How to set up an i/v drip

Rolfe

Adult human female
Joined
Sep 11, 2003
Messages
55,385
Location
NT 150 511
Over in the CT forum, an unimaginably ignorant CTer called Malcolm Kirkman is busy trying to persuade the masses that the whole drama at the Pentagon on 11th September was a stage show. One of his points is that there was apparently some video or picture of an injured survivor being transported on a stretcher, and someone was running alongside, holding up the i/v bag.

I'm no medical man and will accept that 'pressurised' is the wrong word.
However, the main argument is still true. There is no necessity to hold up such a bag, they are not gravity fed. No one remotely connected to medical work, would hold up such a bag. Ergo, the pictures are staged.


He has somehow got the impression that i/v bags are not dependent on gravity, and do not need to be held in an elevated position. (He seems to have misunderstood something someone said to him 25 years ago and made no further enquiry.) He believes that the image of a helper running alongside a stretcher holding the drip is only for movies, and any alleged factual footage showing this must therefore have been staged for dramatic purposes.

Now I know most people here connected to medical work don't go near the CT forum on a bet. But can we collect a few signatories here to show Malcolm that once more, he's wrong?

Rolfe.
 
Now I know most people here connected to medical work don't go near the CT forum on a bet. But can we collect a few signatories here to show Malcolm that once more, he's wrong?

Rolfe.

I'll go if you give me a link. Otherwise I'm afraid of getting dirty. :)

Linda
 
Here's the reply I made to Malcolm in that other thread:
:boggled:
Wrongo, bucko.

Gravity drip.

In case you were wondering, gravity flow equipment isn't obsolete. Current Wolf catalog page showing gravity flow IV sets. Gravity flow is used for non- critical applications such as hydration (saline solution to keep patients who can't drink from drying out) or emergency conditions where you can't set up a pump, or high flow applications where the patient needs blood fast.

Either A) keep your trap shut about things you know nothing about or B) expend a little Google-Fu and save yourself some embarrassment.

Wikpedia tells you how it is used, and the Wolf site shows that the technology isn't obsolete.

My only connection to medical equipment is seeing it in use by professionals. My wife was in a clinic last year to have some major varicose veins worked on. The IVs used were of the gravity feed sort.
 
All the medicine I know, I learned from watching House...but I thought that some IVs use gravity and some use a pump. If that is true, I doubt the IVs used out in the field in an emergency like 9/11 would have a pump.
 
He's wrong.
I'm a trauma nurse and work with IV's every day. If not run through an IV pump, IV's actually are "gravity run". The higher you hold the bag, the faster the fluid runs into the patient. If the bag is at the same level as the patient, the fluids don't run and there is often a backup of blood into the IV tubing.
Pressure is typically applied to such fluid bags only when used with special pressurized tubing for the purpose of obtaining certain hemodynamic readings (such as arterial blood pressure).
Trauma victims often require large volumes of fluid following injury in order to maintain adequate blood pressure. Having someone hold the bag up above the patient is an effective and easy way to help administer the volume of fluid needed by the victim.
 
Military medic for over 14 years, including over a year duty ion an active combat zone.

IVs are gravity fed. You can pressurize of pump them. Hospitals will typically use pumps for TKO connections (To Keep Open- a term for an IV line that's installed mainly to push medications through and allow a site for injections), and for medications because it allows greater control of the flow rate. In emergency situations, you can pressurize the bag to increase flow. There's a device that looks (and works) a lot like a blood pressure cuff that can be used for those situations. Typically, this would be if you're transporting a patient and don't have somewhere to hang the bag, or just to increase flow rate. Additionally, a common tactic was to place the IV bag under the patient's head (like a pillow) and allow the weight of the head to pressurize the bag and maintain flow. That's what we call a "field expedient" method.
 
Same as jens. We get ours from a company called BAXTER. They supply gravity only lines and lines that do both. The cannulae go into viens(hopefully) so it's not like it is fighting against arterial blood pressure. All the lines I have seen have a thumbwheel to regulate flow when not in a pump. Malcolm Kirkman has had his moment of glory. Bring him back down to earth.
 
Also I have never seen blood given via a machine (not counting blood warmers). If you look at WWII, Korean or Viet Nam War pics you will see no machines for IV fluids.
 
In emergency situations, you can pressurize the bag to increase flow. There's a device that looks (and works) a lot like a blood pressure cuff that can be used for those situations. Typically, this would be if you're transporting a patient and don't have somewhere to hang the bag, or just to increase flow rate. Additionally, a common tactic was to place the IV bag under the patient's head (like a pillow) and allow the weight of the head to pressurize the bag and maintain flow. That's what we call a "field expedient" method.


I wonder if it was something like this that caused Malcolm's misunderstanding. He has spoken of some incident 25 years ago where he attempted to hold the bag aloft, and was told not to, or that it was unnecessary for some reason. This has led him to conclude that these bags never need to be held up, and therefore any scene showing this being done is staged.

It's possible in that event either some sort of emergency pressurising device was being used, or the medics had already put the bag under the patient's head and didn't appreciate some amateur moving it. So Malcolm was told not to bother.

His problem now is that he thinks this applies to every situation, and that holding the bag up would not be necessary or normal practice. Therefore the scenes surrounding the Pentagon (which included someone holding up a drip) must have been staged for dramatic effect.

What he needs telling is that while it is possible that sometimes the bag would not be held up or might not need to be held up, in fact holding the bag up is still quite normal and usual practice.

Rolfe.
 
Couldn't the helper just squeeze the bag gently?
You could, but you run the risk of squeezing too hard. Also, if you are transporting the patient you'd have a hard time providing a consistent flow. Safer by far to either raise the bag, or else place a weight on it.
 
No. The bag is connected to a drip set where you can control the flow rate, they are rated at drops per mililiter and so if you know the rate of the drops you can determine flowrate.

You could, but you run the risk of squeezing too hard. Also, if you are transporting the patient you'd have a hard time providing a consistent flow. Safer by far to either raise the bag, or else place a weight on it.

Sounds all very low-tech to me. Definitely needs more features:D
 
I wonder if it was something like this that caused Malcolm's misunderstanding. He has spoken of some incident 25 years ago where he attempted to hold the bag aloft, and was told not to, or that it was unnecessary for some reason. This has led him to conclude that these bags never need to be held up, and therefore any scene showing this being done is staged.

It's possible in that event either some sort of emergency pressurising device was being used, or the medics had already put the bag under the patient's head and didn't appreciate some amateur moving it. So Malcolm was told not to bother.

His problem now is that he thinks this applies to every situation, and that holding the bag up would not be necessary or normal practice. Therefore the scenes surrounding the Pentagon (which included someone holding up a drip) must have been staged for dramatic effect.

What he needs telling is that while it is possible that sometimes the bag would not be held up or might not need to be held up, in fact holding the bag up is still quite normal and usual practice.

Rolfe.

Truth be known, even the pressurized systems have the IV bottle or bag ABOVE the pump and the patient. The pressurized systems I've seen (and remember, I'm not a doctor, I'm just a guy who's been in a few hospital rooms) use gravity flow from the bag to the pump.
 
OK, but anyone here likely to collapse with incredulous mirth on seeing a runner beside a stretcher holding up an i/v bag? Anybody here going to laugh that this is more than 25 years out of date, and insist that the scene cannot possibly be real and must have been staged?

Rolfe.
 
If you have an IV bottle, you have to have a way for air to get back in to replace the liquid that flows out. There a is little plastic doohickie for just that job. No need for a big hole in the bottle.

If it's an IV bag, then you don't even need that. The bag just collapses under air pressure, so no vacuum forms in it.
 
OK, but anyone here likely to collapse with incredulous mirth on seeing a runner beside a stretcher holding up an i/v bag? Anybody here going to laugh that this is more than 25 years out of date, and insist that the scene cannot possibly be real and must have been staged?

Rolfe.

No. Seems common sense if the helper's hands aren't required for something more urgent. Gravity's free and extremely reliable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom