Americans, stop paying income tax. You don't have to.

the Head of the IRS couldn't state a law, 3 ex IRS agents who left their jobs because they found out there was no law testify on the video, a woman who sat on a tax case jury tells how the jury asked the judge to present them with the law, and he couldn't.
And you just believe it all?

Please read the links I gave you. It's BS. I CITED THE LAW.

Irwin Schiff once appeared on television and offered to pay $100,000 to anyone who could identify the section of the Internal Revenue Code that impose any liability for tax. A man named Richard Newman identified sections 1, 6012, 6151, 6153, 7201, 7202 and 7203 in a telephone call to the television station the following morning and then sued Schiff when he refused to pay the $100,000. The 6th Circuit Court of Appeals agreed that Newman was right about the tax laws and that Schiff’s claim was “ridiculous,” but ruled for Schiff because Newman did not telephone the television station with the correct answer within the time specified in Schiff’s offer (i.e., during the time that Schiff was actually on the air). Newman v. Schiff, 778 F.2d 460 (8th Cir. 1985).

That is case law that you can actually look up. I can cite case after case. You are wrong. The video is hollywood. It's smoke and mirrors. It's everything that JREF exists for.

Presidential Candidate Ron Paul states there is no law, law professors state there is no law... etc etc.. how much more do you need?
The courts HAVE ruled again and again that there is law. How much do YOU need?

it's not surprising given the recent attention that the IRS might circulate on the web something that LOOKS LIKE a law, but that would have no standing in a court of law.
One more time: I cited case law from The United States Suprme Court.

I'm watching your video, will you read my 3rd party links?
 
so far the weight of testimony is on my side.
Are you nuts? Do you even know what skepticism is? I'm citing you case law and you are relying on an old form of propaganda perfected in the 1930's.

just out of interest, do you believe in anything that isn't the establishment take on things?
I'm a skeptic. I use critical thinking. You show me the evidence I will believe it. I've followed a lot of CT and it's bunk. There are many things about my government that I'm skeptical of.
 
that lawyers argument seems to rely quite a big on the 16th Amendment. The film says that the 16th Amendment was never properly approved.
"The film says"? That's it then, I cite you case law and I cite you statute and you simply reply, "the film says".

You haven't read much if this is your answer BTW.
 
Last edited:
The FY2008 Budget:

(this is just the Department of Transporation, but)

139$ Mil to be given to cities to reduce congestaion

some 2 billion dollars to the Federal Highway Adminstration. Hmm.

(Source: http://www.gpoaccess.gov/usbudget/fy08/pdf/budget/transportation.pdf)


Or: http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2007/08/minnesota_and_the_politics_of.cfm

Which notes a federal initative to bring more money to the infrastucture..

thanks for the links, but i don't quite see the point you're trying to make. the point in the documentary is that the money collected in income tax is all swallowed up by interest payments on the debt to the federal reserve. there's a list of maybe 30 other forms of tax US citizens pay, which goes towards education, infrastructure, defence etc..
 
"The film says"? That's it then, I cite you case law and is cite you statute and you simply reply, "the film says".

You haven't read much if this is your answer BTW.

yes, the film.. with tax lawyers, law professors, IRS agents and the Head of the IRS.. i suppose if just one of these sat down and wrote something on a website you'd be more inclined to agree with it, simply because it agreed with what you think.
 
yes, the film.. with tax lawyers, law professors, IRS agents and the Head of the IRS.. i suppose if just one of these sat down and wrote something on a website you'd be more inclined to agree with it, simply because it agreed with what you think.
No, I only care about the law. BTW, I can't find the Head of the IRS saying what you claim. Also, the film is cut and edited. This IS a common ploy of propaganda. No one should trust this. It's interesting but it is contrary to a mountain of evidence. For crying in the dark I cited you the statutes and case law. Now you are pretending they don't exist because.... wait for it... a movie says so. Really plum, are you that credulous?

BTW, from the Shiff lawsuit I linked above.

Although Newman has not "won" his lawsuit in the traditional sense of recovering a reward that he sought, he has accomplished an important goal in the public interest of unmasking the "blatant nonsense" dispensed by Schiff.
The film is propaganda plum, it happens all of the time.
 
anyway, i'm off to bed, ..hope this hasn't been too taxing for anyone :)
Tomorrow I want you to provide the time on the video where the head of the IRS declares there is no law.

Fair enough?
 
For those of you playing at home, the maker of the film admits that people ARE going to jail for tax evasion.

If you want to protest that is fine but please don't think there is no risk. There is.
 
thanks for the links, but i don't quite see the point you're trying to make. the point in the documentary is that the money collected in income tax is all swallowed up by interest payments on the debt to the federal reserve. there's a list of maybe 30 other forms of tax US citizens pay, which goes towards education, infrastructure, defence etc..

The claim here is that interest payments on debt is the same as the amount collected in income tax.

That claim can be tested if you look at the budget papers for the US.

But the statement you make is problematic. Firstly the interest payments do not go to the Federal Reserve, they go to whoever ultimately holds the debt. Secondly, income taxes are not hypothecated to interest payments.

To deal with the first point. The debt market works like this. The government (or a corporation or other entity) decides that it wants to borrow money. As far as I am aware the government does this through the Federal Reserve but the Reserve is only the middleman (corporations etc go through investment banks).

The Government tells the Fed that they would like to borrow $1billion. The Fed asks lenders (which could be banks or corporations or other governments or even ordinary investors) if they would be willing to lend the government money and how much interest would they demand. If both the Fed and the lenders can come to an agreement then the Fed borrows the money. The lenders give the Fed their money and in return the Fed gives the lenders a bond (which is just a piece of paper that says that the holder will get a particular amount of money at a particular point in time). The Fed gives the money to the government and the government gives the interest payments back to the Fed to give to the borowers.

The second point about hypothecation. Income tax goes into general government revenue along with all sorts of other taxes. Interest repayments are taken out of this pool of government revenue along with payments for all sorts of other things (like infrastructure, army etc). There is nothing which says that income tax goes to paying off interest just as there is nothing which says that the other taxes go to pay off other expenses. The only exception is if a tax is hypothecated, which means that the tax must go to pay a particular purpose.

If you stop paying income tax then interest payments won't go down. It will probably just mean that something else doesn't get paid for.
 
Last edited:
If you stop paying income tax then interest payments won't go down. It will probably just mean that something else doesn't get paid for.
That was the other big problem I was going to tell him.

Even if it is discovered that it is illegal to collect income tax the commitment is still made. The money has to be paid. It doesn't go away by aboloshing the income tax. Congress would have to levy a fee to pay the interest. It's as simple as that.
 
now you're obviously trying to obfuscate the issue by using a word like "hypothecated"
This is a complete diversion, as the OP and the video are about the lack of an income tax law. Watch it for yourself.

I am not trying to obfuscate anything. The claim was made that federal income tax is only used to service privately held public debt- this would require that federal income tax is held in a separate account from other federal revenue streams, and is earmarked for that one specific purpose. Why use 26 words when the English language has provided such a useful one already? One which is used widely in eth discussion of tax policy. As I said, I have seen this film (it’s been discussed her before more than once), and I was addressing a specific claim in the film which you have repeated here.
 
Plum's claim of income tax only going to pay interest on the debt is easily dismissed. I have two sources for this.

The first is http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/fy2007/pdf/hist.pdf For 2005, you can see that the revenue from income taxes is $927 billion. Interest on the debt is $183 billion. Seems like the govt has a lot left over to pay for other programs after paying the debt interest.

Another source is my 1040 Tax Forms and Instructions booklet (from 2006) which shows the pie charts near the end. Personal income taxes account for 38% of revenues. In the notes below the total revenue for 2005 is given as $2.2 trillion which translates into 0.38 x $2.2T = $836 billion. There is also a pie chart for outlays where net interest on debt is 7%. In the notes below total outlays are $2.5 trillion so outlays for interest on the debt is $2.5T x 0.07 = $175 billion.

So no matter which source you look at, personal income taxes are about FIVE times higher than interest on the debt.

Clearly Plum's claim that all the income tax goes to service the debt has been falsified here.

Lurker
 
that lawyers argument seems to rely quite a big on the 16th Amendment. The film says that the 16th Amendment was never properly approved.


Sigh. Of all the wacky conspiracists out there, tax protestors have to be my least favorite.

Plumjam, I ask you to consider this: What is law?

What is it that makes something law and something else just a good idea or just voluntary?

I submit to you that law is anything enforced by threat of physical violence. The government and the government alone is the legitimator of force. The government can use force to compel its citizens but other citizens may not use force to compel each other. Being robbed at gunpoint is a crime but being taxed is not. This is true by definition.

Now, we in the US happen to be lucky enough to live in a democracy. This means that, while the government controls us by threat of force, we control the government. We get to decide what the government does with its power. It used to be that the government used physical violence to supress labor strikes. We the people decided we didn't want that, elected leaders who promised not to do it and the government changed its policy. Now it uses the threat of physical violence to prevent private companies from supressing labor strikes.

On the issue of income tax the undisputable fact is this: if you don't pay income taxes, the government will physically accost you and throw you bodily into jail. Agents of the government will actually grab your arms, chain them together, strip you naked, stick a finger up your butt, hose you down, put you in a scratchy jumpsuit and throw you in a cell for years.

That will happen. You might think it shouldn't happen but that won't stop it.

As a democracy, we have the opportunity to tell the government not to do this. In just about every election in every municipality in the entire US - from President to state senators to local magistrates - you can almost always find a tax protestor on the ballot. This is someone whose only desire is to repeal income and other taxes.

Guess what? The always lose. We have the chance to vote for this policy change and we choose not to.

So not only is paying income tax the law because it's enforced with violence, but it's a law we as Americans consider just because we do nothing to change it.

No technical whinging about ratification of the 16th Amendment and unclear tax codes will change that.
 
LossLeader - you're right, of course. The law is internally self-defining, and I certainly wouldn't argue with you on that. There is a slight addendum which might needed to be added to the above, though - and it's that laws can be ruled unconstitutional (in the US) or in breach of superordinate European legislation (in the EU).

I think that's why tax protesters try and whine about the 16th's ratification - it makes them feel like they have an out (and, AIUI, they might have had if the 16th hadn't been ratified). Of course, that's all beside the point because were it shown that there was some legal inconsistency, a Bill would be introduced immediately to fix it - but I thought it worth mentioning.
 
Why does it appear that tax protesters, and most other conspiracy theorists actually, are arguing an ideology and world view rather than facts?

What is the deal with this obvious marriage of conspiracy theories and ideologues? More than once PlumJam mentioned our believing what the 'establishment' says. That's one step from accusing us of being shills, and then I suspect invariably on to the paid debunker claims.

Why does it always have to come down to that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom