[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Don't bother, I'm not that desperate.


Does that mean that despite having conceded (after Huntsman's meticulous documentation) that gravity-fed i/v infusions are standard, you still think they can't work as seen in multiple pictures, because there's no BIG hole in the top to let the gravity in?

Does that mean you still think gravity doesn't act on objects in a vacuum? Despite numerous links to the "guinea and feather" experiment?

In that case, since you're obviously inhabiting some sort of parallel universe, there's not much point in conversing.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Does that mean that despite having conceded (after Huntsman's meticulous documentation) that gravity-fed i/v infusions are standard, you still think they can't work as seen in multiple pictures, because there's no BIG hole in the top to let the gravity in?

Does that mean you still think gravity doesn't act on objects in a vacuum? Despite numerous links to the "guinea and feather" experiment?

In that case, since you're obviously inhabiting some sort of parallel universe, there's not much point in conversing.

Rolfe.
You can say what you like on the internet. As a general rule, I don't like criticising people. It's a bad habit to get into. I'm not here to do that. But if you insist, I'm afraid your investigative skills don't impress me much.
Not so many posts ago, you went to some lengths to indicate that I was the same person named in your search and had been bankrupted some six or so years ago.
You failed to realise that the first named person is the one taking the action.
Knowing you, you might then go on to conclude that the named person was taking action againgst a building society, which has to be true because, as I say that is the order as written.
You might then assume that the first named was bankrupting a building society. That also, need not be the case. There are many possibilites.
The first named person might be taking a general action on behalf of a number of others for example, were that person qualified to do so. That is only one connotation. As I say, there are many. The only one that is surely incorrect is the one you plumped for. Not very good ,eh?
Secondly, you say you are familiar with the north of England. Yet you assume the term 'bride' means newly married. It could just as easily mean girlfriend. But then, you would have to be from the north to know that.
You also assume I have recently been on honeymoon. All incorrect, so not much there for me to have faith in your powers of deduction.
 
Charming.

At least you've shown that you're not actually looking for any sort of debate.
I've answered both questions numerous times. I'm fed up with pole No.2.
There's just so much, it's laughable.
Let's stick with the angle of approach for a while.
 
What's a tripler?

No, no, no. No more dodging, no more dancing, no more evasion. Answer the question, Malcolm. Do you admit to being wrong about the IVs and that they work like we've been claiming they work ? Do you admit to being wrong about gravity ? Yes or no.

Is the photo you posted of the entrance hole or not?

It's certainly not the exit hole, Malcolm. It's the area of the pengaton that was damaged by the plane. DAMAGED. The whole thing didn't enter the Pentagon like the Coyote would. But it's the damage caused by the plane. And it's pretty wide.

Why would you expect the whole thing to punch through the reinforced wall ?
 
Here's one for you.
What is the angle that the 'plane' hit the Pentagon, according to NIST?

Malcolm, perhaps this works with your buddies when you're drinking a beer, but around here, dodging a question by asking another question pretty much makes you look ridiculous.

You can say what you like on the internet.

No, you can't. Reality isn't different on the internet.
 
I've answered both questions numerous times. I'm fed up with pole No.2.
There's just so much, it's laughable.
Let's stick with the angle of approach for a while.


The questions jsiv was referring to had to do with the "helicopter operations" signs, not the light poles. And the question of the "helicopter operations" signs was brought up by you. You asked for a debunking, jsiv gave it. You have made no response.

What possible reason could jsiv have for looking into the angle of approach at your insistence when you don't respond to other issues we've looked into at your insistence?

Admit that the two pictures are of different "helicopter operations" signs, refute the evidence that has been given to you or ST[rule8]U.
 
You can say what you like on the internet. As a general rule, I don't like criticising people. It's a bad habit to get into. I'm not here to do that. But if you insist, I'm afraid your investigative skills don't impress me much.
Not so many posts ago, you went to some lengths to indicate that I was the same person named in your search and had been bankrupted some six or so years ago.
You failed to realise that the first named person is the one taking the action.
Knowing you, you might then go on to conclude that the named person was taking action againgst a building society, which has to be true because, as I say that is the order as written.
You might then assume that the first named was bankrupting a building society. That also, need not be the case. There are many possibilites.
The first named person might be taking a general action on behalf of a number of others for example, were that person qualified to do so. That is only one connotation. As I say, there are many. The only one that is surely incorrect is the one you plumped for. Not very good ,eh?
Secondly, you say you are familiar with the north of England. Yet you assume the term 'bride' means newly married. It could just as easily mean girlfriend. But then, you would have to be from the north to know that.
You also assume I have recently been on honeymoon. All incorrect, so not much there for me to have faith in your powers of deduction.


Sounds fascinating. Do tell!

Rolfe.
 
OK, I'm one sick puppy. . . .


"Veterinarian, heal thyself." :p

2. He says his name is Malcolm Kirkman.
Well, he's never claimed it's his real name. . . .

I Googled a bit, but not expecting anything as I'd imagine it's a common enough name. However, the results were mildly interesting. Searching the Web produced only 383 returns, and the first few pages are nothing but a slew of links to 9/11 discussion boards, including this one, with posts all along the lines we're familiar with. When I searched "pages from the UK only", I got only three returns.


According to www.192.com, there's only one Malcolm Kirkman on the UK electoral rolls.

3. He says he's in his 50s.
This has been questioned by a number of people, including me, but as we get to know him better, I'm becoming convinced. Yes, his attitude and reasoning are very immature, but there's immature-young, and then there's immature, how do I put it, just never matured. He never uses the net-slang of the teen brigade, even though he's posting on other forums where it's common usage. He asked what a troll was, seemingly sincerely, and there have been other questions suggesting a similar naivete. It's extremely unlikely that a teenager with a computer wouldn't use these slang expressions, or fail to have picked up on what a troll is. And you don't have to be young to be immature.


I agree completely with your analysis on this, Rolfe.

4. He says he's retired.
Given that I'm inclined to credit the age, this could well be true. However, "retired" doesn't only imply "made my pile and am now reclining on it". A school janitor forced into early retirement because the cleaning had been outsourced to the McChar franchise would be in the same position.


See below for a reason for Malcolm's possible involuntary retirement.

5. He says he's very rich.
Now, if you were that janitor, and decided to post on an Internet forum, would you come clean about that? You well might. But on the other hand, a very arrogant person with a high opinion of himself might well prefer to adopt the persona of a rich early retiree.


He's obviously not rich enough to make a $1000 (£488 at today's exchange rate) donation to charity without putting a serious crimp in his lifestyle. :rolleyes:

If Malcolm were indeed rich and successful, I'd say it would be likely that we'd come across some reference to his life in the real world on the Internet.

But I only found that one link to his name which wasn't related to spouting the same CT mantras. This one. Just under half way down the page. . . .


I found another web page referencing the same case; it's listed under "reported/important cases" on a barrister's CV. More on this below.

Well, that insolvency was nine years ago, maybe five years before Malcolm claims to have retired. A lot can happen in five years. But that would be one hell of a rags to riches story.


I found the actual judgment a while back, based on the page you linked (originally provided by Arkan Wolfshade, who presumably put Malcolm on ignore immediately after outing him as a potential troll). I haven't brought it up before now because I didn't want to appear to be making an argumentum ad hominem abusive. It took a while to find it originally, and then to re-find it, as the page in question appears to lack search-engine tags. At any rate, this opinion reveals a lot about Malcolm's background and personality. Unfortunately, the clerk who wrote this has Malcolm's last name as "Kirkham" in the text. However, both the case name and the plaintiff's name say "Kirkman," and the case is cited as such on both above-linked pages, plus the site where it's posted. Based on the other obvious transcription errors, it's clear that someone at some point got the spelling of Malcolm's last name wrong. Money quotes are in bold.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE LTA 97/7408 CMS3
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL (CIVIL DIVISION)
ON APPEAL FROM THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE,
MANCHESTER DISTRICT REGISTRY
(HIS HONOUR JUDGE HEGARTY )
Royal Courts of Justice
Strand
London WC2

Friday, 24 April 1998

B e f o r e:

LORD JUSTICE ALDOUS
LORD JUSTICE WARD

- - - - - -

MALCOLM KIRKMAN
PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT

- v -

SKIPTON BUILDING SOCIETY
DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT

- - - - - -
(Computer Aided Transcript of the Palantype Notes of
Smith Bernal Reporting Limited, 180 Fleet Street,
London EC4A 2HD
Tel: 0171 421 4040
Official Shorthand Writers to the Court)
- - - - - -

The Applicant, Mr Kirkman, appeared in person

The Respondent, did not appear and was not represented

- - - - - -

J U D G M E N T
(As approved by the Court )

- - - - - -
©Crown Copyright [Whether this document is still covered is questionable, from what I've read. In any case this excerpt should qualify as "fair use."]
Friday, 24 April 1998

J U D G M E N T
LORD JUSTICE ALDOUS: This is an application for leave to appeal the decision of His Honour Judge Hegarty QC sitting as a judge of the High Court of 15 September 1997 whereby the judge dismissed an appeal against the refusal of District Judge Shaw given on 31 July 1996 to set aside a statutory demand served upon the applicant the previous June.

Before I come to the merits of the application I must shortly set out the factual background. Mr Kirkham [sic from here on] was the owner of a property known as 9 Kestrel Drive, Darwen, Lancashire. By a legal charge dated 21 July 1991 he charged that property to the Skipton Building Society to secure a loan of £117,000. On 25 February 1991 he paid the first instalment due under the mortgage amounting to approximately £1,452. He also applied and obtained, through the Bolton office of the building society, for personal accident and sickness insurance. . . .

On 26 February 1991 the premium for the policy was paid to the Guardian Royal Exchange and debited to Mr Kirkham's account. On 21 March 1991 Mr Kirkham paid the second instalment. It was the last instalment that he paid. In May 1991 he made a claim on the policy . . .

Mr Kirkham failed to make payments to the building society during the two month period provided for in the insurance certificate. On 13 June 1991 the building society wrote to him pointing out that his account was over £4,000 in arrears, which amounted to three monthly payments. They informed him that, unless the arrears were cleared within the next seven days, their solicitors would be instructed to take proceedings for possession of the mortgaged property without further notice. It is to be noted that two of those months would be those referred to in the policy as deferred months, while the other month would have been a month which, if his claim had been a correct one, should have been paid by the Guardian Royal Exchange to the Skipton Building Society.

Proceedings for possession were not take [sic] at that time. There was a conversation between a Mr Bolton on behalf of the building society and Mr Kirkham which resulted in Mr Kirkham writing a letter dated 17 October 1991 in which he enclosed the keys to the property and voluntarily handed over possession. It is Mr Kirkham's case that that letter was written on the basis that he would give up voluntary possession and the property would then be sold and (as he said) he and the society would be quits. I should say that the building society do not accept that was agreed, but Mr Kirkham says that it was, although at the moment he cannot prove it.

The property was sold for £83,000, providing a net sum of just over £80,000. That meant there was a shortfall of just over £56,000. It was not until 12 June 1996 that the building society took steps to recover that shortfall when they served a statutory demand for that amount.

On 5 July Mr Kirkham applied to set aside that statutory demand. His application came before District Judge Shaw on 31 July 1996. The district judge had difficulty in understanding the grounds upon which it was suggested that there was a bona fide dispute as to the debt, or that Mr Kirkham had a claim which equalled or exceeded that claim by the society. He dismissed the application. The fact that the district judge had difficulty in understanding his case was probably Mr Kirkham's fault. He lacks the ability to explain the matter so that a judge can understand it. In any case the district judge held that there was no evidence that the building society had made any misrepresentation, as Mr Kirkham alleged, and there was no grounds for concluding that there was any agreement between the parties as to what would happen on possession being handed over.

Mr Kirkham appealed. I need not dwell on the procedural difficulties that resulted. Ultimately his appeal came before His Honour Judge Hegarty QC who sat, as was appropriate, as a Judge of the High Court. He dismissed the appeal and refused leave to appeal. It is against that judgment that Mr Kirkham now seeks leave to appeal.

Mr Kirkham's case was examined in detail by the judge who gave a detailed and careful judgment. In particular, he analysed the two issues which have been argued before us, namely whether there was a negligent misrepresentation which induced Mr Kirkham to enter into the arrangement with the building society; and secondly, whether there was a contract between the parties which provided that Mr Kirkham would give up possession of the house on the basis that both sides would call it quits. He dealt with those issues at length and concluded that there was no possibility of Mr Kirkham succeeding on them. In those circumstances he refused leave to appeal.

I will not go into all the issues that Mr Kirkham has placed before us; it is sufficient for me to concentrate on his case based upon misrepresentation.

We extracted from Mr Kirkham a copy of a letter from the Guardian Royal Exchange of 22 August 1997. Enclosed with that letter was a copy of the Master Policy under which he was insured. The policy was between the Guardian Royal Exchange and the Skipton Building Society, the Skipton Building Society being named as the insured. . . .

That insurance policy contained, as the certificate did, an exception to the policy for the two month deferred period. . . .

Mr Kirkham says that the position was this. He accepts that he did not make payments for the two month deferred period, but thereafter the payments should have been made by the Guardian Royal Exchange to the building society and that, if that had been done, as the building society should have made sure occurred, he would have at most been two months in arrears. In those circumstances it would have been most unlikely that any Court would have granted possession. Thus he says the damage which has been caused to him was caused by the building society not obtaining payments from the Guardian Royal Exchange under the group personal accident policy. He says that the difficulties he encountered were not brought to his notice when he entered into this policy. He was led to believe that, if he changed . . . to the Skipton Building Society, he would have the advantage of a cheaper and better insurance. As it turned out that did not happen. In those circumstances, he says, he has a valid defence to the claim by the building society. At most he owed them two months' repayments, and he should not be required to pay them any more.

I have tried to set out the argument which Mr Kirkham put forward. I suspect that he has not analysed it in that way. However, I have come to the position that the argument raises a point which is proper to be considered by this Court and therefore it would be appropriate to give leave to appeal.

I must urge Mr Kirkham to obtain legal advice. Having heard him address this Court, I have a feeling that, if he does not do so, it is likely his appeal will fail. I would give leave.

LORD JUSTICE WARD: I agree.

ORDER: Leave to appeal granted; 28 days to serve the Notice of Appeal; copy of judgment to be supplied at public expense.[emphasis added]


Name confusion or not, this has to be our Malcolm. The bolded quotes eliminate any reasonable doubt of that.

6. He says he lives in the UK.
Yes, I believe that. He has some ugly Americanisms, but his spelling and usage are by and large UK. Yes, I so believe that. . . .


I concur--especially about the "ugly Americanisms."

7. He says he's lived for some time in the US. Specifically, he said he'd lived for some time in the vicinity of the Pentagon, I think he said Arlington?
I don't believe him. I don't think anyone could reside in the US for any length of time and not know that the floor above the ground floor is designated the "second floor". I'm even mildly surprised he hadn't picked that up from film and TV.


I agree on this; however, in the interest of full disclosure, I have to say that I do know of one building near me that has both a ground floor and a first floor. Due to the terrain it has doors that open off of the first floor on two sides, and the ground floor on two sides. It's about 45 years old, and also has a basement and a second floor. I suspect that the unusual features are the reason that this naming convention was used. Also, Malcolm's having lived here for a bit would explain the above-average number of Americanisms (ugly and otherwise) in his writing.

8. He says he recently got married, indeed he claims to have been posting from his honeymoon.
Gimme a break! Of course I've no evidence one way or the other, but the idea of any woman wanting to marry oor Malkie, in his 50s, no job, and sued for insolvency nine years ago, probably for mortgage arrears? With male chauvinist attitudes that would have most women reaching for the works of Germaine Greer? Not a high probability in my book.


Sadly, I've known some women who've shown extremely poor judgment in picking men, so anything is possible. Also, I noticed that Malcolm actually didn't post very much during his "honeymoon."

9. He says he's a member of Mensa.
We've been a bit snippy about Mensa, I know I have, and I know there are people who are desperately wanting in all sorts of ways who've got into Mensa because they have the right problem-solving abilities. Nevertheless, I've sat the Mensa test, and it's not a walkover. I know several people I'd class as reasonably intelligent who have failed it, even if only just. Bearing in mind the sort of questions in that test, and that Malcolm lacks the reasoning skills to realise anything from the improbability of all media sources successfully collaborating over a 25-year period to show only obsolete medical equipment, to the impossibility of there being no gravity inside a TV set (at sea level), I don't see him getting to page two on a bet.


I concur. As someone who's scored high enough on a real I.Q. test to qualify for Mensa, but chooses not to join, I have to say this seems highly unlikely to me also.

I can't think of a 10 right now, but maybe this gives us a bit more insight into the person we're discussing with.


10. He claims to have "an honours degree in law."

Given the justice's comments in the judgment, my reaction has to be:

:faint: :faint: :faint:
 
Last edited:
sts60 said:
Of course it does. Which is why a few moment's of Googling - not even real research - would have shown you immediately that your ideas about vacuum and gravity (and IV bags) were wrong.

As I said before, this sort of stuff seriously undermines your credibility. The claims belie a very poor understanding of basic physical principles and a poor set of observational skills, and your stubbornness in clinging to them despite repeated explanations speaks poorly of your willingness to admit errors and actually learn something. Is that the impression you want to give? Do you think you'll convince anybody that way?

I'm trying to help you here. You can wave it off if you want, but don't say I didn't try.
You'll have no difficulty waving off the points I've made about the video then will you?
*Sigh*. Have I made any comments about this video? No. I am neither accepting nor challenging your claims about the video. I have only challenged you about the IV bag issue and your understanding of basic physics. And I've tried to help you by pointing out such issues, and your response to them, hurt your cause. But if you don't want help, fine; that's your call.
 
The questions jsiv was referring to had to do with the "helicopter operations" signs, not the light poles. And the question of the "helicopter operations" signs was brought up by you. You asked for a debunking, jsiv gave it. You have made no response.

What possible reason could jsiv have for looking into the angle of approach at your insistence when you don't respond to other issues we've looked into at your insistence?

Admit that the two pictures are of different "helicopter operations" signs, refute the evidence that has been given to you or ST[rule8]U.
jsiv can speak for himself.
Show me where I brought up the sign.
 
The questions jsiv was referring to had to do with the "helicopter operations" signs, not the light poles. And the question of the "helicopter operations" signs was brought up by you. You asked for a debunking, jsiv gave it. You have made no response.

What possible reason could jsiv have for looking into the angle of approach at your insistence when you don't respond to other issues we've looked into at your insistence?

Admit that the two pictures are of different "helicopter operations" signs, refute the evidence that has been given to you or ST[rule8]U.
1, If you go to the posts that jsiv mentioned you will see that he was referring to the poles.
2. Allow other people to speak for themselves.
3. I refer you to my previous post with regard to me introducing the sign.
 
Not so many posts ago, you went to some lengths to indicate that I was the same person named in your search and had been bankrupted some six or so years ago. You failed to realise that the first named person is the one taking the action. Knowing you, you might then go on to conclude that the named person was taking action againgst a building society, which has to be true because, as I say that is the order as written.
You might then assume that the first named was bankrupting a building society. That also, need not be the case. There are many possibilites.
The first named person might be taking a general action on behalf of a number of others for example, were that person qualified to do so. That is only one connotation. As I say, there are many.


No, what you've said above is not true. A creditor might be able to force a person into bankruptcy. However, when a person seeks bankruptcy protection, he is the petitioner to the court. He then "sues" his creditors. Note the case names in this article including: Thomas v. Money Mart Financial Services, Inc. and Martens v. Countrywide Home Loans. Thomas and Martens were the debtors filing for voluntary bankruptcy protection. Money Mart and Countrywide were not being bankrupted by these two debtors.

In general, if a bankruptcy case name has a person listed as the petitioner and an institution as the respondent, it is a safe bet that the individual is the one going bankrupt. If a litigant is representing a larger group, the case name will reflect it by stating "et al." Here's a non-bankruptcy case so titled: Arnold, et al. v. United Artists Theater Circuit, Inc.. In some parts of the world, "et al." might be replaced by "and others". In fact, on the same page that your case was listed, several cases included "and others" in the name including Katz and others v. McNally and others.

While it is impossible to say for sure, from just the case name listed on that page, it is reasonable to conclude:

1. You were not taking a general action on behalf of others; and

2. You were seeking voluntary bankruptcy protection from a creditor, most likely your mortgage company or the builders who held a note on your home.

Once again, you have stated things as though no one on this board had any expertise. And once again someone who knows what they're talking about has been able to contradict you. I, as it happens, am an actual lawyer.

However, this is the easiest thing in the world to debunk. All you have to do is publish the court documents relating to your case. That would close the matter completely.

Of course, it's possible that after all these years the papers have simply floated away since, as we know, they had no hole in the top to let the gravity in.



Edit: As suspected, the case had to do with Malcolm being indebted to his mortgage company. His insinuation that he was somehow taking an action on behalf of others to drive a mortgage company into bankruptcy is conclusively proven false.
 
Last edited:
"Veterinarian, heal thyself." :p


You got me there!

According to www.192.com, there's only one Malcolm Kirkman on the UK electoral rolls.


That's the surprising bit. Both names are common. But just this one combination. I have a friend whose husband is a Paul Kirkman. I Googled him too. Lots of returns, and my Paul only appeared half way down the first page (he's a town councillor in Essex). I then Googled Michael Kirkman and David Kirkman, just at random, and again got lots of returns. But only one Malkie. Tough cheddar.

I didn't say before that I just didn't think Malcolm was bright enough to realise that using a pseudonym or a handle on the Net might be a good idea, but I'll say it now.

I agree completely with your analysis on this, Rolfe.


Well, if it wasn't obvious by now, your further revelations have clinched it.

See below for a reason for Malcolm's possible involuntary retirement.


Who knows. But it's not the track record of someone who's retired on the back of a nice bank balance or pension.

He's obviously not rich enough to make a $1000 (£488 at today's exchange rate) donation to charity without putting a serious crimp in his lifestyle. :rolleyes:


Which should teach him about making empty gestures, but probably won't. It reminds me of the nuisance caller who tried to scare me by saying she was from the Inland Revenue and I owed them £50. The paltry nature of the sum she thought might worry me said more than anything else.

I found another web page referencing the same case; it's listed under "reported/important cases" on a barrister's CV. More on this below.

I found the actual judgment a while back, based on the page you linked (originally provided by Arkan Wolfshade, who presumably put Malcolm on ignore immediately after outing him as a potential troll). I haven't brought it up before now because I didn't want to appear to be making an argumentum ad hominem abusive. It took a while to find it originally, and then to re-find it, as the page in question appears to lack search-engine tags. At any rate, this opinion reveals a lot about Malcolm's background and personality. Unfortunately, the clerk who wrote this has Malcolm's last name as "Kirkham" in the text. However, both the case name and the plaintiff's name say "Kirkman," and the case is cited as such on both above-linked pages, plus the site where it's posted. Based on the other obvious transcription errors, it's clear that someone at some point got the spelling of Malcolm's last name wrong. Money quotes are in bold.


Bloody hell, Spitfire! I only Googled his name, for entertainment at coffee break. I didn't expect to find as much as I did, and didn't intend to rake any further. I was mostly intrigued by the apparent confirmation of my hunch that he spoke like my Halifax-reared godson. (Who really does have an honours degree in Law, from Oxford, silly boy.) What my GP friend said about "Tod" (which coincidentally was where Shipman started his killing spree) was that they were all so inbred that practising medicine in that town was a whole new education.

Name confusion or not, this has to be our Malcolm. The bolded quotes eliminate any reasonable doubt of that.


Oh for sure. The funny thing is, it reminds me of another "MK", a Maurice Kirk who was struck off the veterinary register and has been bothering the courts for years. For some reason I can't get off that guy's email list. I think he's even further gone than Malkie.

I concur--especially about the "ugly Americanisms."

I agree on this; however, in the interest of full disclosure, I have to say that I do know of one building near me that has both a ground floor and a first floor. Due to the terrain it has doors that open off of the first floor on two sides, and the ground floor on two sides. It's about 45 years old, and also has a basement and a second floor. I suspect that the unusual features are the reason that this naming convention was used. Also, Malcolm's having lived here for a bit would explain the above-average number of Americanisms (ugly and otherwise) in his writing.


You only need a TV (with null-G at the centre of course!) to pick up all sorts of horrors. (I particularly hate the use of IV, which seems to be a Roman numeral, for i/v as in intravenous, I put up with it from Yanks, but not here.) And it's hard even to visit the US without picking up on the floors thing. Even in Britain, there are a few international hotels who do that, to avoid confusing the colonials.

Sadly, I've known some women who've shown extremely poor judgment in picking men, so anything is possible. Also, I noticed that Malcolm actually didn't post very much during his "honeymoon."


I don't honestly know. I knew I could make that post more accurate (and get to 10!) if I actually sourced the quotes from Malcolm's posts, but I do actually have some work to do and life's too short. I just remember someone saying, bloody hell Malcolm, you're not saying you're going to keep posting during your honeymoon! and not being contradicted. I'm no expert in West Yorkshire slang, and said godson hasn't been hot enough in the pickup department to have provided amorous examples. (One girl, once, called Hazel, and all I remember is his sister's dismissive comment - "she's a nut". :D ) I guess when you look at what dweebs some women will settle for, anything's possible. I just suspect that inventing a girlfriend or new wife may go with inventing a fortune and Mensa membership and a Law degree.

I concur. As someone who's scored high enough on a real I.Q. test to qualify for Mensa, but chooses not to join, I have to say this seems highly unlikely to me also.


Totally. In fact it was the friend who eventually married Paul Kirkman who persuaded me to join, because she said that at least the men one might meet would have two neurones to rub together. (They did, but most of them were total nerds. I didn't renew my subscription.) The questions were definitely testing.

10. He claims to have "an honours degree in law."

Given the justice's comments in the judgment, my reaction has to be:

:faint: :faint: :faint:


I knew it! I knew I'd missed one!

:hb:

I suppose it was his experience in the Manchester District Court that prompted him to think of that. I think we can take that one as definitely refuted.

You know, when Malcolm pointed out about the plaintiff's name being first, my immediate reaction was, the story of how Malcolm tried to sue the Skipton Building Society for bankruptcy has got to be more interesting than any story about how said building society tried to sue Malcolm.

You know, I might even look at the lamp-post pictures next week, just for an even bigger laugh.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
No, what you've said above is not true. A creditor might be able to force a person into bankruptcy. However, when a person seeks bankruptcy protection, he is the petitioner to the court. He then "sues" his creditors. Note the case names in this article including: Thomas v. Money Mart Financial Services, Inc. and Martens v. Countrywide Home Loans. Thomas and Martens were the debtors filing for voluntary bankruptcy protection. Money Mart and Countrywide were not being bankrupted by these two debtors.

In general, if a bankruptcy case name has a person listed as the petitioner and an institution as the respondent, it is a safe bet that the individual is the one going bankrupt. If a litigant is representing a larger group, the case name will reflect it by stating "et al." Here's a non-bankruptcy case so titled: Arnold, et al. v. United Artists Theater Circuit, Inc.. In some parts of the world, "et al." might be replaced by "and others". In fact, on the same page that your case was listed, several cases included "and others" in the name including Katz and others v. McNally and others.

While it is impossible to say for sure, from just the case name listed on that page, it is reasonable to conclude:

1. You were not taking a general action on behalf of others; and

2. You were seeking voluntary bankruptcy protection from a creditor, most likely your mortgage company or the builders who held a note on your home.

Once again, you have stated things as though no one on this board had any expertise. And once again someone who knows what they're talking about has been able to contradict you. I, as it happens, am an actual lawyer.

However, this is the easiest thing in the world to debunk. All you have to do is publish the court documents relating to your case. That would close the matter completely.

Of course, it's possible that after all these years the papers have simply floated away since, as we know, they had no hole in the top to let the gravity in.



Edit: As suspected, the case had to do with Malcolm being indebted to his mortgage company. His insinuation that he was somehow taking an action on behalf of others to drive a mortgage company into bankruptcy is conclusively proven false.
You pre suppose far too many irrelevant things.
This thread is supposed to be about 9/11 being an inside job.
Is your real name Loss leader?
 
"Veterinarian, heal thyself." :p




According to www.192.com, there's only one Malcolm Kirkman on the UK electoral rolls.




I agree completely with your analysis on this, Rolfe.




See below for a reason for Malcolm's possible involuntary retirement.




He's obviously not rich enough to make a $1000 (£488 at today's exchange rate) donation to charity without putting a serious crimp in his lifestyle. :rolleyes:




I found another web page referencing the same case; it's listed under "reported/important cases" on a barrister's CV. More on this below.




I found the actual judgment a while back, based on the page you linked (originally provided by Arkan Wolfshade, who presumably put Malcolm on ignore immediately after outing him as a potential troll). I haven't brought it up before now because I didn't want to appear to be making an argumentum ad hominem abusive. It took a while to find it originally, and then to re-find it, as the page in question appears to lack search-engine tags. At any rate, this opinion reveals a lot about Malcolm's background and personality. Unfortunately, the clerk who wrote this has Malcolm's last name as "Kirkham" in the text. However, both the case name and the plaintiff's name say "Kirkman," and the case is cited as such on both above-linked pages, plus the site where it's posted. Based on the other obvious transcription errors, it's clear that someone at some point got the spelling of Malcolm's last name wrong. Money quotes are in bold.




Name confusion or not, this has to be our Malcolm. The bolded quotes eliminate any reasonable doubt of that.




I concur--especially about the "ugly Americanisms."




I agree on this; however, in the interest of full disclosure, I have to say that I do know of one building near me that has both a ground floor and a first floor. Due to the terrain it has doors that open off of the first floor on two sides, and the ground floor on two sides. It's about 45 years old, and also has a basement and a second floor. I suspect that the unusual features are the reason that this naming convention was used. Also, Malcolm's having lived here for a bit would explain the above-average number of Americanisms (ugly and otherwise) in his writing.




Sadly, I've known some women who've shown extremely poor judgment in picking men, so anything is possible. Also, I noticed that Malcolm actually didn't post very much during his "honeymoon."




I concur. As someone who's scored high enough on a real I.Q. test to qualify for Mensa, but chooses not to join, I have to say this seems highly unlikely to me also.




10. He claims to have "an honours degree in law."

Given the justice's comments in the judgment, my reaction has to be:

:faint: :faint: :faint:
All very interesting and all totally irrelevant.
I might just as easily have called myself Jesse Ventura.
 
1. I am not claiming to know what was in the mind of the faker, only that the photo is clearly faked.


How is it "clearly fake?" You've conceded that the IV bag doesn't prove anything.

You agree then that the pall of smoke over the Pentagon was burning oil that was nothing to do with the building itself. Can you find an MSM report that tells us this.


Changing horses. And please refrain from putting words in my mouth. As with most large fires, there were many different materials burning, in many different quantities, and at various times. So the smoke had many constituents, and most certainly had much "to do with the building itself."

3. You say the hole on the first floor only. Please, he is describing the ONLY hole in the Pentagon in answer to the question that was asked him.


I didn't say anything about what floor the hole was on; I said he very likely couldn't see the lower part of the hole due to having his view obstructed by firefighting equipment and smoke. If he only saw the upper portion of the hole before the building collapsed, how could he describe the entire hole based on his observations??
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom