Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Don't think that I'm 'intolerant' just because I don't like you.

And me liking or disliking you has nothing to do with my condemnation of your support of mutilating children.
 
As Loss Leader shows us, there's nothing worse than a coward with a big mouth.

I've been admiring Loss Leader's ability to remain calm and rational in the face of a disturbing degree of intolerance. And he makes me feel a coward by continuing to engage with you and others, when my response would be to ignore. And even though he now feels poorly for his outburst, I don't think it's a bad thing to let others know that the intolerance is an issue important enough to get passionate about.

Linda
 
"a disturbing degree of intolerance"
You're joking right?!?! HE supports mutilating children for NO good reason, but the people who oppose him are 'intolerant'

How, I ask, T.F. does that work?
 
You see, I circumcise my children for the Jewish people. I do it to maintain unity, cohesiveness and identity among my ethnicity. I have no fear of what God will do to me (or my children) and I have no fear of what other Jews might think of me. I live in terror that my refusal to circumcise my children or participate in other religious obligations will make it any harder for other Jews to do so.

Aren’t religious freedoms protected by law? Why would you eating pork say, make it any harder for someone else not to? I’m a vegetarian and I don’t feel compelled to eat meat or find it any harder object to eating it even though I do not know any other vegetarians.

What about the other commandments that have been ignored or modified to fit in with 21st century ideas of morality? For example, your religion no longer stones blasphemers to death. I have been corrected in my assumption that many Jews still feel compelled to marry only other Jews. Are homosexual Jews accepted within your community? All these things go directly against commandments in your religious text.

How do you think these changes to your own and others’ faiths came about? My guess is that the various behaviours were tested against the Golden Rule and found to be lacking.

If the ritual of circumcision is still very important to Jews, why could it not be modified to be more symbolic than physical? For example, men who are already circumcised and wish to convert to Judaism have a pinprick of blood drawn.

I've been admiring Loss Leader's ability to remain calm and rational in the face of a disturbing degree of intolerance. And he makes me feel a coward by continuing to engage with you and others, when my response would be to ignore. And even though he now feels poorly for his outburst, I don't think it's a bad thing to let others know that the intolerance is an issue important enough to get passionate about.

Linda

I hope you are not putting me in the ‘others’ group there Linda. I have no interest in curtailing anyone's freedom to think or do whatever they want, as long as it does not physically hurt anybody else, no matter how much DNA they have in common.

However, I fully admit that at times I can be offensive and blunt. Can’t we all?
 
"a disturbing degree of intolerance"
You're joking right?!?! HE supports mutilating children for NO good reason, but the people who oppose him are 'intolerant'

How, I ask, T.F. does that work?

As far as I can tell, your inability to understand the explanation for how it works is the same thing that leads to the intolerance.

Linda
 
I hope you are not putting me in the ‘others’ group there Linda. I have no interest in curtailing anyone's freedom to think or do whatever they want, as long as it does not physically hurt anybody else, no matter how much DNA they have in common.

Yes, I am. However, since my position is indefensible, this should be of no concern to you.

Linda
 
Yes, I am. However, since my position is indefensible, this should be of no concern to you.

Linda

Being called anti-Semitic is of great concern to me. Am I anti-Islamic too because I object to FGM?

I have tried to keep my argument as far away from religion as possible. However, when LossLeader started arguing his culture or religion are valid reasons to circumcise infants I have pointed out that these have been used to validate other behaviour that Jewish people no longer consider acceptable, such as stoning blasphemers to death or not being allowed to marry non-Jewish people. Thus how can anyone have any confidence they are valid reasons for circumcision of infants?

Cultural and religious convictions can be used to understand why people are behaving the way they are, not as reasonable justification for an action before it is performed.

BTW Linda, the people in the thread who have been making anti-Semitic or overly personal comments have been warned by the mods. I fully agree with those warnings.
 
Last edited:
What about the other commandments that have been ignored or modified to fit in with 21st century ideas of morality? For example, your religion no longer stones blasphemers to death. I have been corrected in my assumption that many Jews still feel compelled to marry only other Jews. Are homosexual Jews accepted within your community? All these things go directly against commandments in your religious text.

How do you think these changes to your own and others’ faiths came about? My guess is that the various behaviours were tested against the Golden Rule and found to be lacking.


Well, this is exactly what I was talking about - the erosion of the Jewish faith in the face of outside pressures. Kellyb's questions and yours below are exactly the thing that I fear most. When I'm asked, "Well, you modified other practices, so why not this one?" it is precisely what I worry about. I don't want to help you (meaning "secular" or "homogenous" social forces) to dismantle my religion.


If the ritual of circumcision is still very important to Jews, why could it not be modified to be more symbolic than physical?


The answer is that I don't know and I don't care. The religious authorities I trust recommend circumcision. If they changed their opinions, I would change mine. But I have no desire to reform my religion or dilute it in any way. This is the rule. I follow it so that the next person who wants to doesn't have to have my non-observance used by others as an argument for his non-observance.

The fact that the rule could and maybe should change does not alter the fact that it is the rule today. Does this make me less of a skeptic or free thinker? In this area, yes.


Being called anti-Semitic is of great concern to me.


FWIW, I have never considered any post of yours to have been antisemitic. Arguing that a Jewish practice is "wrong" does not apear to me to be antisemitic. Antisemitism is a personal attack against me based entirely on my ethnicity. So, when you say that Jews shouldn't circumcise their children, I find that somewhat narrow but in no way an attack on Jews just for being Jewish. On the other hand, when someone says that I live up to the negative stereotypes of Jews, the implication is that I am in some way lacking based on the very fact of my ethnicity.

Now, you did call me deluded ... twice. But that was just impolite. It wasn't hateful.
 
I don't want to help you (meaning "secular" or "homogenous" social forces) to dismantle my religion.

What else do "they" want Jewish people to stop doing? I want the Pope to stop telling Africans not to use condoms, but I'm not trying to "dismantle" the Catholic church.

However, I admit I would not be bothered if it, or Islam or Judaism or Christianity or any other religious or other organizations that promote paranormal beliefs disappeared.

The fact that the rule could and maybe should change does not alter the fact that it is the rule today. Does this make me less of a skeptic or free thinker? In this area, yes.

Ok.

FWIW, I have never considered any post of yours to have been antisemitic. Arguing that a Jewish practice is "wrong" does not apear to me to be antisemitic. Antisemitism is a personal attack against me based entirely on my ethnicity. So, when you say that Jews shouldn't circumcise their children, I find that somewhat narrow but in no way an attack on Jews just for being Jewish. On the other hand, when someone says that I live up to the negative stereotypes of Jews, the implication is that I am in some way lacking based on the very fact of my ethnicity.

I don't say Jews shouldn't circumcise their children. I say no one should circumcise their children unless it is medically indicated. Religion or culture has nothing to do with it for me since so many different cultures and religions circumcise their children for different reasons. E.g.,

Jewish: God said so.
Muslims: Mohammad did it.
Americans: Everyone else is doing it.
Etc.

It doesn't seem to be a defining characteristic of any particular group. It appears to be a more "basic" impulse than any religion or culture will admit to.

Now, you did call me deluded ... twice. But that was just impolite. It wasn't hateful.

Like I said, I can be offensive and blunt at times. I'm not proud of it, but it happens.
 
(Revising, cause I should have waited till I was more awake to write another response ;))
 
Last edited:
"your inability to understand"
I'm not unable to understand... There hasn't been an explanation presented that wasn't a total pant load.

" The answer is that I don't know and I don't care."
So... wilfully blind and ignorant, "Follow The Leader" is the game you play, and one of your moves was to mutilate your child.... Again, as long as you're not pretending to be rational.

"you did call me deluded ... twice."
Apparently for good reason.
 
And you're proud of the fact that you're mutilating your children?!

That's disgusting.

What do I have to say for you to put me back on your ignore list?

I pity your children


CH, please stop personalizing the argument; attack the argument, not the arguer.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Last edited by a moderator:
And you're proud of the fact that you're mutilating your children?!


I think I've stated numerous times that I am immensely proud. The circumcision of my first son was one of the proudest moments of my life.

Considering how often I've explained that, your use of both a question mark and an exclamation mark is bizarre.
 
I've already said this, BC, but I'll repeat it because you may not have been here when I did:

I am a lawyer and, as such, it is very important to me that the law and morality coincide. I have spent my entire adult life attempting to make sure they do. But there is something about a moral judgment that we must accept: We may be wrong.

A thought or idea held at any one time by any one person might be completely wrong. It might turn out that some other idea is right, even an idea that we now despise.

Our law recognizes this and has built in something of a failsafe: a plurality of practices are tolerated. Families and religious groups are allowed to test out their own rules. The more there are, the greater chance that one of them will find the right way. This adds a special robustness to the US that (I personally believe) is lacking in countries where human rights are not as highly prized. It adds a creativity and the friction between different cultures creates an energy that we can harness to move ourselves forward.
Even though I am not a lawyer, I'm not stupid, and I actually do understand why our laws are the way they are. I do understand what you're saying here, and I agree.

So, in order for it to be right that circumcision should be banned for all people including Jews, we must be sure we are 100% correct. There must be not the slightest bit of doubt. If we ban a practice, we may never be able to resurect it. Our society will become less diverse and (I think) less productive.

Are you 100% sure that you are objectively and scientifically right about circumcision? Perhaps you are. In any case, the courts are not and the plurality survives.
Ok, I'm not sure where you got the idea that I'm 100% against all circumcisions. I've never said anything like that, and certainly didn't mean to imply it. What I'm against is routine infant circumcision. You don't seem to care what I think, so maybe this part isn't for you. I speak out against circumcision because it really seems like Americans do them for no rational reason at all, in fact, it seems like most people don't even think about it before they do it. In fact, I get the feeling that most people are so ignorant about their own anatomy, that they can argue that it's a good thing, when they don't even know what they're arguing because they've never had a foreskin that they can remember, and are inherently biased.

No, I am not 100% sure that I am right about circumcision. However, I hold the view that if the outcome of a permanent procedure is unknown or ambiguous, then it is better to be cautious about it, and not do the procedure, than it is to perform it, and be wrong.

Anyway, certainly I believe that there might be medical reasons for circumcision, although, even for conditions like phimosis, it may not be necessary to take the permanent step of circumcision to cure it.

Those things that I said above have nothing to do with you, because your argument is religion. I've come to the realization that I can't argue with you anymore, not because anyone is "right" or "wrong," but because I find the religion argument to be irrational. To me, it's no different than arguing with some christian or whomever about their faith. I don't understand it, it means nothing to me, but obviously it holds relevance for you. Again, I don't mean to be snarky, so I'm sorry if it comes out that way. I'm just being blunt.
 
Once again LL, I pity your children.


CH, please stop personalizing the argument; attack the argument, not the arguer.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The reason people become emotional is because of the appalling nature of whats being done. The reason that the procirc people are so calm is the same as the one going through the heads of the mothers holding down their little girls. The reason emotion becomes involved is because its a clearly sexually motivated operation. Of all the parts to be singled out for being wrong its the vagina or the penis, yet of course the operation itself is devoid of any moral implications, and "normal" people shouldnt be moved to action at the sight of a baby's genitals being sliced into.

----------------

So Loss, as I understand it, if you were an Aztec, and I a Spaniard, and I said to you "Human Sacrifice is a horrible practice." Your reply would of course be "I dont like it, in fact, I wouldnt do it, but the truth of the matter is that Im afraid that the people around me will stop doing it if I dont."

The fact of the matter is, as said by others, Judaism is, like other religions, always evolving. Why you see circumcision as a primary concern in your religious practice is the questionable part. Are you saying youre only a Jew because someone cut off your foreskin (and sucked out some blood as I understand it), and because you dont eat pork, theres nothing more to it. The essence of Judaism is foreskinless pork abstinence.

I feel that you are using that argument as another excuse. Ive read a bit about Judaism, and I agree with you in that I think the world is a better place with Jews. The Talmud has some wonderful musings on life. However, I dont understand the need to violate someone else's rights in order to make you feel as if youre upholding your religion, is that really all there is to uphold? Do you feel Judaism would collapse if people ate pork and left their children intact? If thats the case your religion is well on its way to extinction, I however dont believe that is the essence of your religion.

Would you use that same line on any other topic? About your new child?

"Yeah, and hes going to study the bible too!" "Yeah, Im not going to let my son eat pork!"
Or does it only fit with this particular practice.
"Im going to cut off my son's foreskin and theres nothing you can do about it!"

There is something at work other than the reason youve devised. And as such, Im pretty much talking to noone, because your views arnt going to change. You differ the responsibility of making any decision to someone else.

(Thanks for the welcome 1 page back I think Osmo.) (Also, I dont mean any disrespect, and Ive not become emotional, if what Ive written creates an emotional response in you, take it up with yourself.)
 
I am a lawyer and, as such, it is very important to me that the law and morality coincide. I have spent my entire adult life attempting to make sure they do. But there is something about a moral judgment that we must accept: We may be wrong.
It is for moral reasons that RIC is unacceptable in all cases, unless medically necessary. Morality and the law should come together to ban this barbaric, sadistic, abusive practice.

This adds a special robustness to the US that (I personally believe) is lacking in countries where human rights are not as highly prized.
Apparently, one of those human rights that is preserved here is the right to disregard the human rights of another person, so that adults can get their proud jollies, and can avoid feeling inadequate or different from their social group.

So, in order for it to be right that circumcision should be banned for all people including Jews, we must be sure we are 100% correct. There must be not the slightest bit of doubt. If we ban a practice, we may never be able to resurect it. Our society will become less diverse and (I think) less productive.

Are you 100% sure that you are objectively and scientifically right about circumcision? Perhaps you are. In any case, the courts are not and the plurality survives.
First, circumcision has not been evaluated by the law to determine whether it is even ethical. It is legal only because it has escaped scrutiny and a fair scientific analysis. Using the law as a justification holds no water, it has no bearing on whether circumcision is harmful or moral. When it was legal to kill jews or take their property, it was just as immoral and unethical as it is today.

Second, you've got it backwards. In order for a permanent cosmetic amputation or alteration of a sex organ to be allowed on a non-consenting, we must be 100% sure it causes no harm. There is no dispute over whether circumcision causes harm, pro-circs simply argue that the harm isn't that big of a deal by saying "the pain can be managed with anesthetics" or "change the diaper" or "the medical benefits outweigh the risks of complications". Circumcision causes physical harm, the only disagreement is how much harm and whether that harm is fully offset by other benefits.

Finally, I can't help but notice that you are still ignoring the harm caused by loss of the sensitivity and function of the foreskin. You are depriving your sons of some of the pleasure of sex, and by extension life.
 
The reason emotion becomes involved is because its a clearly sexually motivated operation.


That is not clear to me at all. My motivation is that it is an element of my religion.


So Loss, as I understand it, if you were an Aztec, and I a Spaniard, and I said to you "Human Sacrifice is a horrible practice." Your reply would of course be "I dont like it, in fact, I wouldnt do it, but the truth of the matter is that Im afraid that the people around me will stop doing it if I dont."


No, that doesn't follow at all. With circumcision, I am substituting my jusgement for my incompetent child with his best interests in mind. The Aztecs sacrificed their enemies. So, their enemies were not incompetent, they were not the Aztecs' children and the Aztecs didn't have their enemies' best interests in mind.


Are you saying youre only a Jew because someone cut off your foreskin (and sucked out some blood as I understand it), and because you dont eat pork, theres nothing more to it. The essence of Judaism is foreskinless pork abstinence.


I have said nothing of the sort. I am not Jewish because I am circumcised, I am circumcised because I am Jewish. Also, there's no blood sucking going on anymore in Conservative Judaism.

And as I have also said, if I stop the practice of circumcision, it will make it harder for other Jews to continue the practice.


However, I dont understand the need to violate someone else's rights in order to make you feel as if youre upholding your religion

No one's rights are being violated. In fact, my son's right to practice his religion is being protected.

Do you feel Judaism would collapse if people ate pork and left their children intact?


Indeed, I do.


Would you use that same line on any other topic? About your new child?

"Yeah, and hes going to study the bible too!" "Yeah, Im not going to let my son eat pork!"


I will, in fact, be preventing my son from eating pork. And I will be forcing him to study the bible.


There is something at work other than the reason youve devised.


The fact that you are incredulous about my thought process does not mean that there is something else at work.
 
Apparently, one of those human rights that is preserved here is the right to disregard the human rights of another person, so that adults can get their proud jollies, and can avoid feeling inadequate or different from their social group.


No one's rights are being disregarded. My son has the right to make decisions regarding his bodily integrity just as you or I do. However, he is incompetent to understand or evaluate his options so the law has asked me to substitute my judgment for him. I have proudly undertaken this honor and intend to execute my duties only in furtherance of his best interests.


Second, you've got it backwards. In order for a permanent cosmetic amputation or alteration of a sex organ to be allowed on a non-consenting, we must be 100% sure it causes no harm.


First of all, my son is not non-consenting. He is incapable of consenting. There is a difference.

Second of all, this is not the rule. I know you'd like it to be the rule. I know it seems logical to you that it should be the rule. But it is not. Your wishing it were does not make it so.


Circumcision causes physical harm, the only disagreement is how much harm and whether that harm is fully offset by other benefits.


I agree.


Finally, I can't help but notice that you are still ignoring the harm caused by loss of the sensitivity and function of the foreskin. You are depriving your sons of some of the pleasure of sex, and by extension life.


I have not ignored this argument.

The peer-reviewed and properly researched studies linked to in this thread have not demonstrated that circumcised men derive less pleasure from sex than uncircumcised men.

No scientific evidence having been adduced, all that is left is anecdotal evidence. I have read the descriptions that the uncircumcised men in this thread have given of the sexual pleasure they enjoy. Some of them were a little too frank for my taste.

But those anecdotes are offset by my own experience as a circumcised male. And my experience is that I enjoy sex quite a great deal (or, at least, I did until I got married). I don't really enjoy anything more than sex. So I have a hard time believing that the uncircumcised men are enjoying it more. If I were to enjoy it any more than I already do, the process wouldn't last nearly as long and that would make me not enjoy it as much.

All anecdotes having cancelled each other out, nothing is left of your argument regarding sexual pleasure.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom