[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
With your great wealth of education and experience you will easily be able to explain lamp pole No.2, the missing guard rail at the triage site and precisely where across the front of the Pentagon the 757 hit.
Here they all are,
http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies1.htm

From an outsider perspective (as I don't delve into the murky depths of the various CTs).

Malcolm, when you can't work out how an i/v drip works, and think that gravity doesn't exist inside a television, why on earth would you expect anyone to give any credence to any of your other theories?
 
From an outsider perspective (as I don't delve into the murky depths of the various CTs).

Malcolm, when you can't work out how an i/v drip works, and think that gravity doesn't exist inside a television, why on earth would you expect anyone to give any credence to any of your other theories?
Your statement is not logical.
Kindly read my previous post.
Feel free to examine the photos yourself.
 
You do agree that in one photo there is a rail and in another photo there is no rail. You say there are two sidewalks involved.
That is not correct, the photos are of the same sidewalk.
It now must follow that the triage photo had been faked.
Why fake the triage photo except as part of a bigger fake?
The attack on the Pentagon was faked = the whole 9/11 bit was faked.


Malcolm, I answered this in my post 3187. Kindly respond.
 
With your great wealth of education and experience you will easily be able to explain lamp pole No.2, the missing guard rail at the triage site and precisely where across the front of the Pentagon the 757 hit.
Here they all are,
http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies1.htm

Judging from the first page of that site, we have nothing to prove. This guy is an Apollo denier! JWs "photo analysis" credibility is fatally shot in the second paragraph.

- Guardrail: Since we only see it from above, can't be certain its the same spot and since it was taken "a few days later" according to this site we have no reason to bother explaining anything. Is it a steel guardrail? Its hard to tell from some overhead shot. Is it a temporary fence? I've personally erected plastic mesh on steel pole fencing in hours. To me these are two different spots and all the yapping later on is just a distraction.
- Triage: They located the triage there because it's next to a major highway and close enough to the scene to move victims. The second guardrail doesn't exist except in the "later pictures" and further up the road, and the first one can be driven around (as evidenced by the fact that they DROVE AROUND IT.
- Pretty Girl: I'm sure she appreciates the compliment, except that he insinuates that she wasn't really injured and was staging a fake pic.
- Fake Priests: Anybody bother calling the priest? Why is it so hard to think that a priest was driving along next to a building that's surrounded by interstate highways?
- Photoshopping: Based on one change in grass color? Maybe it was recently sodded. Maybe they have sprinklers. We're supposed to overturn tons of physical evidence and forensic evidence based on landscaping?
- Fake sign: It looks to me like two different signs. The top one stands behind a guard rail on a strip of grass in front of the helipad. The bottom one is behind a sidewalk with no helipad. Also the "dark pole" described is in the far foreground, the sign isn't next to it, its behind it.
- Bagman nonsense: The SUV is a first responder vehicle. This guy is a real dim bulb. The bagman isn't treating anyone, he's holding an IV bag and the photographer has rotated from one frame to the next, changing what people are in the shot. Then JW complains because the SUV is moving, which is normally what emergency vehicles do during emergencies. So I assume the photographer was in a good spot to get good shots and was out of the way of the EMTs. So he stayed in the same general area and took pictures for a bit.
- Whatsit: Uh, it's the rear end of a fire truck. Y'know, from behind?
- North vs South vs: Give this guy a compass. His claimed directions don't match reality. "south" is southeast and east is... eastsoutheast as far as I can tell.
- Planted Wreckage: When was this planted? The pics are a half hour after impact, during which time there were thousands of witnesses sitting on the highway that runs next door. And by "most researchers", I assume he means himself.
- Whatsit2: ITS THE BACK OF A TRUCK. Sheesh. Oh, and now it's spraying water, or to quote JW "note the addition", or perhaps the firemen are doing what firemen DO.
- LONG and short: Yeah, photo expert guy? The top pic actually has been manipulated. It's been compressed vertically without maintaining the horizontal ratio. My 5 years of experience told me that in about 3 seconds. And the whatsit is still the back end of a fire truck.
- Bloody Shirt: Uh, it's not bloody. Its a shadow. See? He's bending forward and the light is coming from behind, mister expert photo analyzer.
- Photo Op: Hey, see that spray of water behind the VP? That's coming from the whatsit. Odd, since it isn't really there. Also, I'm not sure the VP missed a photo op, since he's standing here getting his photo taken.
- Guardrail: Here we go again. The photographer is on the sidewalk, looking across it and the grass. The ONE guardrail is behind him. You even show it in the second shot.

I'm done with this. The guy has no credentials as a photo analyzer or historian, he has no clue what he's looking at and is harping over nonexistent discrepancies.
 
No plane flew under the Pentagon and no plane flew into the Pentagon. There is only a flyover left.

Actually, there are other possibilities, but that's neither here nor there. How do you know that "no plane flew into the Pentagon" ? Because there's no cookie-cutter hole in the building ? That's been explained to you more than once. Because some bloke says he saw the plane on the north side of the citgo ? A few hundred people disagree.

So, I ask you again, Malcolm. For the sake of argument, let's say you're right. Let's say it WAS a flyover. HOW DID THE PLANE LEAVE THE SCENE UNNOTICED ? It's a big 757, remember.

How hard was that to work out.

Because it doesn't follow from an unproven premise.

If you maintain that a plane did hit the Pentagon then satisfy me as to where.

See that big hole, there ?

Then tell me how the same lamp post can be both standing on its spot and lying on a grass bank.

It can't. It's either not the same post or one of the two is wrong.

Before you do that that, when are you going to tell us what happened to the grass barrier at the triage site?

I'll leave that to the others. Oh, wait, they already adressed that. Did you read their answers ?
 
With your great wealth of education and experience you will easily be able to explain lamp pole No.2, the missing guard rail at the triage site and precisely where across the front of the Pentagon the 757 hit.
Here they all are,
http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies1.htm


Two points, Malcolm. First, unlike you, I prefer to pontificate only on matters I actually know something about. For example, I'm a vet, as I said, so I know about i/v infusions and I've actually used the equipment you were declaring no longer existed. This is what counts, not qualifications for the hell of it. Second, does this post tacitly admit you intend to concede the whole matter of gravity in a vacuum, and whether or not plastic bags can empty their contents without having a BIG hole in the top? Because it's not that simple.

I've no intention of even looking at the damn photos until this point is cleared up. You throw around frankly ludicrous assertions, insult better-informed people who try to put you right (I'm thinking particularly of your response to fls here, lest you misunderstand), and tie yourself in ever-tightening knots trying to defend an increasingly indefensible position. Of course, you can simply change the subject, ignore any attempt to bring you back to it, and move on to your next ludicrous assertion waiting for the people with the specialist knowledge in that area to work you over. But why do you think you can simply demand that people whom you've ignored, insulted and patronised, but who were actually right, should keep dancing to your agenda?

You see, the example of the i/v infusions clarified a very important matter. It showed that you're not primarily interested in the Truth. You're interested in supporting your own theory, any way it takes.

Your original point was that gravity-fed i/v infusions had been obsolete for at least 25 years, thus the picture showing such an infusion must have been staged. You explained the frequent portrayal of such infusions in the modern media as being staged just because that's what the public expects to see.

Was this ever plausible? While dramatic presentations might sometimes lag a little behind cutting-edge practice, they're not fossilised. "The public" contains many people who have first-hand experience of such infusions, as healthcare workers (not just the doctors and nurses, but the cleaners, the WI volunteers, the porters, the librarians and so on), as patients, as hospital visitors and even as bystanders at accident sites. How long is it likely to take for this level of awareness to work its way through to the TV and film producers - some at least of whom pride themselves on the accuracy of what they're showing? Not 25 years, I submit.

Where do film producers (and people staging publicity shots and so on) get their props, anyway? They don't make everything from scratch, not if it can be bought cheaply. They simply use the "real thing". If nobody was using gravity-fed drips, and hadn't been for 25 years, where would they get them from? Is there some warehouse somewhere holding old stock, just for the cameras? At what point does the charade become impossible to continue, simply because the obsolete kit is no longer available? Sooner than 25 years, I imagine.

And what about news footage? It's quite common to see news reports from nasty accident scenes, showing casualties on stretchers with elevated i/v infusions in place. Often the footage is stated to be live. Why are these being "staged"? Why is the news team going to all the effort of setting up the accident scene with obsolete equipment, just because "it's what the public expects to see"? Don't be daft, they're showing what is actually there.

To keep up what Malcolm was postulating for 25 years suggests a conspiracy of massive proportions to keep the sight of the newer technology from the public. But why? It's not top-secret! Just thinking about his original assertion for about ten minutes reveals it to be as implausible as hell. Malcolm's lack of realisation of this is really telling, and illuminates a lot of what he's claiming, which is frankly implausible to the nth degree. When someone has as little ability to apply common sense as this, how sensible are any of his assumptions likely to be?

However, it got worse. When a number of people in a position to know the facts came along and pointed out that you were mistaken, Malcolm, did you take a good look at what they were saying, and demonstrate your commitment to the Truth? Did you hell! It was originally a small point. You made a mistaken (and frankly rather silly) assumption based on something you misunderstood some time ago. When the mistake was originally pointed out, it would have been easy for someone really dedicated to Truth to admit the mistake and move on to better and more defensible ground.

However, the grim, last-ditch, I-have-to-be-right-at-all-costs clinging to a position becoming increasingly untenable with every post demonstrated your true colours. Not, I seek the Truth, but, I seek to defend my agenda. Even to the point of essentially calling the doctors and paramedics who tried to put you right liars. (Why would we be lying about this? Because we knew the scene was a setup but wanted to conceal this? Don't be ridiculous!)

The minute it was demonstrated that the gravity-fed systems were not obsolete, but were in fact in common use, your point was dead in the water. But no. Once you realised that systems did actually exist that worked the way you thought they all worked (though they're not common), you had to show that such a system (no matter how esoteric and specialised) had to be what was used at the Pentagon that morning.

I would be contending that the military buy in bulk. That they would only buy IV bags that didn't have to be held up in the air....


That's a long long way from your original contention, that in fact such a system was all they could buy. And even if you had been right about that (Huntsman, may he be duly canonised, managed to produce enough evidence that even you couldn't continue), it wouldn't have been enough to show that the picture was a fake. The incident happened in the middle of Washington, beside a big office building not expecting military action, in peacetime. Why would it be impossible that civilian emergency medical equipment got deployed?

The shifting of the ground here exposes your defensive and essentially agenda-driven mindset with killer clarity. If you really want anyone here to believe that you're primarily interested in the Truth, you're going to have to clean up your act quite a bit. And that involves admitting the Truth when it's staring you in the face (or even handed to you on a silver platter), even if it's not what you wanted it to be, or imagined that it was.

It also involves getting a grip when it comes to basic physics. Asserting stubbornly that water won't flow out of a flexible polythene bag without a BIG hole in the top is just silly, when attempting the experiment with the ziplock bag suggested by one poster - or simply attempting to empty a rubber hot water bottle - would clearly demonstrate the Truth. Compounding the error by insisting that the hole is to allow gravity in (rather than air) - all I can say it, it argues a level of education and understanding I would have thought mort people surpass by the time they enter secondary school. Going on to assert that there is no gravity inside a TV tube? Well, we've been over that. Insisting that this must be true because how otherwise would the electrons get to the other side?

:crazy:

This is a very deep hole you've dug here. It's not going away just because you decide you want to address another point. I would suggest, if you want to acquire any credibility at all, you explicitly agree that yes, a flexible polythene bag does not need any hole in the top (BIG or otherwise) to allow the contents to flow out of a tube entering at the bottom, and yes, gravity does act on objects in a vacuum, and yes, electrons can cross a CRT because of their speed and the absence of any air molecules in the way, even though gravity is right there, as everywhere.

If you continue to be intransigent on these points, I fail to see why I (or anyone else for that matter) should oblige you by looking at any photographs.

And I'm not the only one.

From an outsider perspective (as I don't delve into the murky depths of the various CTs).

Malcolm, when you can't work out how an i/v drip works, and think that gravity doesn't exist inside a television, why on earth would you expect anyone to give any credence to any of your other theories?


You see? And despite your attempt to brush this off, this is an entirely logical standpoint.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
By the way, using my uncanny pregognitive ability, I predict that if Malcolm addresses the earlier post of mine here at all, he will merely quote the whole thing, then again direct me to photographs of an area I've never seen in my life and have no way of verifying.

But that doesn't make it all go away.

Rolfe.
 
I have to second Rolfe's comments in post 3226, Malcolm. Such discussions are not irrelevant. They speak poorly of your grasp of elementary physical principles and indicate a willingness to cling to manifestly wrong beliefs in the face of detailed factual explanations. That cannot fail to damage your general level of credibility.

It's to your credit that you eventually conceded that you were wrong about IV bags, but only after stubbornly denying and evading the overwhelming expertise and evidence for several pages and employing a number of rather juvenile taunts. That's no way to convince anybody of your claims.

BTW, do you acknowledge that vacuum does nothing to keep out gravity? Do you have any questions about my television-tube post?
 
Time to change some basic assumptions

I didn't intend ever to get drawin into this thread, because I felt that Malcolm Kirkman had neither any credibility nor any sincerity. I can see now that I was wrong. It's hard to admit it, but I've been wrong about a great many things, and it's time to let go. I couldn't believe for a long time that 9/11 could have been an inside job, but Malcolm has finally come up with a point I can't answer.

Let's take this one bit at a time.

First of all, we know that the WTC towers were air conditioned. As Malcolm explained, air conditioned buildings have no openings in them, so if the air conditioning fails, all the people in the building suffocate. This is all well known and unarguable.

Secondly, we know that the roof doors on both WTC towers were locked, preventing the people trapped inside from escaping to the roof.

There was therefore no opening in the sides or the top of the burning section of either tower.

Therefore, we can only conclude that the only possibility is that the towers were pushed downwards by energy beams from space. They couldn't possibly have simply collapsed at near gravitational free-fall speed as they did, because there weren't any holes to let the gravity in.

Malcolm, I'm convinced. When you finally get your Royal Commission to investigate 9/11, call on me to testify for the prosecution.

Dave
 
I'm not clear as to what your answer is.
Was the barrier built after the photo was taken or is there no barrier in the aerial shot?
http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies5.htm

Wow...Did NOT expect this to confuse you. But to be specific, then.

The barrier was built BEFORE the arial shot was taken, but AFTER the others in that picure.

The text next to the picture said the arial shot was taken "A few days later", plenty of time to erect the fence.

You can't possibly have thought about any of this. What POSSIBLE reason could there be for air-brushing out a FENCE? A fence that anyone who had seen the location previously would immediatly know was airbrushed out? Was the fence in the witness protection program? Was the fence the 2nd gunman on the grassy knoll? Did it know how to find Waldo?

Inquiring minds want to know! What is your reasoning behind thinking some sinister power would erase a barrier?
 
Wow...Did NOT expect this to confuse you. But to be specific, then.

The barrier was built BEFORE the arial shot was taken, but AFTER the others in that picure.


It doesn't even look like a guardrail, like he and the site claims.

More than likely it is just a fence put up to keep people away from the vehicles and equipment. A temporary fence takes only minutes to set up. Nothing strange or unexpected about that.
 
no plane flew into the Pentagon.

What evidence do you base this claim on?

There is only a flyover left. How hard was that to work out.

What evidence is there that AA77 flew over the pentagon?

If you maintain that a plane did hit the Pentagon then satisfy me as to where.

Where the explosion/damage occurred, and where all of the airplane parts were found to have damaged the building. The same place all of the eyewitnesses report seeing it hit, and the same place the surveillance tapes show the impact.
 
Uhm.

http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies8.htm

Am I seriously supposed to believe that these two pictures are of the same spot?


It reminds me of a story my mother tells about the 1964 World's Fair. My father had a map by which he would bark directions at my mother based on where they were in location to the custard stand. He would insist they had to go left because the custard stand was behind them and such. They,of course, spent the entire day completely lost (a hard thing to do when one could have used a huge giant globe for a landmark). It was only at the end of the day that my parents realized there was not one but a dozen different custard stands.

Here is the helicoper landing pad at the Pentagon. Which is more likely: 1) that there is only one sign warning that this is a helicopter operations area and it is located by the highway; or 2) that there are several signs with at least one located near the small adjacent parking lot, one by the larger parking lot, one by the walkway on the other side, one by the off ramp and who knows hoe many others? After all, based on the winds, a helicopter could come in to land from any direction. It might come in over the parking lot or over the highway or cross the off ramp and scare the hell out of the people on the walkway on the right side. It might come in from over the Pentagon, suddenly appearing above the heads of some staffers who had ducked out for a smoke.

I'm terrible at spacial relations and I don't know the Pentagon. But these are pictures of two different signs in two different places.
 
Me said:
First of all, it was not a cold morning. Temps were in the 60s (F).

Second, "everybody" are never at work in the nation's capital, one of the most popular tourist destinations in the world.

Mal, it's entertaining as all get-out how someone interested in the "truth" can be so blindingly wrong time after time after time. But you really should get a new act. Perhaps the accordian would suit you best?
Now kindly address the question of,
1. Lamp pole No.2.
2. The disguised guard rail at the triage site.
3. Whereabouts across the face of the Pentagon did the plane hit.
I have conceded on the IV bags, I willl do the same on the above three points. Just as soon as you can explain them.
No, you should respond to my points irrespective of any other claim. One does not relate to the other.

In regard to your question numbers 1-3 above, I do not know as I'm not qualified to expound on the matter. I have not studied or even made myself marginally aware of it. Others here may, just not me.
 
Last edited:
Uhm.

http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies8.htm

Am I seriously supposed to believe that these two pictures are of the same spot?


Good call, jsiv. I though they might actually be the same sign, with the pedestrian light pole looking closer than it should because of telephoto foreshortening, but they actually are two different signs.

Here is the original photo White cropped the top picture from. This sign is clearly located right between the only two trees along the sidewalk, and nearly in line with the crossbar in the "H" on the helipad (See Loss Leader's helipad photo above.)

Now watch the following video. Starting about the 2:45 mark (about 1:02 with the embedded counter), as the camera pans from the ambulances and back to the firefighting, an identical sign is visible right in front of the control tower, with no pedestrian light pole anywhere in the shot. So that could be the one in the bottom photo.


This is vintage Jack White. :rolleyes:
Code:
 
No, you should respond to my points irrespective of any other claim. One does not relate to the other.

In regard to your question numbers 1-3 above, I do not know as I'm not qualified to expound on the matter. I have not studied or even made myself marginally aware of it. Others here may, just not me.
That sounds like a cop out to me, as I'm sure it does to all and any unbiased reader. You are not qualified to pass an opinion as to whether you can see a lamp pole or a guardrail !
Anything but admit the truth eh.
 
What evidence do you base this claim on?



What evidence is there that AA77 flew over the pentagon?



Where the explosion/damage occurred, and where all of the airplane parts were found to have damaged the building. The same place all of the eyewitnesses report seeing it hit, and the same place the surveillance tapes show the impact.
You wouldn't be trying to avoid the reader seeing the truth would you, by attempting to shift the focus away from the photographs?
 
I didn't intend ever to get drawin into this thread, because I felt that Malcolm Kirkman had neither any credibility nor any sincerity. I can see now that I was wrong. It's hard to admit it, but I've been wrong about a great many things, and it's time to let go. I couldn't believe for a long time that 9/11 could have been an inside job, but Malcolm has finally come up with a point I can't answer.

Let's take this one bit at a time.

First of all, we know that the WTC towers were air conditioned. As Malcolm explained, air conditioned buildings have no openings in them, so if the air conditioning fails, all the people in the building suffocate. This is all well known and unarguable.

Secondly, we know that the roof doors on both WTC towers were locked, preventing the people trapped inside from escaping to the roof.

There was therefore no opening in the sides or the top of the burning section of either tower.

Therefore, we can only conclude that the only possibility is that the towers were pushed downwards by energy beams from space. They couldn't possibly have simply collapsed at near gravitational free-fall speed as they did, because there weren't any holes to let the gravity in.

Malcolm, I'm convinced. When you finally get your Royal Commission to investigate 9/11, call on me to testify for the prosecution.

Dave
Yet another crude attempt at a diversion.
 
Two points, Malcolm. First, unlike you, I prefer to pontificate only on matters I actually know something about. For example, I'm a vet, as I said, so I know about i/v infusions and I've actually used the equipment you were declaring no longer existed. This is what counts, not qualifications for the hell of it. Second, does this post tacitly admit you intend to concede the whole matter of gravity in a vacuum, and whether or not plastic bags can empty their contents without having a BIG hole in the top? Because it's not that simple.

I've no intention of even looking at the damn photos until this point is cleared up. You throw around frankly ludicrous assertions, insult better-informed people who try to put you right (I'm thinking particularly of your response to fls here, lest you misunderstand), and tie yourself in ever-tightening knots trying to defend an increasingly indefensible position. Of course, you can simply change the subject, ignore any attempt to bring you back to it, and move on to your next ludicrous assertion waiting for the people with the specialist knowledge in that area to work you over. But why do you think you can simply demand that people whom you've ignored, insulted and patronised, but who were actually right, should keep dancing to your agenda?

You see, the example of the i/v infusions clarified a very important matter. It showed that you're not primarily interested in the Truth. You're interested in supporting your own theory, any way it takes.

Your original point was that gravity-fed i/v infusions had been obsolete for at least 25 years, thus the picture showing such an infusion must have been staged. You explained the frequent portrayal of such infusions in the modern media as being staged just because that's what the public expects to see.

Was this ever plausible? While dramatic presentations might sometimes lag a little behind cutting-edge practice, they're not fossilised. "The public" contains many people who have first-hand experience of such infusions, as healthcare workers (not just the doctors and nurses, but the cleaners, the WI volunteers, the porters, the librarians and so on), as patients, as hospital visitors and even as bystanders at accident sites. How long is it likely to take for this level of awareness to work its way through to the TV and film producers - some at least of whom pride themselves on the accuracy of what they're showing? Not 25 years, I submit.

Where do film producers (and people staging publicity shots and so on) get their props, anyway? They don't make everything from scratch, not if it can be bought cheaply. They simply use the "real thing". If nobody was using gravity-fed drips, and hadn't been for 25 years, where would they get them from? Is there some warehouse somewhere holding old stock, just for the cameras? At what point does the charade become impossible to continue, simply because the obsolete kit is no longer available? Sooner than 25 years, I imagine.

And what about news footage? It's quite common to see news reports from nasty accident scenes, showing casualties on stretchers with elevated i/v infusions in place. Often the footage is stated to be live. Why are these being "staged"? Why is the news team going to all the effort of setting up the accident scene with obsolete equipment, just because "it's what the public expects to see"? Don't be daft, they're showing what is actually there.

To keep up what Malcolm was postulating for 25 years suggests a conspiracy of massive proportions to keep the sight of the newer technology from the public. But why? It's not top-secret! Just thinking about his original assertion for about ten minutes reveals it to be as implausible as hell. Malcolm's lack of realisation of this is really telling, and illuminates a lot of what he's claiming, which is frankly implausible to the nth degree. When someone has as little ability to apply common sense as this, how sensible are any of his assumptions likely to be?

However, it got worse. When a number of people in a position to know the facts came along and pointed out that you were mistaken, Malcolm, did you take a good look at what they were saying, and demonstrate your commitment to the Truth? Did you hell! It was originally a small point. You made a mistaken (and frankly rather silly) assumption based on something you misunderstood some time ago. When the mistake was originally pointed out, it would have been easy for someone really dedicated to Truth to admit the mistake and move on to better and more defensible ground.

However, the grim, last-ditch, I-have-to-be-right-at-all-costs clinging to a position becoming increasingly untenable with every post demonstrated your true colours. Not, I seek the Truth, but, I seek to defend my agenda. Even to the point of essentially calling the doctors and paramedics who tried to put you right liars. (Why would we be lying about this? Because we knew the scene was a setup but wanted to conceal this? Don't be ridiculous!)

The minute it was demonstrated that the gravity-fed systems were not obsolete, but were in fact in common use, your point was dead in the water. But no. Once you realised that systems did actually exist that worked the way you thought they all worked (though they're not common), you had to show that such a system (no matter how esoteric and specialised) had to be what was used at the Pentagon that morning.




That's a long long way from your original contention, that in fact such a system was all they could buy. And even if you had been right about that (Huntsman, may he be duly canonised, managed to produce enough evidence that even you couldn't continue), it wouldn't have been enough to show that the picture was a fake. The incident happened in the middle of Washington, beside a big office building not expecting military action, in peacetime. Why would it be impossible that civilian emergency medical equipment got deployed?

The shifting of the ground here exposes your defensive and essentially agenda-driven mindset with killer clarity. If you really want anyone here to believe that you're primarily interested in the Truth, you're going to have to clean up your act quite a bit. And that involves admitting the Truth when it's staring you in the face (or even handed to you on a silver platter), even if it's not what you wanted it to be, or imagined that it was.

It also involves getting a grip when it comes to basic physics. Asserting stubbornly that water won't flow out of a flexible polythene bag without a BIG hole in the top is just silly, when attempting the experiment with the ziplock bag suggested by one poster - or simply attempting to empty a rubber hot water bottle - would clearly demonstrate the Truth. Compounding the error by insisting that the hole is to allow gravity in (rather than air) - all I can say it, it argues a level of education and understanding I would have thought mort people surpass by the time they enter secondary school. Going on to assert that there is no gravity inside a TV tube? Well, we've been over that. Insisting that this must be true because how otherwise would the electrons get to the other side?

:crazy:

This is a very deep hole you've dug here. It's not going away just because you decide you want to address another point. I would suggest, if you want to acquire any credibility at all, you explicitly agree that yes, a flexible polythene bag does not need any hole in the top (BIG or otherwise) to allow the contents to flow out of a tube entering at the bottom, and yes, gravity does act on objects in a vacuum, and yes, electrons can cross a CRT because of their speed and the absence of any air molecules in the way, even though gravity is right there, as everywhere.

If you continue to be intransigent on these points, I fail to see why I (or anyone else for that matter) should oblige you by looking at any photographs.

And I'm not the only one.




You see? And despite your attempt to brush this off, this is an entirely logical standpoint.

Rolfe.
All those words of distraction rather than face the truth.
I have dealt with the IV bit as you well know.
Now you have no proper reason to dodge.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom