TruthSeeker1234
Banned
- Joined
- Sep 9, 2006
- Messages
- 1,756
http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/ABPlaneStudy/SalterDeconstruction.html
Eric Salter has offered what he calls a rebuttal to my Chopper 5 velocity analysis.
"Chopper 5 Composite" by Ace Baker
"Rebuttal of Ace Baker's 'Chopper 5 Composite' Analysis" by Eric Salter
His entire critique is premised around a demonstrably false claim. Namely, Salter claims that the camera motion of the Chopper 5 shot is perfectly stable, and so would have a perfectly consistent effect on the apparent motion of the airplane. I invite everyone to please download the Chopper 5 video and step through it frame by frame, paying attention to the apparent motion of the twin towers, to see whether this apparent motion is perfectly consistent from frame to frame, or not. I am confident that everyone in the world except Eric Salter will agree that the motion is quite unsteady and inconsistent.
download Chopper 5 video clip
In addition to the false claim about the stability of the helicopter shot, Salter wrongly suggests that fine detail is more important than overall position in determining velocity, he dismisses the validity of my control cases based on an irrelevancy, fabricates a huge margin of error with no control case whatsoever, concocts a strawman argument and attributes it to me, incorporates the strawman into a false dichotomy, directs attention to an unrelated video claiming it would have had to have been made the same way as Chopper 5, all while concealing his stabilization data from us, so that we cannot actually test his basic claims.
Eric Salter has offered what he calls a rebuttal to my Chopper 5 velocity analysis.
"Chopper 5 Composite" by Ace Baker
"Rebuttal of Ace Baker's 'Chopper 5 Composite' Analysis" by Eric Salter
His entire critique is premised around a demonstrably false claim. Namely, Salter claims that the camera motion of the Chopper 5 shot is perfectly stable, and so would have a perfectly consistent effect on the apparent motion of the airplane. I invite everyone to please download the Chopper 5 video and step through it frame by frame, paying attention to the apparent motion of the twin towers, to see whether this apparent motion is perfectly consistent from frame to frame, or not. I am confident that everyone in the world except Eric Salter will agree that the motion is quite unsteady and inconsistent.
download Chopper 5 video clip
In addition to the false claim about the stability of the helicopter shot, Salter wrongly suggests that fine detail is more important than overall position in determining velocity, he dismisses the validity of my control cases based on an irrelevancy, fabricates a huge margin of error with no control case whatsoever, concocts a strawman argument and attributes it to me, incorporates the strawman into a false dichotomy, directs attention to an unrelated video claiming it would have had to have been made the same way as Chopper 5, all while concealing his stabilization data from us, so that we cannot actually test his basic claims.
Last edited: