Rolfe
Adult human female
You're nominating anyone percieved as being "truther" or "neutral" in order to make an Ad Hom.
Argumentum ad hominem isn't just a classy synonym for "insult". It refers to a particular type of argument, essentially fallacious, where the character or record of the person putting forward the proposition is attacked and this attack held thus to discredit the proposition.
I saw a classic example here the other day, when someone mentioned a CTer's web site. The response was, you don't want to pay any attention to him, he believes in the Protocols of the Elders of Zion.
That's an ad hom. Logically, whether or not the person believes in the Protocols of the Elders of Zion has no bearing on whether his arguments regarding the Twin Towers are fallacious or not. (Though knowing the former may help one judge what the quality of the latter may be like.)
It's a useful term. It has a specific meaning. This usefulness is removed when the term is used simply as a synonym for "insult".
"Insult" is a perfectly good word. Why not use it, and leave the technical term alone for use in its proper context?
Rolfe.
PS. If you really meant that someone's arguments were being dismissed just on the grounds that "he's a truther" and not on their merits (or lack of them), I apologise, because that is correct usage. However, it didn't appear that the term was being used in that way.
Last edited:
