one country that mounted an intelligent response to a new infectious disease, one that was thought to be fatal, and without hope. They stopped the vectors of infection, tested all high risk, them all the population, isolated infectious people, then treated them with the best they could offer.

And because of this, we have the perfect set of HIV and AIDS patients to research, to actually understand how it spread, and what it does, and how it responds to treatments, and how you die, don't die, or how you resist it.

I find it interesting that Cuba and the great science about HIV/AIDS from there, is absent from both HIV sites, and HIV questioning sites. Perhaps both sides could learn a little humility and science from Cuba.

Probably not, but who knows?

The mind likes a strange idea as little as the body likes a strange protein and resists it with similar energy. It would not perhaps be too fanciful to say that a new idea is the most quickly acting antigen known to science. If we watch ourselves honestly we shall often find that we have begun to argue against a new idea even before it has been completely stated."

~ Wilfred Trotter
 
Last edited:
HIV is found in chimps and monkeys.
You mean SIV. Although HIV can infect chimps.

WASHINGTON (AP)-Twenty-five years after the first AIDS cases emerged, scientists have confirmed that the HIV virus plaguing humans really did originate in wild chimpanzees, in a corner of Cameroon.
http://www.livescience.com/health/ap_060525_hiv_trace.html
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/5012268.stm

(AP) The ancestry of the virus that caused the AIDS epidemic has been traced to two strains of virus found in monkeys in Africa.

The viruses probably passed into chimpanzees when the apes ate infected monkey meat, researchers say.
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2003/06/12/health/main558432.shtml
 
One Myth at a time

HIV isn't just one retrovirus. HIV mutates all the time, and there are multiple types.

HIV is a highly variable virus which mutates very readily. This means there are many different strains of HIV, even within the body of a single infected person.

Based on genetic similarities, the numerous virus strains may be classified into types, groups and subtypes.
http://www.avert.org/hivtypes.htm
 
Last edited:
HIV infections began in New York City and San Fransisco.

Altman, Lawrence K. 1982 Clue Found on Homosexuals' Precancer Syndrome. In New York Times, Vol. NYT820610. New York, NY.

1981 History

Kaposi's Sarcoma (KS) was a rare form of relatively benign cancer that tended to occur in older people. But by March 1981 at least eight cases of a more aggressive form of KS had occurred amongst young gay men in New York.2

At about the same time there was an increase, in both California and New York, in the number of cases of a rare lung infection Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP)3.
http://www.avert.org/his81_86.htm

In July 1981, the New York Times reported an outbreak of a rare form of cancer among gay men in New York and California. This "gay cancer" as it was called at the time was later identified as Kaposi's Sarcoma, the face of AIDS. About the same time, emergency rooms in New York City began to see a rash of seemingly healthy young men presenting with fevers, flu-like symptoms, and a rare pneumonia called Pneumocystis. This was the beginning of what has become the biggest health care concern in modern history.
http://aids.about.com/od/newlydiagnosed/a/hivtimeline.htm
 
But I have no doubt that HIV causes some people to have immune problems, that some people develop AIDS, and die. Most of these people will be drug users or homobisexual.

Are you sure of this last statement? Do you mean that of the people infected with HIV, needle-users and homosexuals have higher rates of AIDS? Or do you simply mean that these populations are more at risk to get the virus to begin with?
 
HIV was spread by medical procedures, (blood and needles)

At the beginning of the year, it was reported that a large number of children in Romanian hospitals and orphanages had become infected with HIV as a result of multiple blood transfusions and the reuse of needles. Jonathan Mann, the head of the WHO's Global programme on AIDS, noted that 'Eastern Europe is the new frontier for the AIDS epidemic'.69
http://www.avert.org/his87_92.htm
 
Are you sure of this last statement? Do you mean that of the people infected with HIV, needle-users and homosexuals have higher rates of AIDS? Or do you simply mean that these populations are more at risk to get the virus to begin with?

Here we run into the crux of the matter. It is both. Unless you are African. Africa does not match Western Countries.

So in almost every country, except Africa, most HIV, most HIV that develops into AIDS, and HIV that results in AIDS that results in death, has been homobisexual men or I.V. drug users. This is what statistics show.
 
Remember how this topic starts off. HIV is different depending on where you are. There are multiple strains, types, and it spreads differently in different regions, populations and countries.

It helps to remember HIV is not just a retrovirus. It is multiple things. Once we get to AIDS it gets much more complex.
 
These are wrong.

HIV can be detected in healthy dogs blood, using standard tests.
Half of all dog blood samples obtained by the Veterinary Hospital of the University, California, and tested with the Western Blot reacted with one or more HIV recombinant proteins [gp120--21.5%, gp41--23%, p31--22%.p24--43%]
Strandstrom HV, Higgins JR, Mossie K, et al. Studies with canine sera that contain antibodies which recognize human immunodeficiency virus structural proteins.

For the record, there is no evidence that dogs can get HIV or AIIDS.
 
These are wrong.

HIV can be spread by infected vaccines.

May 11, 1987, The London Times
1105346a2fa6e417b4.jpg


I would link to the article, but I can't find it online. It had an interview with Gallo himself, as well as WHO information, and some really interesting statistics to back up the story.

"The link between the WHO program and the epidemic in Africa is an interesting and important hypothesis.. ... if the hypothesis is correct it is a tragic situation and a warning that we cannot ignore."
- Dr. Robert Gallo

The AIDS epidemic may have been triggered by the mass vaccination campaign which eradicated smallpox, ...

The World Health Organization, which inspired a 13-year campaign, is studying new scientific evidence suggesting that immunization with the smallpox vaccine Vaccinia awakened the unsuspected, dormant human immuno defence virus infection (HIV),...
...I thought it was just a coincidence until we studied the latest findings about the reactions which can be caused by Vaccinia. Now I believe the smallpox vaccine theory is the explanation to the explosion of AIDS.... The greatest spread of HIV infection coincides with the most intense immunization program.. about 14,000 Haitians who were involved in the vaccination program then brought the disease home to the Caribbean.

Obviously, this story, and the resulting reaction to it, is going to be difficult to verify. As in, what is the truth?
 
Last edited:
These are wrong.

HIV can't be contracted from lab monkeys or chimps/

Wait a minute. Are you saying HIV CAN be contracted from lab primates? By a needlestick? Bites? How?

Are you aware that over 10,000 Chimps have been used in research labs? And they have been used for a very long time? For all kinds of experiments, including cancer and vaccine trials? As well as used to culture vaccines? Do you have any idea how many needlesticks, bites and culture accidents occurred?

If you believe HIV came from Chimps, and the lab chimps came from Africa .... and you can get HIV from chimps ... well... do you want to open that door? Think about it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom