Israel to attack Iran to draw in USA?

Are you aware that the Iranian government was displaying banners reading "Death to America!" and "Death to Israel!" at the big military parade they held the other day?

They most definitively are trying to start a war of sorts against Israel, the US, and the West by trying to drive everyone in the region against us (as well as sponsoring terrorism.) Iran needs to tone down the rhetoric if it's going to be possible to have rational negotiations with them.
Oh no! Banners!! I'm so scared!!!! :rolleyes:

So what? How do we respond to words and protests? I say we need to not respond at all. Rattling our sabers back at them plays right into their hands. If they want to "start a war" by driving Israel or America to launch an unprovoked preemptive strike, then we've again played into their hands.

Don't we need to tone down our rhetoric? Or do we base our actions on Iran? I thought we held ourselves to a higher standard.
 
If they want to "start a war" by driving Israel or America to launch an unprovoked preemptive strike, then we've again played into their hands.

I hope there are people in Iran who are still sane and moderate enough to not want that, and I hope they will soon make Ahmadinejad know and show him the door.
 
I hope there are people in Iran who are still sane and moderate enough to not want that, and I hope they will soon make Ahmadinejad know and show him the door.

I does not matter if Mahmoud leaves, the mullahs will find another "electable" stooge to be their front man.

DR
 
I hope there are people in Iran who are still sane and moderate enough to not want that, and I hope they will soon make Ahmadinejad know and show him the door.
You know what the problem with that is? Moderates are what they are... if they had guns and planned on leading armed insurrections, they would hardly be considered moderates anymore, would they?
 
If Israel attacks Iran, shouldn't the rest of the world enact sanctions against Israel? Isn't that what we normally do when one country attacks another without provocation?

If you are an America/Israel hater who puts on blinders to the ambitions of Iran in making nuclear weapons, perhaps.

Meanwhile, back in the real world...
 
Oh no! Banners!! I'm so scared!!!! :rolleyes:

So what?


So their desire is to see Israel gone, dead, wiped from existence. This isn't even something they deny. In fact, Ahmadinejad continually reminds people of it. It's a stated goal of his. It's not a great secret.

Note that this is not saying that they want to "kill all the Jews." No, they simply want the State of Israel to be dissolved and the people relocated somewhere else, preferably outside of the Middle East.


How do we respond to words and protests? I say we need to not respond at all. Rattling our sabers back at them plays right into their hands.


They aren't content with just empty words and protests though. They do whatever they can to drive others to engage in physical attacks against us (meaning Israel and any western presence in the region.)


If they want to "start a war" by driving Israel or America to launch an unprovoked preemptive strike, then we've again played into their hands.


Their wish is probably not to start a war that involves Iran itself, but rather to get everyone in the region to make us feel so unwelcome that we pack up and leave, giving them a greater opportunity to become a dominating force in the middle east -- without any fighting on their own land. Warfare by proxy.

The problem though, Ellison, is where do you draw the line? When does it cease to be an "unprovoked preemptive strike?" Take Israel. Iran has been shown to be behind attacks on Israel, both indirectly through supporting terrorist groups, and directly through members of the Iranian Guard operating in countries like Lebanon. If you have indisputable evidence of this taking place, would striking back at Iran really be preemptive or unprovoked?

What if Iran decides to increase their activities in the future, after they've obtained even more advanced weaponry, including nuclear warheads? What do you do then? Striking back has just become a lot more risky. This is probably the reason Iran wants nuclear weapons, not because they intend to attack anyone with them "first." They want free reigns to do whatever they want, without the risk of any major repercussions.

That's how I see it, anyway.

The whole thing is a big mess, and I fear that it's inevitably going to escalate beyond the point of no return. It's sad to watch.
 
The President of Iran making idle threats against Israel is not a real threat.

I encourage you to try to get elected espousing that position. "The person in the country that hates us is making statements they want to drive us all into the sea and kill us. As your leader, I judge these threats to be idle and meaningless, and to treat it as such."

Would you elect yourself leader?
 
I encourage you to try to get elected espousing that position. "The person in the country that hates us is making statements they want to drive us all into the sea and kill us. As your leader, I judge these threats to be idle and meaningless, and to treat it as such."

Would you elect yourself leader?

Hey, Bush got (sort of, but not really) elected twice. The ability to get votes isn't an indication of intelligence or insight. The reality is that if you tell too much of the truth, you don't get elected...
 
I think this is telling of Iran's intentions:



(although I do not know when this video was taken, but you can clearly see Ali Khamenei)
 
Last edited:
An inconsequential preacher in the US says that the US should assasinate Hugo Chavez, and people go ballistic and denounce it for all it's worth. The President of Iran declares that Israel should be wiped off the face of the earth while pursuing a nuclear program and people scramble to make excuses for him and criticize Israel for contemplating action, go figure. :rolleyes:

That kind of nonsense is a major reason why I am not on the Political Left,as opposed to the nonsense which keeps me from being on the political right.
Blaming Israel indirectily for 9/11 is wack.
 
Oh no! Banners!! I'm so scared!!!! :rolleyes:

So what? How do we respond to words and protests? I say we need to not respond at all. Rattling our sabers back at them plays right into their hands. If they want to "start a war" by driving Israel or America to launch an unprovoked preemptive strike, then we've again played into their hands.

Don't we need to tone down our rhetoric? Or do we base our actions on Iran? I thought we held ourselves to a higher standard.

I love your "if we just ignore Militant Islam it will go away " attitude.
 
I love your "if we just ignore Militant Islam it will go away " attitude.
I love your "I understand the issues on a child's level, so I'll misrepresent the positions of cooler heads" attitude.
 
I love your "I understand the issues on a child's level, so I'll misrepresent the positions of cooler heads" attitude.

I would love to know what you would have done on 9/12,2001,since "cooler Heads" probably means "do nothing beyond a few symbolic UN Resolutions".
 
I'm going to ask one more time that you conduct yourself in an honest and adult manner.

OK.

Which of the above was a falsehood? Address the points and don't get your knickers in a knot because I don't like your analysis. We are debating along with another who does hold that opinion about 911. It sounded like you were of like mind, but if not on that issue, I apologize for the sarcasm on that point.

The other points I made were in direct response to yours and call for a reposte, not a whine.
 
wrong!

Quote:
Ahmadinejad Says Britain, Israel, US To 'Vanish Like The Pharaohs'

from http://www.hyscience.com/archives/20...inejad_say.php

And you think America et al will last for ever?
The American economy is in trouble. This is the Chinese century, not the American. And although a war against Iran may delay that, or speed it up, it will not change it.

Quote:
Ahmadinejad: Destroy Israel, End Crisis

from here: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn...080300629.html

And that article quotes Ahmadinejad saying: "Although the main solution is for the elimination of the Zionist regime, at this stage an immediate cease-fire must be implemented," he said.

So, again, it is regime change.
Just like ending Apartheid was regime change. The Apartheid regime of South Africa has been eliminated. Did you oppose that too?
 
FireGarden said:
And that article quotes Ahmadinejad saying: "Although the main solution is for the elimination of the Zionist regime, at this stage an immediate cease-fire must be implemented," he said.
At this stage Iran wants a cease-fire because it wants its nuclear research to mature and does not not need another battle on their hands. The international community will destroy their nuclear achievements to date if they started a war with Israel. But don't worry, I'm sure that as soon as they have nuclear capabilities Israel wil be the first to taste it and America probably second, third or fourth. Wait your turn, we're first. You'll taste the fruits of your ignorance after us.

You will sometime (and I hope it will be soon) have to realize that what Iran says to the international community is made up of many many lies: The recent ones I can remember:
1. Iran has no homosexuals like you have in the U.S.
2. Iran does not support terror.
3. Women are very highly regarded in Iran. They are honored more than the men.

Those are just 3 examples that have been prooven to be lies.
 
Last edited:
So, again, it is regime change.
Just like ending Apartheid was regime change. The Apartheid regime of South Africa has been eliminated. Did you oppose that too?
Even if you were correect, Ahmadinejad wishes to replace a democratic government with an Islamic theocracy. The South African analogy would be accurate if you were advocating the current regime be ousted in favor of an apartheid regime.

How many Jews live in the Palestinian-controlled West Bank and Gaza? How many Christians? How many Buddhists?
 
Last edited:
I would love to know what you would have done on 9/12,2001,since "cooler Heads" probably means "do nothing beyond a few symbolic UN Resolutions".


The trials for Lockerbie didn't take place in Scotland or America. The Taliban offered to hand bin Laden over to Pakistan:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2001/10/04/wpak04.xml

I would have put more pressure on Pakistan to accept the offer. Or I would put forward an offer of trial in another location. Demanding that bin Laden be handed over to America directly, before trial, turned out not to work.

Of course, Clinton missed a similar chance when Sudan offered to hand bin Laden over to Saudi Arabia.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom