[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, Malcolm, not so. Look again at what that web page says this very new model, nothing like what you described can do.




​
This thing can change a voice from sounding male to sounding female and vice versa. This isn't complicated and essentially just involves modifying the harmonics. A pre-set programme can handle it. It's nothing like making one person's voice sound convincingly like another's.

Neither does this machine change the pitch of what is sung. This simply indicates to the singer by a colour-coded display, whether or not s/he is on pitch. It's then up to the singer to correct the pitch accordingly. So, no cigar.




What you said was that the original karaoke machines could instantaneously corrent the pitch of a singer so that off-tune notes sung into the microphone were heard as in-tune from the amplifier. Now if this was really the case, and this astonishing capability had been sidelined by competition from cowboys who had infringed the copyright on the name "karaoke", don't you think this might be discussed on the web somewhere?

Don't you think the owners of the trademark might have been taking some legal steps to stop this infringement? Steps that might be documented somewhere? Don't you think we'd easily find advertisements and promotions of the "real thing", highlighting its capabilities and urging us to shun the cheap copies?

I'm definitely calling BS on this. Malcolm is claiming not just that there is some sort of new super-duper karaoke machine which can make Florence Foster-Jenkins sing as on-pitch as Joan Sutherland, he's claiming that this is what all genuine karaoke [TM] machines have always done, and that anything that doesn't is just a cheap knock-off. There appears to be absolutely no evidence for this ever having been the case, and it's something for which we would expect evidence to be all over the place if it were actually the case.




It shouldn't be hard at all. What you are claiming is a big deal. That the original "karaoke [TM]" machines all had this capability, but that cowboys have since flooded the market with cheap knock-offs which don't. Infringing either trademark or copyright while they were at it. If anything like this had happened, there would be plenty articles and discussions referring to it.

I've just had a look at the Wikipedia article on Karaoke. It's interesting, and I learned some new stuff in there (for example that there is indeed a connnection to the classical tapes and records called "music minus one", usually concertos with the solo part missing and things like that, which were on sale in the 1970s to allow classical musicians to practise without requiring an accompanist). There's also stuff about legal disputes regarding patent rights. What there isn't, is the slightest hint that there was ever any capacity to change the pitch of the singer's voice.

Why would such a major feature of the history of the system not get any sort of mention in Wikipedia, Malcolm? Why aren't we seeing the owners of the original-type machines advertising their capabilities and urging the consumers not to accept cheap substitutes?




Malcolm, the chances of anyone here trusting you on anything, especially considering your track record, make a snowball in hell look positively invulnerable.

So now the feature which was common to all the original karaoke [TM] machines is now something so esoteric that it's a tightly-kept trade secret which is nevertheless "well known among musicians". Which exist, but are almost impossible to find.

No, for sure not.

Malcolm "just thought", based on something he heard or observed years ago, that it was a legal requirement for air crew to present themselves to passengers on boarding, so the passengers could see they weren't drunk. Even the posters on the CT forums told him this was nonsense, and suggested he might consider admitting he was mistaken.

Malcolm "just thought", based on something he heard or observed years ago, that gravity-fed i/v infusions were obsolete, and that any visual representation of such in the media had to be "staged". It took the combined forces of an inordinate number of doctors, nurses, paramedics, a vet and other posters with up-to-date medical knowledge to persuade him that he'd been mistaken.

Malcolm "just thought", based on something he heard or observed years ago, that the real true original karaoke machines could correct the pitch of the singer's voice real-time.

:hb:

Seems to me this is just another of the same.

OK, and I mean this. If Malcolm can find absolute proof that "the original karaoke machine" back in the 1970s or 1980s was able to make an out-of-tune voice emerge from the speakers in-tune, in real time, by altering the voice and not the backing track, I will donate £500 (more than the $1,000 he offered to donate if it could be proven that Dubya, as President, had attended a photo-op with primary school kids prior to 11th September 2001) to the registered charity of his choice.

Get to it, Malcolm.

I've heard what several posters have said about "pitch control", a system where the Foster-Jenkins' voice is unaltered, but the pitch of the pre-recorded music is varied (usually manually) to make dear Florence sort of blend in. This seems to be a relatively recent feature, but it appears to be a development of a feature which all karaoke machines did indeed have from the get-go.




Yup, looks as if this is indeed the source of Malcolm's misunderstanding. A simple function to allow the singer to choose to have the music play in the key that suits their vocal tessitura, becomes in Malcolm's mind, voice-morphing technology.

Sigh, why am I bothering. The miracle would have been if Malcolm had actually been right. That would have been a real first.




Funnily enough, no.

Rolfe.
Tessitura, how long did it take you to find that?
Foisted on your own petard yet again. The machine knows the note coming in, it's then a tiny adjustment to lift or lower it a couple on notes. I'd use top C as a marker myself.
The mike Spitfire put up was a kids toy. The real deal costs a lot more that that. There you go, any machine that can do as above, could easily alter incoming by a couple of notes. I've been shown to right again - that's what you get when you tell the truth. You should try it sometime.
 
Therefore you believe that EVERY expert in EVERY 9/11-related field, and EVERY person related in any way to this event and EVERY person who disagrees with you, EVERYwhere, is a government-paid shill, even those who live outside the US ?

If so, then it is my utmost pleasure to tell you that you are severely detached from reality. You are so enamored to your opinion that facts disagreeing with you MUST be faked or planted, that opponents MUST be in on it, and that they are ALL out to get you.

Edited by jmercer: 
Removed uncivil remark



Belz, I'm letting this through in a modified version because of the other content; however, please refrain from adding uncivil remarks in the future.

Thanks
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer

Why don't you read the odd one of the many references I put up?
 
How many times do you need to be corrected on this, Malcolm? Why do you repeat yourself again and again after you've been shown to be grossly misinformed?

Raytheon developed a system called JPALS, which is the military version of LAAS, which is replacing ILS, which has been around for over 40 years. These systems have the capability to "take control" of the aircraft via autopilot, not remote control. I asked about 30 pages ago if you needed help with the distinction between remote control and autopilot and you didn't respond. I'll do it here. Very simply - autopilot functions, like "APR"(also called "ILS") and autoland still require pilots to be on board.

From Raytheon's press release:




Notice it says "autoland(s)" which, as I've told you probably dozen times or more, is merely an autopilot function. The worlds first commercial airliner capable of performed fully automatic landings - autolands - was the L1011 Tristar, which was introduced in the early 1970s.

All JPALS and LAAS are doing is modernizing the way aircraft navigate. Now please stop with the "Raytheon flew around an airliner by remote control" canard. They didn't.

And don't respond to this post with a link quoting Der Spiegel. Der Spiegel is not an aviation publication and their article is extremely inaccurate(they actually stated the purpose of the system is to thwart hijackings). If you can find an Avionics Magazine or an Aviation Week article describing JPALS as a hijacking supression and/or remote control system - I'd be impressed.
The previous exchange ended with one of you conceeding that getting a plane airborne with no one on board was old stuff.
Are you disputing that?
 
Taking you at your word, which is a real stretch on here,

I think I need a new irony meter after this one. However, you do not have to take the word of anyone. Jus tread the 3GPP specs. Specifically the 25.xxx specs deals witt UMTS RAT.

was the situation the same in 2001?

Well, read the Release99 spec and figure it out for yourself (Hint: the 99 in Release99 is a hint. This brought to you from the Deparment of Redundancy Deparment).
 
You're gonna feel foolish. You want a way to convert one persons voice to sound like another's. Phone up an impressionist. Here's one,
http://www.perfectlypetersen.com/funny-friday/general-patton-speaks-out-against-all-that-is-stupid/


I'm going to feel foolish?

Malcolm, first you claimed that voices were morphed using technology so simple that the Japanese developed it decades ago and that it's available in high-end karaoke machines. When asked, you utterly failed to provide any proof whatsoever. Some people on this board did your work for you and found out that a person's vocal pitch might be changed in real time but: a) it's not automatic; and b) it doesn't make you sound like anyone in particular, it just makes your voice sound different.

Now you're abandoning the whole karaoke angle and claiming that teams of impressionists were used to make the fake phone calls which were, in any event, technologically impossible? Do you have any evidence of this whatsoever? Is there a single impressionist in the world who admits to this? How about this: Is there one impressionist in the world who says he can listen to a voice and convincingly reproduce it to the person's family in a single day?

Once again, in order for you to maintain your theory that the flights never took off, you've had to add a complication. Now your conspiracy requires teams of impressionists and, I guess, some muscle men to force the passengers to give the impressionists samples of their voices.

But I'm the one who is supposed to feel foolish?


Next:

I asked you how the concept of "probable cause" helps your argument. You have now answered:
With regard to demanding a new and properly independent enquiry.


Could you please clarify your answer. How does the concept of "probable cause" help with regard to demanding a new and properly independent enquiry? What you have said makes no sense at all in its present form. It's as if I said, "You need to take Plavix," and when you asked why, I answered "With regard to your pancreas." What is wrong with the pancreas and how does Plavix help?

Similarly, despite my understanding of both probable cause and government enquiries, I have no idea why you think one thing is supposed to help the other.

Please clarify your point or, as you usually do, abandon it.


Tell me I'm wrong about these figures,
82 % = believe they've been lied to about 9/11.
68 % = ---ll--- inside job.
90 % = Govt murdered JFK.


You are wrong about these figures. This Scripps Howard poll showed that 36% of Americans believe the US government very likely or somewhat likely participated in the 9/11 attacks. This is about half of the number you claim. The poll also showed that 40% of Americans believe the government participated in the assassination of JFK. This is less than half the amount you claim. So, once again, you're dead wrong.

(source)
 
Pitch changing

It is perfectly possible to change pitch with a DSP. Making a rig to change pitch that will fit into a microphone wouldn't be a terribly difficult thing for a competent engineer to do.

That is NOT the same as making something that will correct false notes (how's it supposed to know what's false?) or making your voice into someone else's.

There's far more to voice than just pitch. There's cadence and timbre. There's the way you form your sibilants and unvoiced phonemes. There's also word choice. Then there's that indifinable quality of "live." There are some damned good voice synthesizers out there, but they don't sound "live."

If you'd like to try it, get a copy of Audacity. It has a pitch shift function built in. Try it. You'll notice a change in pitch, all right. But, I seriously doubt you could get it to match your voice to your buddies voice to the point that his mother would think you were him.

Granted pitch shift technology, you've got maybe 5% of what you'd need for a voice morphing device. Where's the other 95%?
 
Because the clowns who botched up the cover up

Just enough for laypeople to catch on...

didn't realise that 757's didn't have seat back phones.

How come you didn't realise that they had airfones ?

Neither did they realise that cell phones don't work above 2,000 ft and only work under 2,000 ft when you are going slow as when coming in to land, for example.

Why do you lie, Malcolm ?

You'll have to trust me on this one.

No. I don't think I will.

You're gonna feel foolish. You want a way to convert one persons voice to sound like another's. Phone up an impressionist.

So.... they found an impressionist that could make his voice sound like this unknown person ? How ? Wasn't it Karaoke a few posts ago ?

Tell me I'm wrong about these figures,
82 % = believe they've been lied to about 9/11.
68 % = ---ll--- inside job.
90 % = Govt murdered JFK.

Yes, you are.

And even if you were, it wouldn't prove anything. Reality does not conform to people's beliefs.
 
That's why Raytheon and Boeing they did a remote control take off, fly around and landing in August 2001. (Der Spiegel, Raytheon).

That's not what I said, Malcolm, and you know it. If you were correct, no military operation would ever take place.

You keep saying that the "official story" is impossible because there'd be a chance of something going wrong. Well, same for YOUR story, and every story in the universe. NOTHING would ever get done if people thought that way.

So are you going to abandon this ridiculous line of thinking, or not ?

With the majority of people now believing that 9/11 was an inside job, deniers are skating on thinner and thinner ice.

Why ? Because might makes right ? What other messed up philosophies do you have, Malcolm ?

Why don't you read the odd one of the many references I put up?

What does that have to do with it ?

You are accusing, litterally, millions of people of being dishonest by disagreeing with you, Malcolm.

How is that rational ? How can you possibly believe that you are so incapable of being wrong that anyone who disagrees with you is automatically a paid shill, an enforcer of the statu quo or an NWO ninja ?

Honestly ?
 
I think it would come as quite the surprise to the loved-ones of the 911 victims who called from the planes that the voices on the other end were fake.

Somebody better alert those people. Somerled, perhaps you could give them a call and break the news to them (you have all the evidence that their loved-one's voices were phoney, right?), and then maybe they and you can go together arm-in-arm to the closest law enforcement agency and give them all the evidence.
 
Ah well, never mind. It caused me to regard myself in quite a new light. "Government Loyalist?" I like it.

Alex, you're doing a fine job. I like your current initiative on broadcasting very much.

Rolfe.
You mentioned £500 in one of your longer rants. Do you want to change your mind about that now, or later?
http://www.audio4fun.com/
 
I think I need a new irony meter after this one. However, you do not have to take the word of anyone. Jus tread the 3GPP specs. Specifically the 25.xxx specs deals witt UMTS RAT.



Well, read the Release99 spec and figure it out for yourself (Hint: the 99 in Release99 is a hint. This brought to you from the Deparment of Redundancy Deparment).

Yet another hot dog, who turns up with all the quali's etc.
You talk total baloney, otherwise planes would not have put in their own on board cell phone masts.
For outright lies and false credentials, you are consigned to the 'ignore' bin permanently.
 
It is perfectly possible to change pitch with a DSP. Making a rig to change pitch that will fit into a microphone wouldn't be a terribly difficult thing for a competent engineer to do.

That is NOT the same as making something that will correct false notes (how's it supposed to know what's false?) or making your voice into someone else's.

There's far more to voice than just pitch. There's cadence and timbre. There's the way you form your sibilants and unvoiced phonemes. There's also word choice. Then there's that indifinable quality of "live." There are some damned good voice synthesizers out there, but they don't sound "live."

If you'd like to try it, get a copy of Audacity. It has a pitch shift function built in. Try it. You'll notice a change in pitch, all right. But, I seriously doubt you could get it to match your voice to your buddies voice to the point that his mother would think you were him.

Granted pitch shift technology, you've got maybe 5% of what you'd need for a voice morphing device. Where's the other 95%?
Because the machine already knows the song that being sung.
You don't want to add to Rolfe's £500 do you. I have the info ready and waiting.
You've just granted real time pitch shift technology, so I guess your answers no.
 
I'm going to feel foolish?

Malcolm, first you claimed that voices were morphed using technology so simple that the Japanese developed it decades ago and that it's available in high-end karaoke machines. When asked, you utterly failed to provide any proof whatsoever. Some people on this board did your work for you and found out that a person's vocal pitch might be changed in real time but: a) it's not automatic; and b) it doesn't make you sound like anyone in particular, it just makes your voice sound different.

Now you're abandoning the whole karaoke angle and claiming that teams of impressionists were used to make the fake phone calls which were, in any event, technologically impossible? Do you have any evidence of this whatsoever? Is there a single impressionist in the world who admits to this? How about this: Is there one impressionist in the world who says he can listen to a voice and convincingly reproduce it to the person's family in a single day?

Once again, in order for you to maintain your theory that the flights never took off, you've had to add a complication. Now your conspiracy requires teams of impressionists and, I guess, some muscle men to force the passengers to give the impressionists samples of their voices.

But I'm the one who is supposed to feel foolish?


Next:

I asked you how the concept of "probable cause" helps your argument. You have now answered:



Could you please clarify your answer. How does the concept of "probable cause" help with regard to demanding a new and properly independent enquiry? What you have said makes no sense at all in its present form. It's as if I said, "You need to take Plavix," and when you asked why, I answered "With regard to your pancreas." What is wrong with the pancreas and how does Plavix help?

Similarly, despite my understanding of both probable cause and government enquiries, I have no idea why you think one thing is supposed to help the other.

Please clarify your point or, as you usually do, abandon it.





You are wrong about these figures. This Scripps Howard poll showed that 36% of Americans believe the US government very likely or somewhat likely participated in the 9/11 attacks. This is about half of the number you claim. The poll also showed that 40% of Americans believe the government participated in the assassination of JFK. This is less than half the amount you claim. So, once again, you're dead wrong.

(source)
Do us both a favour, take five and have a couple of cups of coffee.
To the equation 'probable cause' and 'a new enquiry' add the term 'grand jury'.
 
Tessitura, how long did it take you to find that?
Foisted on your own petard yet again. The machine knows the note coming in, it's then a tiny adjustment to lift or lower it a couple on notes. I'd use top C as a marker myself.
The mike Spitfire put up was a kids toy. The real deal costs a lot more that that. There you go, any machine that can do as above, could easily alter incoming by a couple of notes. I've been shown to right again - that's what you get when you tell the truth. You should try it sometime.


Did you have to look it up? Vocabulary envy isn't pretty, Malcolm.

You've simply repeated what you said before, and declared yourself to be right. I don't think you even know how to tell the truth.

I'm waiting for evidence.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
You mentioned £500 in one of your longer rants. Do you want to change your mind about that now, or later?
http://www.audio4fun.com/


So this software, available new in 2007, somehow helped them to fake voices six years ago in 2001?

Well, let's just see what AV Voice Changer Software Diamond can do ...

Yeah, it says it can change the pitch and timbre of your voice in real time. Here's what it doesn't say it can do: change your voice to match some real person's.

And here's what people have to say about the software:

The software is horrible the voice changes are far from normal human voices. I tried so many different tones, pitches, and everything else and could not get the darn thing to create a realistic sounding voice.

source

I have no doubt this software helps disguise your voice. But recreate somebody else's? Nonsense.

And even if it could, where are the people who worked the software? Where are the programmers who created the software six years before it was invented? Where are the guards who beat the passengers until they agreed to give normal-sounding voice samples? Where are the technicians who determined the pitch and timbre of the passengers' voices so they could reproduce them? Where are the men in black who actually pretended to be the passengers? And where are the passengers today?

You see, every time you have to change your story, the conspiracy just gets larger and more complicated. That's what paradigms do just before they deflate and die.
 
To the equation 'probable cause' and 'a new enquiry' add the term 'grand jury'.


This continues to make no sense. Could you please expand this beyond just a single sentence? You are not getting your point accross. What does a grand jury have to do with probable cause and a new inquiry? How do these three things fit together? What grand jury are you talking about? What exactly do you believe should happen and what exact laws make it realistic?
 
Tessitura, how long did it take you to find that?
Foisted on your own petard yet again. The machine knows the note coming in, it's then a tiny adjustment to lift or lower it a couple on notes. I'd use top C as a marker myself.
The mike Spitfire put up was a kids toy. The real deal costs a lot more that that. There you go, any machine that can do as above, could easily alter incoming by a couple of notes. I've been shown to right again - that's what you get when you tell the truth. You should try it sometime.


Malcolm, stop pretending that a karaoke machine has anything to do with nonexistent voice-morphing technology. Show some self-respect.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom