Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

You can remove flesh from your child, but noone can touch you, which would seem to imply your child wouldnt want to have flesh removed from him, as you dont from yourself.


I do not know why you say, "No one can touch you." I don't know to what you are referring. As to whether my eight day old son would or would not want to be circumcised, the matter is of no consequence.


I love how you say its in the best interest for the incompetent child, implying what, that the child will never be competent to decide if they want it or not?


I have never implied that my child will never be competent. I don't know what I've said that would lead you to infer it.


Id like to point out on the issue of slavery that slaves were indeed enslaved for their own good, or that was one of the rationales used anyway. Christians enslaving heathens were saving their souls, just as youre saving your son's soul by mutilating him.


Great. So of the three prongs of the test for substituted judgment, let's give it to the slaveholders and say that slavery was in the best interests of the slaves. Now you just have to satisfy the other two prongs: that the slaves were incompetent to understand the risks and benefits of the proposed procedure and that the slaveholders were the next of kin and natural medical proxies for the slaves.

Can you do that with slavery?

Because I can when it comes to circumcising my child.

That is pretty frankly, moronic. Youre worried about him becoming sexually damaged.... so you sexually damage him, good logic there.


There is no evidence that infant circumcision negatively affects sexual performance or pleasure. So, in fact, I have exercised good logic and I thank you for recognizing such.


Right, the reasoning, as above, is the same youre using. God told them to, or at least they used God, cause he so readily speaks for himself, to justify what they wanted.


Once again, slavery and rape to not satisfy the prongs of the test for substituted judgment that the individuals be incompetent and that the decision-makers be the family of the individual. They are also not in the individual's best interests. So, the fact that they believe God told them to does not make them analagous to circumcision.


Heres a site, it purports itself to be Jewish, it is an older article, but your mandate to cut your baby's penis is slightly older ay ;). http://www.jewishcircumcision.org/jnews90.htm


Um, okay.


Id also like to comment on your lack of response to the issue of modern Jewish circumcision not being the original practice. I, as well as others, would have a much harder time arguing against the cutting off of the protruding tip of the foreskin, vs removing the majority of skin from your son's penis, which come to think of it, isnt even what God told you to do... hmm.


The religious authorities I trust recommend circumcision in its current form.
 
Since youre being a bit silly about the definition of rape by the way, here you go. (Not you Linda.)

Rape. N.

1. The crime of forcing another person to submit to sex acts, especially sexual intercourse.
2. The act of seizing and carrying off by force; abduction.
3. Abusive or improper treatment; violation: a rape of justice.



Were you to have posted a picture of a kitten, you could not have contributed to this debate less.
 
Were you to have posted a picture of a kitten, you could not have contributed to this debate less.

I seem to recall a certain Jewish fellow, adamant about mutilating his sons, saying that rape refers only to intercourse.

With your religious bias anything can be said. Yes, the various peoples enslaved over the years have always been viewed as inferior, and unable to make proper choices or lives anyway, so they might as well be enslaved. So yes, they are incompetent.

While youre using your faith as an excuse for whatever you want, were all brothers in God, Jesus, Beelzebub, or whatever deity/faith system you want to employ. So, Ill just use an outrageous argument to refute your outrageous argument. Im your next of Kin, cause God made me and you, our father is the Lord, making me your sibling in faith, yes? Why not. (Happy time fun faith mode.)

Theres no evidence that circumcision effects sex? How many studies do you need to look over. Positively, negatively, neutrally. Tell me how removing a part of the body that can be used for a variety of sexual purposes doesnt effect sex? How is that possible? Remembering that sex is something people do other than to produce babies, an uncircumcised person is physically(avoiding the fun sensation issue) capable of doing more than a circumcised person. Your view is physically impossible and therefore wrong.

As for the article, I suppose I should have thrown some background in for that. When you say your religious advisers you seem to imply some sort of unity among them, the existence of the site proves otherwise. The article voices a concern, though as I said it is a bit old. But also as I said, your mandate for circumcision predates it by a few thousand years. (As a slight aside, its always been a curious matter for me, how science must be updated in light of new evidence and people frequently look back at old scientific ideals with a bit of amusement, somehow religion, having been written when the entire race was largely ignorant of everything, never needs to be updated or rethought.)


In its current form... I trust then that youve inquired about it? I doubt you have but rather work off a broad "Jews do it" ideology, without bothering to consider its origins, or much else.

As I said a few posts back, dont misunderstand about my position on faith or family. I support both, so long as theyre not harming other people. Babies and children are people, much as everyone likes to deny it. Making in my view, any abuse such as this all the more heinous.
 
Last edited:
If those involved sincerely had my best interests at heart, yes.

Linda

So if my religion told me that it was good to rape my child every night before bed otherwise the boogyman would get him that would be ok?

I personally don't want people to take action based on "my best interests". I want them to get it right!

The do-gooders in this world have already caused enough harm don't you think?




And Loss Leader, you are either being purposefully obtuse, or you are just completely and utterly brainwashed. The way you are twisting the study to make it sound like circumcising your child is good makes me sick.

FACT: Circumcision causes decrease in sexual function when done at any age.

Can I prove it? No I cannot. However the study you are referencing is certainly a good indicator that I am correct.

Will it ever be proven? I believe so. To me it's obvious on the face of it, but then again I wasn't mutilated.

Maybe we'll come back to this thread over the decades as more evidence accumulates. I don't see it turning out good for the mutilators and rapists. History has and will continue to judge those that are participants.
 
So if my religion told me that it was good to rape my child every night before bed otherwise the boogyman would get him that would be ok?

Honestly, why the aversion to making a considered and thoughtful response to what I say?

I personally don't want people to take action based on "my best interests". I want them to get it right!

The do-gooders in this world have already caused enough harm don't you think?

How do you distinguish between the two?

And Loss Leader, you are either being purposefully obtuse, or you are just completely and utterly brainwashed. The way you are twisting the study to make it sound like circumcising your child is good makes me sick.

His sense of humour is perhaps a bit wicked.

FACT: Circumcision causes decrease in sexual function when done at any age.

Can I prove it? No I cannot. However the study you are referencing is certainly a good indicator that I am correct.

Will it ever be proven? I believe so. To me it's obvious on the face of it, but then again I wasn't mutilated.

I think the problem with making these kinds of statements is that, on the face, they appear patently false. The billions of men who have functioned just fine without a foreskin, and their sexual partners, are apt to look at that statement and go "huh?" I think if you tried really hard, you could find a way to answer this question. And maybe even discover, in a manner that was valid, quantifiable differences to the benefit of the uncircumcised state. However, it is clear that the sexual experience does not depend upon an absolute amount of sensitivity, or that most men are hovering around some sort of minimal threshold, barely able to make it over the top.

And the excuse that I am looking for a salve to my conscience does not apply, since I am not responsible for the "mutilation" of anyone.

Maybe we'll come back to this thread over the decades as more evidence accumulates. I don't see it turning out good for the mutilators and rapists. History has and will continue to judge those that are participants.

Exactly. Won't we feel foolish trying to justify our support of that black period in history when children were forced to participate in a public education system.

Linda
 
The question isn't whether or not physical abuse of children is immoral, it's whether or not circumcision constitutes an act of physical abuse. As do many others here, you are beg the question. You assume the answer in your argument.

How about these:

This one seems to fit quite well: The non-accidental injury to a child.

If those involved sincerely had my best interests at heart, yes.

Linda

So you're ok with this going on then, too?

The relative who called police said an exorcism had also been attempted Thursday.

"The purpose was to release demons from this very young child," said Sgt. Joel Tranter.

Officers arrived at the house Saturday and entered when they heard screaming coming from a bedroom, Tranter said.

A bed had been pushed up against the door; the officers pushed it open a few inches and saw Marquez choking his bloodied granddaughter, who was crying in pain and gasping, Tranter said.

A bloody, naked 19-year-old woman who police later determined to be Marquez's daughter and the girl's mother was in the room, chanting "something that was religious in nature," Tranter said.

I mean, the adults really believed it was in the best interests of the child, so that made it ok.
 
Hey, at least at my child's genital mutilation there's cake.

No reasonable argument will sway you, and as I said a while back your presence at all in this topic is very fun.

Ill just throw out the morbid hope that your son has some bad complications, or grows up to hate you. Then you can still be right.
 
So you're ok with this going on then, too?



Oh honestly, Ivor. You've been one of the most careful and reasonable foreskinners here but that was just plain silly.

You know for a fact that the test of whether something is in a child's best interests must pass basic social muster. You know exorcisms that involve choking three year-olds don't. And you know that, so far, circumcision does.

Furthermore, you know that circumcision is a generalized and widespread religious practice whereas exorcisms involving choking are neither generalized nor widespread.

I'm glad to engage in a reasonable discussion but that exorcism comparison was goofy at best.



(Also, I don't know if you noticed but the person who died wasn't the child. The grandfather died after being accosted by the police.)
 
Oh honestly, Ivor. You've been one of the most careful and reasonable foreskinners here but that was just plain silly.

You know for a fact that the test of whether something is in a child's best interests must pass basic social muster. You know exorcisms that involve choking three year-olds don't. And you know that, so far, circumcision does.

Furthermore, you know that circumcision is a generalized and widespread religious practice whereas exorcisms involving choking are neither generalized nor widespread.

I'm glad to engage in a reasonable discussion but that exorcism comparison was goofy at best.

(Also, I don't know if you noticed but the person who died wasn't the child. The grandfather died after being accosted by the police.)

Yeah, following a religious ideal in order to treat them "to their best interest." Thats just highlarious. Whereas me doing the exact some thing with my child is a lawfully sanctioned and endorsed procedure.

I suppose that this sort of thing was never endorsed in history right? Excorcisms(among quite a few other religious relics) have never been practiced with any seriousness.
 
Ill just throw out the morbid hope that your son has some bad complications, or grows up to hate you. Then you can still be right.


Let me be very clear that you have just wished physical pain and suffering on my unborn son - a boy who has done nothing to you and who is innocent in every regard.

I just want to understand that you believe that it would be just and fair if my mistaken beliefs about circumcision were rewarded with medical complications and anguish in a person who does not share my beliefs and who has never offended you in any way.

The way you think I should be punished is for someone who is not me to be injured.

Have I correctly encapsulated your views?

I am disgusted beyond my ability to express or your ability to comprehend. Whereas I undertake my actions because I believe them to be in my son's best interests, your hopes have nothing to do with his interests at all. They are punitive and pusillanimous. Wishing ill on an infant makes you perhaps the sickest, sorriest, stupidest individual whom I have ever had the unfortunate occassion to meet.

I hope your filthy, hateful attitude towards infants is discovered long before you are ever entrusted with the care of one.

And, for the sake of everyone around you, I hope you are as ineffectual at realizing your ugly aspirations as you are at defending them.

Do not bother replying except to explain that your improvident comments are regretted by you.
 
Honestly, why the aversion to making a considered and thoughtful response to what I say?



How do you distinguish between the two?

Linda

It's called science!

No Aversion expressed because my response was a serious analogy. You see I'm attacking the JUSTIFICATION not the act itself. The justification for raping the child every night is the same as the justification for circumcision. That justification is CONTROL. The parent may not realise this. It's clear for example that LL is not in control of his own faculties as they have been subverted by a religious meme. If he was a native to Africa we could easily be having this conversation about how his daughter needs to have her clit cut off otherwise their culture would die. No difference see? This is the part you guys aren't getting. Genital mutilation is genital mutilation, in this case the analogy is very apt because the reasoning is identical. It's my daughter and *I* know whats in her best interest SO THERE and it's LEGAL so therefore it's right (at least LL uses this a lot in his arguments).

If I hear another legal argument I'm going to throw up. This has nothing to do with the law, we are talking about whether or not it's moral. I fully realize that LL has the law on his side. That isn't the point and it certainly doesn't make it right. Our morals are obviously different... which is funny considering how often religious types bleet on about how you can only be moral with god in the picture.

Circumcision is evil and anyone that knowingly takes part has my disdain. Then again I pretty much feel the same way about religion in general so it's not a very exclusive club.
 
Let me be very clear that you have just wished physical pain and suffering on my unborn son - a boy who has done nothing to you and who is innocent in every regard.

I just want to understand that you believe that it would be just and fair if my mistaken beliefs about circumcision were rewarded with medical complications and anguish in a person who does not share my beliefs and who has never offended you in any way.

The way you think I should be punished is for someone who is not me to be injured.

Have I correctly encapsulated your views?

I am disgusted beyond my ability to express or your ability to comprehend. Whereas I undertake my actions because I believe them to be in my son's best interests, your hopes have nothing to do with his interests at all. They are punitive and pusillanimous. Wishing ill on an infant makes you perhaps the sickest, sorriest, stupidest individual whom I have ever had the unfortunate occassion to meet.

I hope your filthy, hateful attitude towards infants is discovered long before you are ever entrusted with the care of one.

And, for the sake of everyone around you, I hope you are as ineffectual at realizing your ugly aspirations as you are at defending them.

Do not bother replying except to explain that your improvident comments are regretted by you.

Ohh you make me laugh Loss, the irony. You dont care, why should I? Would it be better if God told me to tell you that? Need I say that complications need not be painful? You are the one who is directly attacking your son's penis, yet you become sooo protective. If he does have some complications call the Mohel and cut off something else.
 
Last edited:
It's called science!

You made the statement that you considered people acting on the basis of "my best interests" would come to a different outcome than "get it right!" I asked how you would distinguish between the two (how can you tell if the product of their consideration was the result of them acting in my best interests or the result of them getting it right). Is "science" meant to answer that particular question? If so, how?

No Aversion expressed because my response was a serious analogy. You see I'm attacking the JUSTIFICATION not the act itself. The justification for raping the child every night is the same as the justification for circumcision. That justification is CONTROL. The parent may not realise this. It's clear for example that LL is not in control of his own faculties as they have been subverted by a religious meme. If he was a native to Africa we could easily be having this conversation about how his daughter needs to have her clit cut off otherwise their culture would die. No difference see? This is the part you guys aren't getting. Genital mutilation is genital mutilation, in this case the analogy is very apt because the reasoning is identical. It's my daughter and *I* know whats in her best interest SO THERE and it's LEGAL so therefore it's right (at least LL uses this a lot in his arguments).

As has been discussed numerous times in this thread, what we do on behalf of or to others has to pass several tests in order to be justifiable. While parents are charged with the primary interest in their children, there is also a societal interest in the protection of their members. Raping a child would fail society's test. And society's tests are represented by laws, which is why legal arguments are relevant to this issue.

Removal of the clitoris also fails society's test. Partly because the nature of the procedure is more physically damaging, and partly because the decision is far more coercive.

So essentially you are right. The argument rests on whether or not the action passes the tests that you mentioned. However, your analogies were flawed since they would not pass the same tests.

If I hear another legal argument I'm going to throw up. This has nothing to do with the law, we are talking about whether or not it's moral. I fully realize that LL has the law on his side. That isn't the point and it certainly doesn't make it right. Our morals are obviously different... which is funny considering how often religious types bleet on about how you can only be moral with god in the picture.

Circumcision is evil and anyone that knowingly takes part has my disdain. Then again I pretty much feel the same way about religion in general so it's not a very exclusive club.

You recognize that different people have different morals. Is disdain for those who happen to have morals different from your own unavoidable? Do you see some way for this disdain to be absolute rather than relative?

Linda
 
As has been discussed numerous times in this thread, what we do on behalf of or to others has to pass several tests in order to be justifiable. While parents are charged with the primary interest in their children, there is also a societal interest in the protection of their members. Raping a child would fail society's test. And society's tests are represented by laws, which is why legal arguments are relevant to this issue.

Removal of the clitoris also fails society's test. Partly because the nature of the procedure is more physically damaging, and partly because the decision is far more coercive.

Linda

Of course, what determines justifiability is subject to change as well. I think one of the main reasons its still seen as justifiable relates to the large portion of men here that are. Which understandably results in a bias.

Also that the huge amount of money that could be lost if the medical community just came out and declared it damaging, what with lawsuits and all.

I think in connection to removal of the clitoris, this just being based on my readings and such, that the abolishment of female mutilation in this country has to to with sexism essentially. Somehow people think that females are more innocent/vulnerable, and therefore more worthy of protection than males, who should be rough and tumble, etc.
 
Last edited:
Oh honestly, Ivor. You've been one of the most careful and reasonable foreskinners here but that was just plain silly.

You know for a fact that the test of whether something is in a child's best interests must pass basic social muster. You know exorcisms that involve choking three year-olds don't. And you know that, so far, circumcision does.

Furthermore, you know that circumcision is a generalized and widespread religious practice whereas exorcisms involving choking are neither generalized nor widespread.

I'm glad to engage in a reasonable discussion but that exorcism comparison was goofy at best.

(Also, I don't know if you noticed but the person who died wasn't the child. The grandfather died after being accosted by the police.)

I suggest you use your google-fu and look at how widespread and socially acceptable exorcism of children is. Jews and Muslims don't have the monopoly on barbaric cultural and religious rituals performed on a child for its own "benefit", you know;)

Most exorcisms involve some pain being inflicted on the child to force the demon out. How is that so different to what Jews and Muslims do to their children during circumcision?

BTW, I hope the birth of your second son goes well for both him and his mother and his circumcision is as quick and as pain free as possible.
 
Removal of the clitoris also fails society's test. Partly because the nature of the procedure is more physically damaging, and partly because the decision is far more coercive.

Rubbish! You just don't like the idea of girls being hurt in this way because you have a clitoris and can empathize, whereas you have no idea what sensations men have from their foreskins, thus you discount their loss.

http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/links/doi/10.1111/j.1471-0528.2002.01550.x/abs/

Objective To examine the association between female genital cutting and frequency of sexual and gynaecological symptoms among a cohort of cut versus uncut women in Edo State of Nigeria.

Design Cross sectional study.

Setting Women attending family planning and antenatal clinics at three hospitals in Edo State, South–south Nigeria.

Population 1836 healthy premenopausal women.

Methods The sample included 1836 women. Information about type of female genital cutting was based on medical exams while a structured questionnaire was used to elicit information on the women's socio-demographic characteristics, their ages of first menstruation (menarche), first intercourse, marriage and pregnancy, sexual history and experiences of symptoms of reproductive tract infections. Associations between female genital cutting and these correlates of sexual and gynaecologic morbidity were analysed using univariate and multivariate logistic regression and Cox models.

Main outcome measures Frequency of self-reported orgasm achieved during sexual intercourse and symptoms of reproductive tract infections.

Results Forty-five percent were circumcised and 71% had type 1, while 24% had type 2 female genital cutting. No significant differences between cut and uncut women were observed in the frequency of reports of sexual intercourse in the preceding week or month, the frequency of reports of early arousal during intercourse and the proportions reporting experience of orgasm during intercourse. There was also no difference between cut and uncut women in their reported ages of menarche, first intercourse or first marriage in the multivariate models controlling for the effects of socio-economic factors. In contrast, cut women were 1.25 times more likely to get pregnant at a given age than uncut women. Uncut women were significantly more likely to report that the clitoris is the most sexually sensitive part of their body (OR = 0.35, 95% CI = 0.26–0.47), while cut women were more likely to report that their breasts are their most sexually sensitive body parts (OR = 1.91; 95% CI = 1.51–2.42). Cut women were significantly more likely than uncut women to report having lower abdominal pain (OR = 1.54, 95% CI = 1.11–2.14), yellow bad-smelling vaginal discharge (OR = 2.81, 95% CI = 1.54–5.09), white vaginal discharge (OR = 1.65, 95% CI = 1.09–2.49) and genital ulcers (OR = 4.38, 95% CI = 1.13–17.00).

Conclusion Female genital cutting in this group of women did not attenuate sexual feelings. However, female genital cutting may predispose women to adverse sexuality outcomes including early pregnancy and reproductive tract infections. Therefore, female genital cutting cannot be justified by arguments that suggest that it reduces sexual activity in women and prevents adverse outcomes of sexuality.

I bet if it was being performed by trained doctors in hygenic conditions then FGM could achieve a complication rate similar to male circumcision.
 
Ivor said:
I bet if it was being performed by trained doctors in hygenic conditions then FGM could achieve a complication rate similar to male circumcision.

And tweeked over time to create or discover some obsure health benefit.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom