Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Before any letter gets sent, I strongly recommend finding a published spectrum of ethanol to compare it to this one. Either that or getting your own spectrum of ethanol. If you want to question the spectrum (and I think you can legitimately do that) there should be more basis for it.

If you can say, "Roy's spectrum of ethanol does not match that published by XXX). How do the authors account for the discrepancy?" it will add significant weight.


Harder than you might think! I scoured my university library in vain for such a thing.

The fact that ethanol does not signficantly absorb after what, 280nm, is why ethanol can be used as a solvent for things that do absorb in that range.

That may be why even basic spectroscopy primers don't carry full wavelength scans of ethanol. None that I could find...

As for getting a spectra of our own, that could be useful. It would be even better if the authors provided the product number for the ethanol that they used, so at least one could check with Sigma or whatever company provided it. The company may be able to provide the absorbance values. Sigma does, for some of it's ethanol grades.
 
Before any letter gets sent, I strongly recommend finding a published spectrum of ethanol to compare it to this one. Either that or getting your own spectrum of ethanol. If you want to question the spectrum (and I think you can legitimately do that) there should be more basis for it.
Done it. Roy's "standard" is highly contaminated (possibly- acetone, a standard denaturant). His homeopreps look like ordinary (i.e., slightly contaminated), potable, 95% alcohol.
If you can say, "Roy's spectrum of ethanol does not match that published by XXX). How do the authors account for the discrepancy?" it will add significant weight.
This is nice, in theory; but you are dealing with the "Faculty of Homeopathy," not scientists. The sloppiness in Roy's article is within the norm for those people.

If one wants to know how the authors account for spectral differences, they should have explained how, given a coded sample of a remedy, they could use their data to identify the "remedy" and its "potency." All they say is "look, they are different."

As for those wondering about Figure 2, we don't have enough data to speculate on it. Oh, heck, I speculate that they have one bottle of each prep (NV, NM). They prepared 10 samples from each for the UV-Vis. Then, they plotted the highest and lowest trace from each set of 10 to show ... just how poor their sample handling technique is. That is, the "envelope" (or, range) of traces which different samples of the same prep can generate. (2A- 12c and 6c- almost look like they had someone competent working that day.)
 
{snip} When you superimpose the part of figure 2 that supposedly represents the 'envelope of difference' for 30C Nat Mur, onto the first graph in figure 1, which shows a comparison between 30C Nat Mur and 30C Nux Vom...the graphs are identical. So the same graph is supposedly representing two different things.
When I started posting this afternoon, I did not realize how much I had missed.

There is an old saying "Never attribute to malice what can be explained by incompetence." A simple explanation for this is that all we are seeing are selected spectra of variously mis-handled ethanol samples. It is not surprising if two different sets of spectra correspond. However, your point is well-taken.
Apart from that, the curves in figure 1 are all from figure 2 (the envelope of differences figure), suggesting they are comparing extreme examples rather than 'representative' ones. {snip}
Thanks, I did not see that.
 
Done it. Roy's "standard" is highly contaminated (possibly- acetone, a standard denaturant). His homeopreps look like ordinary (i.e., slightly contaminated), potable, 95% alcohol.


When you said "done it" does that mean that you did get a spectrum? If so, what did you see in that 320-330 region?

Could you reproduce the feature by adding a touch of acetone?
 
Harder than you might think! I scoured my university library in vain for such a thing.

It's going to be in the VERY OLD literature. I think I found a reference from the 50s, but from a Korean journal that our library didn't have. I would suspect you might even have to go older than that. Like in Chem Ber in the 30s or so.

The fact that ethanol does not signficantly absorb after what, 280nm, is why ethanol can be used as a solvent for things that do absorb in that range.

But they don't call it a significant absorption, so that doesn't really help. Just because a solvent doesn't have significant absorption past some wavelength does not require that it have NO absorption out there. Very weak transitions are still measurable spectroscopically, and don't get in the way of most chromophores.

I wouldn't be surprised if Aldrich even has a spectrum past 300 nm. No one bothers.
 
But no "description" of a UV spectrum is going to mention a minor bump at 320 nm, even if it is there. Note that this supposed feature is claimed to be minimally detectable, which means that the extinction coefficient is probably less than 1/1000th of that at lambda max, if that. You can't find this in a general description of the spectrum (just as a description of the vibrational spectrum won't mention every single bump, either)

You'd really need to see the spectrum to examine it properly.
 
But no "description" of a UV spectrum is going to mention a minor bump at 320 nm, even if it is there. {snip}
Where did you get this idea? Look at the "standard" spectrum in Roy's paper, it is not a minor bump at 324 nm. And the absorbance below that is way above the reported spectrum. You need considerable experience with spectra before you can argue with us about them. If you know what you are doing, you can get a lot of information from the published descriptions of spectra; otherwise it would be pointless to publish them.

Also, comparing your own spectra to his is a meaningless exercise since you don't know what impurities are causing his results. We know he is not using "spectral grade" ethanol. All you could say is yours look like his, or not.
 
Last edited:
Where did you get this idea? Look at the "standard" spectrum in Roy's paper, it is not a minor bump at 324 nm. And the absorbance below that is way above the reported spectrum. {snip}
The [newly] italicized part was not clear- the absorbance in Roy's published spectrum in the 300-250nm range is much greater than in the spectrum described by Aldrich.
 
I need Wilsontown to tell me which traces are identical though.

Righto...

As we know, the top graph of figure 1 is identical to the top graph in figure 2a, although they purport to represent different things.

In the middle graph of figure 1, the 12c NM curve matches the curve picked out by filled circles in the middle graph of figure 2a. The 12c NV curve matches the curve picked out by filled circles in the middle graph of figure 2b.

In the bottom graph of figure 2, the 6c NM curve matches the curve picked out by filled circles in the bottom graph of figure 2a. The 6c NV curve matches the curve picked out by filled circles in the bottom graph of figure 2b.

Hope that's all intelligible...

I'd be happy to sign any letter. I'm BSc and PhD, though in an unrelated field (geology).
 
Oh, missed one...

In the top graph of figure 2b, the curve picked out with filled circles (30c NV) is the same as the curve picked out with open circles (30c NM) in the top graph of figure 2a, which is in turn the same as the 30C NV curve in the top graph of figure 1.

What a mess. I only hope it all makes sense...
 
Where did you get this idea? Look at the "standard" spectrum in Roy's paper, it is not a minor bump at 324 nm. And the absorbance below that is way above the reported spectrum.

Here is the Aldrich description of the spectrum of spectro grade ethanol

UV absorption λ: 205 nm Amax: 1.00
λ: 210 nm Amax: 0.65
λ: 220 nm Amax: 0.35
λ: 255 nm Amax: 0.04
λ: 300-400 nm Amax: 0.01

The stuff from 300 - 400 nm is 1% of the intensity at the 205 max. That IS a minor bump in the spectum.
 
{snip} The stuff from 300 - 400 nm is 1% of the intensity at the 205 max. That IS a minor bump in the spectum.
That is exactly the point! We went all through this a while back. Roy's spectrum for his standard, pure ethanol has a large, local maximum at 324nm (A=.65), and strong absorbance below that (i.e., towards shorter wavelengths, A>.60). Clearly, Roy's homeopathic preps are different from his "ethanol standard" because his "standard" is not pure ethanol.


Wilsontown- Your observations are useful; however they fit in with my notion, which is that his homeoprep samples are all just USP/NF 95% ethanol (slightly dirty, compared to spectral grade). Thus, one would expect a lot of identical spectra from "nominally" different preps. On the other hand, if they use a collection of various unmatched cuvettes, some with fingerprints, dirty pipettes to transfer samples, different spectrometers, etc.; that could explain the range of spectral traces they recorded.
 
That is exactly the point! We went all through this a while back. Roy's spectrum for his standard, pure ethanol has a large, local maximum at 324nm (A=.65),

That is NOT a "large" local maximum, at least not compared to the other peaks. A relative absorption of .01 is not large by any stretch.

In fact, without actual extinction coefficients, you can't determine how intense the peak actually is. Based on the information from aldrich, though, we know that the region from 300 - 400 is about 1% of the max at 205.

Put this spectrum so that the 205 max is on full scale, and you basically can't see the peak at 324, especially on top of the background in that region.
 
Apparently we have different views about what constitutes a "large" peak. I tend to consider peaks that are 1% of the intensity of the maximum to be minor.

I'll wait for you to explain to me how you determine that it is a "large maximum."

Oddly, I've tried to bring the level of this conversation up. I keep wondering about the absorption intensity, but you never address it. What is the cross section for that peak? In general, I usually consider "intense" absorptions to have extinction coeffeficients in the 10s of thousands. If the intensity for ethanol at lambda max is 1e4, then this peak might be 100. That's not very intense at all.

I don't believe any of Roy's work, but your objection, "The peak isn't listed in the Aldrich description of UV spectra" is probably the lamest criticism I've heard. Read what Rolfe wrote about the problems with the spectra, including purification of the solvent, and the issues of scaling are completely mind-boggling (in fact, if you look at the spectra for the "homeo" solutions, it's not just in the 300 - 400 region where they absorb less, they don't absorb the same at 200 nm, either)

In fact, if you go back and read what I wrote at the beginning of the thread, _I_ was the one who brought up the issue of transition that 324 peak refers to.

If I want to know what a detailed spectrum looks like, I am going to have to look at the spectrum itself. I won't rely on someone's description of it, because you never know what they consider sufficient enough to mention.

Since you brought it up, I will mention, I'm pretty sure I have seen a lot more spectra in my life than you have. I look at and interpret spectra pretty much every day, and have been doing it for more than 15 years, so if you think this is a "sophomore" then you are mistaken.
 
{snip} Since you brought it up, I will mention, I'm pretty sure I have seen a lot more spectra in my life than you have. I look at and interpret spectra pretty much every day, and have been doing it for more than 15 years, so if you think this is a "sophomore" then you are mistaken.
Against my better judgment ... I am underwhelmed ... Fifteen years (!) ... even a lab tech should know more about the subject.

I have been a chemist more than 35 years, and I am now retired as a chemistry professor. I doubt you have seen more of anything in your career ... certainly, not spectra. If you have your old spectroscopy books, re-read them; the answer is out there.
 
Watch out, they'll be comparing the size of their burettes in a minute! :eek:
 
That is NOT a "large" local maximum, at least not compared to the other peaks. A relative absorption of .01 is not large by any stretch.

Which is the whole point. There is not a large peak in the absorption of ethanol. There is one in the data Roy presents. Therefore he was not using pure ethanol.
 
I'm just signing in here - I haven't read all the new posts, but grateful thanks to Wilsontown for the detailed information on duplications.

Spent all weekend on a friend's yacht, and the weather was unexpectedly great (quote, "if you get home without disseminated melanoma, you'll be lucky"), so although the paper came too it remained in my handbag in the locker.

I think we've way enough ammunition to do a letter, and way enough people prepared to sign I believe. I'm used to scrutineering medical/biological papers for journals, so if you like I'll draft something, once I get caught up.

This isn't about objecting to the publication of woo. This is about clear incongruities and inconsistencies in the data presented, no different from similar incongruities if they were found in a paper proposing something quite uncontentious and mainstream. On that basis, even Peter Fisher, as editor of the journal, ought to take some notice.

Rolfe.

PS. My address is in Britain, so my suggestion is that I write on my own headed paper, with address, then it doesn't matter where any other signatories come from, they can just append names and qualifications alone.

I'm half-tempted to leave off my veterinary qualifications and just include my biochemistry qualifications, to head of the "oh she's only a vet" comments, but probably it won't make any difference.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom