Review of Dr. Griffin's NIST criticism now available

Many JREFers are only too pleased to address these very poor theories, and extract as much advantage from them as possible.


The only thing that follows from this is that the conspiracy theorists should stop using them. (Incidentally, I take no pleasure in addressing these arguments time after time after time. In fact, I find it marginally depressing. I suspect that many JREFers can sympathise.)
 
I'm going to ask a mod to move a good deal of this thread to AAH, unless someone sees it as necessary to the discussion of RMackey's paper.
 
You say:" I'm not asking you to find specific errors in it, as you are incompetent to do so."

So pomeroo, why are you posting?



I am posting to complain that one of the most dishonest and scientifically-illiterate fantasists is presuming to offer substance-free criticisms of a paper he doesn't intend to read.




Why are you communicating with someone who you think is "incompetent", if you are so great?


How do you infer my "greatness" from my annoyance at Swing Dumpster's presumptuousness? Are you saying that rationalists should not communicate with conspiracy liars because the former tend to be bright and the latter are stupid and ignorant?
 
You called me on false authority when in fact, RMackey is not an authority on the design and construction of high-rise steel structures, nor is he a structural engineer. Therefore, he is neither qualified to support or attack NIST or critiques of NIST. He is qualified to support or critique items in his field only at least that has been the standard for the debunking.
Now how am I using a false authority argument when that has been the standard of the debunking community? I will accept your fallacy, if you can accept that the debunking community has been practicing that fallacy since the inception of the so called "truth movement".

As for your specific example: please see past comments on SLC as well as various threads on JREF where truthers have brought up critiques of any aspect of the official story.
:dl: :dl:

RMackey , and myself, to name 2, are engineers who design and analyze structures--of all types. We are required to know materials, fastening, and load paths. We are the type of engineers that STRUCTURAL ENGINEERS come to for consultation on things that are different from what has been done before.
I dare say that a Structural Engineer is better versed on Building Codes, specific construction methods (bolted, riveted, welded, Rebar, Remesh, etc) than he or I ever will be (or care to be, for that matter)
Engineering tends to be pretty specialized when it gets down to the nuts and bolts. Structural Engineers (By NSPE standards) , HVAC engineers, Nuclear Engineers, Industrial Engineers, Process Engineers (to name a few) have to be so full of their particular requirements and needs that they get the people who specialize in other things to give their advice.
Next time you see a Greyhound Bus ( a million miles is just getting broken in), or an F-16 (with the fuselage intact), or the Space Shuttle lift-off, or read about Viking's Mission to Mars, or the tethered satellite system, you can say "I have exchanged messages with a guy who worked that, and he don't know diddly"
See how many people believe you...
 
At the risk of changing the tone of this thread, let me ask our resident and visiting fantasists to comment on R. Mackey's refutation of the free-fall myth. Starting on page 34, Mackey dissects the often-repeated falsehood that the towers fell too quickly for a purely gravity-driven collapse, unassisted by explosives. Tell us what he gets wrong.

C'mon, now, here's your chance: tell us why Griffin's parroting of the errors of Jim Hoffman and Judy Wood has greater explanatory value than Mackey's exposition. Be specific.
 
One of the big tactics used by OTers on here is based on 'straw man arguments, and in Mackey's 'paper' - to stay on topic - I noticed some topics that Mackey chose to "debunk" such as:

Claim: Larry Silverstein said Pull, meaning they decided to demolish the building."

Claim: BBC reported WTC 7 had collapsed before it actually collapsed. This was a script they slipped out early and proves the conspiracy.

Claim: The fallen light poles are suspicious.


A perfert example of 'straw man' is exactly what Mackey is doing -

He's 'debunking' these (very easy) 'claims' and pretending they are representative of serious CT claims, which is a straw man
In fact, you could say an army of straw men :)

This would be more believable if CTists didn't use this defense EVERY TIME A THEORY GOT DEBUNKED.

You see, each time an argument used by a CTist is proven flat-out wrong, he simply says that the argument wasn't a "serious CT claim" and accuses his opponent of "strawman" (which is a false positive anyway). Then he can safely ignore his opponents rebuttal long enough for him to pretend it was never refuted, then he can just bring it up all over again.

It seems that EVERY CT claim isn't a "serious CT claim" once it gets proven wrong. But until then, it gets parroted like the gospel truth as if it alone refutes the entire official story.

Mind you, these allegedly non-"serious" CT claims are considered VERY serious by other members of the Truth Movement. "Seriousness" is in the eye of the beholder. Why are YOU speaking on behalf of your ENTIRE MOVEMENT with regards to the "seriousness" of these claims?

You have two options: Either accept that these arguments have been thoroughly refuted, or provide reasons as to why they have not. None of this "But they weren't SERIOUS arguments lolololololol" cop-out junk. That's just a way to hide from a debate that you're afraid you can't win.
 
Prove the design, done by Robertson was for high speed!

Here is what the chief structural engineer said – he wrote this first hand. Not a news story or hearsay, it is fact.
Oops he said slow speed. Darn you are wrong before you posted. Why even try? Stop posting hearsay, bring facts. I do.
Oops just looks like more revisionism after the fact to me. Cherry picking? Just words from the horse’s mouth. Go ahead and cherry pick something he said years before the collapse that even comes close to the revisionism you cherry picked.
 
Oops just looks like more revisionism after the fact to me. Cherry picking? Just words from the horse’s mouth. Go ahead and cherry pick something he said years before the collapse that even comes close to the revisionism you cherry picked.
You have hearsay, please produce some facts. I have facts, you have talk, you have lost.

Show me on first hand 600 mph impact study. There is only one chief engineer, it is Robertson. http://www.asce.org/pressroom/news/display_press.cfm?uid=1349
 
Last edited:
adfsadfdsafdsafdsafdsa


The speed of the design was slow speed. You can ask Robertson. The design was for a slow speed aircraft lost in the fog.

If you were smart you would ask a pilot why this was used. You might ask can a 707 do 600 mph at 1300 feet? No a 707 max speed at 1300 feet is 355 KCAS; and by law it is limited to 250 KIAS, and by law the plane is not allowed near buildings!!! And there is no reason a plane would be at 1300 feet in NYC. So what is the speed of an aircraft to impact the WTC and why? At takeoff the jet is well past 1300 feet shortly after takeoff, oops, it is not able to hit the WTC. Darn. But if the plane was landing and lost in the fog and had lots of fuel in NYC, it would leave and go to Philadelphia and land in the clear weather. But if the plane was lost and low on fuel it could hit the WTC! Oops, slow speed, low fuel is the most likely accident, there is no regular time a plane is near the WTC. And a 707 does not do 600 mph at 1300 feet when the pilot is a rational person.

Now I will ask Robertson what he says. BTW, the NIST stuff about 600 and the other people that say 600 is hearsay, no one who built the WTC said 600 mph.

Here is what the chief structural engineer said – he wrote this first hand. This is not a news story or hearsay, it is fact. [/FONT][/SIZE]

So you are wrong and R Mackey is correct. You could look up this stuff and do your own research and stop being a truther who clings to hearsay. You need training on seeing hearsay!

I should ask a pilot? Why? You aren't a structural engineer.
And there is no reason a plane would be at 1300 feet in NYC.
LOL. Ok. Tell the terrorists that. You've never had a mechanical malfunction to cause to you to fly that low? So the law now determines the altitude of planes? Check.

Your telling me I rely on hearsay, correct? Please do explain that and make sure you mention NIST as part of the hearsay.


Please see NIST. Also, I'm also relying on the comments of the head structural engineer after the 1993 attack. This of course at a time when the design parameters of the building would be at the beck and call of the designers and engineers. We would expect them to be pouring over all aspects of the design of the building as well. And the fact of the matter is who would know the parameters of the building better than the head structural engineer after an attack on his building.
I'm also relying on this fact as originally sourced from the document that was used as part of the buildings critique when confronted by lawsuit questioning the integrity of the building. This of course contradicts Mr. Robertson statements.
I'm curious if accepting Mr. Robertson's statement here, will the reader also accept Mr. Robertson's comments on the condition of molten steel 21 days after the attacks?

Oh, and one other thing, did Mr. Robertson give the calculations to NIST?
 
You say:" I'm not asking you to find specific errors in it, as you are incompetent to do so."

So pomeroo, why are you posting? Why are you communicating with someone who you think is "incompetent", if you are so great?


Actually, if you want to be respectful to everyone here, TerryUK, you'll want to head back to the thread you abandoned and try to support your position.

That would be the courteous thing to do for those who have given their time to helping you out.
 
At the risk of changing the tone of this thread, let me ask our resident and visiting fantasists to comment on R. Mackey's refutation of the free-fall myth. Starting on page 34, Mackey dissects the often-repeated falsehood that the towers fell too quickly for a purely gravity-driven collapse, unassisted by explosives. Tell us what he gets wrong.

C'mon, now, here's your chance: tell us why Griffin's parroting of the errors of Jim Hoffman and Judy Wood has greater explanatory value than Mackey's exposition. Be specific.

Actually, Mr. Mackey should take it upon himself to confront structural engineers who find fault with NIST instead of a theology professor.

Will that happen, R. Mackey?
 
The speed of the design was slow speed. You can ask Robertson. The design was for a slow speed aircraft lost in the fog.
So how would a plane hit the WTC at 600 mph in an accident? What is the most likely impact design for an aircraft impact? And how could it be 600 mph since it would have shown damage to the core and the people would be trapped, Robertson would not call that building survival, and he would have designed for the 600 mph if that was the design but it was about 180 mph with flaps down low fuel.

Leslie Robertson / steven Jones interview



part two



part three

 
Last edited:
:dl: :dl:

RMackey , and myself, to name 2, are engineers who design and analyze structures--of all types. We are required to know materials, fastening, and load paths. We are the type of engineers that STRUCTURAL ENGINEERS come to for consultation on things that are different from what has been done before.
I dare say that a Structural Engineer is better versed on Building Codes, specific construction methods (bolted, riveted, welded, Rebar, Remesh, etc) than he or I ever will be (or care to be, for that matter)
Engineering tends to be pretty specialized when it gets down to the nuts and bolts. Structural Engineers (By NSPE standards) , HVAC engineers, Nuclear Engineers, Industrial Engineers, Process Engineers (to name a few) have to be so full of their particular requirements and needs that they get the people who specialize in other things to give their advice.
Next time you see a Greyhound Bus ( a million miles is just getting broken in), or an F-16 (with the fuselage intact), or the Space Shuttle lift-off, or read about Viking's Mission to Mars, or the tethered satellite system, you can say "I have exchanged messages with a guy who worked that, and he don't know diddly"
See how many people believe you...

I missed the part where you were a structural engineer who is responsible for the design of buildings. It sounds to me like you are a mechanical engineer, correct?

If I want to discuss satellite systems, cell phone satellites for the entire continent of South America or some of the inner workings of the International Space Station and its systems, I will talk to my brother-in-law Ron an employee of a private contractor. I suspect you can narrow it down and perhaps you share the same Employer.
If I want to discuss weapon's sales to foreign countries I will contact his wife. Frankly, I'm not impressed by the resume.

Now if you can trace the route of the mythical fireball to the basement of WTC: North Tower, I would be happy to discuss that with you. Because I have yet to see that happen from a tour guide, a rocket scientist, or NIST for that matter.
 
Actually, Mr. Mackey should take it upon himself to confront structural engineers who find fault with NIST instead of a theology professor.

Will that happen, R. Mackey?

:D You really need to stop confusing arguments and qualifications.

I also see you still haven't read my paper. I too find "fault" with NIST, and I outline three such faults in detail. Stop contaminating my thread until you know what you're talking about.

Many structural engineers have comments on NIST. We all know it's imperfect. I discuss them in depth.

Now, if you mean "structural engineers who support the Truth Movement," then please, send them my way. If you can find any, that is. ;)
 
Now if you can trace the route of the mythical fireball to the basement of WTC: North Tower, I would be happy to discuss that with you. Because I have yet to see that happen from a tour guide, a rocket scientist, or NIST for that matter.


"Mythical fireball?" Are you suggesting that Willliam Rodriguez's story of a fireball -- backed by real burn victims -- was a myth? He's not 100% accurate, but I'm quite confident that there was such a fireball.

Elevator shaft 50A, that's the path. Real easy. It's been told to you before, so go find out where.
 
You have hearsay, please produce some facts. I have facts, you have talk, you have lost.

Show me on first hand 600 mph impact study. There is only one chief engineer, it is Robertson. http://www.asce.org/pressroom/news/display_press.cfm?uid=1349
John Skilling was the head structural engineer for the World Trade Center. In a 1993 interview, Skilling stated that the Towers were designed to withstand the impact and fires resulting from the collision of a large jetliner such as Boeing 707 or McDonald Douglas DC-8. “Our analysis indicated the biggest problem would be the fact that all the fuel (from the airplane) would dump into the building. There would be a horrendous fire. A lot of people would be killed, ... The building structure would still be there.” - Twin Towers Engineered To Withstand Jet Collision, The Seattle Times, 2/27/93

A white paper released on February 3, 1964 states that the Towers could have withstood impacts of jetliners travelling 600 mph -- a speed greater than the impact speed of either jetliner used on 9/11/01.

“The buildings have been investigated and found to be safe in an assumed collision with a large jet airliner (Boeing 707—DC 8) traveling at 600 miles per hour. Analysis indicates that such collision would result in only local damage which could not cause collapse or substantial damage to the building and would not endanger the lives and safety of occupants not in the immediate area of impact.” - City in the Sky, Times Books, Henry Hold and Company, LLC, 2003, page 131
 
... and all three accounts fit, to the letter, what was seen in WTC 1 and WTC 2.

NIST agrees that, had the fires been extinguished, neither structure would have collapsed, nor would occupants outside the immediate impact area have been imperiled.

How, exactly, anyone was supposed to put out those fires, on the other hand, remains an open question.

There is no dispute here, except among the most fervent cherry-pickers. This has been explained here at the JREF Forum hundreds of times. Let's not derail any further.
 
I should ask a pilot? Why? You aren't a structural engineer.

LOL. Ok. Tell the terrorists that. You've never had a mechanical malfunction to cause to you to fly that low? So the law now determines the altitude of planes? Check.

Your telling me I rely on hearsay, correct? Please do explain that and make sure you mention NIST as part of the hearsay.


Please see NIST. Also, I'm also relying on the comments of the head structural engineer after the 1993 attack. This of course at a time when the design parameters of the building would be at the beck and call of the designers and engineers. We would expect them to be pouring over all aspects of the design of the building as well. And the fact of the matter is who would know the parameters of the building better than the head structural engineer after an attack on his building.
I'm also relying on this fact as originally sourced from the document that was used as part of the buildings critique when confronted by lawsuit questioning the integrity of the building. This of course contradicts Mr. Robertson statements.
I'm curious if accepting Mr. Robertson's statement here, will the reader also accept Mr. Robertson's comments on the condition of molten steel 21 days after the attacks?

Oh, and one other thing, did Mr. Robertson give the calculations to NIST?
I am an engineer and a pilot. But better yet, I have Robertson who did the design for a slow speed aircraft, you and NIST have just hearsay, you have failed to produce first hand facts, I have. You have lost again.

FACTS
Leslie E. Robertson,- "...our design (a slow-flying Boeing 707 lost in the fog and seeking a landing field). … "
FACTS, like first hand stuff. Not your error of hearsay junk.

Point match game
 
"Mythical fireball?" Are you suggesting that Willliam Rodriguez's story of a fireball -- backed by real burn victims -- was a myth?

Do I detect the tactic of using the part of Rodriguez's story that suit you whilst, at other times discrediting him?
 
John Skilling was the head structural engineer for the World Trade Center. In a 1993 interview, Skilling stated that the Towers were designed to withstand the impact and fires resulting from the collision of a large jetliner such as Boeing 707 or McDonald Douglas DC-8. “Our analysis indicated the biggest problem would be the fact that all the fuel (from the airplane) would dump into the building. There would be a horrendous fire. A lot of people would be killed, ... The building structure would still be there.” - Twin Towers Engineered To Withstand Jet Collision, The Seattle Times, 2/27/93

A white paper released on February 3, 1964 states that the Towers could have withstood impacts of jetliners travelling 600 mph -- a speed greater than the impact speed of either jetliner used on 9/11/01.

“The buildings have been investigated and found to be safe in an assumed collision with a large jet airliner (Boeing 707—DC 8) traveling at 600 miles per hour. Analysis indicates that such collision would result in only local damage which could not cause collapse or substantial damage to the building and would not endanger the lives and safety of occupants not in the immediate area of impact.” - City in the Sky, Times Books, Henry Hold and Company, LLC, 2003, page 131

You have failed to connect Skillings quote with the assertion of high speed in the white paper. Dismissed
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom