Another Vaccination Scare?

Eos said:
The irrefutable proof is that sanitation did not eradicate polio. Vaccines did. And polio viruses look the same and do the same things to the body, no matter what. Please let me know what they called the illness to make it seem like rates were going down. I'm sure you'll understand if I find that whole claim far-fetched.

The idea that sanitation would eliminate polio is really silly, so I agree with you there.

The diagnostic change was this:
1) they didn't know that other viruses like echoviruses, coxsakievirus, etc, caused paralysis before then, so any case of sudden paralysis was called polio.
2) they lengthened the time someone needed to be paralysed for a reporting of "polio".
3) polio "the gut infection" was no longer reportable

Read the second (righthand) column here:
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV605.jpg
 
Last edited:
:boggled: Science doesn't work that way. Does your high school offer biology or chemistry courses? Does your local college offer any? Take some courses and find out how it really works. It's cool, fun, and you'll find out how it really works. Then you'll understand why people like mercola and weil are so unethical.
Who are these?

So... your theory goes something like this:

1. Get chemistry kit
2. Find irrefutable proof that vaccines are useless and dangerous
3. Visit the 12 o clock news: "This just in: Vaccines proven worthless and dangerous"

Nope. I'm right about how science works. You have an idealized idea of how science *should* work, but that's not how the system works in reality. Nobody cares about your silly "proofs" and your little "evidence".
 
The irrefutable proof is that sanitation did not eradicate polio. Vaccines did. And polio viruses look the same and do the same things to the body, no matter what. Please let me know what they called the illness to make it seem like rates were going down. I'm sure you'll understand if I find that whole claim far-fetched. The more credible graphs do show that polio was a problem until after 1963.
I find the claim far fetched as well, but my reaction is not to dismiss it, but to want to know more about it. I don't find it entirely incredible.

Your accusation that I'm only following other scientists unquestionably is beyond ignorance (and ironic since you actually do that by following any bad source of information ignorantly), and just a stab because you keep coming up short. Why not listen and learn for a change instead of making accusations? Why not try to learn from us instead of embarrasing yourself with bad sources of information? Why not finally read OUR sources of information instead of flailing around in woo land sources? The internet is the worst place to try to find information, so why not take a real biology course instead? Then one day you just might be able to tell the bad sources from the good, just by knowing what to look for.
Alright, sources are only good if they reinforce what you already believe to be true. So we have the same procedure after all, just different opinions on what we originally believe to be true with no way to convince the other.

Refute the DDT->Polio connection.

I find it a strong argument that Polio was non-existent prior to the proliferation of DDT. That makes the viral theory unsound, since viruses don't pop out of nothing. Hence, that makes the vaccine theory unsound. Follow my logic there?

I mean, I can cite one simple fact about polio - that what we call polio was completely unknown 150 years ago - and with this little act completely destroy all credibility of your arguments regarding it, including all credibility you claim the peer reviewed journals have, especially regarding the supposed polio vaccine. For lack of a better hypothesis now, we can investigate the DDT hypothesis.

pretty good, huh?

That's science. you find a massive flaw in a theory and then abandon it for a better alternative.

Ignoring the facts and insisting on a falsified theory, that's not scientific.
 
Last edited:
I'd think that there would be a lot of money and fame given to any scientist that was able to prove that a specific vaccination did not work or, that beyond a doubt, thimerasol caused autism. I wonder why that has never happened?

Probably why no one has yet claimed Randi's Million Dollar Challenge.

From the FDA website:

In 2004, the IOM's Immunization Safety Review Committee again examined the hypothesis that vaccines, specifically the MMR vaccines and thimerosal containing vaccines, are causally associated with autism. In this report, the committee incorporated new epidemiological evidence from the U.S., Denmark, Sweden, and the United Kingdom, and studies of biologic mechanisms related to vaccines and autism that had become available since its report in 2001. The committee concluded that this body of evidence favors rejection of a causal relationship between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism, and that hypotheses generated to date concerning a biological mechanism for such causality are theoretical only. Further, the committee stated that the benefits of vaccination are proven and the hypothesis of susceptible populations is presently speculative, and that widespread rejection of vaccines would lead to increases in incidences of serious infectious diseases like measles, whooping cough and Hib bacterial meningitis.

http://www.fda.gov/cber/vaccine/thimfaq.htm#q11
 
I find it a strong argument that Polio was non-existent prior to the proliferation of DDT. That makes the viral theory unsound, since viruses don't pop out of nothing. Hence, that makes the vaccine theory unsound. Follow my logic there?
Polio was also nonexistent before the advent of television. You could use your logic to say TV caused polio.

Regarding polio popping up out of nowhere, it was probably always around. As mass media got better, health hysteria increased and people heard about diseases and causes and whatnot. There were also societal changes that probably caused a real increase in paralytic disease, so the two together made it seem like there was some new epidemic.
 
They talk about cases in the 1700s that are more verifiable, but some outbreaks are indicated in ancient history too. http://www.cloudnet.com/~edrbsass/poliohistory.htm

Currently we know this about polio
The polio virus attacks the nerve cells that control muscle movements. Many people infected with the virus have few or no symptoms. Others have short-term symptoms, such as headache, tiredness, fever, stiff neck and back, and muscle pain.
More serious problems happen when the virus invades nerves in the brain and causes paralysis of the muscles used in swallowing and breathing. Invasion of the nerves in the spinal cord can cause paralysis of the arms, legs, or trunk.

Polio is diagnosed by a blood test or culture.

In the United States, the last case of "wild" polio was in 1979
http://www.dhpe.org/infect/polio.html

Though apparently no study was ever conducted to examine the long-term effectiveness of the Salk vaccine, the statistics dramatically illustrate at least its short term success. From pre-vaccine highs of about 58,000 cases in 1952 and 35,000 cases in 1953, the rate dropped to about 5600 cases in 1957, the first year after the vaccine was widely available (Jones, 1993).
By 1962, the Salk vaccine was replaced by the Sabin oral vaccine. The effectiveness of this new vaccine had been demonstrated in field trials conducted in 1958 and 1959. Using live, attenuated (weakened) virus, the oral vaccine was not only superior in terms of ease of administration, but also provided longer lasting immunization (Nathanson, 1982).
http://www.cloudnet.com/~edrbsass/poliohistory.htm

The vaccine worked, and still works. One day the disease may even be irradicated, like smallpox was.
 
There are articles, books, news reports and medical studies that lead people to believe stuff, which is how it starts.
Maybe that's how all that business got started about violent crime and hospital admissions peaking when the moon is full.

Are you aware that the snippet you provided concerns the first phase of a two-phased study, the second of which failed to replicate the findings of the first? Subsequent to Simpsonwood, Verstraeten himself published findings which summarize to:
"No consistent significant associations were found between [thimerosal-containing vaccines] and neurodevelopmental outcomes."

PEDIATRICS Vol. 112 No. 5 November 2003
 
Eos...
Have you read my links?

It explains quite well what happened in the 50's. Most (or maybe even all) of the effectiveness of the Salk vaccine was an illusion.

The Sabin vaccine really did work, though. The Salk vaccine, not so much.
 
Maybe that's how all that business got started about violent crime and hospital admissions peaking when the moon is full.

Are you aware that the snippet you provided concerns the first phase of a two-phased study, the second of which failed to replicate the findings of the first? Subsequent to Simpsonwood, Verstraeten himself published findings which summarize to:
"No consistent significant associations were found between [thimerosal-containing vaccines] and neurodevelopmental outcomes."

PEDIATRICS Vol. 112 No. 5 November 2003

Why do you think the first phase was never published?

And why didn't the release it publicly like the were planning on doing?
 
The Salk vaccine worked (induced immune response), it was just not as safe as the Sabin vaccine. We use the dead virus now because it is safer. The live vaccine is more transportable and still used in poorer countries.

Anyone else want to evaluate kelly's information?

My sources say that it worked compared to placebo in initial trials.
A famous example of the clinical trial is the 1954 test of the Salk vaccine as a treatment for preventing poliomyelitis. Over 400,000 schoolchildren took part in this test. Half the participants—the experimental group—received the vaccine, and the other half—the control group—were given a placebo vaccination—that is, they were inoculated with a substance containing no active ingredient. The value of this vaccine was gauged by comparing the number of cases of polio that developed in each group.
Like most well-designed trials, the Salk vaccine study incorporated the double-blind principle: The trial subjects did not know whether they were getting real medication or a placebo, and the researchers who examined the subjects for polio did not know who had been given the vaccine and who had been given the placebo. The principle of withholding information from the subjects is vital in most tests of therapy in order to control for any "placebo effect"—the tendency for subjects to feel better simply because they believe have been treated with a beneficial substance. The test could also be invalidated if parents who knew that their children had received the placebo would arrange for them to get the real vaccine. The withholding of information from the researchers is also vital to a well-conducted study, for it eliminates any unconscious tendency to bias the test data, a tendency that is apt to arise in any situation that calls for some degree of subjective judgment in diagnosing disease or analyzing data.
http://www.quackwatch.org/06ResearchProjects/doyle.html
 
Last edited:
Polio was also nonexistent before the advent of television. You could use your logic to say TV caused polio.

Regarding polio popping up out of nowhere, it was probably always around. As mass media got better, health hysteria increased and people heard about diseases and causes and whatnot. There were also societal changes that probably caused a real increase in paralytic disease, so the two together made it seem like there was some new epidemic.
I'm not saying its DDT. That it *may* be DDT is a testable hypothesis that can be falsified. I'm saying its not the virus that causes polio, that is a testable hypothesis that has been falsified.

It can be any number of things. DDT, Television, white flour, rampant masturbation. You could investigate a number of things. But that's off the point, the fact remains, the poliovirus->polio hypothesis is falsified.

Then why would a polio vaccine be effective at preventing polio?

One could argue that the polio virus may be a necessary factor for polio, but does not cause it, and thus a working polio vaccine may actually prevent polio. (A similiar hypothesis is the mainstream for HIV)

But I find this improbable. Most people that are infected with polio, are asymptomatic. The polio virus is a harmless passenger virus for the vast majority of people, and there is no reason to believe that the polio virus, and not the underlying intoxication cause the life-long crippling damage.

More realistic is the hypothesis that the polio virus was simply scapegoated for the devastating polio epidemics that were widespread at the time, and the vaccinations were actually completely worthless and had nothing to do with the reduction of incidence of polio.

This is all scientifically very probable. Now if DDT was the actual intoxicating agent or something else may be subject to debate. But it is very improbable that the polio vaccine is any more than an expensive placebo.
 
Eos said:
The Salk vaccine worked (induced immune response), it was just not as safe as the Sabin vaccine. We use the dead virus now because it is safer.

You're getting them mixed up there. The Salk vaccine was the killed vaccine. When it was really dead, it was perfectly safe. (initially...enhancement effects aside).

It was the Sabin vaccine that eliminated polio, though.

My sources say that it worked compared to placebo in initial trials.
They went over what was wrong with the clinical trials in my links, too.

It wasn't actually inactivated a lot of the time, so of course it worked great (when the vaccinees didn't develop paralytic polio from it).
Once they actually killed the viruses, it more or less quit working.
 
The non-live version works quite well, and the live version works even better (but is not as safe).

I wasn't mixing them up, I was just mentioning what is used now. I never said Salk's was the live vaccine.

I'm just not sure I trust your sources of information (typical me).
 
W said:
The polio virus is a harmless passenger virus for the vast majority of people
*sigh*
That's not really the right use of the phrase, but whatever. Yeah, it's not a big deal in 999 out of 1,000 people who catch the virus.

More realistic is the hypothesis that the polio virus was simply scapegoated for the devastating polio epidemics that were widespread at the time, and the vaccinations were actually completely worthless and had nothing to do with the reduction of incidence of polio.

No, OPV very much eliminated polio. There's lots and lots of good science behind that. *Some* of the initial "polio" cases back in the day weren't even caused by polio viruses, though. So on that note you kinda have a bit of a point.
But polio viruses are definitely the main viruses that cause paralysis. Other viruses do it, too, but polio (primarily the Mahoney strain) is basically the "worst". So it wasn't just a big hoohaa over nothing.
 
The non-live version works quite well, and the live version works even better (but is not as safe).

I wasn't mixing them up, I was just mentioning what is used now. I never said Salk's was the live vaccine.

I'm just not sure I trust your sources of information (typical me).

You can google the speaker's names. You can even find references to the Illinois Medical Journal in pubmed.

ETA:
Dr. Cox
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._R._Cox

Dr. Ratner:
http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,826940,00.html
 
Last edited:
You know I won't take Wikepedia as a source :D

And the 1961 Times article states:

Despite this, overall effectiveness of Salk vaccine in preventing paralytic polio has ranged statistically from 75% to 90%.

If you ask me, some folks were really pushing for Sabin's vaccine. It's very hard to evaluate the old information, not being easy to be able to cross-reference the people writing it :(

Rouser also posted this information before: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=15062&page=4

Btox says Ratner was kooky, and judging from other things Ratner has written, I don't know if I can disagree with Btox.
 
Last edited:
Eos said:
You know I won't take Wikepedia as a source
Ok...here...

http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,790779-2,00.html


Dr. Herald Rea Cox, 34, U.S. Public Health Service bacteriologist stationed at the Rocky Mountain Laboratory in Hamilton, Mont. He found a new and safer method of making typhus and Rocky Mountain spotted fever vaccines—cultivating them inside half-incubated eggs. The typhus vaccine is being used by the U.S., Britain and Canada to immunize their armed forces.

He was pretty well known and well published. He's all over the web.

I know this stuff is crazy, but it's for real.

And the 1961 Times article states:

Key word being "statistically". The problem was that the trials were flawed and they ( the WHO) changed the diagnosis.

Rouser also posted this information before:

Yeah...I have the actual publication in full, though. :D
Not just something off a random website.
 
Thing is, we still only have their word that they were flawed. They didn't re-do trials to show that the Salk vaccine was ineffective. Not even animal trials. The general consensus is that it is effective, was effective.

The killed vaccine is the most widely used today, being safer.

In the U.S., cases of polio are now extremely rare, and ironically, are almost always caused by the Sabin vaccine itself -- being live, the virus can mutate to a stronger form. Elsewhere there are still about 250,000 cases per year, mostly in developing nations where vaccination has not become widespread. The World Health Organization has goals to eradicate polio completely in the first decade of the twenty-first century.
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/aso/databank/entries/dm52sa.html

I'd rather risk one case of polio per million with vaccine than thousands without a vaccine, but that is why Sabin's is not as widely used anymore. The Salk/nonlive vaccine is safer to use, and we use it where polio is largely never seen anymore. The Sabin vaccine is more effective, and that is why it is used when polio is still a present threat.
 
Last edited:
Thing is, we still only have their word that they were flawed. They didn't re-do trials to show that the Salk vaccine was ineffective.

No...they did better than that. They got rid of that crappy vaccine as quick as they could and replaced it!

The general consensus is that it is effective, was effective.

Concensus among who, though?
If the concensus at the time was that it was effective, they never would have rushed in the live vaccine with it's known risk of VAPP as soon as they could.
The concensus now isn't one based on lots of good data or anything. It's just a leftover of the hoopla that was needed to start off the polio immunization program. They couldn't just come right out and say "Woah...sorry, guys...wow we really screwed that one up!"
So it just sort of went away.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom