Pipirr
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2006
- Messages
- 1,433
Before any letter gets sent, I strongly recommend finding a published spectrum of ethanol to compare it to this one. Either that or getting your own spectrum of ethanol. If you want to question the spectrum (and I think you can legitimately do that) there should be more basis for it.
If you can say, "Roy's spectrum of ethanol does not match that published by XXX). How do the authors account for the discrepancy?" it will add significant weight.
Harder than you might think! I scoured my university library in vain for such a thing.
The fact that ethanol does not signficantly absorb after what, 280nm, is why ethanol can be used as a solvent for things that do absorb in that range.
That may be why even basic spectroscopy primers don't carry full wavelength scans of ethanol. None that I could find...
As for getting a spectra of our own, that could be useful. It would be even better if the authors provided the product number for the ethanol that they used, so at least one could check with Sigma or whatever company provided it. The company may be able to provide the absorbance values. Sigma does, for some of it's ethanol grades.